[Advanced] Lily's Mythical Beings Mafia

[WWWwombat]

FYI I am on page 3 and already want to lynch Red.

[Minuet]

Okay, you all want more from me, I am an enhancer. I choose who to enhance every night. Last night I choose Ishy, hence why he had two views. This is why I was upset about Ed saying he did something to Ishy. I was concerned he wouldn't get his 2 views. Since he did it made me wonder what Ed did to Ishy's role.

Red you said for the person who helped Ishy not to reveal, but since you all wanted more from me and well are bound and determined to lynch me I have revealed. Like I said if I am not lynched I will probably be nk by the mafia. Which is okay, the finder and doc roles need to be protected. I just don't want you all to waste a lynch on me. Defeats the purpose of being available for them to nk and they might pick someone with a better power.

Ed why did you reveal during the night that you even did anything for Ishy? I would never had said anything or revealed if you hadn't. Makes me wonder if you were role fishing or up to no good. I don't trust that you are innocent at this point.

The purple is for Verbal. I stopped posting in purple cause people complained about it.

Okay, one final word on the finder revealing who he/she views. Yes, the mafia can pick off those people that have been confirmed. However, we never know who the godfather is. Did you ever think they wouldn't kill their godfather who would view innocent? So, see the town could use the information for good. I still think that my view is right and all of you are entitled to your opinions. I am not advocating lynches on you for disagreeing with me.

Sorry I didn't get on till now. I was sick all day and in bed.

Okay, I see I am going no where voting for Ed. After re-reading post I agree with Hoofie about Nolder. His post after Hybrid's death is a bit off.

Unvote Vote Nolder

[Nolder]

FYI I am on page 3 and already want to lynch Red.

while I sort of agree, I feel this way every game I'm in with red

so I have to be really careful about voting her

I dunno why but red's playstyle just irks me a lot

[Nolder]

honestly this is really bugging me

I'm actually having decent reads this game (I think, I was right about Hybrid at the least) and you all want to lynch me

I know some are mafia but some of you are town too and that's really lame

I'm done posting for now

you guys have really sapped my enthusiasm for this game

[WWWwombat]

Tigs, Gilligan's Island mafia. Ask Min, who was the mod. I was symp.

 

And it worked too. :D

 

And Red was the mod. I will find it later.

[WWWwombat]

My brain works funny. I can read that almost as easily as regular type

 

Dyslexia!

[WWWwombat]

If I had a nickel for every time Nolder linked that damned "Too Townie" article as scum...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'd have a nickel.

[Sakaea]

My brain works funny. I can read that almost as easily as regular type

 

Dyslexia!

 

 

Dyslexia FTW!

[John E. Kelley]

Okay, you all want more from me, I am an enhancer. I choose who to enhance every night. Last night I choose Ishy, hence why he had two views. This is why I was upset about Ed saying he did something to Ishy. I was concerned he wouldn't get his 2 views. Since he did it made me wonder what Ed did to Ishy's role.

Red you said for the person who helped Ishy not to reveal, but since you all wanted more from me and well are bound and determined to lynch me I have revealed. Like I said if I am not lynched I will probably be nk by the mafia. Which is okay, the finder and doc roles need to be protected. I just don't want you all to waste a lynch on me. Defeats the purpose of being available for them to nk and they might pick someone with a better power.

Ed why did you reveal during the night that you even did anything for Ishy? I would never had said anything or revealed if you hadn't. Makes me wonder if you were role fishing or up to no good. I don't trust that you are innocent at this point.

The purple is for Verbal. I stopped posting in purple cause people complained about it.

Okay, one final word on the finder revealing who he/she views. Yes, the mafia can pick off those people that have been confirmed. However, we never know who the godfather is. Did you ever think they wouldn't kill their godfather who would view innocent? So, see the town could use the information for good. I still think that my view is right and all of you are entitled to your opinions. I am not advocating lynches on you for disagreeing with me.

Sorry I didn't get on till now. I was sick all day and in bed.

Okay, I see I am going no where voting for Ed. After re-reading post I agree with Hoofie about Nolder. His post after Hybrid's death is a bit off.

