Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[dicetosser1]

looking at the mynd/ithi thing. Yes you can say ithi started it by jumping at mynd. But she would have had NO WAY to know he was a gladiator let alone that he would use it D1.   this is no matter whatithi/rags is. Based on play im thinking ithi is town and mafia enjoyed the Games that day.

 

 

No time for rereading. Just found out I have to go out of town again for the next 3 days at least.  I need to get to getting my stuff ready to go. But I will give a thought for the road as it were.

 

Why would Thane self vote twice? and self hammer when he is mafia? Symps often have unusual recruiting mechanisms. One that would fit very nicely into this scenario would be that the recruit (Adler) had to be pardoned by the Governor (King o' Bohemia, Who happens to be her old bf).So Thane knows he needs to get lynched in order to get recruited. Hallia may have 1 or 2 shots at it. If she saves the symp they join the team fully. However, either Hallia herself or the team in masse decide that it was too risky and would make her look too bad in everyone's eye. So she cut him loose for town cred. 

 

Csarmi, would you say that Hallia has been more talkative than usual this game? Anyone else who feels strongly about that can chime in also. 

 

Convoluted but possible i guess.

 

Also Turin  Ive seen symps who can and cannot see the QT    no way to know til the end of game.

[csarmi]

@Dice: yea she wouldn't know the gladiator but she'd know that Thane should be saved if possible and what's better than lynch a townie instead.

 

Look at the gladiator fight too.

[csarmi]

I had the impression of Ithi overselling there and focusing on Mynd too much. Didn't pursue it there... But worth a look.

[TheRagnarok]

looking at the mynd/ithi thing. Yes you can say ithi started it by jumping at mynd. But she would have had NO WAY to know he was a gladiator let alone that he would use it D1.   this is no matter whatithi/rags is. Based on play im thinking ithi is town and mafia enjoyed the Games that day.

 

 

No time for rereading. Just found out I have to go out of town again for the next 3 days at least.  I need to get to getting my stuff ready to go. But I will give a thought for the road as it were.

 

Why would Thane self vote twice? and self hammer when he is mafia? Symps often have unusual recruiting mechanisms. One that would fit very nicely into this scenario would be that the recruit (Adler) had to be pardoned by the Governor (King o' Bohemia, Who happens to be her old bf).So Thane knows he needs to get lynched in order to get recruited. Hallia may have 1 or 2 shots at it. If she saves the symp they join the team fully. However, either Hallia herself or the team in masse decide that it was too risky and would make her look too bad in everyone's eye. So she cut him loose for town cred. 

 

Csarmi, would you say that Hallia has been more talkative than usual this game? Anyone else who feels strongly about that can chime in also. 

 

Convoluted but possible i guess.

 

Also Turin  Ive seen symps who can and cannot see the QT    no way to know til the end of game.

Csarmi is trying to confuse looking at multiple scum targets D1 with trying to derail a lynch.  He wants to blur that line in an attempt to give something to his hilarious.  Ithi made it clear that she thought Mynd was pushing misinformation on a character claim, which brought about the accusations of scum.  But accusing someone of being possible scum does not equal causing a derailing.  Otherwise anyone who had listed anyone as being scum could be considered guilty of the same thing.  The only way that Thane was not going down D1 was if Mynd did what he did.  So his entire point is bull. 

[Turin Turambar]

Chae's defense of Thane didn't seem weird to me.

 

I asked her directly and I know that's how she actually feels about Thane's "special" way of playing.

 

I'll have a hard time reading her BTW.

 

 

I don't really feel like addressing this again so this is the last time I'll do.

 

I'm not putting in more effort cause I can't. This isn't likely to change during the game and it may get worse.

 

If you don't like it, I'm sorry but there is nothing I can do right now and actually I don't even care.

 

 

@Rags the crucial information you're missing is that Chae is my bonded (and I have a good idea about how she's playing Mafia and all) and Tgane is Char's husband.

 

Also Thane has some history of playing as scummy as possible when town.

The bolded in the first and third quote seems to contradict each other. You have a hard time reading her and yet you have a good idea about how she is playing. Also If you have a hard time reading her then why did you support and follow earlier so easily.

[csarmi]

I thought I'd have a hard time cause bonded (we've only played together once in the shayol ghul OUAT game but there was nothing to read there cause I got lynched before she started playing) and cause I know how self-aware she keeps playing... But it actually made it easier.

[csarmi]

Ie. I thought that having too much information on how she plays, how she thinks, how she is would make me keep second guessing myself and actually freeze on my read on her but instead it just came easy and naturally.

 

Still wifoming myself to a very small extent but yea I'm confident.

 

Came as a surprise to me.

[Turin Turambar]

And yet you still question my Ithi read.

[TheRagnarok]

Everyone got damn quiet.

[Turin Turambar]

Yes. A lot of Europeans in the game so they are sleeping.  I am off to sleep as well due to an early start tomorrow

 

. I will be a bit scarce again until Thurday at the earliest. I will try to give as much time at end of days as I can until I return home. 

 

 

Just go ahead and solve the game while I'm sleeping. I  have faith in your ability to achieve that.

[hazelkrs1]

Bahahahahahahaha!!!!!!! I WAS SO FREAKING SPOT ON!

