90's Action Hero Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins

[Turin Turambar]

There were only 5 people talking in the room where it happened. 

Dice

Rand

Verb

DPR

Ironeyes 

 

I don't think anyone other than Dice  or Ironeyes was ending up lynched once Dice claimed cop with 2 minutes on the clock. The only potential would have been Heavy and there wasn't enough time with the people there. Ironeyes would have voted him. I think Rand would have. I don't know about DPR. I don't think Verb would have. I don't know about Dice. Probably not important anyway. 

 

I blame @Darthe.  Lololololol 

[DPR]

2 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

And after that I murdered my father with a pogo-stick. 

 

It is such a shame that no one can read anything I'm posting otherwise I could have saved you from your "mistake", DPR. But obviously me posting immediately after you was completely invisible just like my posts now. 

 

Marsh didn't make a mistake or slip, and his convoluted theorising proved he was Town, if you assume I'm Town, so you could have cleared him by eliminating me.

 

Dont know why I'm bothering actually *sighs*

The problem may be you… 

 

Try making shorter, coherent statements  with lots less emotion and we may be able to communicate.

 

So far you’re in the “too obvious to be mafia” pile for me, but Gudrean occupied the same spot last game. Until she didn’t. 
 

In no world was Marsh obvious town except to 3 players. 

[Verbal32]

2 minutes ago, Turin Turambar said:

There were only 5 people talking in the room where it happened. 

Dice

Rand

Verb

DPR

Ironeyes 

 

I don't think anyone other than Dice  or Ironeyes was ending up lynched once Dice claimed cop with 2 minutes on the clock. The only potential would have been Heavy and there wasn't enough time with the people there. Ironeyes would have voted him. I think Rand would have. I don't know about DPR. I don't think Verb would have. I don't know about Dice. Probably not important anyway. 

 

I blame @Darthe.  Lololololol 

 

While I concur on the blaming of Darthe, heh, what is the point of this post?  If I'm missing something, my bad - but I don't understand what you're saying....

[Tigraine]

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

Dice Im leaning towards voting for you, which might tip the balance, and I have 15 minutes left before I leave my train. Talk to me, can you respond to what Ive said about you, and besides me obviously, who are your strongest scum reads

 

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

Kk I feel confident that Id want Dice out over Marsh, 

 

Vote: Dice

 

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

Ugh I'm scootering home for the next 3 min, brb

 

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

And nvm I'll wait it out online

 

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

But my data is choppy and Im off the train 😭

 

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

Dice you are cutting it damn close if you have something to say

 

12 hours ago, RandA lThor said:

You can very easily be mafia tryna manipulate us, I don't have enough to change my vote

This whole thing completely reads scummy af. 

 

It's obvious Dice was claiming an important town role. But you wouldn't stop until he said which one...fine, I'll give you the benefit of doubt on that one.

 

But the rest of that exchange literally reads as 1) you're spamming the thread with excuses of why you may or may not be available to unvote. 2) said spamming is doing nothing except making it harder for anyone trying to hurry and decide about a vote because they have to read what form of transportation you're currently using. 3) it reads to me like you're making those excuses to buy time.  The only reason I can figure you'd want to do that is you're waiting for your scummy buddies to give you input. So you covered yourself by teetering back and forth on whether you'll be available at any given moment. 

 

Just based on pages 26-28, I'm almost positive you're scum.  Unless you're really new to mafia...idk.

 

Someone hints at an important town role, idk how you go from being absolutely unwilling to unvote dice to sure I'll vote Marsh.  

 

Just wanted to get that out there.  

 

 

[DPR]

11 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

 

As somebody who looks for slips as a method of scumhunting, no.  I didn't notice it, because I don't think he slipped.  I think you pounced on what you thought you could qualify as a slip.  It's pretty much what I did last game as scum.  You're making my point for me here, Wes.

You’re just annoying at this point. 
 

Why did you tunnel Ithi so needlessly, but wait to throw a surprise vote down on dice? 

[Verbal32]

1 minute ago, DPR said:

In no world was Marsh obvious town except to 3 players. 

 

How often do you see that level of effort in scum players on D1?  Pretty much never is the answer.  Nobody is "obvious" town, but he was pretty reasonably town.  That's more than enough.

[Ithillian Turambar]

11 minutes ago, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

And after that I murdered my father with a pogo-stick. 

Is it possible for the condemn dude to get themselves as a target?

 

Cos it would explain so much.

[Verbal32]

2 minutes ago, DPR said:

You’re just annoying at this point. 
 

Why did you tunnel Ithi so needlessly, but wait to throw a surprise vote down on dice? 

 

100% misrep

 

I didn't tunnel Ithi - I just called out how she wasn't considering Marsh as town.  If you read my WTL, it had you and Dice.  I added her afterwards.

 

So, a surprise vote for somebody I had sussed in my first reads post?  Actually, he was literally the first sus I had all game (his bowing to Key).

 

Try harder.

[DPR]

1 minute ago, Verbal32 said:

 

How often do you see that level of effort in scum players on D1?  Pretty much never is the answer.  Nobody is "obvious" town, but he was pretty reasonably town.  That's more than enough.

We’ve seen people do all sorts of goofy shit over the years - you know that. 
 

Plus, he wasn’t putting in all that much effort. He was mostly trying to support the points he wanted supported. That’s not solving, that’s directing. 

[Verbal32]

5 minutes ago, Tigraine said:

It's obvious Dice was claiming an important town role.

 

I think I missed this.  Can you point me to where Dice said something that was obvious?

[DPR]

1 minute ago, Verbal32 said:

 

100% misrep

 

I didn't tunnel Ithi - I just called out how she wasn't considering Marsh as town.  If you read my WTL, it had you and Dice.  I added her afterwards.