Unvote Vote Nolder

 

At this same moment on D1, I was in the exact same boat as you are now Min. I was nearly lynched, and had to reveal my role to stop it. After that happened, everyone believed me and gave me a new lease on life. I would be a total hypocrite if I didn't extend the same courtesy to you.

Unvote Min. Vote Noldor.

And even if she wasn't a mirror image of my D1, her role reveal seems totally true to me, especially after Ed revealed that he didn't target me at all. And with his reveal, I would prefer an Ed lynch to anyone else I've seen till now, but can't see an Ed lynch getting any traction this close to deadline. Which only leaves Nol as any kind of an alternative. And I have to admit, the case against him is weak, weak, weak. But even if he should flip town, as far as I'm concerned, it's lose a roleless townie, or lose an Enhancer townie that benefitted me and town already. Simple logic as far as I'm concerned, but should we have a flurry of activity and an Ed lynch should form really fast, know that I would jump on that in a heartbeat.

[John E. Kelley]

And welcome to the madness Wom.

[Karasayl]

This is dumb. First of all verby, I've been translating and quoting Karas' text for everyone, so apparently you're also too lazy to read my posts. Small FOS at you for making it seem harder than it is. Here's Karas' last post:

 

Well it might be distracting (and annoying with the backwards thing), and its certainly no huge revelation, but I was thinking about Nolder's gameplay. Keep in mind I've never played with him before, but my scumdar is just pinging too much (his reads?) with him to the point I started thinking- maybe hes trying to get lynched :\ So since I wasn't convinced on Min, Amadine not answering Bg's question seemed like only real option. Now I do have a FoS on some other people...but its way to early for me to be touting that. Since Womby has joined and we have an extention, I can switch my vote if need be though.

 

If there wasn't a deadline extension, this post would have pinged to me. The case on Amadine is as weak as they get, omg she didn't respond to BG's question about her alignment! Let's lynch anyone who doesn't outright say they're town! Let's go ahead and get EVERYONE to say whether or not they're town or scum, cause that's a good idea. I'm town. BG, your turn.

 

It's just laughable to me that BG really only wanted to hear Ama say she was scum, then was satisfied enough to unvote. I don't think she's def town, but she really hasn't pinged to me yet. Either way, we got some time now, we can pressure more peeps, why are we stopping right after we get an alignment out of them? That ain't pressure. I wanna see some people sweat under the town's focus, the more they squirm the more info we're likely to get.

 

@ Sakaea: Okay I guess I can understand your point about Lanth. You're right, he hasn't really contributed much at all to any scumhunts. He might deserve an FOS for having his activity level drop so much since the no lynch debate.

 

.tey ti laever ot gniog ton m'I tub ,nosaer a evah od I

 

.top eht rits ot ekil I..he tub ,hcterts a saw amA no etov eht hguoht timda lliw I

 

ETOVNU

[Karasayl]

ENIDAMA ETOV ,ETOVNU

 

..sklof siht od ot yrroS .em ot denethgila neeb tsuj sah ecnatropmi fo gnihtemoS

care to enlighten us?

 

 

): evoba eeS

[Barmacral]

Barm, Vambram did post. I wonder were Lanth is though. I don't think he has posted since day 2 started.

 

 

On Day 1, there was a series of discussions between Des and Hybrid. I got a gut feeling that pinged my personal scum detector from Hybrid. I voted to lynch him, and it turns out that the lynching of Hybrid revealed that he was a Roleblocker whom was a Dragon on my team, the Town Team. Clearly, everyone of us Town players made a mistake in the lynching of Hybrid.

Now, here we are on Day 2, and the deadline is coming up on Wednesday. I am not getting a scummy feel from anyone right now... at least not a strong enough ping to cast a vote. However, I shall sleep on this, and come back tomorrow. Hopefully, I can return in time to cast a vote before the deadline is reached.

 

Wow. Did not see that one at all.

 

Anyways, unvote. I will vote again tomorrow once I've had more sleep and can catch back up on the game.

[LilyElizabeth]

I had Hoof down twice. This is the correct vote count now. Sorry about that.