 

 

I'm seriously on freaking fire lately

 

 

GAWD I can't wait to read scum QT after the game. They must have crapped their collective pants when I figured out Thane might be symp (thank you Turin for challenging me on the Irene Adler thing, and thank you Tsuki for your tinfoiling, both led me to the epiphany)

 

 

Soooooooooo Chae is 100% CONFIRMED. Csarmi is too, and hilariously so. His bravado right at EOD is making me laugh my keister off. Especially one post in particular, I'll have to grab it in a sec. Still catching up, but yeah-

 

@Scum: PWNTTTTTTTT

 

[hazelkrs1]

#LAZYDESPOTISTHEBESTDESPOT

 

[hazelkrs1]

 

Or you can look for people who are actually scum and stop tunneling? 

 

You just keep falling over yourself to OMGUS me, don't you?

 

 

BAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!

 

Tsuki wins errone. We can all go home nao

 

[hazelkrs1]

Man this stuff is amusing.

 

Krak is NOWHERE to be seen now that his goose is cooked. Don't worry Krak, it will all be over soon

 

Csarmi is in full #damagecontrol mode, which is hilarious considering how many times he said earlier in the game how his activity level would never go any higher this game, not no way, not no how (yet he's all looking for spew and trying to say the derail on Thane D1 should be looked into.... even tho it was Mynd, who flipped town, who caused the derail lulz)

 

Oh and el oh el @ his "I'm practically confirmed", like a Miller is GUARANTEED to be in a role madness game. That tickled me to a great extent.

 

Yup, those two are CONFIRMED all right, as in CONFIRMED SCUM.

 

I thought Pray was in #damagecontrol mode too there for a bit and that Hallia might be derptown, but with Csarmi's recent wifom defense of Hallia (saying she would Governor save a symp as scum- laughable. Would lock her in as scum for everyone else, and don't forget his "she might be third party" lol) I'm pretty much ready to lock her in as scum as well.

 

Lenlo is on my radar however, for that catch by Turin about the three scumreads listed thing. Also think it was Turin that pointed out that strange "scumread" of Lenlo by Chae D1 could have actually been distancing, which is supported by the fact that she shot Turin instead of Lenlo.

 

Speaking of Turin btw, it's been insane how much we've been able to wreck scum together this game. See what we can accomplish when we don't tunnel on one another bro?

 

 

And I dont find Ithi and Turin's switch on Thane all that alarming from D1, it seemed to come naturally from their suspicion of Mynd. They didn't recalibrate their read of Thane after that like they should have, but regardless I can see where they would have arrived at the conclusion that Thane was lynchbait. So they're both still LOCK CLEAR for me.

 

Soooooooo much more I wanna say atm, but we're starting audit now. Will have to go into moar detail later, and start going back through to see if I missed anything. Not too sure Thane knew who his teammates were, since his reads seemed to shift so much, and it looks like I was right in that him calling out the roles was his signal to teammates. Chae/Krak is scum JOAT, and thinking Hallia is GF with a Governor shot perhaps, and Csarmi a goon.

 

Toodles for now!

 

[csarmi]

Always great to know I'm spot on.

[Basel Gill]

While we wait for NAs...

 

Mod Fun Fact: at the time the Holmes books were written, Baker Street addresses only went from 1 to 100. Doyle deliberately made up a fictional address at 221B to prevent any real people from being bothered by fans.

[hazelkrs1]

I should've allotted more time to come back to this game and get into the muck after Thane's flip. Sorry guys, will bust my tail tonight. Too sleepy now

[Krakalakachkn]

Mos def not scum despite my lack of WIM up until this point.

 

 

 

Let me proooooove you wrong and get into this game. It'll be later tonight after work, so let's say about 8-9 hours.

 

 

Until later,

 

 

#KraktheJOATGOAT

[Turin Turambar]

So everyone is waiting for day. Okay. I'm on the road until thursday so will just post as can.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Day will not break until Basel gets back online. About 4 hours or so.

[Turin Turambar]

Figured as much. Thanks for the heads up Cindy.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Drive safe. :)

[csarmi]

Have a good drive.

[Basel Gill]

Holmes and Watson returned to their rooms to find that Mrs. Hudson had set out a light evening supper. After eating, Watson stepped out of the building for a short while to see to his personal affairs. When he returned, things were strangely quiet. Lastrade and some other fellows from the Yard were approaching. "Something suspicious, perhaps," Watson told them. "Holmes gave no indication he was going out, but there is no sign he is in there."

 

Watson went up the stairs and was met by a frantic Mrs. Hudson. "Oh, Dr. Watson, 'tis horrible! You must come at once!" Watson rushed up the stairs to find a sight he never would forget the rest of his life. "HOLMES!!!" he called out, rushing to where his friend lay on the floor. Holmes was gasping for breath, trying to speak despite the knife wound in his throat. "Watson. You must... must..." What exactly had to be done would stay unsaid as the great investigator drew a last breath of air and then expired. The only sound for several long minutes was that of Mrs. Hudson weeping.

 

NotBob, Sherlock Holmes, Town Detective, has been killed.

 

It is now Day 3. With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch DL is Fri. June 27th at 9 PM EST.

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140627T21&p0=422

[Basel Gill]

Not voting (12): Krak, Len, Rags, Dice, Turin, Tina, Des, Hally, Tsuki, BFG, Pral, Csarmi