DEMONOLOGY - GAME THREAD

[Zander?]

 

 

I like you as scum cause I don't like your hunt.  Your meta is no different D1 this game than D1 last game.  You do this on purpose to hide.  It's obvious. not very flattering.

I was town D1 last game lol

 

 

But you are scum D1 this game...lol

 

 

.....lolololololol

 

 

 

I have, but he hasnt given any reasons for me being a wolf beyond his reaction to this catchup. Beyond that his sole reason was "Hes afk", when half the game is afk. Now I dont think I am misrepping him. I think what I said, with the quotes I have shown, perfectly support what I have said. Nowhere in there however did I ever say "Snow is a wolf". "Lets lynch Snow". "Vote Snow". All I did was say that it was wolfy and that I didnt like his handleing of Zander in the first half of the game. In response to that, he hops all over me tries to argue semantics and dissect every post I make. The entire time with, what seems to me but im clearly biased in this debate, as a predetermined notion that I am a wolf. Predetermined notions like that are wolfy imo.

Blue's fine.  I mean villagers tunnel villagers too but it's generically fine.  But red, if you want to talk semantics "wolfy" vs "a wolf" is about as petty as it gets mate.  I'm reading this out of context from your actual argument with him but I would safely assume that any player ought to read your list as "Snow is the person I'm most comfortable lynching right now".

 

I'm not sure how relevant that is to your argument with him? but I guess my thinking is if Snow's a villager trying to figure out which of the people voting him is a wolf he has grounds to suspect you.

 

Still want to know what his reason for wanting to lynch you prior to your reads list was though.

 

Thats fine. Suppose I could word it better as "Leaning wolf" or whatever, but its supposed to be the middle ground between 100% wolf lynch this person and Null

 

 

Post 530, sorry. Was off by one.

Is it sad that I couldn't be arsed to look up one post or notice that you were directly quoting it above, but I remembered that it was on page 27?

 

Yeah probably.

 

It gives me the heebeegeebees for a second every time I've read it because he took up the exact same line as a wolf in TG, but I can't help but think he wouldn't say it consistently as a wolf unless he'd say it as a villager too.

 

Policy lynching is stupid but we know villagers do it. My ISO-less memory of Snow's early game was his focus on Hermes. /shrug

 

Pretty safe. Glad to know im not the only person who found it questionable though. And as AJ said, Snow hasnt given a reason for why im wolf beyond "Hes afk, put pressure on slot". So his wolf read of me is really rather recent all things considered.

 

 

Early based on when he stated it in his reads list?

[Lenlo]

Alright Zander, we are talking, thats good.

 

The pushing or not pushing is a matter of opinion. No fixing that and thus theres no way your going to be able to reconcile my suss of Snow.

 

The catch up post was for the first 40 pages, most of which was fluff and a slog to read through with alot of different people.  So with those in mind, of course its not going to be stupid in depth.

 

There are alot of nulls because theres alot of people with less than 10 posts in this game. Should they be anything other than nulls? I dont see why that ones a problem. You call the list easy to throw together, other people say the list has to many non-nulls/has more reads than they expected. It cant be both.

[John Snow]

 

-snip-

Seemed like a lot of reads for the amount of content in the first 30 pages, but Len could just be better at reading spam than I am. (I'm like 70% percent sure that's the right grammar)

He did have a lot of nulls tbf so I wouldn't say it was a super in depth list but I see your point to some degree

 

Anyone else you'd string up atp? You're in first and Lenlo isn't that close of a second

 

 

Not really. I need to go back and reread some people in the morning, but I think Lenlo's the way to go atp. 

 

There's a few things that are definitely striking me as odd that I haven't commented on. I'll grab those in the morning too. 

[John Snow]

Also, Jesus Christ Zander. Learn to snip quotes. 

[Zander?]

I am in desperate need of Pralaya content.

 

Yep.

 

All i know is that he thinks im Town.

 

Other that no idea.

 

Its not a great look for him imo.

 

 

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

i must have missed something. I thought hermes was the only one to claim. 

 

 

These weird pop in posts with little to no content are off putting.

 

Im not sure of your Meta but it feels like youre lurking and just making off comments to look involved.

 

If youre a Villager you need to open up more and share your thoughts/reads and get more involved in real time if possible.

 

Would you mind posting like a laid out reads list with some reasoning please?!?!?!?!

 

It will go a long ways in helping me and prolly others as well formulate a read on you.

 

 

 

 

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

 

I'm already voting Snow bud

 

You're missing out

 

 

Nah, pretty sure I found scum...could vote Krak or Darthe...but Shad deserves to swing?

 

 

Why Krak?!?!?!

