[Rey Mafia] Julius Caesar - THE CONSPIRATORS HAVE KILLED CAESAR!

[Al Jenn Mael]

If you were mafia you would have been pretty sure that wombat was the finder.

 

False. Ed was a townie recruited to the Cult. Most likely neither group (Aside from the cult) new who was who.

 

He only mentioned you

 

Right after Wombat died Ed said that Lia, Alanna, and Pale were scum. Lia fliped innocent. He did say he was going to send Tigs in, but was recruited/killed first. I may be wrong, if so please find the quote.

 

As for Tigs, you seem innocent enough, but that doesn't mean anything. I'm tempted to start fishing now that we can guess most of the rolls. I'll wait till tomorrow...

 

A good question Tigs, why were you in such a rush to vote Pale. You have to post each day not vote... As long as you typed 'here' you could have left...?

 

[a pale tanned lover]

False. Ed was a townie recruited to the Cult. Most likely neither group (Aside from the cult) new who was who.

It would be easy for the mafia to spot. Ask yourself a question if you were mafia would you vote for the lie detector or finder?

[a pale tanned lover]

Right after Wombat died Ed said that Lia, Alanna, and Pale were scum. Lia fliped innocent. He did say he was going to send Tigs in, but was recruited/killed first. I may be wrong, if so please find the quote.

Ed makes bold statements in all his games, he also said he lied about knowing Tigs was innocent, if she was mafia i think he would have said since he would have only won with the cult.

[Tigraine]

Yeah I know that he said I was innocent, I'm trying to point out the fact that everything that he said means nothing. I'm saying that just because he said people were innocent doesn't mean that it is still true or ever was.  I am innocent but I can't speak for the rest of the group!

He only mentioned you ;D

 

He mentioned a lot of people...he was the lie detector!

 

You've posted quite a few quotes from other people, trying to put suspicion on everyone and finding meanings in their words that just aren't there.  Don't you understand that this makes you look scummy?

[a pale tanned lover]

He mentioned a lot of people...he was the lie detector!

No he said he checked you, not everyone else.

You've posted quite a few quotes from other people, trying to put suspicion on everyone and finding meanings in their words that just aren't there.  Don't you understand that this makes you look scummy?

Should i post my own quotes then and talk about them? I only posted your quotes after Al had asked me and pete about you, same with wayward Fool.

 

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Well Ed was telling the truth about someone, or at least that is what I got from Rey's post

[a pale tanned lover]

Well Ed was telling the truth about someone, or at least that is what I got from Rey's post

A pm or on here?

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

----

 

Cicero paused as he observed the paper he had found concelealed in the bust of Caesar. He had spent the best part of the night searching, while most of the Romans lay asleep, one strewn not a cubit from him, snoring insensibly. It read "Truth from a liar is often not trusted. But sometimes it is truth nonetheless." A riddle of some sort. Well, he would have this solved in not time at all. He was Cicero after all - legendary philosopher and senator - one of the most respected minds in the civilised world.

 

He froze, turning slowly at what he knew had not been a natural sound. As he turned and faced his death, his eyes widened in shock. Then the axe was embedded into his skull.

 

Naeann, Cicero, leader of the Orator's Cult is dead.

 

 

 

I bolded the relevant part.

[a pale tanned lover]

Well Ed did claim about six or seven people were mafia, including you and me.

[Alanna]

Hmm. Well if that's true, my bet is on Pale. Tigs could be included in that as well, but Pale looks more suspicious to me right now. He was kind of lying low for a lot of the game, and then when Pete called him on it, he started making arguments against everyone else.

[Tigraine]

He mentioned a lot of people...he was the lie detector!

No he said he checked you, not everyone else.

 

This is a stupid arguement...our lie detector checked more than me.  I made the statement that just because he cleared somebody doesn't mean that it was true or is true. 

[a pale tanned lover]

Hmm. Well if that's true, my bet is on Pale. Tigs could be included in that as well, but Pale looks more suspicious to me right now. He was kind of lying low for a lot of the game, and then when Pete called him on it, he started making arguments against everyone else.

Actually Ed isn't playing anymore so i would post more on here.......sure anyone who doesn't just want to spam a mafia game will understand......

