Wheel of Time Mafia Game Thread

[dapianoplay3r]

Sorry dude but you are acting very scummy. I got home thinking I would go for Drew but after reading what I missed you changed my mind and that's why Im voting you.

UNVOTE, VOTE CURT

(I just always unvote now because I seem to forget to do it all the time and people think that's scummy)

[mcs0083]

VOTE CURT The Wheel weaves what the Wheel wills

[dapianoplay3r]

or in layman's terms "sh*t happens"

[killuliu]

Sorry for not posting yesterday (though I had one idea I already forgot, it was about something someone said :D), I have had hardly enough time to read this, let alone write. But as I said in my last post, I've been suspecting Curt and Drew for a while now, and I'm more than happy to vote CURT

[dapianoplay3r]

so we are about 3 or 4 votes away from a lynch right?

[Alanna]

I think it might be more like 1 or 2, but I'm not sure. Well, I likely won't be online again before the deadline, so I hope we reach a majority. I feel pretty good about this lynch.

[Myndrunner]

.... The Wheel weaves what the Wheel wills

 

 

or in layman's terms "sh*t happens"

 

This made me LMAO seriously! I think that when you sum up Robert Jordan's prologue, that's pretty much it!

[hotpocket2006]

Well as I have thought Curt was scum for awhile, I am for this lynch. So I will UNVOTE, VOTE CURT

[dapianoplay3r]

.... The Wheel weaves what the Wheel wills

 

 

or in layman's terms "sh*t happens"

 

This made me LMAO seriously! I think that when you sum up Robert Jordan's prologue, that's pretty much it!

 

thanks. I almost didnt post it because I thought it would be seen as a useless non pG13 comment. Im glad you liked it

[Talya]

WOW Everyone jumped on there quick.

 

Lets go with Curt

 

UNVOTE (just because I can't remember if I voted, don't think so but it has recently go me in trouble ) Oh and it doesn't help I'm coming down with flu!

 

VOTE CURT

[Myndrunner]

Awww, I hope you feel better Talya....

 

....even though the flu is no excuse for poor mafia gameplay!!!

[dapianoplay3r]

Oh gutted. The flu is going around my course too. So far I havent got it and im just keeping my fingers crossed

[Talya]

Awww, I hope you feel better Talya....

 

....even though the flu is no excuse for poor mafia gameplay!!!

 

I'll try to do good mafia game play then.,..

 

I actually really don't need this right now, It's the end of the year at work and I have things to get done, and I have my daughters show this week...I think I should just fall over and sleep for 48hours, lol

[Amadine]

Yes, yes, i know... i've been inactive. No excuses *rolleyes*

 

From what i have just read over the last few pages i'm happy with a vote on Curt or Drew. I understand that i have not gone to the effort of presenting my own casings but you do what you can when you can and right now i can't. I *think* Mynd is town, there's too many references to the same things and unless he keeps super detailed notes i think he would have slipped up somewhere along the line. Anyway to that end i will join the wagon on CURT and see which way the dice fall.

[trench]

I'll switch over for the consensus. Unvote Vote Curt

[CurtisScafe]

Oh well. i guess defending myself is scummy. Giving you a good case against someone is also scummy.

It is just so funny how quickly Mynd is believed even though I put the facts out there for everyone to see

 

37 players

9 Town dead

2 Mafia dead

2 Others dead

 

I'm guessing about 23 town 11 mafia give or take 2 from either for the neutral players

I'd say you have about 2 more nights unless you get really good. But based on what I've seen, letting someone lead you all around. I just wonder who the next town is to die.

 

I leave you will this: continue to follow Mynd and he will surely lead you to destruction

Farewell and good luck

[Verbal32]

Although a bit slanted perhaps by some scar tissue at the hands of my style, Verbal's assessment of my playstyle is close to accurate. I get reactions from folks and then use logic to dissect their reactions. Verbal may have been on to my logic trap in that Christmas Mafia game, but like Drew here, he still sprung it and it resulted in his mafia team losing.

 

My style is only distracting to those players who do not think for themselves. Nearly everyone in this game has been forming their own conclusions, so to argue that I am leading anyone is an obvious attempt at mudslinging.