 

If its activity based why him over someone like Pral or Amega for example?

[Zander?]

I still think Leelou could easily be a wolf but I keep signing up for advanced games like a clown.

 

Ya I need to ISO her again because im not sure what Tress saw or thinks she saw because other then that Im not sure why anyone would have her as a Villa atp.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Looking at Snow's ISO I see nothing obvious that indicates why/when he started scum reading Lenlo

 

There's just a one-liner that says Snow is putting Lenlo into his WTL

 

Are you more inclined to lynch Snow or Lenlo since you're amazing analysis?

 

I'm already voting Snow bud

 

You're missing out

 

 

Nah, pretty sure I found scum...could vote Krak or Darthe...but Shad deserves to swing?

 

 

I doubt Shad is scum. He didn't vote anyone at all D1 in the game you're talking about until near DL when you were ran up. His snap vote on Leelou is already in contrast if you wanna talk meta.

 

I won't ask about Darthe cause I already know the answer.

 

Why Krak though?

 

 

Dude deserves to swing.

 

Y not Darthe?

 

How do you have him in you town pile?

 

Could you vote Crusher?

 

 

I seen Crusher post a couple times in the sign up thread but not here so, thats a little worrisome imo.

 

 

 

 

 

I wonder how many wolves are hiding behind the fact that villagers are hiding behind their role pms.

 

lulz

i must have missed something. I thought hermes was the only one to claim. 

 

 

Amega are you openly wolfing in my thread?

 

It's ok.  You can tell me.

 

 

^^^Fake News ^^^

 

 

BEST POST EVER!!!!!!!!!

 

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[Zander?]

The more Notbob calls me a wolf the more I think he's a villager.

 

God I'm so easy to pocket.

 

Shad if youre a Villager and you make another post like this and I drive a lynch on you....you cant say shit to me post game for mislynching you!!!!

 

 

I read the back and forth between Snow and Lenlo this evening and am not entirely sure what to think about it.  I don't necessarily think it's a hard bus party, but both of them have struck me as questionable.  

 

Maybe we should just lynch Nolder after all.  

 

I will be around a lot tomorrow before deadline, housework be damned.  Would really like Crusher, Ironeyes, Pral, Krak and Amega to put some more thoughts out there so I can see where they're coming from.

 

I really really really dont think Lenlo and John Snow are w/w here.

 

It reads a little weird you thought to comment on that imo.

 

Maybe so lolme but still feels a little weird.

[dicetosser1]

 

-snip-

think youre wrong here zander. Lenlos go at snow fairly screams town.

 

How? At all?

 

 

Also @ ZANDER

 

Scum lenlo does not come out that hard when hes basically starting out. His tone is honest and gives me visions of him standing yelling in ure face, neck veins bulging.

 

Reads honest reaction

 

@ Tress a lot of people in this game play together on JN, if that's of any use to you.

 

I'm well aware.  I've played there once, and co-modded a game a few years back with Hally.  I tend to avoid it because I know how much they all adore DM visitors

 

 

Well they adore SOME of us. You me, not Zander tho.

 

 

 

 

 

Though I did like how you hid during my calls for your investigation results you sick cowardly scum.

I don't even understand what this means.

 

 

When you scummed...you hid like a three year old.  Just saying.

 

And I've been pretty much waggling my **** in the middle of the thread since the minute it opened so :???: I don't know what you mean by calls for my investigation results.

 

 

Shad plz remember this is not JN.

[Lenlo]

Do you think we could be v/v Zander? Or is it a flat w/v interaction?

[Zander?]

Car salesmen are people too Zander

 

Color me offended

 

Wolves arent real people imo.

 

 

I mean we can continue this dance of soft sussing me (Shad included) or you can sack up and accept that if I'm a wolf you're not gonna catch me D1 or just tell the voice in your head to shut up and see if we lynch some wolves

 

I'd go with the second option imo

 

Ill go with the third option.

 

Zander gonna Zander

 

Im not tunneling on you...yet....so if youre Town bare and work with me.

 

If youre Scum please continue.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Though I did like how you hid during my calls for your investigation results you sick cowardly scum.

I don't even understand what this means.

 

 

When you scummed...you hid like a three year old.  Just saying.

 

And I've been pretty much waggling my cock in the middle of the thread since the minute it opened so :???: I don't know what you mean by calls for my investigation results.

