Harry Potter Mafia Maddness <Game Over - Congrads Town & Siblings>

Wayward_fool · May 31, 2010

[quote author=WWWwombat link=topic=58099.msg1692674#msg1692674

In other words there is no possibility of an "empty day." So what's your real reason for voting Mynd?

Well I wanted to make sure there was someone "with the most votes"? At least this way we can make sure it's someone we choose as opposed to a possible tie and a random.org result.

Make sense?

That and I'm not really keen on ending Day one without a vote.

Thorum · May 31, 2010

Bear with me, I've got 10 pages of catching-up to do. This post may, no, will get long.

Unless there is something more to Ama than has already been said she'd be nothing but a confirmed innocent and the healer is far more important than a plain miller.

I don't think mafia will kill either of us as long as both of us are alive. They'd give town a 'known innocent' for free.

There's a good chance there are likely to be Mafia on Thorum's votes there.

OF COURSE there is. I have 10 votes atm...

There's a good chance there are likely to be Mafia on Thorum's votes there.

Nothing against you Talya love... but this cracks me up when people constantly say this. NO KIDDING! There are likely mafia NOT on the vote too. ::) That's like announcing we are playing a Harry Potter themed mafia game.

See?

Welcome back, Wolfie!!!

No hard feelings, I hope?

Btw, there's still a lot of votes on me. Either you believe our claim or you don't. If you do, take your vote away. Just a free suggestion of mine ;D

Is that fear I'm sensing?

More like the beginning of exasperation.

I don't like any of this...just so you all know. Thorum reveals the best possible claim for a scum to make and Amadine confirms him which means ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. (sorry Ama) Then Thorum goes all self sacrificing and votes himself. I have done this in a game where I was innocent because I was frustrated and it pretty much caused us to lose the game. I think it is a ploy to make people think, "Oh poor Thorum, he must be telling the truth if he's gonna vote himself to get away from the aggrivation."

Here's what I think about it: I know that if Thorum flips innocent then I will be targeted heavily and I'll deal with that when it comes. Innocent or not, someone that will vote themselves is of no use to the town in my opinion. If we have to lose an innocent, who better to lose than someone that bails when it gets aggrivating *shrugs* Thorum

Here's what I think. I'm going to take this one bolded section at a time. Please bear with me. First of all, it DOES mean something that she confirmed him. If he flips innocent, we have to presume that she is innocent as well. The opposite also applies. She has to know that if he flips scum, she is doomed. This is what gives me pause. We still have until Monday to vote.

Secondly, it is much too early in a 41 player game to think that he is going to cause us to lose. Day 1 almost always ends in the lynch of an innocent. Just because he is frustrated now does not mean he would not be valuable later in the game (if innocent).

Finally, this just looks like you're trying to avoid the repurcussions if he flips innocent. This post is really making me take a harder look at you, Tigs.

aemon, why is the tenth person who votes for me worth a harder look than the eigth (for example)? There probably is a logical explanation.

I find myself beliving amadine's sirius claim, it would make sense for sirius and dung to have contact in the game as they are both in the order. Mynd however is pinging my radar, although it will most likely mke little diffrence in the outcome of todays lynch i am going to [glow=red,2,300]unvote Thorum [/glow] and [glow=red,2,300]vote Mynd[/glow]

I don't know how this could fit in any kind of mafia ploy. Check out the votecount just above this post.

If he doesn't get lynched and then his number comes up again, you are crazy to think his reaction won't be exactly the same.

Like I do in every game?

No, the thing which made me pull the switch Thursday was double:

- EVERY proposition I made was seen as an extra reason why I was mafia, instead of being given an honest chance (the proposition, that is);

- You talked about me for 15 pages. About nothing else.

I'll continue later. I'm at the end of page 23.

Wayward_fool · May 31, 2010

I have no diea how my ost ended up being formatted like that. *grumbles* Oh well...

Wolfie · May 31, 2010

*pats Boopsy's back* No worries.

Talya · May 31, 2010

You wondered why I mentioned that someone on your vote would be Mafia, you may think it obvious. I then mentioned about Mynd being a little quieter than usual.

