90's Action Hero Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins

[Ithillian Turambar]

52 minutes ago, Darthe said:

Hiiii.  I've went back and changed the formatting of all the flavor, and added flavor for the night kill.

I saw! That font is MUCH better and the spacing now lets me read though the dialogue more easily. I think you might have still forgot to put Rand's name in there though?

 

I might be wrong. 

[Ithillian Turambar]

4 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

I went back to the lunch actually.  Started going backwards looking for the list he gave you. I had already been going forward thru to answer for earlier and hadn’t seen it.

 

so instead of being difficult how about you just tell me what I missed?

 

4 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

Ok so just read you last post and found it.  That wasn’t there when I answered btw

 

right so he had nyn as scum not town had nothing on ithi and key and tig town.

 

Still went with what I said as my suspects for bussing him

 

Not being difficult.  It was on the previous page. I even quoted it again in my reply.

 

And did you just say that because you didn't remember,  you just went with what your thoughts were?

 

Dude, you can't just present your own thoughts and cover them by saying they were Town on the Dead Mafias list but it's too difficult to go find the list. When they were not.

 

If they were actually just your own thoughts why not just say that?

 

 

[Ithillian Turambar]

6 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

@DPR I went looking but got sick of it so going off memory here

 

iirc ed town read me, nun, key and ithi

 

his muck up with nyn and me at eod eliminates her imo. That leaves ithi and key

 

 

 

6 hours ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

Rand was the Doc, so glad I spent time getting a quote for the 3p thing.

 

 @RandA lThor Thank you so much for coming back and playing. I hope you stay and play more games. 💙

 

Thanks Darthe for the slow roll.

 

 

 

Yeah. You got some of that right.

 

5 hours ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

Well I was trying to point out that Dice's rememberings about Eddie's garbage list were not correct.

 

And I was wondering why he would put out incorrect information.

 

But then I got sidetracked by possible things that Darthe did or did not do.

 

5 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

I DID say I was going off memory

 

what did I get wrong?

 

5 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

I went back to the lunch actually.  Started going backwards looking for the list he gave you. I had already been going forward thru to answer for earlier and hadn’t seen it.

 

so instead of being difficult how about you just tell me what I missed?

 

4 hours ago, dicetosser1 said:

Ok so just read you last post and found it.  That wasn’t there when I answered btw

 

right so he had nyn as scum not town had nothing on ithi and key and tig town.

 

Still went with what I said as my suspects for bussing him

 

Not sure why you would say my post showing Eddie's list was not there... when I posted it quit a bit earlier. It says an hour... but DM isn't great with time.

[Ithillian Turambar]

@Darthe you did still forget to put Rand's name in.

 

If only you had an editor to help lol

[dicetosser1]

18 minutes ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

 

 

Not being difficult.  It was on the previous page. I even quoted it again in my reply.

 

And did you just say that because you didn't remember,  you just went with what your thoughts were?

 

Dude, you can't just present your own thoughts and cover them by saying they were Town on the Dead Mafias list but it's too difficult to go find the list. When they were not.

 

If they were actually just your own thoughts why not just say that?

 

 

I went with the thoughts I had and had posted when Zander asked about possible bussers 

 

when I’ve gone to answer for earlier i did a bunch of hunting for the quotes

 

i went to do the same here looking for Ed’s read list that I knew you had mentioned.  I went back a bit before the lunch and didn’t find it.  I couldn’t be bothered searching further forward then I had already done for the previous answer to for so I went of memory

 

my memory was wrong . Ok.

 

point is I was asked why and the first thing I had posted was why. I had said you two were the most likely to bus him. I went looking for the list to give more info on the why. 
 

[Ithillian Turambar]

Thankfully Ed had not made many posts so I was able to use the search on the profile page to find his actual list.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I did not Bus Ed. I am not Mafia. I was voting Tigs. I changed my vote to Ed to prevent a possible tie on DPR

 

When Ed claimed I unvoted and went back to Tigs.

 

When Ed tried to say that you had been Roleblocked, and that meant his action had worked, which proved he was to Doc I challenged him.

