[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[SiRReN]

For the record Darthe, I was following Regy. We talked about it and decided to do it together. If I'd felt strongly against it I would have said something, but I honestly wasn't completely against it.

[Darthe]

I wasnt either. I voted him too. Im giving cory my push for the reasons outlined, and im driving enough that id hoped to get something more from him. Instead it was an effing mess, and I cant help that. So got no choice but to move on.

[Cory Caboose]

*walks back in like nothing happened*

 

[Cory Caboose]

... forgot my keys.

 

*gets keys, leaves again*

[Clovdyx]

He left. Bummer, but unchangeable.

 

Clov where ya at irt the lynch?

 

Nowhere.  I haven't seen whatever happened between 2:30 when I went back to work and 6:30 or whatever time I left the office.  I'm going to start my reread now.

[Cory Caboose]

Clov if you are a villager you may be our only hope

 

No pressure

[Sili Quirrels]

I will always defend Cory, or someone who is legit upset, look at oh...any game where it has ever happened?

i'm usually upset and you never defend me.

[Sili Quirrels]

is my upsetness not legit enough or something?

[Andrej]

Fwiw I felt good about the lynch.

 

I was between BFG and Zalanna after catching up for lunch. BFG was already at 4 and had shown back up and was posting constructively imo. I didn't feel the need to continue wagoning her so I voted Zalanna instead for a bigger spread. I didn't expect a pile on like what happened at EOD.

 

What Sili says about them getting wagoned for being afk is over simplifying it. They were afk at the wrong time when they needed to be here the most. I standby the arguments made against them, and the empty promises were not encouraging when taken into context.

 

It sucks. We were wrong, but I'm not really discouraged. Such is Mafia.

 

The amount of vote movement at EOD with the wagons as close as they were means that we had to be right somewhere. I agree with Regy or Sirren, whoever said it, that continuing with BFG or Wildfire tomorrow is a good approach while we continue to pin down reads on others. Just because we mislynched D1 doesn't mean we need to have catastrophic failure. Like chill out.

[Clovdyx]

Still catching up, but I feel the need to do this.

 

i think if clov was a wolf his arguments would be bloody terrible and i'd know it instinctually like the last couple times i've played with him and he was a wolf.

 

You mean the game where you literally said I could lead town after you drew the N1 NK and proceeded to follow me on the game-sealing mislynch, or the game where it literally took an investigation for you to vote me?

[Hallia]

If you're getting upset because someone is picking at you? I would. I seem to recall threatening to find you irl in this thread already and hug you.

[Sili Quirrels]

If you're getting upset because someone is picking at you? I would. I seem to recall threatening to find you irl in this thread already and hug you.

oh, lol, i thought you were joking.

[Andrej]

Do you feel validated now Sili?

 

Idk why this is even a topic rn.

[Darthe]

:(

[Clovdyx]

Somebody remind me to congratulate Hallia postgame on a really good post if she's town, or an absolutely sick post if she's mafia.

[Wildfire Sedai]

Well, I am finally officially caught up. Here are a couple of quotes I found during my read that I thought were very informative....Please look at the bold italicized parts 

 

 

I already fought it off today

I don't think I've ever had a real life day this involved as a wolf ever and I'm probably not even capable of it

 

I don't know that you're wrong, but I'm pretty sure you've said this pretty much every time you've randed scum.  Ever.

 

 

 

 

 

Regy you should know by now why I am handling your slot the way I am

If you had no idea about my "deep dark super stronk wolfgame" people seem to be so afraid of, how would you be reading my slot? On my content alone?

snipped

snipped

 

Here are two references to HIS "wolf game." Totally unasked for, or so it seems to me.  Is this some subtle hint that he's wolf? Is he playing on the edge? 

 

What say you Cory? 

[Cory Caboose]

BFG is the wolf I let get away yesterday

 

God bless her heart she got out of it

 

Clov she really is a wolf.

[Regy Rusty]

Greetings friends I took a break from the thread to wash some dishes (and good thing too because I missed the rest of that argument that I probably wouldn't have been able to keep out of and possibly made worse) and think and I came up with something else

 

To anyone who thinks Cory could be mafia, consider this and give a cogent explanation if you would:

 

Why, if Cory is mafia and BFG is town, would Cory be the first to pull off her and say to give her a chance? BFG was eminently lynchable until Cory switched to Zalanna. A town BFG day 1 lynch would've been way more valuable to the mafia AND wouldn't have put Cory under any more suspicion than he's under already. The longer town BFG lives the greater opportunity she has to clear herself and become someone the mafia has to kill.

 

This isn't an argument that BFG is scum (those are separate) but I think it's a pretty good one that Cory isn't. If he's town he doesn't know BFG's alignment and had every reason to have doubts once she defended herself. His reasoning makes sense from that perspective. It doesn't make sense as scum unless he was sure I was suddenly going to change my mind which would have been impressive because I wasn't even sure what I was going to do.

 

As for the possibility that they're w/w - if so they've played a very strange game as I think both of them could have easily gotten away without making the other their only (in BFG's case) or one of their few (in Cory's case) primary targets. Especially since the end result of their antagonism is that it's very likely at least one of them is going to get resolved soon. So I don't think that's likely.

 

I think Cory is town, I don't think this could come from him as mafia. If I'm wrong he's thoroughly fooled me but at this point it's going to take some kind of incredible smoking gun to get me to change my mind on him. This is the wrong avenue to explore.

 

That's all.

[Cory Caboose]

Seph might be a wolf too.

[Andrej]

Seph might be a wolf too.

Yes.

[Wildfire Sedai]

Thank you, Regy....when you say it like that it makes more sense...noted.

[Cory Caboose]

Regy Darthe doesn't even think I'm a wolf probably

 

He's just being Darthe

 

It's ok

[Regy Rusty]

Seph might be a wolf too.

 

Right that was in my head while washing dishes as well

 

BFG set up the hammer once and Seph actually did it

 

Not that it mattered TOO much since the phase was almost over anyway but Seph still joined the bandwagon last

[Andrej]

His vote on BFG is important to that transition, Regy.

[Regy Rusty]

Regy Darthe doesn't even think I'm a wolf probably

 

He's just being Darthe

 

It's ok

 

Doesn't matter it's still valid and can be brought up later if things go that way again