[Basic/Standard] A Wind in the Door Mafia - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[Sleeper Service]

GOAT

 

nice work town, I didn't even have to finish that re-read

 

THANKS TRESS!

[Cory Caboose]

Thanks for playing Hoya :)

[csarmi]

Hoya was kind of overpowered.

[Sleeper Service]

I was good the first couple days, though pral was a victim of serious wrongness on my part. Second to last day got hectic, last day you guys SLAMMED IT before I got to re-read. Was sweet. 

[csarmi]

You of all people was the least likely to get Pral right.

 

Don't worry about that.

 

It's funny he fot lynchdd by 4 poggers btw.

[csarmi]

I was good the first couple days, though pral was a victim of serious wrongness on my part. Second to last day got hectic, last day you guys SLAMMED IT before I got to re-read. Was sweet.

 

We almost self protected last night but then we didn't wanna steal your thunder. BTW if i have any serious doubts about the gf thing i self prot all the time. I had four villagers with 98%+ certainty.

[dicetosser1]

being a hydra was interesting.

 

Csarmi and i work pretty well together   we are different enough to compliment each other and theres no ego to get in the way, but i found myself going to do something and going "oh i need to check with csarmi first" which was weird. his soft claim and then finally hard claim had me goin :O for a second but it was typical csarmi play and while not what I might have done, wasnt like WTF did you do that for.  If he'd pulled a gambit like yates did on leelou there might have been a problem tho   lol

[csarmi]

Hah. Totally forgot to tell you that you dont have to check anything with me first :-)

 

Works better that way. Most actions that make sense at a given time make no sense a couple of hours later.

 

I think we only did consult much on the teally important stuff tho. I think it worked well.

[csarmi]

Yea i did explain the soft claim on qt (that i do that every game so we can prolly get away with it. Actually we kind of did)

[Krakalakachkn]

Town won?

[Sili Quirrels]

No.

 

 

 

Maybe.

Probably, considering the thread header.

 

 

[csarmi]

#hottakes from hydra qt

 

Salami: A rational woman? Nonsense

Tress: modkill for half the hydra?

Dice: [v]modkill[/v] - watches Tress lynched

Salami: [v]Tress[/v] - come on Dice we can do it!

 

---

Salami: {softclaim} ... Confirm nothing. I am known to trying to pull NK as town vanilla... let's abuse that

Dice: lol im staying right away from that

 

---

Salami: {day one PoE}

so it's your call. don't lynch

 

Tina

Cory

HallyYates

JMM

Len

 

Dice: thats my no lynch list too actually

 

---

Dice: {N1} - im seriously thinking either turtle or play the odds and protect cory

Salami: {N1} - They prolly stay away from us/Cory after the show. Maybe even Yates. I would wanna shoot outside that. (*Yolo protects Tina*)

 

---

Salami: {cc} - Smart decision: Lynch Tommy. Let them peek more and see.

Dice: (*votes no lynch ITT*)

 

---

Dice: {n3} - my gut says go turtle actually but its at war with the fact that our job is to protect the cop.

Salami: {n3} - Dice if you don't send the action in 3 hours i will.

Salami: {one minute later} - In fact your gut says turtle. (*Yolo turtles*)

[csarmi]

I think i agree that lenlo seems villagery on his tone, and that makes me trust him more

I think I'm at

DicearmI

cory

hoya

lenlo

For my villagers right now with tom being honorary survivor.

ManGOAT

[BFG]

Congrats Town! Was really, really nice to follow this and see a town unit come together :)

 

<3

[Tommyrod]

Congrats Town! Was really, really nice to follow this and see a town unit come together :)

 

<3

What what? What game were you reading?

 

Silly BFG

[Cory Caboose]

I think it's in comparison to most DM towns

[Cory Caboose]

You know,

 

 

 

 

 

 

Darthe

[csarmi]

We has banished the Tommy.

 

Nothing elsd matters.

[Kivam]

BTW, as a mentor - JMM played about as perfect an IC role as you can.  Nicely in the middle muddle early days, drawing suspicion enough to avoid NK but not enough to be lynched, then confirmed himself late.  I wouldn't have released the info in the middle of night, and it didn't save Yates, which was his goal, but surviving that long helped mechanically lock the game for the town.

[csarmi]

I disagree. He was likely to be cop viewed or vigged. I wouldn't have blamed a vig shooting him. Also he was almost lynched d1. I think he should have confirmed himself in the end day 1 mash.

[Yates]

I think he should have confirmed himself in the end day 1 mash.

Meh. This is like the old argument about claiming miller post 1 or waiting. There are merits to both. I agree that JMM could have done a little better job of making himself more obvious Town [to avoid potential wasted cop view] but you can't argue with the results of his timing. That reveal must have been really frustrating for scum.

[jmm]

That was a pretty fun role to have

[jmm]

Thank you for the help, Kivam!

[csarmi]

Well I certainly did like his play and kind of had him clear Townish too after a while when he started opening up.

[Cory Caboose]

last word