90's Action Hero Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins

[dicetosser1]

  On 4/19/2025 at 6:51 AM, Nynaeve said:

 

Congrats!!

 

Vote: dice

Expand  

Nuns entrance doing something normal and expected.  Vote is wrong

 

 

  On 4/19/2025 at 6:58 AM, Nynaeve said:

I literally just realized what the theme is. lol   very nice, from an 1985 kid's pov. Meshes well with the nostalgic vibe

Expand  

 

just sounds like relaxed nyn
 

 

  On 4/19/2025 at 7:53 AM, Nynaeve said:

 

Odd concern.

You could?

Expand  

 

he snarl starts a little
 

 

  On 4/19/2025 at 9:23 AM, Nynaeve said:

 

Works for me lol

 

I used to spam my ass off in the SS back when. Easier times. The best faction, of course.

Expand  

something I know was true

 

 

  On 4/19/2025 at 9:31 AM, Nynaeve said:

 

Heh. I wish it was fake, would have been oh so clever of me.

It's mostly what happens when you post while making coffee. Multitasking definitely not a thing. Then again coffee is part of the unzombifying proccess... so it's a small price to pay.

 

Glad to hear about the band. I saw Dav scoped my profile page lol  bunch of creepers the lot of you. 

 

I rather not make any promises about getting active again anywhere cause things are still barely bearable here. But I can try to drop by and say hi at some point (vague enough of a promise? lol)

Expand  

 

a nyn response to the fake vote crack I threw at her that is good in tone

 

rest

is still easy and relaxed
 

 

  On 4/19/2025 at 11:49 AM, Nynaeve said:

 

Sounds like I have mad skillz for crushing your spirit with a couple of posts. Maybe I'm not so rusty after all... heh

Expand  

and here comes the real snark

 

 

  On 4/19/2025 at 11:50 AM, Nynaeve said:

No u

 

Hi btw

Expand  

that’s just nyn.  
 

Told you it’s all tone and. Gut read.  You feel like town nyn really strongly to me

[Ithillian Turambar]

I hate making lists.  Feels like work.

 

Town end

 

Nynaeve - asking good questions and being very natural and interactive. Is really looking into details

 

keyholder21 - also doing lots of good poking about. Not afraid to admit mistakes. Nice natural tone and flow. A lot better at quotes than I'll ever be.

 

Turin Turambar - less involved. Not being super helpful. Not afraid to get into things. These are signs of Town Turin for me.

 

Null section

 

DPR - never trust a Pirate but also do not shoot a pirate in the face on day 1. I get mostly good vibes from his enigmatic posts. Happy to provide a list.

 

Verbal32 - Weekend at Verbals.

 

Lenlo - no activity as yet. Darthe is probably having a moment about this.

 

ed2funy - lots of reactions. Not a lot of substance yet.

 

RandA lThor - did make a random vote on Nyn but might have just felt left out cos he was late. Not much else apart from that.

 

dicetosser1 - always angry. I don't like it. Weird beef with Turin. The atmosphere makes me uncomfortable.  Probs doesn't actually think Turin is Mafia though or he'd be on him like shot. Especially with his vote on Heavy being just a Lol vote.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

As an aside though, I'm not sure why you so cross with him. The only interactions you've had here are in Mafia games and you are experienced enough to let that go? 

 

Mafia end

 

Tigraine - just the absolute most purest fly by 'I'll read up and post later honest' post ever. It was only 6 pages in at that point and we never got a sequel.

 

HeavyHalfMoonBlade - I still stand by that overly crafted posts that say nothing, are an attempt to actively say nothing. I think this might be Heavy's first rand as mafia and he had a bit of a moment. Also I'm not sure he gets to tell us when he's doing things that are alignment indicative or not. I think we make that decision. Massive change in post style, despite saying that he was only posting how he naturally posts to start with.

 

Ironeyes - probably gonna be a defence lawyer. Popped up and completely defended Heavy. Says he was worried about LEADING a Lynch on Heavy when I was the first to vote Heavy and Dice was second. Now is doing the 'oh but I'm always scummy as Town' and the 'resigned to my fate' nonchalant follow ups. 

