The Mafia Parable: Basic Game OVER

[Verbal32]

just post it dammit

[Verbal32]

^ edit in the fancy stuff later

[Sooh]

Yeah! Listen to Verb!

 

[Ironeyes]

just post it dammit

[Ironeyes]

Lol I'm not even impatient but there are so many great GIFs tagged "waiting"

[RandA lThor]

I mean, I have a premade scene and I know her role/alignment.. It just feels wrong to not format it like I can on a full comp.

 

BRUHHHHHHH why you gotta blue ball us like this

[Nynaeve]

#fulldarthe mod edition

[Darthe]

[Nynaeve]

 

 

 

Verbal?

O.o

I dont get why he's not here

Stuck in a meeting, just finished. I see we passed DL. I'm fine with that - I was ok with a lynch on any of my current suspects, so I'll just wait for the flip.

Fair enough. Wasnt thst fussed anyhow.

 

>.>

[DPR]

 

 

We've just passed through DL and there are 3 people actively posting, does that not seem weird to anyone else?

Why would it be?

 

 

 

Generally people should be here during or close to DL to help make sure the votes are cast on the best possible option and, as Nyn said, to see the flip.  I don't know what to make of it, it just seems odd.

 

 

 

This and all of the implications surrounding it are just silly. People do have schedules.  

[Darthe]

And so the group proceeded to try and ferret out who might be responsible for their jobs but, being a focus group they only knew how to do one thing. Thhe focused, and they focused harder until one of them needed the loo, and then they focused very hard indeed until one of them promptly fell over dead. It appeared that this one death left them unsatisfied, so they would need to work all the harder tomorrow.

 

Hallia

town vanilla

has died.

 

It is now night One. You have 24 hours to chat and provide actions.

[RandA lThor]

YOU ARE SUCH A LITTLE TEASE GODDAMMIT, I saw the red spoiler text and name text and just assumed she was mafia :/ Ill do some train analysis after this, got some work for right now

[RandA lThor]

 

 

 

We've just passed through DL and there are 3 people actively posting, does that not seem weird to anyone else?

Why would it be?

 

 

 

Generally people should be here during or close to DL to help make sure the votes are cast on the best possible option and, as Nyn said, to see the flip.  I don't know what to make of it, it just seems odd.

 

 

 

This and all of the implications surrounding it are just silly. People do have schedules.  

 

 

I understand, but we've known when DL was for 2 full days now, a heads up would've been nice if you knew you weren't going to be around, like what LZM did.

 

Also, has no one else seen this?  It's been half an hour since the reveal and no comments, whereas there were 3 people not including me talking in the half hour before the reveal.  Are people worried that their reactions to this might not seem good enough or something? I know for a fact, at minimum, LZM and Adella are on rn, and like I said before, DPR, Nyn, and Marsh were on half an hour before the drop.

 

And keep in mind everyone that we do have a claimed vig who we should try to come up with the best possible target for if she is actually a vig.  After this flip, I definitely feel less sure about that, but we should still try to reach a conclusion as a whole on who we want to kill.

 

Imo, since Adella obviously isn't an option, I didn't have too many strong reads past her and Hally.  I think I, like most, have a natural OMGUS reaction towards Marsh and DPR, but honestly I like Marsh a little bit on how easily he accepted my point on why it wouldn't make sense for me to forget his case against me, he seems open minded and flexible to good points, which seems like someone legitimately trying to scum hunt rather than trying to fake it.  DPR I feel like is just an inept townie, nothing he's said comes off particularly scummy, just misinformed or illogical.

 

On my town reads, I still feel fairly strong about Verbal (though his appearance right after DL is suspicious, though I'll assume he isn't lying about RL stuff like his meetings), decently so on LZM, though Clov hasn't been doing much recently and wasn't involved in the final vote process at all.  Out of them, Clov seems the most suspicious.

 

Finally on my other previous null reads besides Marsh and DPR, I honestly have no idea how to read Sooh right now, something seems off, but it's just a personality thing, and for all I know, that could be how she plays.  SK has been pretty afk, which is another null read for me.  Ben I have to reread on since nothing about him sticks out to me even though I know he's been in and out, and Nyn I have to reread on because I'm so thoroughly confused on her that I need to take another look.  I still don't think her personality seems off, but I haven't noticed much about her play.

 

Now analyzing the Hally vote train, Adella's started as a joke vote that ended up staying on her.  Nyn was iirc the first one to truly cast suspicion on Hally, I'll check whether that was backed up with reasonable information or just information made to look reasonable when I do my reread.

 

Then I think Clov hopped on, and then after that it was Marsh, who then unvoted to get on me, then I unvoted Adella to get on Hally, and then was followed by Marsh.  Marsh's voting pattern seems off, though it makes him seem a little more town to me.  It would've been easy for him to stay on the train rather than do that little maneuver, and he wouldn't have gained anything by lynching me if he was mafia.