 

Because why would Mafia roleblock and kill the same night for a claimed Cop They only have to do that to kill the Hider.

 

He then said that actually he'd protected Nyn.

 

I said, I'm sure you said Dice but I will go back and check. Because I didn't want to make a mistake and jump on a non CC claimed role.

 

I unvoted to do this.

 

I went back and checked and saw that he had initially said he'd protected you. Which meant he'd lied.

 

And so I went back and voted Ed.

 

It all happened very very quickly. 

 

At the time you even said that I'd misinterpreted Ed's post about the Roleblock and other people were still saying we def should not vote a non CC role.

 

So I caught a mistake,  did due diligence to confirm the mistake and voted Ed.

 

[Ithillian Turambar]

I should probably remember this page cos I'm sure people are gonna keep having a go and make me say this over and over.

[Ithillian Turambar]

13 minutes ago, dicetosser1 said:

I went with the thoughts I had and had posted when Zander asked about possible bussers 

 

when I’ve gone to answer for earlier i did a bunch of hunting for the quotes

 

i went to do the same here looking for Ed’s read list that I knew you had mentioned.  I went back a bit before the lunch and didn’t find it.  I couldn’t be bothered searching further forward then I had already done for the previous answer to for so I went of memory

 

my memory was wrong . Ok.

 

point is I was asked why and the first thing I had posted was why. I had said you two were the most likely to bus him. I went looking for the list to give more info on the why. 
 

 

And what I'm saying is you can't give your own thoughts and ideas and say they were because of info off of Ed's list when that is not what was on Ed's list.

 

If they are just your ideas why not just say that. Why even bring Ed's list into it.

[Nynaeve]

Hi guys

Unable to catch up atm.

Gotta visit with my dad and then it's my mother in law's 80's bday so... busy and somewhat conviluted day.

 

I hope I can get to it later hopefully.

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

2 hours ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

So with regards to DPR, you've even said that his words are harsh but his actions don't seem to be Mafia. 

I have never said this - I have always said his actions were Mafia through and through. DPR made the comment that most of my read was based on tone - my own words (he claimed) - and actions, but the actions were more tone based as well. 

 

It is strange to see you parrot back what he said, ignoring what I've said. 

 

I also notice you haven't mentioned why you theorised I was trying to make everyone forget Marsh was voting for me when I mentioned in the very post your were replying to. 

 

Also saying you mentioned DPR's gambit four hours before he claimed in a very specific convoy with Verb, is hardly including it in your reads or explaining why you feel when he was obviously creating drama in a fake and contrived way that you would not mention in your reads, and not consider the possibility it was AI. He was using a sledgehammer itt, it does not become a delicate precision tool because you assume he is working for town. Indeed his skill with words in no way makes him more likely to be town as you are trying to claim. That does not make any sense to me at all. 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

2 hours ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

So with regards to DPR, you've even said that his words are harsh but his actions don't seem to be Mafia. 

I have never said this - I have always said his actions were Mafia through and through. DPR made the comment that most of my read was based on tone - my own words (he claimed) - and actions, but the actions were more tone based as well. 

 

It is strange to see you parrot back what he said, ignoring what I've said. 

 

I also notice you haven't mentioned why you theorised I was trying to make everyone forget Marsh was voting for me when I mentioned in the very post your were replying to. 

 

Also saying you mentioned DPR's gambit four hours before he claimed in a very specific convoy with Verb, is hardly including it in your reads or explaining why you feel when he was obviously creating drama in a fake and contrived way that you would not mention in your reads, and not consider the possibility it was AI. He was using a sledgehammer itt, it does not become a delicate precision tool because you assume he is working for town. Indeed his skill with words in no way makes him more likely to be town as you are trying to claim. That does not make any sense to me at all. 

[Zander?]

*popcorneating.gif

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

Bah thought I had lost that post, not double posted. Sorry. 

 

Anyway my WiM is gone. Zander has a hard on for me despite having nothing to back it up. I'm inactive when I'm not. I sound different with explaining at all how or why those differences would be AI. 

 

Tigs wtl me because I didn't run around after Zander. 

