[Basic] Shifters vs Hunters - Game Over! Congrats Mafia!

[Lenlo]

Soundin rather defensive there Hoof. And not just the normal "prove you wrong and try and show you another more appealing target" defense.

 

Are you over reacting and seeming scummy to try and vet yourself in some way since earlier in that same post you say that you get lynched for your own scummieness? Its like your saying "Expect me to be scummy" or "I am always scummy early on so everything is par for the course, dont lynch me!". Im not sure I buy it.

[Blackhoof]

Soundin rather defensive there Hoof. And not just the normal "prove you wrong and try and show you another more appealing target" defense.

 

Are you over reacting and seeming scummy to try and vet yourself in some way since earlier in that same post you say that you get lynched for your own scummieness? Its like your saying "Expect me to be scummy" or "I am always scummy early on so everything is par for the course, dont lynch me!". Im not sure I buy it.

 

Fair points.

[Sakaea]

I believe I wasn't voting for anyone when EP was lynched cus I didn't make it back online before the hammer vote.

 

Hoof, I'm afraid you are sounding way too defensive. FOS.

 

Darthe is just sounding noob-ish right now.

 

And Razen is pinging me slightly for the breadcrumbing remark.

 

I will try to be back later, I'm not sure who to vote for atm.

[John E. Kelley]

Before going after him, would the people who didn't vote yesterday (those that are alive, of course) care to explain why?

 

I personally answered this when EP asked me to hammer him.

 

Just catching up on my lunch break sir.

 

You've really put yourself in a pickle haven't you? Tbh, I think you're telling the truth when you say you're vanilla. But you spun events to a point where you're the only viable choice today. Have no one to blame but yourself, I never made a case against you, only defended against the weak one you made against me. You made your own case on yourself single-handedly.

 

I do suppose, however, that if you wanted to try a new playstyle, doing it as vanilla in a basic game is the best time to do it, but you have to expect the consequences when it backfires. It's all on you at this point.

 

And no, I won't be hammering right now. Not going to allow you to dictate my game when you decide to switch up your game and get yourself lynched.

[John E. Kelley]

It's something that makes me suspicious, especially coupled with his surviving to Day 2. I would have thought that someone would have tried to kill him considering that he practically admitted that he might have had a power role. The fact that he didn't get killed makes me think that either the WIFOM scared the mafia off enough to not kill him or he is mafia, and hence the reason he's still alive. Vote: Blackhoof.

 

Vote Razen

 

Please, I die on Day 1 becasue of the scummy things i say, not because everyone has a vendetta against me. the mafia also do not have some dark conspiracy brewing to make sure i die early... why would they?

 

Who am I, chuck norris? brian boitano?

 

They probably killed Kaylee randomly, as mafia often do on day 1.

 

i have never hinted, bread-crumbed or claimed to have a role, i have no idea what you are on about. and if i did, perhaps the mafia ddint kill me sicne they figured the doc would spot it as well and protect me?

 

you are smoking soemthing razen... seriosuly lol

 

^^This. [/b]Vote Razen.[/b]

 

Can you show me where he claimed this power role?

[John E. Kelley]

Blah.

 

Vote Razen.

[Razen]

I didn't say he claimed one, I said he practically claimed one.

 

It's something that makes me suspicious, especially coupled with his surviving to Day 2. I would have thought that someone would have tried to kill him considering that he practically admitted that he might have had a power role. The fact that he didn't get killed makes me think that either the WIFOM scared the mafia off enough to not kill him or he is mafia, and hence the reason he's still alive. Vote: Blackhoof.

 

im sleeping through day 1 so i dont die

 

Ishy, it was in reaction Hoofy saying that he wanted to survive past Day 1 and how was laying low by his own admission. I interpreted that to mean that he had some type of a power role or was in fact mafia. So no, I don't actually know that. I'm just making an educated guess based on this laying low post and the fact that he is alive. Nothing against you Hoofy, just that you have a tendency to die during Day/Night 1. If you think that's vote worthy, go ahead and vote me.

[Nolder]

Just posting to agree with Razen

people who are activelurking are often assumed to have a power role or be mafia

[John E. Kelley]

Usually, yes. But I think we'd all agree that Hoof on Day One is a special case. It's not a tip off on what his role may be, I see it as a matter of survival.

 

If I got killed, in whatever fashion, every single D1, I'd shut the hell up and wait until D2, wouldn't you?

 

And even doing that, he still stood a fair chance of getting lynched heh.

 

Poor Hoof.

[Nolder]

it's not a special case if no one considers it a special case

he's just a regular player like the rest of us

he's had some bad luck I guess but there's no reason to treat him any different

[Ironeyes]

I think people just say, "Hey, it's day 1, we have no info on anyone, so let's lynch Blackhoof because he always dies day 1!" It's like an inside joke with everyone.