 

 

Also omg I just went back and  double counted and still couldnt figure out why I only had 12 people when there are 13 people playing 😆

[dicetosser1]

You’re right ithi. I should be able to but that’s just not happening yet

 

im Trying not to let it get in the way but tbh it probably will

[dicetosser1]

@Zander?  I just finished mania

 

……..     

 

SERIOUSLY!!????

 

🤬🤬🤬

[Ithillian Turambar]

  On 4/21/2025 at 3:09 AM, keyholder21 said:

  On 4/20/2025 at 7:11 PM, Ithillian Turambar said:

God I hate that you made me go back to find this and now you've just dipped out.

 

See ^^^

 

Also I am still very much feeling that Heavy might be Mafia. As you can see, in his more recent posts, he is perfectly capable of posting in regular sentences. 

 

I still feel that his initial posts were overly crafted and careful to say nothing at all and I'm not sure why a Town person would feel they needed to be that careful. 

 

But then the sudden pop up defence from Marsh made him far more interesting.

 

Damage control?

Expand   Expand  

 

Bold - I didn't make you do anything 😛.  Thanks for quoting it though, so I didn't have to go find it lololol.  My b, I missed that that's what you were responding to.

 

Italics - I did notice the change and it is definitely interesting.  

 

Second bold - did he do this in the other two games - start off confusing and switch to easier to understand?

 

Second italics -  Fair, but FWIW I feel the opposite vibe from that?  Like, why would new scum come in and just being confusing AF and draw all that attention?  More concerning is the 180.

Expand  

Hey look at me and my nested quotes. Send me £10 to find out how I did it.

 

1. Reading through quotes is hard so it's ok. I have also jumped to wrong conclusions.

 

2. Very interesting 

 

3. Not that I recall. Maybe a few interesting phrases but nothing to this extent.

 

4. Panic? A way to deal with a new and unexpected situation? Trying to outwit and be clever? The 180 is def something that I noticed.  At first Heavy said Wut? This is just how I post. And yet now it is not. Could be a Team timezones thing.

 

 

[Turin Turambar]

  On 4/21/2025 at 4:00 AM, keyholder21 said:

 

Fair on the reads.  I like the poking from Ithi and Nyn too - feels like they are trying to solve the game. 

 

Dice, I feel meh on because I feel like that vote is pretty on brand for him regardless lol.

this is my tinfoil on you. It feels like deflection on my most mafia read. I could be wrong. You could be wrong. It makes me twitch.

I agree that IE is defending Heavy.

 

I'm sorry to hear you are hurting from last game. These are supposed to be fun, so that sucks. 

  Reveal hidden contents

But NGL, it is skeeving me out some.

thanks. Not gonna get into it though as not relevant to this game.

 

LOL, I thought you didn't pay attention to it?  I know Ithi was his mod, but I wanted to know why dice was able to understand that's what Heavy was saying since there were some of the rest of us who didn't get that.

it was actually a joke on myself for not knowing about Ironeyes.  Worse because I botched it. I meant to say "was it in the sign up thread" as I would have missed it.

 

It doesn't appear as misrepresentation to me.  More concerning, imo, is the clarity of his response to Ithi.

okay. Maybe it is just me then.

 

Weird q for someone who has much experience playing, even if rusty. Seems pretty clear to me?

 

re: 1 - But Ithi had also been poking at the thread, especially Heavy at the time, and you didn't even mention her?

 

I already addressed the first bold in an earlier post. 

 

Second bold - lol I fight like hell no matter what. I understand what you're saying, but, imo, any townie loss is bad for town.

Yes. I concur. I do hope you are town.

 

Bold - this is a weird characterization.  You hadn't even voted him??

Expand  

Is it okay if I just add colourful comments to the quote? I don't have the desire to break up all the spots to reply. If it bothers people I will find another way. 

colourful bold additions are mine. This was not as easy as I thought it would be. Shad honouring teal out.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh fudge. Well that looked like it worked before I actually posted it.

 

That was answering your questions Key lol

 

I guess I'm not gonna be rich.