 

Ithi is using the most awful arguments - I have no thoughts so I've been sheeping Marsh's thoughts all game. I'm trying to hide things I'm discussing. 

 

And every single one of my reads is garbage as DPR was actually trolling everyone in the thread in a gambit that without his claim would have gotten him eliminated after only one night action. Which obviously really backs up the really skilled wordsmith tirelessly working for town picture that Ithi is painting. So nearly a full week of my time, huge amount of stress and worry was all made completely irrelevant because of the actions of *checks notes* oh, yeah, someone on my team.

 

And what the fluff was on p. 32? Another reason that DPR is definitely town, mafia would have told us, whose argument was that? 

 

Humbug, I say, humbug. 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

2 hours ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

I did not Bus Ed. I am not Mafia. I was voting Tigs. I changed my vote to Ed to prevent a possible tie on DPR

 

When Ed claimed I unvoted and went back to Tigs.

 

When Ed tried to say that you had been Roleblocked, and that meant his action had worked, which proved he was to Doc I challenged him.

 

Because why would Mafia roleblock and kill the same night for a claimed Cop They only have to do that to kill the Hider.

 

He then said that actually he'd protected Nyn.

 

I said, I'm sure you said Dice but I will go back and check. Because I didn't want to make a mistake and jump on a non CC claimed role.

 

I unvoted to do this.

 

I went back and checked and saw that he had initially said he'd protected you. Which meant he'd lied.

 

And so I went back and voted Ed.

 

It all happened very very quickly. 

 

At the time you even said that I'd misinterpreted Ed's post about the Roleblock and other people were still saying we def should not vote a non CC role.

 

So I caught a mistake,  did due diligence to confirm the mistake and voted Ed.

 

Fwiw I thought you were fine on EoD. Dice's reluctance looked worse, and I think someone else seemed rather reticent, Zander was definitely, but given the circumstances it is difficult to call anything I saw AI. 

 

Trouble is once mafia got their tell on Rand with the fishing anyone could have finished Ed off for town cred or at least made sure they didn't stand out. Seems like WIFOM to do anything than be happy Ed was caught. Don't have the WiM to reread. 

[DPR]

8 hours ago, DPR said:

Bookmarking:

 

- dice copped Key for N2

-Ithi had Rand for 3p, which I questioned why and lololol he was actually the doc that died FML

-Turin/Marsh believes dice’s cop claim as cop, and does not believe my claim as hider. 
 

What we now know for fact:

 

-Mafia shot Rand -or- Rand was the Condemner’s target. And I’d say Darthe would mention that the doc was also the Condemner’s target, but 🤷‍♂️ gotta include all the options and figure it out later lol. 
 

It’s martini time. Pirate out. 
 

 

 

 

 

Picking up from here. My current views from the crow’s nest:

 

I don’t believe dice. I would think that the cop, even knowing he’d be RB’d, would try to view a player most likely to solve the game. Solving Key does very little in that direction. All that and the memory stuff = no bueno. 
 

Town core for me today is Nyn/Zander/Verb

Marsh is back with “I know it doesn’t make any sense, but I want DPR to be mafia so bad that I’m willing to overlook logic.” To me, this kinda clears him for today - same logic as Rand being passionate to a fault. 
 

Which is one benefit of picking fights lol. It tends to solve things much more quickly and I’ve never been a fan of paddycake mafia anyway. 
 

@HeavyHalfMoonBlade I’ve called you out for knowing too much about the Condemner role. I’ve asked you to talk about before, but you’ danced around that. Please walk me through how you knew about the role . 

 

 

 

[Zander?]

11 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Bah thought I had lost that post, not double posted. Sorry. 

 

Anyway my WiM is gone. Zander has a hard on for me despite having nothing to back it up. I'm inactive when I'm not. I sound different with explaining at all how or why those differences would be AI. 

 

Tigs wtl me because I didn't run around after Zander. 

 

Ithi is using the most awful arguments - I have no thoughts so I've been sheeping Marsh's thoughts all game. I'm trying to hide things I'm discussing. 