 

So, a surprise vote for somebody I had sussed in my first reads post?  Actually, he was literally the first sus I had all game (his bowing to Key).

 

Try harder.

Okay

 

@Ithillian Turambar do you feel like Verb was tunneling you over Marsh yesterday? 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

Just now, Ithillian Turambar said:

Is it possible for the condemn dude to get themselves as a target?

 

Cos it would explain so much.

Not a fan of Patch Adams then? 

[Turin Turambar]

5 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

 

While I concur on the blaming of Darthe, heh, what is the point of this post?  If I'm missing something, my bad - but I don't understand what you're saying....

Partly, Dice should have claimed sooner if he was going to at all. Once he did it pretty much condemned Ironeyes. I don't know what Dice had him as, so.now more searching. Yay. 

I was trying to figure out what if any other viable trains were available at that point. My conclusion was none. I figured it was worth something.  Meh

[Zander?]

Is it day or night? 

[Verbal32]

Just now, DPR said:

We’ve seen people do all sorts of goofy shit over the years - you know that. 
 

Plus, he wasn’t putting in all that much effort. He was mostly trying to support the points he wanted supported. That’s not solving, that’s directing. 

 

Goofy shit =/= what I'm saying Marsh did.  Him casing Heayy is literally the definition of solving.

 

Who are you trying to fool here?  This is amazing to read how you keep bouncing in every direction.

[DPR]

1 minute ago, Verbal32 said:

 

I think I missed this.  Can you point me to where Dice said something that was obvious?

OMG

 

 

[Ithillian Turambar]

Cheese louise guys. You never talked this much in the Day hahaha

[Verbal32]

1 minute ago, Turin Turambar said:

Partly, Dice should have claimed sooner if he was going to at all. Once he did it pretty much condemned Ironeyes. I don't know what Dice had him as, so.now more searching. Yay. 

I was trying to figure out what if any other viable trains were available at that point. My conclusion was none. I figured it was worth something.  Meh

 

Btw, this was not me nudging at you - I was seriously just wanting to understand.  Makes sense.

[Ithillian Turambar]

2 minutes ago, DPR said:

Okay

 

@Ithillian Turambar do you feel like Verb was tunneling you over Marsh yesterday? 

I dunno. Maybe. I didn't feel like I was being pressured or anything. Verbal has one way of doing things and that's ok.

 

I just decided that I wouldn't let myself get wound all around and around so just play my own game and vote for who I thought was mafia.

 

Which I did.

[Turin Turambar]

3 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

 

100% misrep

 

I didn't tunnel Ithi - I just called out how she wasn't considering Marsh as town.  If you read my WTL, it had you and Dice.  I added her afterwards.

 

So, a surprise vote for somebody I had sussed in my first reads post?  Actually, he was literally the first sus I had all game (his bowing to Key).

 

Try harder.

So why didn't you switch to DPR? You knew your unvote was going to result in your town read dying. Once you were off Dice he was safe. Ironeyes could have voted him then too. 

[Zander?]

Ok it's night so don't gotta read anything yay!!!!!  Lol

 

I hope everyone had a great Easter!!!!!!!!!

 

Now I suppose since in free I should prolly help Darthe as I had family surprise me all long weekend FML lololololol 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

8 minutes ago, DPR said:

In no world was Marsh obvious town except to 3 players. 

That isn't true. All his convoluted theorising all would come crashing down if I flipped town or he flipped mafia. The plausible reasons he would go to all that effort and potentially ping Key or anyone that was reading her as Town is that 1) he was play acting as town to get me miseliminated which is dumb as he could have just like Ithi said I had convinced him. All the rest of it was wasted effort that would only make him look more wolfy. Or 2) he was town and he really thought I was mafia. Nothing else made sense. 

 

You misrepped what he said, brushed off his reply and brushed off my reply and my vote on you. Bizarre that you are now claiming you couldn't have known you were making a genuine error. You knew what you were doing, I just don't get why no one else cares. Not even Marsh did. 

[Verbal32]

5 minutes ago, DPR said:

Okay

 

@Ithillian Turambar do you feel like Verb was tunneling you over Marsh yesterday? 

 

1 minute ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

I dunno. Maybe. I didn't feel like I was being pressured or anything. Verbal has one way of doing things and that's ok.

 

I just decided that I wouldn't let myself get wound all around and around so just play my own game and vote for who I thought was mafia.

 

Which I did.

 

Reasonable answer.  If I was tunneling or needing to get you lynched, I would have voted you and tried to convince others to follow.  I did none of that, because Dice was still my WTL.

 

 

 

1 minute ago, Turin Turambar said:

So why didn't you switch to DPR? You knew your unvote was going to result in your town read dying. Once you were off Dice he was safe. Ironeyes could have voted him then too. 

 

Excellent question.  I didn't think we had time for a CFD (and I'm not that huge of a fan of them anyway).  I was trying to just get posts out and communicate, and then Darthe ended day.  

[Zander?]

7 minutes ago, Verbal32 said:

 

Goofy poop =/= what I'm saying Marsh did.  Him casing Heayy is literally the definition of solving.

 

Who are you trying to fool here?  This is amazing to read how you keep bouncing in every direction.

 

VERBAL HAS BEEN COMOD KILLED HE WAS....

 

Spoiler

Please edit homie.... lololololol 

 

[ed2funy]

33 minutes ago, DPR said:

I think you’re doing everything you can to not see how much it looked like a slip. 
 

He was obviously town, but to not see where others suspected he wasn’t is just being obtuse. I saw what I thought was a slip and voted for it. It is what it is. 
 

 

Obviously town but you voted that way?