 

We need to build a lynch on the player whose lynch will give us the most information either way:

 

Curtdragon - most suspicious from his overreaction to being on the list of possible mafia, and his subsequent posts have been laser-focused on one thing (discredit/lynch Mynd). Scum don't focus on people's casing they only post to discredit them. He hasn't done any casing of his own and newbie or not, he cannot back up his accusations.

 

Adella - lynching her will help either confirm of deny BG's mason team. She hasn't been very active and their alleged third mason team member remains incognito.

 

DrewoftheRushes - He sounded the alarm on my gambit before I could fully spring it. The moment I mentioned that I had targeted Drew, he freaked out. I was still casing CurtDragon and building a lynch on him at that point, so there was no need for him to react like that unless that was part of the mafia plan the whole time.

 

Aemon - the naive finder thing gives me pause. Unless the mod is keeping something from me, I have a full tilt power, as well as Vambram. It doesn't make sense that Aemon would be nerfed while Vam and I were not.

 

Those our the four options that I see. I can go with any of those four right now with confidence that we are doing the right thing for the town.

 

 

I still see you exaggerating on people's reactions, but I get your point. As the deadline is looming, I'll vote with you as I think you're town.

 

Vote: Drew

 

Actually, Verbal, Mynd's vote is with Adella.

 

Yeah, poor wording on my part. I was mostly referring to lynching one of his suspects, and not Mynd himself.

[Talya]

Oh well. i guess defending myself is scummy. Giving you a good case against someone is also scummy.

It is just so funny how quickly Mynd is believed even though I put the facts out there for everyone to see

 

37 players

9 Town dead

2 Mafia dead

2 Others dead

 

I'm guessing about 23 town 11 mafia give or take 2 from either for the neutral players

I'd say you have about 2 more nights unless you get really good. But based on what I've seen, letting someone lead you all around. I just wonder who the next town is to die.

 

I leave you will this: continue to follow Mynd and he will surely lead you to destruction

Farewell and good luck

 

Actually that's not quite right...Mafia should really be more than one quarter of the number, so we are looking at about 9, maybe 8 due to the other ones. So with 2 gone, there should be about 6, 7 at the most left.

[WWWwombat]

And deadline.

 

Day 6 Final Vote Count

 

Curt (13): Nyn, Alanna, Mynd, bg, Drew, Aemon, Moon, Play3r, mcs, killuliu, Song, Talya, trench

Mynd (2): CurtDragon

Drew (1): Verbal

 

With 25 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

[trench]

I thought BG switched over to Curt?

[Myndrunner]

For our convenience....

Players:

 

1. Song 1.<3, Perrin Aybara, Watcher - nightkilled Night 2

2. Austicles, Hurin, Cop - nightkilled Night 5

3. ed2scumy mcs

4. Amoondah, Morgase Trakand, Vanilla Townie - lynched Day 4

5. Alanna

6. AJ (alannalynn)

7. Aemon

8. dapianoplay3r 1.0, Min Farshaw, Limited Flavor Cop - lynched Day 2

9. Amadine

10. Krak

11. Kwom Masbag

12. TMD

13. keyholder Ahmoondah

14. Verbal

15. Red, Moiraine Damodred, Jack of All Trades - killed by the Pattern Day 5

16. Adella

17. Mynd

18. paetric Song 2.0

19. Locke, Aviendha, Commuter - nightkilled Night 4

20. drewoftherushes

21. CurtDragon

22. Virtuhall

23. Quibby

24. stryder68, Faile Bashere, Vanilla Townie - modkilled Day 2

25. tobi Naeann 2.0

26. bgrishinko

27. Naeann 1.0, Padan Fain/Mordeth, Item Conditional Serial Killer - nightkilled Night 1

28. trench

29. Vambram, Mazrim Taim, Survivor/Framer - nightkilled Night 5

30. gadywe, High Lord Turak, Vanilla Townie - modkilled Day 2

31. killuliu

32. Deadlyfreind Talya

33. Tigraine dapianoplay3r 2.0

34. ThorkinBarrimore

35. David Hermes, Be'lal, Mafia Roleblocker - lynched Day 1

36. Blackhoof, High Lady Suroth Sabelle Meldarath, Mafia Goon - lynched Day 3

37. Nyn

 