 

Vote count:

 

Nolder (4) – Des, Red, Min, Ishy

Min (3) – Verb, Hoof, Raena,

Ama (1) – Ed

Vambram (1) – Nolder

 

 

Not voting – Vam, Meesh, Lanth, Wombat, Sakaea, Ama, Bg, Karas, Barm

 

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch. Deadline Thursday 8 PM MST.

[WWWwombat]

Why are so many people not voting? I think I will

 

Vote: Amadine

 

She pinged me earlier and I would like to see two trains.

[John E. Kelley]

With a deadline 24 hours away and not even halfway towards a lynch on anyone, maybe a little more activity everyone?

[Vambram]

Based upon the reveals and non-reveals here on Day 2, I believe that the safest lynch here for Day 2 is Nolder. Also, whether it has been intentional or not, there has just been something that is a little bit too defensive to me in Nolder's post, and in my opinion, that is scummy.

VOTE Nolder

[Minuet]

I will admit that Nolder's defense was a bunch of hot air with no content. If he had a valuable town role I think he would have revealed by now or at least hinted at it. So, if he isn't mafia by some strange quirk I am okay with a lynch on him.

 

This close to the deadline I think we are past doing two competing trains. I mean get out and vote people. We only had the deadline extended due to a new player being added.

[Sakaea]

I will check on this game first thing in the morning. For now, VOTE NOLDER, as I also think he is our best lynch candidate.

[ed2funy]

The person honestly who seems to be pinging most to me is actually Nolder now. Especially with his last post; his whole defense of Hybrid was that Hybrid might be pinging in other ways, but we shouldn't have hammered him on account of him not saying he was town in his role reveal. Now all of a sudden Nolder claims he was aware and stating Hybrid was obviously town. MAJOR ping.

I only agreed that Hybrid seemed a little scummy after Ama's post but by that point I was already convinced he was town

look at the damn evidence!

the blatant bandwagoning with little reason

hybrid as scum wouldn't claim roleblocker

scum wouldn't bus their roleblocker so easily

 

it's all there if you take a damn second to think

 

but given your vote on such shakey grounds it looks like that might be too much for you

 

Nolder, I swear, I hope you get hit by a crane.

You need to stop insulting people in a game.

You need to stop acting like a damn child when you play these games or no one is gonna want to play with you.

 

 

 

 

 

 

*twaps Ama* And you, missy. Making your post like that so we had to highlight it. :P

 

 

 

 

Des, it's her nature. Dirty move by BG, imo, but it is a failsafe. lol

 

 

 

 

Okay, you all want more from me, I am an enhancer. I choose who to enhance every night. Last night I choose Ishy, hence why he had two views. This is why I was upset about Ed saying he did something to Ishy. I was concerned he wouldn't get his 2 views. Since he did it made me wonder what Ed did to Ishy's role.

Ed why did you reveal during the night that you even did anything for Ishy? I would never had said anything or revealed if you hadn't. Makes me wonder if you were role fishing or up to no good. I don't trust that you are innocent at this point.

 

o_O

I honestly don't see how I made you reveal.

 

I believe you, mostly, because of the timing of your posts in the Night and asking me if I gave him super powers.

But I was just throwing WIFOMs out there, mostly. ^.^

 

Tigs, Gilligan's Island mafia. Ask Min, who was the mod. I was symp.

 

And it worked too. :D

 

And Red was the mod. I will find it later.

 

Oh really? Oops. >.<

I fell asleep last night, so I am glad Wombat joined the game. :DI'll be back later with a vote. BEFORE I lay down for the night. lol

[ed2funy]

Oh, and pooey on you, Ishy. Pooey.

[Raena]

Unvote

 

Going to read through the last pages again before I vote.

[bgrishinko]

@Barmy Fair enough, at some point I'll go back and see what it was that pinged me about you, but I was just reading through to catch up mainly and it was an overall vibe.

 

As for now, I'm not convinced about Nolder for one reason... If I were him and Mafia, I totally would have taken the idea that people were assuming I had an investigative role and ran with it. He didn't do that, which leads me to believe that he's just being quick and dirty in his posts... maybe not thinking them through very well. I see why he's getting upset about the Hybrid thing. I've been FOS'd pretty hard before for sticking to my guns about someone being town and then them flipping town and everyone saying I'm acting toooo town. It's a bit of a WIFOM, but I felt pretty vindicated when it happened too and I bragged a little.