 

[a pale tanned lover]

He mentioned a lot of people...he was the lie detector!

No he said he checked you, not everyone else.

 

This is a stupid arguement...our lie detector checked more than me.  I made the statement that just because he cleared somebody doesn't mean that it was true or is true. 

Who else did he check apart from lily?

he said he lied about checking you....after that he was just throwing out names....including Nae

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

[glow=red,2,300]Pale[/glow] what do you mean Ed only accused Tigs, that isn't true he accused 85% of the current people playing.

 

Explain yourself please.

[Tynaal Consen]

Can we actually base so much on ed's claims?

 

I say he prolly threw in some mafia names inbetween townies, making their claims on innocent likely if any other of ed's viewed people were killed and flippend innocent

[Al Jenn Mael]

WAIT! I hate contradicting myself... but didn't Ed view Nae?

 

It makes no sense from how he acted later and everything I can piece together about the cult, but...

[mcs0083]

So what are you saying Al?

[a pale tanned lover]

[glow=red,2,300]Pale[/glow] what do you mean Ed only accused Tigs, that isn't true he accused 85% of the current people playing.

 

Explain yourself please.

On day 3 Ed said he had viewed Tig and she was innocent.

 

[Reyoru]

Vote Count - Day Four

Boopsy (2) - MCS, Al

Pale (2) - Pete, Boopsy

 

Not voting - meercatman, Alanna, Tynaal, Tigs, Pookie, Pale

 

[glow=green,2,300]With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch[/glow]

 

Daedline is Monday 9.30pm GMT

[Pookie]

I can see where Boopsy's coming from on the town cult thing, though I'm not sure I agree.  Ed said he viewed Nae on day 1 and that she was telling the truth with her not-anti-town statement.  I seriously doubt that Nae had a day 1 recruit, so Ed would have had no reason to lie about finding her guilty.  A pro-town cult would be a really weird idea, but this game hasn't been entirely conventional.  ;)  I'm just not sure it's THAT unconventional.  An off-the-wall idea isn't enough to make me vote for Boopsy.

 

I've been thinking about the SK quite a bit.  Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't SKs usually show up as "town" for finders?  So wouldn't a SK be much more interested in lynching a revealed LD rather than a revealed finder?  I looked at the vote lists and besides Wombat and myself, the votes for Ed were Pale and Alanna when we lynched Wombat.  Based on her posts, I think Alanna is town and just didn't trust Ed.  [glow=red,2,300]Pale[/glow] on the other hand has been pinging me since his day 2 vote and his recent posts have only made me wonder more.

[Reyoru]

Vote Count - Day Four

 

Pale (3) - Pete, Boopsy, Pookie

Boopsy (2) - MCS, Al

 

Not voting - meercatman, Alanna, Tynaal, Tigs, Pale

 

[glow=green,2,300]With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch[/glow]

 

Deadline is Monday 9.30pm GMT

[Alanna]

Pookie, I think sometimes SKs can show up as innocent. It's one of the ways for the mod to give them more of a chance to win. But they don't always show up innocent. Still, I agree with your reasoning. Boopsy seemed a little suspicious to me at first, but I think he was just getting frustrated. So I'm going for [glow=red,2,300]Pale[/glow].

[Tigraine]

Can we actually base so much on ed's claims?

 

I say he prolly threw in some mafia names inbetween townies, making their claims on innocent likely if any other of ed's viewed people were killed and flippend innocent

 

This was my point from the start!  Pale took it and turned it into something totally irrelevant. Call it what you will but [glow=red,2,300]Pale[/glow]

[Al Jenn Mael]

I like your reasoning and agree with it Pookie but looking at the voting pattern I'm not willing to change my vote and vote Pale...

 

He got 3 votes on him awefully quickly... and that makes me suspicious.

 

I'm going to wait to hear what he has to say and hope that Pete can figure out something.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

It all hinges on Pale's reply. He got awfully argumentative when I just threw out a suspicoun I had and I dodn't even vote. That is what raised some red flags in my mind, and then his constant gunning for tigs doesn't sit well with me. After Ed accused most of the game thread of being scum, sure he had to get someone correct.