 

So of that train, the most bandwagony seems like Clov, followed by Adella who I remember didn't like the fact that Hally wasn't giving more content in her posts, but don't remember when she actually switched from it being a joke vote to a real vote.

 

Anyways, these are observations based mostly on memory, so I'll reread to get a better look, but as of right now, I don't have really strong feelings on who we should shoot, but I'd prefer if we didn't shoot Verbal, LZM, or (obviously) me.  And Marsh somewhat.  The rest I'd say are definitely fairgame.

[Ironeyes]

Red font. For a vanilla townie. 

 

Darthe really enjoys this doesn't he. 

[RandA lThor]

Red font. For a vanilla townie. 

 

Darthe really enjoys this doesn't he. 

 

Thoughts on who you'd want to kill, who you'd be OK with, and who you don't want killed?

[LedZepMan]

Kill Ny

[LedZepMan]

Nyn

[Ironeyes]

Focus Group.

1. Verbal32

 

2. Ironeyes

 

3. DreadPirateRoberts

 

4. Clovdyx

 

5. Gentled Ben

 

6. LedZepMan

 

7. Shitsure Kamimashita

 

8. Adella

 

9. Nynaeve

 

10. Sooh

 

11. Hallia

 

12. RandA lThor

After D1 and the flip, these are my impressions of everyone, following the order of the player list. 

 

Verb: I got an early town feeling from him and nothing so far has disabused me of that. He's being tight-lipped about specific suspicions, but what he does say is mostly grass-beating and clearly intended toward scaring up some scum. 

 

DPR: Reminds me of town!Zander this game, particularly in his fight with Verb. I think that argument is town butting heads rather than anything else. 

 

Clov: I haven't seen enough from him to form an opinion. He takes me longer to read than most, so I'll wait and see what day 2 brings. 

 

Ben: Made a few slips that could just as easily be attributed to newness as scumminess. 

 

LZM: Pretty null for the moment, mostly because I haven't paid much attention to him. 

 

Sushi: Solid posts, good tone, but sorta scarce. Looking forward to more activity if we can get it. 

 

Adella: Similarly to LZM, I haven't been paying close enough attention to form a read here. 

 

Nyn: I was hoping to clear her from the Hallia flip, but since she was town I can't do that. Lower end of null for now. 

 

Sooh: I'm on the fence, but trending upward slowly. 

 

Rand: Also trending upward slowly, after a good back-and-forth at EOD

[Ironeyes]

Oh shoot, I forgot about Adella's claim. That should put her as a light town lean... 

 

 

 

Red font. For a vanilla townie. 

 

Darthe really enjoys this doesn't he. 

 

Thoughts on who you'd want to kill, who you'd be OK with, and who you don't want killed?

I'd be comfortable with anyone in orange on my list being shot, and I wouldn't shoot anyone in green. 

[Ironeyes]

Or blue. Being shot myself would kinda suck. 

[Ironeyes]

If I had a shot myself I'd holster tonight most likely. None of my reads are strong enough to warrant using a 1x kill on immediately. 

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

We've just passed through DL and there are 3 people actively posting, does that not seem weird to anyone else?

Why would it be?

 

 

 

Generally people should be here during or close to DL to help make sure the votes are cast on the best possible option and, as Nyn said, to see the flip.  I don't know what to make of it, it just seems odd.

 

 

 

This and all of the implications surrounding it are just silly. People do have schedules.  

 

 

I understand, but we've known when DL was for 2 full days now, a heads up would've been nice if you knew you weren't going to be around, like what LZM did.

 

Also, has no one else seen this?  It's been half an hour since the reveal and no comments, whereas there were 3 people not including me talking in the half hour before the reveal.  Are people worried that their reactions to this might not seem good enough or something? I know for a fact, at minimum, LZM and Adella are on rn, and like I said before, DPR, Nyn, and Marsh were on half an hour before the drop.

 

And keep in mind everyone that we do have a claimed vig who we should try to come up with the best possible target for if she is actually a vig.  After this flip, I definitely feel less sure about that, but we should still try to reach a conclusion as a whole on who we want to kill.

 

Imo, since Adella obviously isn't an option, I didn't have too many strong reads past her and Hally.  I think I, like most, have a natural OMGUS reaction towards Marsh and DPR, but honestly I like Marsh a little bit on how easily he accepted my point on why it wouldn't make sense for me to forget his case against me, he seems open minded and flexible to good points, which seems like someone legitimately trying to scum hunt rather than trying to fake it.  DPR I feel like is just an inept townie, nothing he's said comes off particularly scummy, just misinformed or illogical.

 

On my town reads, I still feel fairly strong about Verbal (though his appearance right after DL is suspicious, though I'll assume he isn't lying about RL stuff like his meetings), decently so on LZM, though Clov hasn't been doing much recently and wasn't involved in the final vote process at all.  Out of them, Clov seems the most suspicious.

