[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

 

 

see...I was so hot and bothered I couldn't type right...

 

 

goodnight for now

 

 

Your last post was an hour ago, which was hitting on AJ and not game related, and you come into say goodnight and nothing else? Odd....

 

I finally decided to take notes using an excel spreadsheet.  I was going back and forth between the thread and the spreadsheet.  I do not type that fast so that is why the elapsed time period.

 

 

 

I....can't read Wifi.  I leave that for the professionals.  Typically Sooh, but she's modding, so she can't help me (or can she? )

 

if everyone calls her a villager the wolves have to kill her at somepoint since they can't lynch her. So call her a villa.

 

Then let it marinate for a few days and if it becomes ripe you re-evaluate

 

It is science

 

Thanks dricky.  I like you too.  

 

¿Qué?

 

That wasn't by or about me.

 

 

OOOPPPSSSS LOLOLOL....SORRY...I thought it was you.

[Wildfire Sedai]

oh and how do you embed quotes that don't belong with each other??? cause those two didn't belong with each other as I recall....I don't think...*scratches head*

[Nolder]

 

I am ok with lynching Hallia based on her defense of Darthe but considering how many people are coming to Darthe's defense it makes far more sense to me to lynch him instead of risking a mislynch. That said,I will switch later if necessary.

I don't think we can maj anyone on D1. Sooh said there won't be a hammer so I think this phase is just considered plurality when the DL falls.

 

Anyway - what if Darthe ends up being a mislynch?

 

Does it matter really? We vote who we want to see lynched...

 

If Darthe is town I'll have to reassess. It's not like I've never mislynched someone before.

[Wildfire Sedai]

nvm: I just realized that it was a quote from a post I made.    However people still do make imbedded posts that I can't figure out how they do.  Though, I haven't seen them done this game, yet.

[Wildfire Sedai]

No it didn't take me 20 minutes to figure it out.  I was eating supper.  It took me 20 minutes to respond.  

[Nolder]

 

I am ok with lynching Hallia based on her defense of Darthe but considering how many people are coming to Darthe's defense it makes far more sense to me to lynch him instead of risking a mislynch. That said,I will switch later if necesary. 

 

If Darthe is scum, do you think the entire scum team is out there defending him on this?  Or do you think it is probably null, which is why people are less "defending what he said" and more "trying to explain that it doesn't mean anything alignment-wise for him"?

 

Good question. I think the probability is high actually. This is the kind of game that is made or broken by one lynch or one kill. Losing a mafia member on D1 is pretty devestating and sets the mafia back. I could easily see both teammates coming to defend him if he's scum. Especially if other townies have already provided cover for them to do so.

[Nolder]

 

I am ok with lynching Hallia based on her defense of Darthe but considering how many people are coming to Darthe's defense it makes far more sense to me to lynch him instead of risking a mislynch. That said,I will switch later if necesary. 

 

Are all of your current thoughts revolving around Darthe's claim and the interactions to it? I'd like to see where your thought line is beyond the Darthe drama. While I wouldn't lynch you today, all of my notes on you are connected with your thoughts and reaction to Darthe and I'd like some separation from it. 

 

Well that was kind of forced on all of us by Darthe, I didn't choose it.

 

I have thoughts on others but I prefer waiting for D2 before giving them out.

D1 reads, at least mine, tend to change dramatically from D1 to D2 given the wealth of new information we usually get between a lynch and a nightkill.

I hate saying so and so is town or so and so is mafia and then reacting to new informtion but getting sussed by others for changing my mind.

So these days I just wait until that period is over.

[Wildfire Sedai]

I totally agree with you on that point, nolder.

[MrsClov]

 

 

I am ok with lynching Hallia based on her defense of Darthe but considering how many people are coming to Darthe's defense it makes far more sense to me to lynch him instead of risking a mislynch. That said,I will switch later if necesary. 

 

Are all of your current thoughts revolving around Darthe's claim and the interactions to it? I'd like to see where your thought line is beyond the Darthe drama. While I wouldn't lynch you today, all of my notes on you are connected with your thoughts and reaction to Darthe and I'd like some separation from it. 

 

Well that was kind of forced on all of us by Darthe, I didn't choose it.

 

I have thoughts on others but I prefer waiting for D2 before giving them out.

D1 reads, at least mine, tend to change dramatically from D1 to D2 given the wealth of new information we usually get between a lynch and a nightkill.

I hate saying so and so is town or so and so is mafia and then reacting to new informtion but getting sussed by others for changing my mind.

