Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Hallia]

I did realize Chae! *hugs*

 

Ithi, characters can easily be safe claims. It's the thing commonly done now, so it doesn't do much for me.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Fair enough.

 

I did really think that Mynd was Mafia - and that you popping up claiming as Governor was a Mynd plot. I guess you think I'm Mafia because I don't believe you're Town.

 

But similar to what you say about Characters, Roles can belong to any alignment and your timing felt a bit too convenient to me.

[Hallia]

No, I think you're mafia because of your tone this game and your play. You may think what you will.

[Ithillian Turambar]

You're wrong of course.

 

My tone is the same as it ever was. You seem quite snippy though.

[BFG]

Apologies I've been so quiet, RL has been busy. I have some time tonight, but am out tomorrow and Thursday evening so won't be able to post much then either, should be ok from Friday (when I signed up I assumed that I'd be replacing Charis later on and thus my inactivity now wouldn't be so much of a problem)

[Hallia]

No, I'm right, of course

 

 

I'm happy as a lark! ^_^

 

You aren't normally as snarky as town, that's just me!

 

 

Csarmi does say that I have unnaturally good instincts

[BFG]

Vote count:

 

Mynd (9): Ithi, Turin, Chae, Pral, dice, Len, 鲍勃不是我的名字, Tina

Ithi (2): Mynd, Hallia

 

Not Voting (6): Thrax, Tsuki, Despo, Thane, BFG, Csarmi

 

 

that was the hammer.

 

it is now twilight.

Couple of quick thoughts.

 

@Basel, Cindy is this VC correct (I'm sure it is, but worth checking).

 

And stating the obvious, but the extended twilight vets Hallia's role somewhat (I don't know any other roles that are active to explain a extended Twilight).

 

If I'd been around I'd have probably voted Mynd over Ithi, I didn't follow his case, but I wish Tina/Csarmi had held off on the hammer until he'd posted a full set of reads.

[Hallia]

Yes, it was due to me.

[Ithillian Turambar]

English - not snarky.

 

This is just how I am.

 

And I was quite restrained while Mynd was doing all the name calling and hair pulling.

 

If CSarmi agrees with you that I'm Mafia then he'd be wrong too.

[Hallia]

Welcome to the game BFG!

 

I feel the same about Tina.

[csarmi]

I dunno Ithi.

 

You understood Turin's post about formatting?

[Hallia]

I believe he was describing, not name calling. He described your argument as rabid, not "Ithi, YOU are rabid."

 

 

But I'm over it, we'll see what day brings.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

@BFG the VC is as correct as my counting. If you spot an error let me know. Math is hard.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I believe he was describing, not name calling. He described your argument as rabid, not "Ithi, YOU are rabid."

 

 

But I'm over it, we'll see what day brings.

Well shall we stop calling me rabid now? That would be nice.

 

Hallia - aren't you concerned that revealing your role so early leaves you open to being targeted as the Mafia NK?

 

 

@ CSarmi - how many pages ago was it and I'll go have a look? I wasn't really paying attention this morning cos of stuff happening.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Oh ok I see it. I didn't count csarmis vote at the end cause I thought there were 9 already but the hammer wasn't declared until after that vote so it's moot.

 

I can check it again when I'm on a real computer and have time later

 

Sorry bout that

[csarmi]

Last page maybe? He seems to want an LD list? But he's saying as if it was requested earlier and I saw no such thing.

[BFG]

Oh ok I see it. I didn't count csarmis vote at the end cause I thought there were 9 already but the hammer wasn't declared until after that vote so it's moot.

 

I can check it again when I'm on a real computer and have time later

 

Sorry bout that

No worries, I just wanted to check, because of the possibility of voting mechanic

[csarmi]

Someone called you rabid, Ithi? Where?

[Turin Turambar]

@Hallia, So give your reads. again as asked for. you can explain to Csarmi why I am asking in the way I am as I think you know.

 

@Csarmi, I can't vote every mafia lean I have. You will notice if you read back that I did state yu needed to be lynched in my first reads list unles you could be vetted by some other method.

 

@Tsuki. My rough thoughts about you being mafia stem from my thought about X. your back and forth looked a bit staged. Also your comments with Mynd. It sounded more like the kind of thing a mafia would say to a townie playing dumb. 

 

I'm sorry I still can't get it out of my head why Mynd would do what he did. The suicide challenge, then when he was loking to lose it basically quitting after he took Thane to task for doing the same thing. 

[Ithillian Turambar]

I've gone back a few pages and can see that he's asked for people to post reads in the requested format ... but I can't actually find what the requested format is - so I'm none the wiser lol

 

 

I'm sure it all makes sense in his head.

[Hallia]

At the time I thought you were both town and it warranted outting

[Ithillian Turambar]

Someone called you rabid, Ithi? Where?

Don't you start lol

 

I don't howl at the moon - I am the moon.

 

:profound:

 

 

Although that probably just means I get thinner and fatter over the course of the month and have tidal issues.

[Hallia]

I can when I get home, any formatting on mobile goes out the window:)

[Turin Turambar]

Can we just stop using the R word? there is no need to rehash it. 

[Hallia]

 

Someone called you rabid, Ithi? Where?

Don't you start lol

 

I don't howl at the moon - I am the moon.

 

:profound:

 

 

Although that probably just means I get thinner and fatter over the course of the month and have tidal issues.

Isn't that all of us ladies