 

And every single one of my reads is garbage as DPR was actually trolling everyone in the thread in a gambit that without his claim would have gotten him eliminated after only one night action. Which obviously really backs up the really skilled wordsmith tirelessly working for town picture that Ithi is painting. So nearly a full week of my time, huge amount of stress and worry was all made completely irrelevant because of the actions of *checks notes* oh, yeah, someone on my team.

 

And what the fluff was on p. 32? Another reason that DPR is definitely town, mafia would have told us, whose argument was that? 

 

Humbug, I say, humbug. 

 

You ever think when you accuse people of reading you for "bad reasons" "lies" "incorrect reasons" "misreps" "inactivity". That maybe the fault doesn't lie with the Villagers among the group but perhaps the person posting?  You just gotta keep that kinda stuff in mind regardless of alignments.

[Zander?]

7 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Fwiw I thought you were fine on EoD. Dice's reluctance looked worse, and I think someone else seemed rather reticent, Zander was definitely, but given the circumstances it is difficult to call anything I saw AI. 

 

Trouble is once mafia got their tell on Rand with the fishing anyone could have finished Ed off for town cred or at least made sure they didn't stand out. Seems like WIFOM to do anything than be happy Ed was caught. Don't have the WiM to reread. 

 

How can you say anything is AI for me as you've never seen me Minority Villa LOLOLOLOL 

[Zander?]

Just now, Zander? said:

 

How can you say anything is AI for me as you've never seen me Minority Villa LOLOLOLOL 

 

You're only working with half of all the information needed to solve the equation lololololol 

[Ithillian Turambar]

31 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

3 hours ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

So with regards to DPR, you've even said that his words are harsh but his actions don't seem to be Mafia. 

I have never said this - I have always said his actions were Mafia through and through

I'm sure you did. I'm gonna go back and find it. One sec.

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

6 minutes ago, DPR said:

@HeavyHalfMoonBlade I’ve called you out for knowing too much about the Condemner role. I’ve asked you to talk about before, but you’ danced around that. Please walk me through how you knew about the role

I know nothing more about the role than was discussed in the thread. 

[Zander?]

@DPR

 

Maybe I missed it but what was that big thing irt page 32?!?????

[Zander?]

On 4/20/2025 at 3:17 PM, keyholder21 said:

 

Bold - How did you know this??

 

 

 

Bold - what do you mean by this?

 

 

Bold - Pretending is an interesting word choice.  Why, out of all the discussion would you focus on DPR, and why choose pretending??

 

 

Wolfy pop-in, imo.

 

Key probing which is a good early look.

 

On 4/20/2025 at 3:03 PM, ed2funy said:

 Talking with your scummy friends

 

On 4/20/2025 at 3:03 PM, ed2funy said:

Vote: Tigs

 

hi

 

Starting from Page 10 just gonna read a couple skip a couple see what shakes out.

 

But both these Ed posts are at Tig... someone who hasn't played so in awhile I assume so definitely didn't Wolf in awhile usually likes to do this kinda "looks comfortable interactions and prod a bit even jokingly with a teammate knowing that person's not gonna call it out or question it especially early game.

[Zander?]

On 4/20/2025 at 4:11 PM, Ithillian Turambar said:

God I hate that you made me go back to find this and now you've just dipped out.

 

See ^^^

 

Also I am still very much feeling that Heavy might be Mafia. As you can see, in his more recent posts, he is perfectly capable of posting in regular sentences. 

 

I still feel that his initial posts were overly crafted and careful to say nothing at all and I'm not sure why a Town person would feel they needed to be that careful. 

 

But then the sudden pop up defence from Marsh made him far more interesting.

 

Damage control?

 

This is a pretty early read.

 

Anyone familiar with Ithi's gameplay?  If so can you tell me if this is part for the course for her?  

[Zander?]

On 4/20/2025 at 4:49 PM, Turin Turambar said:

.

My activity is down in part because I'm a bit broken from last game.

 

 

Hey my name is Zander and I too would like to share with our group therapist and the rest of the group the extreme trauma I suffered last game....see....I was the only Villager....and all around me....I mean literally ALL AROUND ME..... every single person....and normally you'd have a couple people you could trust here....but not the case.... literally every single SOAB around me was a filthy evil Wolf!!!!!!!!