 

Nice Game of Thrones quote (I assume)

[dicetosser1]

 

I have, but he hasnt given any reasons for me being a wolf beyond his reaction to this catchup. Beyond that his sole reason was "Hes afk", when half the game is afk. Now I dont think I am misrepping him. I think what I said, with the quotes I have shown, perfectly support what I have said. Nowhere in there however did I ever say "Snow is a wolf". "Lets lynch Snow". "Vote Snow". All I did was say that it was wolfy and that I didnt like his handleing of Zander in the first half of the game. In response to that, he hops all over me tries to argue semantics and dissect every post I make. The entire time with, what seems to me but im clearly biased in this debate, as a predetermined notion that I am a wolf. Predetermined notions like that are wolfy imo.

Blue's fine.  I mean villagers tunnel villagers too but it's generically fine.  But red, if you want to talk semantics "wolfy" vs "a wolf" is about as petty as it gets mate.  I'm reading this out of context from your actual argument with him but I would safely assume that any player ought to read your list as "Snow is the person I'm most comfortable lynching right now".

 

I'm not sure how relevant that is to your argument with him? but I guess my thinking is if Snow's a villager trying to figure out which of the people voting him is a wolf he has grounds to suspect you.

 

Still want to know what his reason for wanting to lynch you prior to your reads list was though.

 

 

actually shad  WOLFY is a description.  eg Zander saying he is minority town never scum is wolfy.

 

Saying someone is A WOLF  or wolf is a noun. Your naming them. That one IS saying you think the person is scum but wolfY is not saying , definitively, that you think their a scum it is saying that their action/s is scummy.

[Zander?]

Alright Zander, we are talking, thats good.

 

1. The pushing or not pushing is a matter of opinion. No fixing that and thus theres no way your going to be able to reconcile my suss of Snow.
2. The catch up post was for the first 40 pages, most of which was fluff and a slog to read through with alot of different people.  So with those in mind, of course its not going to be stupid in depth.
3. There are alot of nulls because theres alot of people with less than 10 posts in this game. Should they be anything other than nulls? I dont see why that ones a problem. You call the list easy to throw together, other people say the list has to many non-nulls/has more reads than they expected. It cant be both.

 

1. I agree with its a matter of opinion my issue is I think that you manufacutred a reason so to speak because I personally dont see any way what John said could be taken as an actual push.
2. I get that and Im not saying that I expected something major or epic just more.  Like I expect Town!Len to comment more or have more to share et.
3. Reads list straight read like making one for the sake of making one imo.

 

My read/vote of you isnt locked in or set in stone man.  If youre a Villager youve got time to show me.  This is just where my heads at currently.

[Zander?]

 

 

-snip-

think youre wrong here zander. Lenlos go at snow fairly screams town.

 

How? At all?

 

 

Also @ ZANDER

 

Scum lenlo does not come out that hard when hes basically starting out. His tone is honest and gives me visions of him standing yelling in ure face, neck veins bulging.

 

Reads honest reaction

 

@ Tress a lot of people in this game play together on JN, if that's of any use to you.

 

I'm well aware.  I've played there once, and co-modded a game a few years back with Hally.  I tend to avoid it because I know how much they all adore DM visitors

 

 

Well they adore SOME of us. You me, not Zander tho.

 

 

 

First post:  I disagree, in GnD he came out at me.  I know its a bit different but still noted.  But Lenlo's reaction is too over the top.  I have no idea what would cause him to be that frustrated atp and with what was going on itt imo.

 

Second post: sadface.gif

[Darthe]

K, i've halfway coherently caught up and I am confident in there being a wolf beyween Z, shad and AJ.  Really doubt its Z tbh.  Thinking Verbs one.  JS could be, or notbob, and maybe Leelou but not if verb/notbob are I don't think.  

 

That's what I've got so far in terms of wolf reads.  bed time

[Zander?]

Do you think we could be v/v Zander? Or is it a flat w/v interaction?

 

I think w/v is more likely atp because of my read on you.

 

But v/v is quite possible.

 

And w/w is a very low possibility imo.

[Zander?]

 

 

I have, but he hasnt given any reasons for me being a wolf beyond his reaction to this catchup. Beyond that his sole reason was "Hes afk", when half the game is afk. Now I dont think I am misrepping him. I think what I said, with the quotes I have shown, perfectly support what I have said. Nowhere in there however did I ever say "Snow is a wolf". "Lets lynch Snow". "Vote Snow". All I did was say that it was wolfy and that I didnt like his handleing of Zander in the first half of the game. In response to that, he hops all over me tries to argue semantics and dissect every post I make. The entire time with, what seems to me but im clearly biased in this debate, as a predetermined notion that I am a wolf. Predetermined notions like that are wolfy imo.

Blue's fine.  I mean villagers tunnel villagers too but it's generically fine.  But red, if you want to talk semantics "wolfy" vs "a wolf" is about as petty as it gets mate.  I'm reading this out of context from your actual argument with him but I would safely assume that any player ought to read your list as "Snow is the person I'm most comfortable lynching right now".

