Blackhoofs Warhammer 40'000 Game [BASIC]

[aemonkristen]

checking in

[Sakaea]

I'm not dismissing the idea, I just find it worried that you latched on to it so quickly, and now are defending it.

[John E. Kelley]

  On 2/1/2012 at 5:50 PM, Sakaea said:

I'm not dismissing the idea, I just find it worried that you latched on to it so quickly, and now are defending it.

 

Preaching to the choir sistah. Vote BG.

[bgrishinko]

Fair enough I suppose. Gotta start scum hunting somewhere though, where better?

[Sakaea]

*worrying, not worried. Need to spell check myself apparently.

[Red2111]

i liek the two trains personally. as well as the fact that we're getting the game started this early

 

  On 2/1/2012 at 5:04 PM, Nolder said:

  On 2/1/2012 at 4:34 PM, Red2111 said:

i dislike how your jumping to conclusions honestly.

please tell me what conclusion I "jumped" to

I thought I explained my thought process well myself

 

you took a simple explination and joke (i mena, i read it as her joking about all the games she's in) and jumped to the conclusion she was a 3rd party player.

 

 

reguardless of your explination, i felt that it was an opportunistic move and blown out of proportion.

[Nolder]

  On 2/1/2012 at 6:54 PM, Red2111 said:

i liek the two trains personally. as well as the fact that we're getting the game started this early

 

  On 2/1/2012 at 5:04 PM, Nolder said:

  On 2/1/2012 at 4:34 PM, Red2111 said:

i dislike how your jumping to conclusions honestly.

please tell me what conclusion I "jumped" to

I thought I explained my thought process well myself

 

you took a simple explination and joke (i mena, i read it as her joking about all the games she's in) and jumped to the conclusion she was a 3rd party player.

 

 

reguardless of your explination, i felt that it was an opportunistic move and blown out of proportion.

I never said she was a 3rd party player

I said she was probably a serial killer

I took her actions and followed them to the most likely explanation

it was well reasoned based on the little information available to me

there is no "jumping" involved

[bgrishinko]

Well... nolder, there was a little bit of jumping considering it was the 4th and 5th post of the game with only 1 post to go off of, of course saying "probably" is a jump, though not to a conclusion I suppose.

 

That being said, I think Sakaea's arguement against me is a fair one, but Ishy seems opportunistic. Red's attacks as well: likes my reasoning against Nolder enough to place a vote, but then promptly FoS's me for it right after. Can't have your cake and eat it too. We shall see.

 

Unvote

 

Vote Ishy

[amegakure]

here. ill check in later

[Red2111]

BG you mis-inturpret me. i agreed with voting Nol, for reasons below. i FoS you because of your "he ust be cyaing himself as a 3rd party"

 

i know you were just beating his grass to see how fast he bolted, but what pings is your latching onto the idea of a 3rd party in this game (same as Nol) and furthering that bit of WIFOM tby accusing Nol of being one.

 

so no, i'm not having my cake and eating it too, i'm taking piece from two different pies and eating those instead

 

 

 

  On 2/1/2012 at 7:31 PM, Nolder said:

I never said she was a 3rd party player

I said she was probably a serial killer

I took her actions and followed them to the most likely explanation

it was well reasoned based on the little information available to me

there is no "jumping" involved

 

 

serial killer IS a 3rd party player Nol, stop waxing semantics with me.

 

imo, you didn't follow the most liekly explanation, you followed the one that would allow you to easily push a lynch on her.

 

that fact that there is so little reason and your making this conclusion is exactly why i say our jumping to conclusions.

[Nolder]

well I don't know what else you want me to do

what I saw was suspicious to me

I could have waited around for something more to happen I suppose but when people have that kind of mentality games drag

is it the strongest case ever? nah not by a long shot but as of now I'm thinking it's pretty good considering we're only 2 pages into the game

[Perfexionist]

Vote Ama because sigs that good are suspicious.

[aemonkristen]

I can see how Nolder started this with the hopes of kick starting the game. Well done. The problem is that even though his original accusation was weak and based on a 2-sentence post, he just won't let go of it. From that came his accusation of her planting the seeds of sympathy and her probable role of SK. I don't feel him as scum right now, but the stubborn clinging to a very weak 1-post case of a player is frustrating.

[Perfexionist]

  On 2/2/2012 at 12:00 AM, aemonkristen said:

I can see how Nolder started this with the hopes of kick starting the game. Well done. The problem is that even though his original accusation was weak and based on a 2-sentence post, he just won't let go of it. From that came his accusation of her planting the seeds of sympathy and her probable role of SK. I don't feel him as scum right now, but the stubborn clinging to a very weak 1-post case of a player is frustrating.

 

Must lynch. Two sentences. SO convincing!

[Blackhoof]

Vote Count

 

Christine (1)- Nolder

Nolder (1)- Red

Bg (1)- Sakaea, Ishy

Ishy (1)- BG

Ama (1)- Perfect

 

 

  On 2/1/2012 at 4:08 PM, Nolder said:

I've always wanted to make a game where everyone is a serial killer or a vigilante

 

wouldnt everyone die... like, within 2 nights?

 

what if..... half the game was serial killers, and half the game was survivors with a healing ability like a doctor? but they couldnt target themselves? Hmmmmmm...... interesting......

[amegakure]

well at the moment i dont see much at the moment. I dont really think Nolder is latched to the idea just more or less not wanting people to point out the flaws. So im getting town from him atm... nothin else to add

[Lenlo]

Lets go with my trivia buddy Ishy for now, that and going with the crowd. I vote BG

[Sakaea]

Ping. But n00b ping, I think.

[Levity]

Noobsheep~

 

But yeah, I don't know, that was an odd argument out of nowhere. We're not going to know what's in the game until it progresses, anyhow.

[John E. Kelley]

  On 2/2/2012 at 2:48 AM, Sakaea said:

Ping. But n00b ping, I think.

Quite right. It took quite awhile for me to get my feet under me at the beginning too. Len will be a pro by the end probably. We'll teach him as we go. For starters: "No Len!! Bad Len!!"

[Lenlo]

*Has learned his lesson... Wont do it again for the next vote.*

At least no one took a rolled up news paper into this.

[Levity]

I have plenty of newspapers right next to me at the moment, actually. o;

[Nolder]

  On 2/1/2012 at 8:10 PM, Red2111 said:

  On 2/1/2012 at 7:31 PM, Nolder said:

I never said she was a 3rd party player

I said she was probably a serial killer

I took her actions and followed them to the most likely explanation

it was well reasoned based on the little information available to me

there is no "jumping" involved

 

 

serial killer IS a 3rd party player Nol, stop waxing semantics with me.

 

imo, you didn't follow the most liekly explanation, you followed the one that would allow you to easily push a lynch on her.

 

that fact that there is so little reason and your making this conclusion is exactly why i say our jumping to conclusions.

it's not about semantics Red

I said Serial Killer becuase I had a reason to think Serial Killer which I clearly laid out

 

have I pushed a lynch on her as of yet? no

I voted her and was done with it

you and BG are the ones that turned this into an issue

[Nolder]

  On 2/2/2012 at 12:27 AM, Blackhoof said:

  On 2/1/2012 at 4:08 PM, Nolder said:

I've always wanted to make a game where everyone is a serial killer or a vigilante

 

wouldnt everyone die... like, within 2 nights?

not necessarily

they could decide not to shoot

or multiple people could shoot the same person

[Amadine]

  On 2/1/2012 at 11:29 PM, Perfexionist said:

Vote Ama because sigs that good are suspicious.

 

HMPF! No siggies for you Perf