Mafia - A Christmas Tale - Mafia Won

[WWWwombat]

T_T

[LedZepMan]

lol. well, we might have another shot. if the mafia doesnt send in a nk, or there is only three scum. I pray that is so

[WWWwombat]

I don't get this.  Why was Locke so complacent about his lynch when he knew it would probably lose us the game?

[LedZepMan]

i dunno, never happened to me before. I dont think.....too many games.

 

probably resignation

[mmeeshal]

And "commuter" is clearly a role of some sort...he could've roleclaimed it and there's no way I wouldn't have believed him, because I don't know what it refers to and I wouldn't believe he'd be making that up...

 

Oh well.  He was innocent, that's all we need to know, it's night time and we need to start praying.

[LedZepMan]

i didn't even notice that.........anyone have any idea on what a commuter is?

[WWWwombat]

http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Commuter

 

Idk if he claimed commuter I might have believed him.  It's hard to tell what i would've done though.

[LedZepMan]

that is definately......wierd

[a pale tanned lover]

I wish Locke had revealed. If we survive tonight then i'm going to be looking at you Meesh.

[Reyoru]

Oh CRAP.

 

Guys I think we just bit the bullet.

 

Now we gotta hope it leaves through a natural orifice without doing any damage. Yep, I just went there.

[mmeeshal]

Bah...Our Healer definitely has a tough Night ahead...  This is going to SUCK if they don't guess right.

 

Yeah, the commuter role is weird...I would've believed him, because I wouldn't really believe he'd go do the research to make a false claim like that.

 

Why look at me, Pale?  I was hardly the first person to want to vote Locke.  Hardly the only one convinced he was scum too.  If you guys go after me during the Day (provided the Healer saves our butts or the night kill isn't sent in) you'll be wasting your time in a huge way.

[LilyElizabeth]

Okay. You're all correct. I've been trying to avoid sharing my thoughts because I didn't want to seem even scummier than I have already managed to be. Rey, that's what you picked up, I'm guessing. Just remember, the more innocent I appear, the guiltier I am, which practically confirms me this game......lol. (A bit of sick humor there.) Al Jenn, I am not a good loser. Sorry. I'm very competitive and used to winning. I'll try to deal with that on my own, so as not to annoy you.

 

So, here goes..... I can't dig myself a hole any deeper, can I?  ;D

 

I think the roleblocker can only function some nights, like odd-numbers or something. If I'm right, we'll know in the morning, and I will look scummy for having my theory confirmed. Either that, or it's not a mafia role, and the person blocked me by accident. That's a low probability, in my opinion, because I did claim to be finder. I'm going with the first theory.

 

I believe Al Jenn and Rey as much as I believe anyone in a mafia game. I've seen Meesh play mafia, and she's tricky, I'll give her that, but she has not pinged my radar since Day One. I'm believing her for now.

 

Whatever I do, Pale tries to make it look bad. I wonder if he's the Godfather? I've had a Godfather who showed innocent upon all views, so I'm not wasting a second view on him at this time, but I strongly suspect him.

 

Ellie is high on my list of suspects. I'm metagaming, but she never posts a great deal, and this game, she's really quiet. I always suspect her, but oddly, nobody else ever seems to much.

 

Wombat is so likeable, I'd hate to get him (is it him? I'm not sure) killed, which is no reason not to...lol

 

Zeppy pings my radar with every post. I don't have a reason, beyond screaming instincts

 

Meercat, I get nothing, one way or the other.

 

Those are my thoughts. Dissect them if you wish. I'm sending in my night action and crossing my fingers. I want that flipping roleblocker!

 

 

 

[Reyoru]

Sound reasoning, on the whole

 

Good luck Lily  ;)

[Reyoru]

Meercatman must be scum. I just know it.

[WWWwombat]

  Quote

Wombat is so likeable, I'd hate to get him (is it him? I'm not sure) killed, which is no reason not to...lol

 

Aww thanks.  And yes I am male.  It's good to hear your thoughts on the matter.  I don't know why you suspect Pale so much.  He doesn't seem to be gunning for you since you found him innocent.  I have no idea what to think about Meesh, and I still think meercatman is scum, but I agree with you on Elli, LZM, Rey, and Al Jenn.

[mmeeshal]

Good thoughts, Lily, if a bit late. :P

 

Rey, that was kind of out-of-the-blue, makes me think of some code or something. :D  I've been there, done that, with the whole mafia code thing.  Heh, a thought...there's very little that mafia can do that I haven't experienced in some form or another...  Obviously that doesn't make me any more skilled at scumhunting though. >.<

 

Anyway...I don't even remember what I was going to say.  Oh.  Now I remember.  These suspicions are good, it just kind of sucks that we're doing this now, when it may not even make a difference in the end because we might all be dead come Morning.

 

**edit new**

Wombat, that's an excellent point about Pale ("he doesn't seem to be gunning for you since you found him innocent.").  Makes him sound more Godfatherlike or something. :D

[WWWwombat]

  Quote

Wombat, that's an excellent point about Pale ("he doesn't seem to be gunning for you since you found him innocent.").  Makes him sound more Godfatherlike or something. :D

 

I think it's exactly how an innocent in his situation would behave as well, so I don't think it tells us anything.

[a pale tanned lover]

  Quote

Why look at me, Pale?  I was hardly the first person to want to vote Locke.

No but you were the most driven.

  Quote

Whatever I do, Pale tries to make it look bad. I wonder if he's the Godfather? I've had a Godfather who showed innocent upon all views, so I'm not wasting a second view on him at this time, but I strongly suspect him.

Actually i just made valid points, nothing too do with making you look bad.