[John E. Kelley]

I think people just say, "Hey, it's day 1, we have no info on anyone, so let's lynch Blackhoof because he always dies day 1!" It's like an inside joke with everyone.

 

A joke I don't care for, and won't participate in.

[Blackhoof]

 

Ishy, it was in reaction Hoofy saying that he wanted to survive past Day 1 and how was laying low by his own admission. I interpreted that to mean that he had some type of a power role or was in fact mafia. So no, I don't actually know that. I'm just making an educated guess based on this laying low post and the fact that he is alive. Nothing against you Hoofy, just that you have a tendency to die during Day/Night 1. If you think that's vote worthy, go ahead and vote me.

 

So a vanilla townie is eager to die?

Not on day 1 to a bandwagon they aren't.

[John E. Kelley]

Just posting to agree with Razen

people who are activelurking are often assumed to have a power role or be mafia

Ishy, it was in reaction Hoofy saying that he wanted to survive past Day 1 and how was laying low by his own admission. I interpreted that to mean that he had some type of a power role or was in fact mafia. So no, I don't actually know that. I'm just making an educated guess based on this laying low post and the fact that he is alive. Nothing against you Hoofy, just that you have a tendency to die during Day/Night 1. If you think that's vote worthy, go ahead and vote me.

 

So a vanilla townie is eager to die?

Not on day 1 to a bandwagon they aren't.

 

Now that Hoof has said he's 'nilla, what say you Nol?

[Alanna]

Vote Count:

Blackhoof (2) - Nolder, Razen

Darthe (1) - Key

Razen (2) - Blackhoof, Ishy

 

Not Voting: Darthe, Lenlo, Sakaea, Arez, Ironeyes

[keyholder21]

Darthe - Okay on the newbie thing. They are randomly assigned, love. Still slightly suspicious of the bandwagon statement, but as you're new, I'll let it slide for now.

 

It's something that makes me suspicious, especially coupled with his surviving to Day 2. I would have thought that someone would have tried to kill him considering that he practically admitted that he might have had a power role. The fact that he didn't get killed makes me think that either the WIFOM scared the mafia off enough to not kill him or he is mafia, and hence the reason he's still alive. Vote: Blackhoof.

 

You know, just rereading this now and the wording bugs me. "practically admitted that he MIGHT HAVE HAD" <---- past tense. But if Hoof is still around, how can you state past tense?

 

Unvote, Vote Razen.

[keyholder21]

Ninja'd by our lovely mod goddess *g*.

[Lenlo]

Razen, your pushing the Hoof thing so hard and the power role claim thing just isnt rubbing me the right way. Your case against Hoof isnt even a very good one imo.

 

Vote Razen.

[Blackhoof]

Oh, i didn't claim vanilla, I was responding to razens implication that people only wish to live if they are mafia or have a role.

[John E. Kelley]

Oh, i didn't claim vanilla, I was responding to razens implication that people only wish to live if they are mafia or have a role.

 

Dammit Hoof.....you're making me look bad by sticking up for ya.

[Blackhoof]

Sorry....=(

[Razen]

Darthe - Okay on the newbie thing. They are randomly assigned, love. Still slightly suspicious of the bandwagon statement, but as you're new, I'll let it slide for now.

 

It's something that makes me suspicious, especially coupled with his surviving to Day 2. I would have thought that someone would have tried to kill him considering that he practically admitted that he might have had a power role. The fact that he didn't get killed makes me think that either the WIFOM scared the mafia off enough to not kill him or he is mafia, and hence the reason he's still alive. Vote: Blackhoof.

 

You know, just rereading this now and the wording bugs me. "practically admitted that he MIGHT HAVE HAD" <---- past tense. But if Hoof is still around, how can you state past tense?

 

Unvote, Vote Razen.

 

Remind me in the future that I must look carefully at grammar before I post. You get what I'm saying - so why point out a semantic detail? In the whole scheme of things, this is a basic game, so I highly doubt that someone's role would be shifted or taken away.

 

Razen, your pushing the Hoof thing so hard and the power role claim thing just isnt rubbing me the right way. Your case against Hoof isnt even a very good one imo.

 

Vote Razen.

 

I posted my suspicions, then everyone got all up in arms about it, I explained, and people still got up in arms. You, good sir, have an excellent reason to want to hop onto my train. I'm going down, you can hop on and get yourself one step closer to winning this game.

 

I'm vanilla town, so whatevs. But I would look more closely at Key and Lenlo. They had pretty weak reasons, IMO, for voting me. And I still say that Hoofy has either a power role or is scum.

 

Unvote, vote Lenlo.

[Arez Al'Loke]

Can someone remind me why a train is building on Razen?

 

Is it the usual, he made a tiny/big mistake, lets blow it out of proportions?

[Nolder]

Razen makes a lot of sense

I don't know why this bandwagon as formed

I do find it interesting that Ishy and Blackhoof started it though

[Arez Al'Loke]

He might..

 

Yes, it is interesting..