[Turin Turambar]

  On 4/21/2025 at 7:16 AM, dicetosser1 said:

like I said it was cause he was carrying on about never being lynched

 

you are pure tone and gut feel. Went “Town Nyn real quick” like I’m not doubting it at all

 

as for insight. I’m not sure any of us can help with that cause I don’t think any of us worked him out. He is confusing and emotional. There was a lot of questioning and sussing because he seemed to know too much for a newbie , too many terms etc, but he was researching as he went I believe

 

you’re right I did

 

i was sitting here waiting for her to come back and thinking it bad that she hadn’t 

 

tbh I haven’t noticed now if she has come back. 
 

so off what I’ve seen it doesnt look good but I won’t lynch someone day one off it

 

 

there’s two things here

 

1) it takes virtually no effort for Turin to p me off atm and carrying on about non town behaviour is gonna do it.   I am absolutely biased when it comes to him atm.

 

2) crap all.  He’s pontificating on non town behaviour and voting me because I was playing around with heavy.  I hadn’t been back, hadn’t replied to his question or anything.  Hence half cocked.  I wouldn’t say I tried to discredit his thought process as I disagreed with it.  As soon as I do that it can be labelled discrediting can’t it?

Expand  

So your Heavy vote was a joke? Your Rand vote is real? You are voting Rand right? (This wouldn't be an issue if the mods kept up)

 

Nyn, OK.

 

Speak for yourself. I feel I have a reasonable feel for Heavy when he isn't RPing his posts. He can be insightful and obviously town when he is clear. My problem with his early posts was it felt like he was faking his RP Heavy trying to cover. That was why I asked if he could be more "zen" which he was later in his first game and throughout most of the second game (except for during the cursed D2). I'm waiting to see where he goes from here but he is definitely still in my wtl group.

 

Tigraine is still null for me until she actually posts. DL is less than 24 hrs away though so tick tick... Lenlo too for that matter.

  Reveal hidden contents

Still love you, Len

 

Maybe that's a you thing. I'm not sure what it's all about. For me the goal of this game is to find townies to protect, and find non-town to lynch. If you engage in non-town behaviour then you get put in the non-town group. Last game, you were MAFIA, you engaged in non-town behaviour. You refused to clearly declare your towniness, despite being given a valid reason to do so, and worse imo refused to share a "tell" you had for a player that turned out to be a teammate. You did something again that I consider non-town behaviour in stating a willingness to lynch Heavy for the lols. Townies playing to their win condition don't do things like that. You can say now it was a joke but it didn't look like one and everything on thread is real until it clearly isn't. Bottom line is I think you are mafia again.

 

It's not personal for me. It is just me trying to solve this game.

[dicetosser1]

Do is like 11am for me and tomorrow is my crazy day

 

i will try to be here at do but can’t guarantee it

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

Just slept for most of the past 36 hours and still slept in till 11. I was dreading the catch up but it was less than expected, lol. So I'd apologise for slanking but it seems unnecessary. Autocorrect wanted me to apologise for spanking, not sure what it knows that I don't. 

 

Not liking how everybody seems plausibly town.

 

I'd expect Turin if town to be more active and town-cheerleading, but he is not doing anything suspicious. 

 

Ithi seems a bit too critical of everything.

 

Nyn has been posting a lot and asking questions but not overly solving.

 

Key seems the most straightforward townie doing townie things.

 

Dice was making jokes(!) being grumpy and making out of game references. The jokes is a new one for me, grumpy is NAI and the wrestling posts are a tell possibly of mafia distraction tactics?

 

Marsh sounds plausible but not sure I like his logic yet he hasn't used it in anger yet so difficult to have an opinion.

 

Ed seems to have posted nothing but fluff. 

 

DPR and Verb seem to be having something of a love in without noticibly contributing. But is it a town love affair or a mafia one? 

 

Lenlo, Rand and Tig no read on. 

 

So not being much help, I'm afraid, even after my herculean sleep. I'd say run up Dice, but in my experience Dice reacts in exactly the same way to being voted for in both alignments. Maybe Ed to see which way he jumps? But I'm loath to vote at random, however I have little else to go at this point and DL is rapidly approaching. 

 

Regarding my "change" in style, from my pov, I still just posting the way I always do. *shrugs* not really a lot I can say to reassure anyone on that score. I still stand by that voting for someone for saying nothing when everyone else is making joke votes and posting memes seems unfair, but there we are. 

 

 

[Turin Turambar]

For me Heavy it wasn't what you said early. It was how you said it. That the was no real content, you weren't taking stances etc.. wasn't important.  I read it as not real. Not even in the way you can at times be RP lite in conversation ( my take, sorry if I offend). It felt like an imitation of that so it was a bit jarring. 