 

I'm also pretty keen on believing Min because it'd be pretty easy for a doubler to counter-claim. Now, there is a possibility that Min and Ishy are running a gambit. If something incriminating happens on one, and flips mafia, then I say this is a rare case of being able to link players safely. But for now, both are off my voting list.

 

I will think on this a little longer

[bgrishinko]

I fully expect you to start thinking I ping because of this, but Meh... My Barm suspicions articulated:

 

whats wrong with a No Lynch Sakaea?? you info off a No Lynch as well, more so than a random or inactive lynch.

 

Are you seriously arguing in favour of a No Lynch on day 1? Unvote, Vote: Red

 

I am of the opinion that this whole No Lynch thing from day one (I don't want to get into the argument again, because... well, its been argued) was a big attempt at making a mountain our of a molehill. I didn't see anything wrong with it. It seemed jokish at first, "Oh we can do that! Then by all means NO LYNCH!" but it isn't a bad position to take on Day 1 as Day 1 tends to be the most dangerous lynch for town since there is nothing to go off of and your really just hoping for a slipup. As such, Red stuck up for it and made it serious. Just my opinion, so I sided with Red in my thinking, which made me start stink eyeing Barm among others.

 

I am against the idea because you can get more info off of a real lynch than waffling around a no-lynch. I agree that a random lynch is worse, but advocating a no lynch when there are no strong lynch candidates or a deadline in sight (meaning no risk of a random lynch) is VERY anti-town.

 

Again. Red wasn't advocating anything. Calling it "VERY anti-town" seems to be pushing a bit stronger than needed. Sounds like someone pretending to be overly town.

 

Vote Des.

 

An early attempt to start a Barm bandwagon by making the third vote on page 1 would be bad enough, but then your late vote on Red made it a little too obvious. It was plain that there was going to be plenty of us making fos's in her direction, and it was so easy as to be lazy to jump on a Red wagon. And her whole "No Lynch" vote is nowhere near scummy as far as I can tell, just something to kickstart the game and get some reads on our reactions, to which I say, Mission Accomplished Red.

 

I quite agree with the Despothera vote, actually. When I was counting votes a while back he was a bandwagon vote both on me and on Red.

 

Okay, fair enough, establishes an opinion on the Desp vote. And tries to paint votes as "bandwagon" votes when I'd argue they were no such thing.

 

OMGUS much Des?

 

Reinforces dislike of Desp and ridiculousness of his ideas. Fair enough, but...

 

 

Just callin it like I see it Barm. You look at the points I brought up and tell me Ishy's not pinging right now. I know you might think I am, but take a step back really quick and pretend you don't already have bias against me.

 

I think the cases between you and Ishy are equally strong. You have been the 3rd or later person on both the "joke vote" for me and the vote for Red, and did an OMGUS vote on Ishy (with apparently great success).

 

Unvote, Vote: Despothera

 

Aaaand now Barm is saying that Desp's case on Ishy is equally strong? Attempts to paint the "bandwagon" votes in a more... bandwagony light. Also, side note: I don't see Bandwagons as a problem. I think that at somepoint, someone's got to take the lead on vote count and trying to paint all day 1 votes over 3 as scummy is odd to me. Playing the bandwagon card is a big WIFOM unless you are analyzing the votes retrospectively on later days. But when someone starts calling Bandwagon this and Bandwagon that, it kills the chances for that sort of analyis on later days.

 

You've made a lot of crap up to fit your own arguments there Lanth, and I'm not going to waste my time responding to it. Instead of making your own crap-logic up constantly, why don't you go back and actually read what people are posting.

 

Aw, now ya see? This is what I'm talking about. I thought Lanth's logic was fine. Sounds to me like Barm didn't read what Lanth (he/she?) said and therefore didn't respond.

 

 

 

Anyway. Then you were gone, so that pretty much sums it up.

[bgrishinko]

Now there aren't many people voting right now, and deadline is tonight. In good conscience, I want to avoid voting Nolder right now, but I may switch to him to avoid the Randomness, for now I'm going to have to vote on my pingiest read so far:

Vote Barm