[mmeeshal]

Nah, not really.  Just the most active poster, so I obviously came across as being the one who wanted him dead the most.  While I was indeed very focused, it wasn't on Locke, it was on trying to get the right lynch.  I wasn't trying to stall the hammer on Locke, but at the same time I don't think it would've hurt if we'd actually remembered we had till tomorrow to reach a majority.  I was pretty sure Locke was scum but I wasn't yelling at everyone to jump on his lynch train; in fact, one reason I got kind of mad at Zep was because he voted Locke because he had nothing else to go on, except Elli.  While it was mildly irritating that he ended up deciding to switch his vote away from Locke after our spat, I was okay with that because at least he was putting his vote where he thought it belonged.

 

That's all I wanted, a correct lynch.  Not necessarily a Locke lynch.  I even prodded him multiple times to defend himself, or go down fighting if he was truly a Townie.  I didn't want to end up facing this crap toNight, but oh well, now I am.

[meercatman]

The only reason I don't post much is that when there is the most activity on the site, it is early in the morning here and I am asleep. When I am on most there is not much happening. As well as that, I am an newbie, so I am unable to give massive long analyisis like meesh would. And what makes you think that scum don't post much?

 

And to me, Pale, Led and Wombat are the most scummy. I beleive that rey and al are masons, and I trust Lilly as being the cop. Meesh seems to be fighting the hardest for the town, although that could just be to hide scummynessness. Elli hasn't posted much so it is hard to tell.

[Al Jenn Mael]

Well the hat I don't have is off to the mafia, you have had 6 straight unanswered townie kills. If we survive the night which I believe we will, it means that there are only 3 (or less) mafia. Since the town has had so many abilities (Commuter, Mason Group, Double voter, Finder*, and Healer*) (*Unconfirmed, but likely) it makes sense that the mafia has been balanced similarly. I can't see how 3 mafia would balance out but I will believe that they have a godfather, a role blocker, and maybe just a regular goon.

 

For better or worse I'm going to believe you Lily. As much as I would prefer not to, it is time to stand strong if we can. Tomorrow might also be a good time for the Dr. to make an appearance. Being in the background has been an advantage thus far, but the more 'confirmed' or 'highly likely' townies we can get the better.

 

Pale I think you're the Godfather. Simple as that.

 

Meesh I don't know how elaborate of a lie you can construct, but I really suspicious but... well who knows.

 

Honestly my suspicions thus far have sucked. With everyone who I believe to be Scum turning out to be innocent it in turn makes the few remaining... Well you can see obviously enough.

 

Meer/Led/Wombat you are all pretty balanced in my opinion.

 

There are 9 people left. So I shall assume 6 townies and 3 mafia or we lose pretty much. We have a finder, some masons, and most likely a doctor. That makes 4 of 6. So that makes an unclaimed doctor and two vanilla townies.

 

I still think Ellie is the Dr. and I will run with that until evidence proves to the contrary. She NEEDS to post, in fact Talya should have Mod Killed her most likely by now.

 

Well guys I hope I see you in the morning, for now I'm going to go and make as many dolls and presents for Christmas as possible. So if we die Santa can still bring happiness to the world.

 

***TALYA****

Since we can't talk out of game to Ellie can you please PM her, please!

************

[LilyElizabeth]

Al Jenn, you make some good points. I do think the third mafia member has an ability, too, though I don't know what it is. I know as a mod, I would have given them each something.

 

I agree about Pale, actually.

 

I disagree about the doctor. He/she should stay hidden.

 

Assuming that those we believe are telling the truth, who is Crusher's mason partner? Two teams of two masons, right? Probably? I wish that person had revealed, although now, it would look a bit scummy to do so.

 

Sorry to take so long to share my thoughts. I really didn't have many of them formed earlier. Just my feelings about Pale and Zep. Pale, I'm sure of, and Zeppy, less so. And just my feeling on both. Well, that and the metagaming stuff I have on Pale, which I'm still not revealing. If I do, I'll never see through him again. Oh, yeah, and a feeling on the one I viewed tonight. If I get a result, I'll share who and what. If I'm blocked I'll try them again tomorrow, if there is a tomorrow. That's part of why I don't often share much. I don't want them to see me coming after them....lol.

 

My hope is that the roleblocker is town and Locke switched their target with me, to protect me. I've had the commuter power in a game, remember, Meesh? That's something I would have done with it. Remind me to tell you what did end up happening. I don't think you know, and it's funny, but not relevant to here and now.

 

 

 

[mmeeshal]

I agree with Lily about the Healer, Al Jenn.

 

And while I hope and pray there are only 3 mafia, I still want to be functioning under the impression that there are 4, because better safe than sorry.  Everyone who has a night action needs to make it count, unless you're scum, and in that case I hope all of you break each and every one of your fingers and toes before you can get the night kill sent in, and that your computers all freeze until the game is over. No hard feelings. ;D

 

Oh, and Al Jenn, I'm not good at lying.  Even when I'm mafia, I tell the truth as much as I possibly can.  Twist things sometimes, leave others out, or emphasize what I want while downplaying what I don't want people to be thinking about, but I try not to directly lie if I don't absolutely have to.  The more truth you stick in a misdirection, the more genuine you sound and the more people are likely to believe you.

 

**edit for new post (excepting the very first statement)**

Lily, did you read Wombat's link to what the commuter role is?  You had a manipulator role, not the commuter role.  A commuter is way different.

[LilyElizabeth]

No, I didn't. I misremembered the role, obviously. I'll go refresh my memory. Thanks.

 

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Yeah. I was thinking bus driver. Both have to do with vehicles....lol  :-[