Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[dicetosser1]

aaannnd the answer is no. he just claimed Watson

[csarmi]

Feel like placing a vote Dice?

[csarmi]

[unvote]

[V]Tina[/v]

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

Csarmi (2): Len, Tsuki

pray (1) Des

Tsuki (2): Hally, BFG

Des (2): pray, Turin

Tina (1): csarmi

 

Not voting (3): Krak, Tina, dice

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140702T21&p0=422

[csarmi]

Don't do it Hallia, be a rebel. I got yo back!

[csarmi]

 

So def sticking with Pray/Tsuki/Tina now. Pray is flustered that Rags left a hint behind incriminating him, and Tsuki and Tina both continued the antagonistic push against Csarmi again today (acting like his self-vote was that significant even tho it was for CONSOLIDATION). All three are LOCK SCUM for me.

And if I flip Town, who is scum? Cause we are running short on mislynches. That is what I want to know - I WILL flip town, but if I do so, who is the Scum? See, the point of this game is NOT for your best buddy, townie, bondee to live, it is for your TEAM to win. So, If I flip Town, who is scum?

 

If that's a snipe at me clearing Chae. I didn't clear her because she was my bondee. I cleared her on some interactions based on what I know about her mafia game approach (and that's a lot, trust me).

 

So who do you think the scum are? You locked Csarmi/Chak/Hally/Pray team earlier, Pray seemed to have been viewed scum, but you never moved there. Why?

 

What are your reads on everyone?

[csarmi]

oh you did... later

 

questions remain tho

[csarmi]

[unvote]

 

[V] Despo

 

Pralaya is town. Trust me on this

 

I'm Dr. Watson.

 

Despo, if you thought I must be the doctor then why in the seven seas would you #Yolo vote me? And then why would you broadcast that to the thread? A townie would have kept there mouth shut there.

 

Csarmi, if you truly doubted rags lestrade claim why did you ask him for results? In fact you queried both investigators about things. You also asked NotBob about his magic 8 ball post. Each following night they died.

I don't really remember about NotBob. I think I had a town read on him and wanted to know his opinion. Just seemed natural there. Was stupid in retrospect, honestly I just wasn't thinking clearly. I might have tipped of the mafia team there :(

 

For Ithi/Rags - I thought to catch him in a lie or smth. I didn't think that through either cause it never seriously crossed my mind that he'd be cop, not until he flipped.

[Hallia]

O.o you asked a question? I missed it.

[Turin Turambar]

Despo, don't play in such a dogmatic manner. Of course there are times that town should keep quiet about reasons. That is why you broadcast your townieness so that you have town credit when you need it. Your just fishing now.

 

 

I'll tell you tomorrow, if I'm alive.

 

@Csarmi, so your answer is you just played bad? It never crossed your mind that someone who claimed to be inspector lestrade could be an investigator, even after Holmes flipped as something other than cop? I don't by it.

[Turin Turambar]

Still, if Hally is town, why would she vote Tsuki that way yesterday? Hally, explain why you are voting Tsuki and why you voted him, unvoted him and voted him again yesterday.

I think this is it.

[hazelkrs1]

I'm in a pissy mood so prob shouldn't even be posting this but w/e

 

Turin, at the very least if you're town you're WRONG about me. I think I've done a very good job of broadcasting my towniness throughout this game. I've looked to #solve, have considered new info and let my reads adapt to that, and have done as much #work as anyone to help catch scum.

 

I REALLY don't like you acting like we should all just trust you on this even tho you're being cryptic as hell when town needs ALL THE INFO IT CAN GET, but screw it. We have multiple scum to catch, not just one.

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Tina[/v]

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

Csarmi (2): Len, Tsuki

Tsuki (2): Hally, BFG

Des (2): pray, Turin

Tina (2): csarmi, des

 

Not voting (3): Krak, Tina, dice

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynchDL is 9PM tonite EST

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140702T21&p0=422

[Turin Turambar]

So you agree that I am town. As such you should expect that I do have a reason that is in the town's best interests for doing as I am. I gave the information that town needs. You are asking for additional information that the town doesn't need and will be detrimental to the town.

 

I disagree that you have broadcast your townness as several people that you have as town have expressed a willingness to vote you. You can say I'm wrong if you like. I disagree there as well. Hence my vote.

 

Mr grumpy pants Despo. LOL.

 

 

You wanna earn some points with me take a look at dice. I just recalled two instances when I and then later tsuki questioned him. In both he seemed more perturbed that someone was "trying to run up a train on him" than accusing him of being mafia. It seemed odd to me.

[Turin Turambar]

Gotta drive again. Until later.

 

 

Oh and vote Despo, please.

[hazelkrs1]

So you agree that I am town. As such you should expect that I do have a reason that is in the town's best interests for doing as I am. I gave the information that town needs. You are asking for additional information that the town doesn't need and will be detrimental to the town.

