Beyond the Wall - Game Thread - GAME OVER

[dicetosser1]

proof?

[Katiora]

How can anyone prove it?? I'd show you my pm but that'd defeat the purpose if I just got modkilled

[Andrej]

It's her or Celeste at this point Dice.

[Katiora]

[v]katiora[/v]

[Andrej]

???

[Wildfire Sedai]

My internet went down....why did you vote on yourself....??? 

[dicetosser1]

you know give thoughts.

 

claims.

 

 

things like that

[dicetosser1]

fine

 

vote katiora

[SiRReN]

Well this is gonna be interesting :/

[Wildfire Sedai]

is that even allowed???

[Wildfire Sedai]

I'm gonna finish my reread but seems kind of silly to answer any questions with regard to day 1 when d1 is over....

[Andrej]

I think she hammered herself?

 

That's sketchy :-/

 

I'll be back later to see the flip. I don't think it's gonna be good though

[dicetosser1]

im voting purely for the self vote.

[Andrej]

DL was 9 minutes ago. You vote won't count I don't think

[Shad_]

 

I don't know, I think Dice has been barking up the wrong tree quite a bit in this game and on the one hand it's usually a good look when he's off in left field doing his own thing, on the other it feels a little opportunistic.  Like a matter of trying to defend hard without looking like you're defending hard by actually going after the people pushing the lynch instead of just defending.

 

/shrug

 

Kind of want to see a Z flip before I put too much thought into it.

 

im not actually defending zander you know.  i havent given one reason why he is town. Im taking issue with lenlos thinking and a post of sirrens  not people wanting to lynch zander

 

and to another question from u   yeah i think you missed something. I quoted sirrens post and highlighted the whole planning bit when i voted her. Also said about since when does town have a plan?  she responded to me after which i said i was leaving my vote

 

Red, I just don't see how you can have all of these reads revolving around the treatment of Zander and yet have no opinion on his slot at this point.  I mean you've called multiple players scummy for their pushes on Zander.  If you're a villager, you should think the slot is > rand town at this point even if you consider it null on its own merits, unless you think he was heavily bussed, which I assume you would have stated at this point.  So defending him isn't a bad thing under these circumstances and I don't see why you'd deny it.  If you're a wolf and Zander is a villager, I think you'd be pretty chill with letting his lynch go through.  Neither is the case here.  You're sort of distancing from him by insisting you don't have an opinion on him while still sussing the people who push him.  That feels like a wolf defending a team mate.  The fact that you're denying any sort of defense is part of the issue.

 

 

Blue, I did see you highlight a particular statement and I didn't really understand why at the time.  You literally just said "Wanna tell me how town can carry on with what they were planning? Vote: Sirren".  I took your next post as a follow-through, not a second point.  If your an issue was specifically her use of the word "planning"...  ok?  I'll grant that you didn't change your reasoning mid-stride then, but it's weak to the point that I didn't even interpret it as one at the time.

 

I guess I've never been shy to call things as they are and it doesn't bother me when others do.  Zander was the most likely person to be the D1 lynch at the time she posted.  Calling it the "plan" is just stating reality and if anything demonstrates a lack of concern for how other players perceive you.  That you don't see it this way isn't necessarily bothersome, though I wish you'd been more explicit, but it doesn't really resolve my concern about your second point--the whole business of town!Sirren should have just voted him and not waited for Celeste to start posting.

[Shad_]

DL was 9 minutes ago. You vote won't count I don't think

 

wait what

[Shad_]

I thought DL was 10 pm

[Andrej]

7pm EST iirc

[Shad_]

yeeeeaahhh I wasn't able to check the thread until a few minutes beforehand anyway but would have voted Zander based on where my head was at at the time

[Shad_]

I had Kat pretty much null at the time.  This will be an interesting read.

[Shad_]

[v]katiora[/v]

 

 

fine

 

vote katiora

 

Without knowing what happened yet, voting a player who just voted herself is ~awful.

[Shad_]

If Kat flips town Dice is a wolf approximately  always.

[Shad_]

I am 13 pages behind and want to know what haaaaaappened

[Hallia]

If Kat flips town Dice is a wolf approximately  always.

and if town?

[PrincessBFlea]

I am 13 pages behind and want to know what haaaaaappened

@Shad_ Basically, Everyone has started to feel less good about the Celeste lynch, then she claimed vanilla villager, Kat voted her without having given any reads at all and repeatedly saying she was either confused, didn't see anyone being scummy or didn't have any opinon. Enter the Chinese Firedrill, per AJ asking people if they would be good with that!