I'm not sure if I'm explaining myself well or not. 

Some of the other posts have felt true to what I view as zen Heavy. There was even one in the middle of page 7 where I was questioning your response to Ithi that I thought was pure. 

 

Keep giving ideas and I think we might get there.  If you are town of course, lol.

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

  On 4/21/2025 at 11:23 AM, Turin Turambar said:

For me Heavy it wasn't what you said early. It was how you said it. That the was no real content, you weren't taking stances etc.. wasn't important.  I read it as not real. Not even in the way you can at times be RP lite in conversation ( my take, sorry if I offend). It felt like an imitation of that so it was a bit jarring. 

I'm not sure if I'm explaining myself well or not. 

Some of the other posts have felt true to what I view as zen Heavy. There was even one in the middle of page 7 where I was questioning your response to Ithi that I thought was pure. 

 

Keep giving ideas and I think we might get there.  If you are town of course, lol.

Expand  

This is a sus post. Turin knows I'm sus of people that push me, and knows I'm partial to people saying nice things about me (as I stressed that all last game). This feels too nice, too chummy. 

 

That said I don't think it is a smoking gun  and normally I would wait and see how this develops but as I am such a high person of interest on most people's lists I thought I'd put it out there now incase I don't have time to later. 

 

Certainly puts Turin for me on a mafia lean. 

[Nynaeve]

  On 4/21/2025 at 10:56 AM, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Just slept for most of the past 36 hours and still slept in till 11. I was dreading the catch up but it was less than expected, lol. So I'd apologise for slanking but it seems unnecessary. Autocorrect wanted me to apologise for spanking, not sure what it knows that I don't. 

 

Not liking how everybody seems plausibly town.

 

I'd expect Turin if town to be more active and town-cheerleading, but he is not doing anything suspicious. 

 

Ithi seems a bit too critical of everything.

 

Nyn has been posting a lot and asking questions but not overly solving.

 

Key seems the most straightforward townie doing townie things.

 

Dice was making jokes(!) being grumpy and making out of game references. The jokes is a new one for me, grumpy is NAI and the wrestling posts are a tell possibly of mafia distraction tactics?

 

Marsh sounds plausible but not sure I like his logic yet he hasn't used it in anger yet so difficult to have an opinion.

 

Ed seems to have posted nothing but fluff. 

 

DPR and Verb seem to be having something of a love in without noticibly contributing. But is it a town love affair or a mafia one? 

 

Lenlo, Rand and Tig no read on. 

 

So not being much help, I'm afraid, even after my herculean sleep. I'd say run up Dice, but in my experience Dice reacts in exactly the same way to being voted for in both alignments. Maybe Ed to see which way he jumps? But I'm loath to vote at random, however I have little else to go at this point and DL is rapidly approaching. 

 

Regarding my "change" in style, from my pov, I still just posting the way I always do. *shrugs* not really a lot I can say to reassure anyone on that score. I still stand by that voting for someone for saying nothing when everyone else is making joke votes and posting memes seems unfair, but there we are. 

 

 

Expand  

 

Are you currently voting someone?

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

  On 4/21/2025 at 11:33 AM, Nynaeve said:

 

Are you currently voting someone?

Expand  

Nope 

[Turin Turambar]

Lol, Heavy, I'm not even pushing you. I'm trying to figure you out. 

Oh well, I've got a needy dog and need to reread so I'll catch up again after.

 

Btw, DL is 3am for me so I won't be here then. 

[DPR]

  On 4/21/2025 at 11:44 AM, Turin Turambar said:

Lol, Heavy, I'm not even pushing you. I'm trying to figure you out. 

Oh well, I've got a needy dog and need to reread so I'll catch up again after.

 

Btw, DL is 3am for me so I won't be here then. 

Expand  

We really do need to settle on a standard EOD time. I’d say 5pm New York Time, but I dunno if that fits with dice in Australia. @dicetosser1 is 5 NYT good for you? Anyone else have a better time? 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

  On 4/21/2025 at 11:44 AM, Turin Turambar said:

Lol, Heavy, I'm not even pushing you. I'm trying to figure you out. 