 

I'm not sure how relevant that is to your argument with him? but I guess my thinking is if Snow's a villager trying to figure out which of the people voting him is a wolf he has grounds to suspect you.

 

Still want to know what his reason for wanting to lynch you prior to your reads list was though.

 

 

actually shad  WOLFY is a description.  eg Zander saying he is minority town never scum is wolfy.

 

Saying someone is A WOLF  or wolf is a noun. Your naming them. That one IS saying you think the person is scum but wolfY is not saying , definitively, that you think their a scum it is saying that their action/s is scummy.

 

 

I have no idea what the point of this post is Dice but I had to call out the Wolfy AF example you tried to tarnish my Villagery reputation!!!!!

[dicetosser1]

 

Do you think we could be v/v Zander? Or is it a flat w/v interaction?

 

I think w/v is more likely atp because of my read on you.

 

But v/v is quite possible.

 

And w/w is a very low possibility imo.

 

 

zander besides lenlo who are you talking about here?

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

I have no idea what the point of this post is Dice but I had to call out the Wolfy AF example you tried to tarnish my Villagery reputation!!!!!

 

 

lol

[Zander?]

K, i've halfway coherently caught up and I am confident in there being a wolf beyween Z, shad and AJ.  Really doubt its Z tbh.  Thinking Verbs one.  JS could be, or notbob, and maybe Leelou but not if verb/notbob are I don't think.  

 

That's what I've got so far in terms of wolf reads.  bed time

 

What makes you think theres a WOlf in me/shad/aj?

 

If you dont think its me who is it more likely and why?

 

Could you give some reasons for any of these?

 

Also with the bold. 

 

Why is that?

 

And also I find it a tad ironic you make a associative read like that when you said to JiF you like it more because he was sussing me for doing it fwiw.

[Zander?]

 

 

Do you think we could be v/v Zander? Or is it a flat w/v interaction?

 

I think w/v is more likely atp because of my read on you.

 

But v/v is quite possible.

 

And w/w is a very low possibility imo.

 

 

zander besides lenlo who are you talking about here?

 

 

it was about john snow and him.

 

i made a comment about tress saying she didnt think john and lenlo were w/w.

[dicetosser1]

thanks z

 

 

Ive been sitting on page 67 for like... 4 hours just to lazy to actually finish it. Ive got a pretty good idea of the thread though.

 

so if ure caught up reads/thoughts on people? other then JS plz

[Andrej]

 

Car salesmen are people too Zander

 

Color me offended

Wolves arent real people imo.

 

I mean we can continue this dance of soft sussing me (Shad included) or you can sack up and accept that if I'm a wolf you're not gonna catch me D1 or just tell the voice in your head to shut up and see if we lynch some wolves

 

I'd go with the second option imo

Ill go with the third option.

 

Zander gonna Zander

 

Im not tunneling on you...yet....so if youre Town bare and work with me.

 

If youre Scum please continue.

Continue what?

 

Your first reason to vote me was because I wasn't posting

 

Now I am. So your reason for still thinking me scum is ??

[Andrej]

K, i've halfway coherently caught up and I am confident in there being a wolf beyween Z, shad and AJ. Really doubt its Z tbh. Thinking Verbs one. JS could be, or notbob, and maybe Leelou but not if verb/notbob are I don't think.

 

That's what I've got so far in terms of wolf reads. bed time

That's a ton of associative reads with zero support

[Nolder]

 

 

 

Current Vote Count:

 

John Snow (6) - AJ, dice, Nolder, honeyBooBoo, Darthe, Hermes

Hermes (1) - John Snow

AJ (1) - Zander

Krak (1) - NB

Shad (1) - Leelou

Lenlo (1) - Tiinker

Leelou (1) - Shad

 

With 21 players, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

 

Deadline: January 7th, Saturday, 6 PM EST.

 

Lack of a counterwagon is not a good sign early D1 imo.

 

Imma catch up and see if I want to move my vote or not but Im not a fan of no other real wagon tho.

 

Not a bad point.

Let's force Kaylee to vote for someone.

 

Unvote

Vote Kaylee

 

 

You still didnt tell me why you voted for john snow ffs, why kay Nolder?

 

For pressure to vote?

 

Seems kinda weak imo

I didn't see you ask, sorry.

I voted John to get a bigger train going.

 

Kaylee I remembered earlier saying she wasn't voting because she didn't have a good read on anyone or something like that and I thought ok well it's been awhile and she should have a better idea by now or she might be stalling so maybe a vote or two will nudge her into a decision.