 

I disagree that you have broadcast your townness as several people that you have as town have expressed a willingness to vote you. You can say I'm wrong if you like. I disagree there as well. Hence my vote.

 

Mr grumpy pants Despo. LOL.

 

 

You wanna earn some points with me take a look at dice. I just recalled two instances when I and then later tsuki questioned him. In both he seemed more perturbed that someone was "trying to run up a train on him" than accusing him of being mafia. It seemed odd to me.

 

No, just because I think you're town doesn't mean I think you have an actual reason for being cryptic about withheld info.

 

You could not have a reason at all, or more likely, not have info at all in your pocket.

 

It's antitown to withhold information that can help town catch scum. Period.

 

Your obtuseness is frustrating to the point you would not believe.

 

As for Dice, I've read him as town since he replaced back into the game. What you just pointed out doesn't really seem that significant at all to me. His reads have coincided with mine a good bit, yet he hasn't remained dogmatic about Csarmi being scum like Tsuki has. I think you pick the wrong "friends"

[hazelkrs1]

And no matter what I do, or how LOCK CLEAR I am in any game, there will always be people that express a willingness to vote me. If you haven't picked up on that by now Turin, I just don't even know what to freaking say to you.

 

I'm a polarizing player, and have fooled enough people over the years to engender a general distrust of me in mafia games.

 

I get it, I don't cry about it. I work around it, and occasionally use it to my benefit.

[hazelkrs1]

W/e. I'm done with it. Most of my frustration isn't coming from this game, I'm just letting it spill out here. Sorry for that.

 

Regardless, I'm feeling very strongly about Pray, Tina, and Tsuki being scum together. If I'm wrong about any of those, then Lenlo gets shoved in the slot.

 

Bye.

[csarmi]

Despo, don't play in such a dogmatic manner. Of course there are times that town should keep quiet about reasons. That is why you broadcast your townieness so that you have town credit when you need it. Your just fishing now.

 

 

I'll tell you tomorrow, if I'm alive.

 

@Csarmi, so your answer is you just played bad? It never crossed your mind that someone who claimed to be inspector lestrade could be an investigator, even after Holmes flipped as something other than cop? I don't by it.

Yea I'm stupid.

 

But even if it did cross my mind I'd have asked him.

[csarmi]

I'm in a pissy mood so prob shouldn't even be posting this but w/e

 

Turin, at the very least if you're town you're WRONG about me. I think I've done a very good job of broadcasting my towniness throughout this game. I've looked to #solve, have considered new info and let my reads adapt to that, and have done as much #work as anyone to help catch scum.

 

I REALLY don't like you acting like we should all just trust you on this even tho you're being cryptic as hell when town needs ALL THE INFO IT CAN GET, but screw it. We have multiple scum to catch, not just one.

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Tina[/v]

You're right about town needing a lot of info and I'M especially pissed at being D4 and nothing useful revealed whatsoever so far. But yea, there are roles that are better not revealed.

 

I'll name a trivial for you: town bomb.

[csarmi]

And no matter what I do, or how LOCK CLEAR I am in any game, there will always be people that express a willingness to vote me. If you haven't picked up on that by now Turin, I just don't even know what to freaking say to you.

 

I'm a polarizing player, and have fooled enough people over the years to engender a general distrust of me in mafia games.

 

I get it, I don't cry about it. I work around it, and occasionally use it to my benefit.

No, you're a player who intentionally plays somewhat anti-town every game so that your scum games have an easier time (and because you play rather selfish, wanna be the "hero" all the time).

[hazelkrs1]

 

And no matter what I do, or how LOCK CLEAR I am in any game, there will always be people that express a willingness to vote me. If you haven't picked up on that by now Turin, I just don't even know what to freaking say to you.

 

I'm a polarizing player, and have fooled enough people over the years to engender a general distrust of me in mafia games.

 

I get it, I don't cry about it. I work around it, and occasionally use it to my benefit.

No, you're a player who intentionally plays somewhat anti-town every game so that your scum games have an easier time (and because you play rather selfish, wanna be the "hero" all the time).

 

 

There is prob some truth to this (I mean the hero part). It DOES usually work fairly well for me tho so /shrug

 

I know you disagree, but I've kept track of the results. Overall I have a very good winning percentage in mafia.

[Tsukibana]

 

If that's a snipe at me clearing Chae. I didn't clear her because she was my bondee. I cleared her on some interactions based on what I know about her mafia game approach (and that's a lot, trust me).

 

 

 

Nope, not just at you. It also applies to Turin and Ithi.

[csarmi]

My point stands tho. My read is strong and well-founded. Don't forget that in case I die.

[Tsukibana]

I won't. And part of that is why I wanted you dead YESTERDAY. Your death would have removed wine, made Hallia look better, narrowed the field. Ugh, to that pardon.