The votes:

Mynd: Dah, Som1, Meesh, Amadine, Pete, Locke, rojano, player, Krak, Boopsy

Thorum: Mynd, Meesh, Verb, Rose, Som1, Boopsy, Aust. Charis, Alanna, Thorum, tigs, Wolfie

So after I mentioned that, Meesh, Som1 and Boopsy transferred their votes to Mynd. As Thorum mentioned night killing him or Amadine proves the other as innocent, so would lynching. The Mafia would prefer to keep that ambiguity. So we now have three names to really look at. I have a good feeling that at least one of these three is Mafia.

I'm going to go with [glow=red,2,300]Boopsy[/glow] Because out of the three he already has a vote on him, and I don't want to add someone new to this. I also think that his swapping votes around a little more than others. And mainly because of what I have mentioned above!

Thorum · May 31, 2010

So, with nowhere else to go: [glow=red,2,300]Thorum.[/glow] (And I figure it probably won't matter much considering we don't need majority vote)

You feel the insurpressable need to bandwagon. I get that ::)

I'm pretty sure the MOD said EVERYONE would have a role, and I believe she meant power by that, not character).

I believe the same.

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow] and I am going to vote [glow=red,2,300]Mynd[/glow] even though from the posts that Dar has made I am more inclined to

believe her scum.

Strange thing to say when a bandwagon is only just starting on Mynd...

You have some valid points there Meesh. I agree that he'd be a better bet than Thorum, who's claims with Amadine seemed to be honest.

I'll be curious to see Mynd's reaction though.

You're changing your vote quick enough to make your previous vote look less strange. Probably more like a quick scan or something?

I don't even have to type the reaction to the next one myself:

Unvote. Vote Mynd

Any particular reason? Otherwise this is the very definition of a bandwagon vote.

rojano is now pinging.

Oh, yeah i forgot. *giggles* I vote for [glow=red,2,300]Thorum[/glow].

why vote for a vouched innocent?

1. Because I vig killed her

2. Because my vote was on her.

3. Because I vig killed her.

4. Because she's not the only one.

5. Because I vig killed her.

I'm gonna post this. Will read on later.

Thorum · May 31, 2010

Also, Pete, I wouldn't call Thorum "semi-confirmed" either. All Amadine's claim does is link her alignment to Thorum's. That makes it less likely that Thorum is scum imo, but it nowhere near confirms him.

No one has counterclaimed either Dung or Sirius.

Which makes it a LOT less likely the two of us are scum.

Thorum · May 31, 2010

Sorry, I pressed 'Post' while I wanted to copy the previous post here. I've stil gotta read 3 pages (28 and onwards)

but I also am keeping an eye on Daruya. Pete mentioned that andit reminded me, but so far she hasn't said anything really contradictory so I still feel Mynd is the better candidate.

What's suspicious about Daruya?

I haven't seen much of Mynd

Before the bandwagon on him started there was quite a lot of Mynd. Now he's cooled down...

Thorum · May 31, 2010

[glow=red,2,300]Mynd[/glow] for lack of another option at the moment.

What about Thorum, or any of the other players?

I have no diea how my ost ended up being formatted like that. *grumbles* Oh well...

It's readable. You deleted a

']'

too much.

So after I mentioned that, Meesh, Som1 and Boopsy transferred their votes to Mynd. As Thorum mentioned night killing him or Amadine proves the other as innocent, so would lynching. The Mafia would prefer to keep that ambiguity. So we now have three names to really look at. I have a good feeling that at least one of these three is Mafia.

I'm going to go with [glow=red,2,300]Boopsy[/glow] Because out of the three he already has a vote on him, and I don't want to add someone new to this. I also think that his swapping votes around a little more than others. And mainly because of what I have mentioned above!

I can see where you get this, but it's still only 'probably', and one chance in three as opposed to one chance in four (if that's the case). Maybe on a normal day I would follow, but now I have to try saving myself.