So these days I just wait until that period is over.

 

Noted and reading this as you're only going to share thoughts if it pertains to Darthe somehow. 

[Nolder]

Fair enough. :P

[Eldrick4221]

Except that as you just explained, views on people change from the wealth of information D2. Changing your opinion is perfectly acceptable and expected. You should be able to explain why you change, though.

 

Choosing not to provide information because you expect it to change isn't a good policy imo. You should state your stance if you have one.

[Andrej]

24 hours ladies and gents.

[Andrej]

Wifi and Eldrick I'd like to know where you two are at with the roster.

[Nolder]

Except that as you just explained, views on people change from the wealth of information D2. Changing your opinion is perfectly acceptable and expected. You should be able to explain why you change, though.

 

Choosing not to provide information because you expect it to change isn't a good policy imo. You should state your stance if you have one.

In my experience most people don't react this way even when they say the same thing.

[Lenlo]

But see AJ, one of my problems is with what she theorized. W/W or W/V were her only immediate thoughts and even if that's just stream of conciousness, it's not a towny one imo.

 

That's in regards to our wifi talk btw

[Hallia]

Oh yay, votes.  I can't log on at all on my new job, and I just got home.  Reading up.

[Wildfire Sedai]

But see AJ, one of my problems is with what she theorized. W/W or W/V were her only immediate thoughts and even if that's just stream of conciousness, it's not a towny one imo.

 

That's in regards to our wifi talk btw

 

Did you ever think that maybe, just maybe SOME people start their way as wolfie to me and have to work their way to townliness??? no names given. and no its not just darthe and aj.

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

But see AJ, one of my problems is with what she theorized. W/W or W/V were her only immediate thoughts and even if that's just stream of conciousness, it's not a towny one imo.

 

That's in regards to our wifi talk btw

 

Did you ever think that maybe, just maybe SOME people start their way as wolfie to me and have to work their way to townliness??? no names given. and no its not just darthe and aj.

 

 

and by w/w I meant darthe/aj for your information....also the same with w/v  just in case you were thinking something else.  I just thought of that now as I reread it.

[Eldrick4221]

Wifi and Eldrick I'd like to know where you two are at with the roster.

  

I dont like that Wiffy was fence sitting early either. I'm not sold that she's scum because of it, but I got my eye on her.

I don't like that Hally and I aren't seeing eye to eye. We usually do when we are both town so that's a thing.

Trying to get over my early suspicion of Darthe and MrsClov. They were both based on early and weak reasons, and I would like something more substantial for a scum read.

I still think there was more to Darthe's post than meets the eye. He had yet to change my mind.

It bugs me that MrsClov thought my early post about the setup was rolefishing, and Darthe's post wasn't. It seems noone shares my insight on that, so I guess I should drop it.

I don't have much to say about anyone else yet.

[unvote]

There's probably nothing to AJ voting Darthe instead of Nolder.

Hasn't changed. Most likely voting within that list.

[Wildfire Sedai]

 Wildfire - TOWN QUEENIE

 

POSSIBLE TOWN

Bopolis: .

 Verbal

Dice

MrsClov

 

NULL

 Niniel

  Eldrick 

 Nolder

 Lenlo 

 Ironeyes

 

POSSIBLE SCUM

 Darthe

.  Hallia

 

 

THEY ARE NOT IN ANY SPECIAL ORDER UNDER HEADINGS

[MrsClov]

 

Wildfire - TOWN QUEENIE

 

POSSIBLE TOWN

Bopolis: .

Verbal

Dice

MrsClov

 

NULL

Niniel

 

Eldrick

Nolder

Lenlo

Ironeyes

 

POSSIBLE SCUM

Darthe

. Hallia

 

 

THEY ARE NOT IN ANY SPECIAL ORDER UNDER HEADINGS

Where does AJ fall on Your list?

[bopolis]

wifi,

 

why do you think hallia is a wolf, because up until that list I don't thnk you ever mentioned her except for quoting one of her posts asking 'what it means'?

[Darthe]

I'm a bit busy today folks, but am gonna [v] nolder [/v].  I'll be back!  Still a fan of lynching wild.

[Andrej]

Happy birthday Darthe

[bopolis]

 

 I have been town...lemme see...this is my 14th game and I only been scum 3 times so yeah 11/14 games.....[snip]

 

 

 

 

question:

 

you have 13 games listed in your signature and two of them are mafia games.

 

So if this is your 14th game, is this also your third scum game?