Day 6 Deadline: Tuesday, Noon ET

 

Probability mumbo-jumbo: Let's check the math here.....1/4 of 37 is about 9-ish, so take away Fain and you are left with about 6-7 mafia total. We've already whacked a goon (Suroth) and power-blocker (Be'lal). I'll bet there are four scum left, two are likely Forsaken and two are likely goons. With about 25 players, that gives us still quite a reasonable advantage. The number of innocents downed seems high because of the total number of players in the game, but proportion-wise, it is actually quite even. For every one town threat we've taken out in some way, we've only lost 3 townies. I'd say we are pretty much evenly locked, and depending on how Curt flips, we might be better off.

 

Now then, from a logic standpoint, BG knows who his mason teammates are so unless he's a scumbag, he and his team can remove three names from the list of remaining suspects instead of just his own.

 

Remaining players in the game after Curt's lynch....for casing purposes, I've left the names of those that were replaced:

ed2scumy mcs

Alanna

AJ (alannalynn)

Aemon

Amadine

Krak

Kwom Masbag

TMD

keyholder Ahmoondah

Verbal

Adella

Mynd

paetric Song 2.0

drewoftherushes

Virtuhall

Quibby

tobi Naeann 2.0

bgrishinko

trench

killuliu

Deadlyfreind Talya

Tigraine dapianoplay3r 2.0

ThorkinBarrimore

Nyn

 

Look at the list above and eliminate those you are quite sure are innocent. From the remaining list of people, there are likely only 4 or so scum left. I'd say from a ratio standpoint, we are in pretty good shape.

 

****

EDIT AFTER WOMBY: BG's vote on Curt didn't count, or wasn't done properly?

[Myndrunner]

Due to the testimonies that many in the town, as well as another in BG's mason team who had played with Mynd before, had given of Mynd's play style, BG was reluctantly willing to put off his suspicions once more until a future date.

 

This did not mean BG felt Mynd was town for sure. Only that the testimonies had appeased BG for now. So he UNVOTE: VOTE CURT

 

^^^ Either this was missed, or there is a vote-swisher out there! Appears that someone didn't want Curt to go down, or we are meant to think they don't. The game is definitely afoot!

[WWWwombat]

Fixed it. Writing up a scene.

[DrewRiley]

 

Probability mumbo-jumbo: Let's check the math here.....1/4 of 37 is about 9-ish, so take away Fain and you are left with about 6-7 mafia total. We've already whacked a goon (Suroth) and power-blocker (Be'lal). I'll bet there are four scum left, two are likely Forsaken and two are likely goons. With about 25 players, that gives us still quite a reasonable advantage. The number of innocents downed seems high because of the total number of players in the game, but proportion-wise, it is actually quite even. For every one town threat we've taken out in some way, we've only lost 3 townies. I'd say we are pretty much evenly locked, and depending on how Curt flips, we might be better off.

 

9-1=6? I agree that there were probably 9 mafia to start out with, but I wouldn't necessarily count Fain as one of those. Even if you do, though, then when he died there would have been 8 mafia left. We killed two, so we're left with six, not four. And that's at minimum. I'd say we're looking at 6-7 mafia still alive, and with 24 total (after this kill), that means 17-18 town (maybe one more lone role, too). I agree we're still in okay shape, but your math isn't working, Mynd.

[Myndrunner]

Drew, we sacked 2 mafia players. Now, if there were two mafia teams and you were on one, I can understand you only feeling like you lost one player, but from the town perspective, we've sacked 2 mafia players, and I would definitely include a serial killer as a threat to the town, so 3 total threats were sacked from 9, which is roughly 1/4 of 36.

 

So Drew, how is your mafia team broken down? Is it Forsaken on one team and maybe Black Ajah on the other? Or does each Forsaken have their own set of goons, or in your case (Graendal) pets?