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Mynd[/glow]

WWWwombat · May 31, 2010

So Thorum is back and making sense. I still see this Mynd bandwagon as pretty scummy, but it looks inevitable now. I might as well help you guys along I guess.

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Mynd[/glow]

I also find it odd that Mynd hasn't said anything in his defense. At this point, I would rather see him lynched than Thorum though, as Thorum is less likely to be scum imo and he appears to be back and ready to help the town. That being said, if Mynd flips innocent, I will be looking very hard at those who started and contributed to his bandwagon.

aemonkristen · May 31, 2010

In my opinion, there are too many people just jumping on the Mynd bandwagon without any reasoning. I could understand last minute votes, but this thing started 2 days ago and grew fast. I don't see Mynd as being scummy and therefore will not vote for him. I will instead vote for [glow=red,2,300]Boopsy[/glow] because of the nonchalant way he voted Mynd, acting as though he were unsure of himself. He knows exactly what he is doing and I think he's just trying to set up an excuse if anyone calls him on it when Mynd flips innocent.

Naeann · May 31, 2010

Boopsy does tend to act somewhat confused when he's mafia. Makes everyone overlook him because who would want to lynch a sweet little boopsy?

However... in Thorum's reread and posts he pointed out... Pete threw a vote on Mynd before the bandwagon really picked up steam and stated that he didn't really find Mynd suspicious but was gonna vote him...

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote

Vote Pete.[/glow]

Naeann · May 31, 2010

Nevermind went back and looked.. he was 5th vote so he voted him basically JUST to bandwagon... either way my vote goes to Pete.

Dahmir · May 31, 2010

Just checking in and just reading up on the pages and to let you guys know that i wont be around for the rest of the day til tonight because today its Fleet week here in NYC and its my first time going so yeah lol. Sorry, wont have any pictures of the ships that i will be visiting...lame i know. Anyways, by the way things look, its either Thorum and Mynd who will get lynched.

Red2111 · May 31, 2010

Deadline

Monday, May 31st @ 2pm CST; 39 alive, 20 to lynch

Vote Count

Mynd (13): Dah'mir, Som1, Meesh, Amadine, Pete, Locke, rojano, Player, Krak, Boopsy, Thorum, Wombat

Thorum(8 ): Mynd, Verbal, Rose, Aust, Charis, Alanna, Tigs, Wolfie

Dah'mir(2): Mottlee, Elli

Rose(1): Crusher

Boopsy(3): Nyn, Tayla, Aemon

Wombat (1): Adella

Aemon(1): Pookie

Nyn(1): Marta

Amadine(1): Pankhuri

Pete(1): Nea

no vote (11): Bela, Daruya, Lia, Aemon, Talya,Summer, Blig Blog, Danya, Taei, Jeran, Koujin

** Names in Red have not checked in and are subject to being punished by the mods come Night

May 31, 2010

Nevermind went back and looked.. he was 5th vote so he voted him basically JUST to bandwagon... either way my vote goes to Pete.

I got some nae love.

I voted to bandwagon myn because he hadthe most votes besides thorum who in my opponion was the most likely innocent among the two. Both could be innocent but mynd stands a better chance of being scum.

I am suspicous of daruya for some long ago quoted reason I gave, but I don't have the time to look it up now.

Red2111 · May 31, 2010

As the trian made its last approach to Hogsmead Trainstation, a heated debate broke out in a compartment about who was guilty. A figure in the watching crowd felt a wonderful floating sensation overcome them; as they drifted inward toward the pleasant sensation they were only dimly aware of the argument still unfolding. A suggestive, yet fimilar, voice echoed through their mind.

"Use the Time Turner."

A small part of him tried to rebel, but the pleasantness began to turn to pain; as the pain lifted, the voice echoed once more in his mind, slighlty more commanding this time.

"USE the Time Turner."

He nodded his head, reaching obediently into the neck of his robes and tugging on a fine golden chian; a tiny, sparkling hourglass fell into his hands. The voice echoing in his head was heavy with satisfaction, the pleasant sensation only increased.

"Good, now turn it 4 times. Then you are to exit the compartment and hide until the trian reaches Hogwarts."