 

Finally on my other previous null reads besides Marsh and DPR, I honestly have no idea how to read Sooh right now, something seems off, but it's just a personality thing, and for all I know, that could be how she plays.  SK has been pretty afk, which is another null read for me.  Ben I have to reread on since nothing about him sticks out to me even though I know he's been in and out, and Nyn I have to reread on because I'm so thoroughly confused on her that I need to take another look.  I still don't think her personality seems off, but I haven't noticed much about her play.

 

Now analyzing the Hally vote train, Adella's started as a joke vote that ended up staying on her.  Nyn was iirc the first one to truly cast suspicion on Hally, I'll check whether that was backed up with reasonable information or just information made to look reasonable when I do my reread.

 

Then I think Clov hopped on, and then after that it was Marsh, who then unvoted to get on me, then I unvoted Adella to get on Hally, and then was followed by Marsh.  Marsh's voting pattern seems off, though it makes him seem a little more town to me.  It would've been easy for him to stay on the train rather than do that little maneuver, and he wouldn't have gained anything by lynching me if he was mafia.

 

So of that train, the most bandwagony seems like Clov, followed by Adella who I remember didn't like the fact that Hally wasn't giving more content in her posts, but don't remember when she actually switched from it being a joke vote to a real vote.

 

Anyways, these are observations based mostly on memory, so I'll reread to get a better look, but as of right now, I don't have really strong feelings on who we should shoot, but I'd prefer if we didn't shoot Verbal, LZM, or (obviously) me.  And Marsh somewhat.  The rest I'd say are definitely fairgame.

 

 

LOL

 

 

 

Focus Group.

1. Verbal32

 

2. Ironeyes

 

3. DreadPirateRoberts

 

4. Clovdyx

 

5. Gentled Ben

 

6. LedZepMan

 

7. Shitsure Kamimashita

 

8. Adella

 

9. Nynaeve

 

10. Sooh

 

11. Hallia

 

12. RandA lThor

After D1 and the flip, these are my impressions of everyone, following the order of the player list. 

 

Verb: I got an early town feeling from him and nothing so far has disabused me of that. He's being tight-lipped about specific suspicions, but what he does say is mostly grass-beating and clearly intended toward scaring up some scum. 

 

DPR: Reminds me of town!Zander this game, particularly in his fight with Verb. I think that argument is town butting heads rather than anything else. 

 

Clov: I haven't seen enough from him to form an opinion. He takes me longer to read than most, so I'll wait and see what day 2 brings. 

 

Ben: Made a few slips that could just as easily be attributed to newness as scumminess. 

 

LZM: Pretty null for the moment, mostly because I haven't paid much attention to him. 

 

Sushi: Solid posts, good tone, but sorta scarce. Looking forward to more activity if we can get it. 

 

Adella: Similarly to LZM, I haven't been paying close enough attention to form a read here. 

 

Nyn: I was hoping to clear her from the Hallia flip, but since she was town I can't do that. Lower end of null for now. 

 

Sooh: I'm on the fence, but trending upward slowly. 

 

Rand: Also trending upward slowly, after a good back-and-forth at EOD

 

 

 

You were pretty hot after Rand at EOD. What changed for you?

 

IMO he talks a lot. Haven't seen a case of diarrhea-of-the-mouth like this in a while.  Thing is, he doesn't evolve - he just keeps pushing the same points. And after the "dedicated townie, rah rah rah" act, I'm feeling better about my vote than ever. 

[Eldrick4221]

Day 1 Final Vote Count:

 

Clov (1/7): SK

Hally (5/7): Adella, Nyn, Clov, Rand, Marsh

Rand (1/7): DPR, Hally

Adella (2/7): Sooh, LZM

Not Voting(2/12): Verb, Ben

[Ironeyes]

You were pretty hot after Rand at EOD. What changed for you?

 

IMO he talks a lot. Haven't seen a case of diarrhea-of-the-mouth like this in a while.  Thing is, he doesn't evolve - he just keeps pushing the same points. And after the "dedicated townie, rah rah rah" act, I'm feeling better about my vote than ever. 

 

 

He poked a hole in my theory that I couldn't properly patch up. Didn't say I'm town reading him, but he's not as strong of a scum read any more. 

[DPR]

 

You were pretty hot after Rand at EOD. What changed for you?

 

IMO he talks a lot. Haven't seen a case of diarrhea-of-the-mouth like this in a while.  Thing is, he doesn't evolve - he just keeps pushing the same points. And after the "dedicated townie, rah rah rah" act, I'm feeling better about my vote than ever. 

 

 

He poked a hole in my theory that I couldn't properly patch up. Didn't say I'm town reading him, but he's not as strong of a scum read any more. 

 

 

 

Which theory? Link to post?