Oh well, I've got a needy dog and need to reread so I'll catch up again after.

 

Btw, DL is 3am for me so I won't be here then. 

Expand  

I know you are not pushing me, that is what I mean. It is harsh to sus someone for being nice, and as I say I don't think this is a definite tell which means you are certainly mafia, but it seems you are more likely to butter me up as mafia than town. 

 

As I said I normally wouldn't say anything at this point and see how it plays out, but given the circumstances I thought I should share this before I possibly cannot. 

[DPR]

  On 4/21/2025 at 11:23 AM, Turin Turambar said:

For me Heavy it wasn't what you said early. It was how you said it. That the was no real content, you weren't taking stances etc.. wasn't important.  I read it as not real. Not even in the way you can at times be RP lite in conversation ( my take, sorry if I offend). It felt like an imitation of that so it was a bit jarring. 

I'm not sure if I'm explaining myself well or not. 

Some of the other posts have felt true to what I view as zen Heavy. There was even one in the middle of page 7 where I was questioning your response to Ithi that I thought was pure. 

 

Keep giving ideas and I think we might get there.  If you are town of course, lol.

Expand  

The tone here strikes me as contrived and has a whif of wolf to wolf in it. 
 

You’ve been general with a few of your descriptions as well. Did you ever figure out what it was that bothers you about me? You mentioned it yesterday and never got back to it.
 

 

[DPR]

  On 4/21/2025 at 12:05 PM, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

I know you are not pushing me, that is what I mean. It is harsh to sus someone for being nice, and as I say I don't think this is a definite tell which means you are certainly mafia, but it seems you are more likely to butter me up as mafia than town. 

 

As I said I normally wouldn't say anything at this point and see how it plays out, but given the circumstances I thought I should share this before I possibly cannot. 

Expand  

This feels like a soft and carefully worded reply. There’s a good bit of mea culpa here, which strikes me as odd, and a lot of trying to not criticize Turin too much (something Turin offers in return) and it just feels off. 
 

Wolf to wolf alarms tripped. 
 

 

[HeavyHalfMoonBlade]

  On 4/21/2025 at 12:24 PM, DPR said:

This feels like a soft and carefully worded reply. There’s a good bit of mea culpa here, which strikes me as odd, and a lot of trying to not criticize Turin too much (something Turin offers in return) and it just feels off. 
 

Wolf to wolf alarms tripped. 
 

 

Expand  

I think if you take it in the context of me sussing Turin for being nice, helpful and supportive my tone makes sense.

 

Though of course I would say that - but I think it is very different for sussing him for making contradictory statements or whatever. 

 

I find it a little but strange that you sussing Turin for a post I also found wolfy, and then sussing me for not sussing enough. It seems a little contrived but I guess with so little content so far all reads are going to feel a little contrived. Still, feels like you are going out your way to generate some suspicion. 

[Nynaeve]

  On 4/21/2025 at 12:01 PM, DPR said:

We really do need to settle on a standard EOD time. I’d say 5pm New York Time, but I dunno if that fits with dice in Australia. @dicetosser1 is 5 NYT good for you? Anyone else have a better time? 

Expand  

 

Right now DL for me is at 5 am. I'll be in bed 5 hours prior to that, if not earlier. So I definitely won't be around for it.

 

Not sure if 5 NYT is good for me. How many hours away is it?

[DPR]

  On 4/21/2025 at 12:47 PM, Nynaeve said:

 

Right now DL for me is at 5 am. I'll be in bed 5 hours prior to that, if not earlier. So I definitely won't be around for it.

 

Not sure if 5 NYT is good for me. How many hours away is it?

Expand  

Yeah, I’m a pirate - not a mathmagician 

[Nynaeve]

  On 4/21/2025 at 11:37 AM, HeavyHalfMoonBlade said:

Nope 

Expand  

 

Why not?

 

Looking around at players and commenting on whether you think they're trying to solve the game or not is nice and all, but at the same time you're hanging back to see which way it goes? Not the best look.

[DPR]

[Nynaeve]

  On 4/21/2025 at 12:51 PM, DPR said:

Expand  

 

Unhelpful as always lol

 

If google is right, i'm 6-7 hours ahead of NYT.

 

5 pm NYT would be around 11 pm to midnight for me which is more doable