Again he gave a nod and obediently turned the Hourglass over 4 times; the cabin filled with people began to disolve and colors began to blur together and he was rushed back into time. A sudden jolt of his feet landing on concrete jolted him out of the mysterious sensation, the voice no longer echoing in his ears.

Stumbling in confusion he looked around to see the Hogwarts Express back on Platform 9 & 3/4'd and everyone starting to board. Shocked and confused he stood there a bit dumbfounded before reaching for the door and walking off the train with the hood of his cloak pulled up.

Passing through the crowd he spotted himself and stopped to look; quickly he pointed his wand at himself, aiming where he knew the Time Turner lay hidden, and shot a spell to break it. A startled yelp was the last thing her heard before he disolved into thin air.

Day 1 has been restarted; all Day Abilities can be re-used.

Deadline

Wed, June 2nd @ 2pm CST; 39 alive, 20 to lynch

Vote Count

no vote (39): Meesh, Amadine, Wombat, Bela, Elli, Mottlee, Marta, Som1else, Thorum, Aust, Krak, Mynd, Daruya, Lia, Aemon, Pete, Boopsy, Nae, Adella, Talya, Tigs, Summer, Pookie, Player, Verbal, Dah'mir, Pankhuri, Wolfie, Alanna, Locke, Charis, Blig Blog, Jeran, Danya, Rose, Nyn, rojano, Taei, Crusher, Koujin

** Names in Red have not checked in and are subject to being punished by the mods come Night

Adella · May 31, 2010

Wait so.. What? Who died?

Red2111 · May 31, 2010

Day 1's been reset. just edited the post to reflect that ;)

aemonkristen · May 31, 2010

Well, I still think [glow=red,2,300]Boopsy [/glow] is one acting most like scum at the moment. My vote stays with him.

Thorum · May 31, 2010

Nice one ;D

[glow=red,2,300]Boopsy[/glow]

See a couple of posts ago.

Red2111 · May 31, 2010

Deadline

Wed, June 2nd @ 2pm CST; 39 alive, 20 to lynch

Vote Count

Boopsy(2): Aemon, Thorum

no vote (37): Meesh, Amadine, Wombat, Bela, Elli, Mottlee, Marta, Som1else, Aust, Krak, Mynd, Daruya, Lia, Pete, Boopsy, Nae, Adella, Talya, Tigs, Summer, Pookie, Player, Verbal, Dah'mir, Pankhuri, Wolfie, Alanna, Locke, Charis, Blig Blog, Jeran, Danya, Rose, Nyn, rojano, Taei, Crusher, Koujin

** Names in Red have not checked in and are subject to being punished by the mods come Night

Myndrunner · May 31, 2010

OMFG!!!! I thought I was dead!!! WOOOOO HOOOO!!!! HOOOWWWWWWLLLLL!!!! Do I owe this miracle to sweet Hermoine? I love muggles!

I was totally expecting to be reading my lynch scene this afternoon and I get a nice friendly ole PM stating that it was all a horrible nightmare! Did ya miss me?!

First of all, without risking a Modkill, all I can say is that I was cooled off by someone at the most inopportune time. My feets were frozen in my tracks and I was unable to point out the GLARING flaws in the logic of those gunning for what became a very easy bandwagon.

...and I was afraid I wouldn't even get to use my awesome ability tonight!

Now, let me sink my teeth into this new batch of information, and I will try not to sound barking mad when I do this, but the scummy mcscummersons have revealed themselves!

I'll be right back...I got some quoting to do.....but I will first leave you all with this!

Was I frozen to keep from unvoting Thorum? Or was I frozen to not answer for my own lynch? Or both?

Thorum · May 31, 2010

At what time exactly were you frozen? Before or after I voted myself? If after, how many votes did you have at that time?

mmeeshal · May 31, 2010

Heh, Mynd being frozen would explain his silence.

Harry Potter Mafia Maddness <Game Over - Congrads Town & Siblings>

Recommended Posts

Guest dragonsworn1991

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook