Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Ithillian Turambar]

[unvote]

 

I'm sorry. I had some terrible news today.

 

This game is now way down my list of priorites.

[Turin Turambar]

[unvote]

 

I'm sorry. I had some terrible news today.

 

This game is now way down my list of priorites.

Ithi don't worry about the game right now. 

 

life takes priority.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I can almost hear people typing and then pressing their back button to delete what they typed, as they try to frame a response to this.

 

I'm thinking a front of Oh Noes, with a high chance of, well it's all because of YOU, and a smattering of - why on earth did you claim!?

[Turin Turambar]

My two-pence:

 

You are over-reacting to the "rabid" thing. Might be a generational or regional thing. I use it all the time, IRL, as just another way of saying "crazy". Would it have been as offensive, if he had just said you were attacking him like crazy people? Probably not. Why so defensive? Call someone "rabid" where I am from, you get a smirk, or maybe the bird (impudent digit)... tell someone to GF-themselves, and you better be ready to throw hands...

Where I come from, Turin is way out of line.

 

[/unvote]

Cause I am going to catch 6 hours of sleep.

the fact that there is a rule devoted to it in mafia shows it to be completely in the game. Mafia can be a harsh game. It appears that it is being played that way today. It was a bad day for Ithi to have to deal with it and I don't appreciate the way she was treated.

 

FTR if this were a RL face to face game I would probably be throwing already. But she has calmed me down some. I only give it out when I feel people are already going there. I generally don't start fights but I don't back away from them either.

 

Who is this inspector guy? is he important?. I don't have time to look him up. 

[Ithillian Turambar]

When did I calm you down lol.

[Ithillian Turambar]

And he's a main character - how could you not know who he is?

[Myndrunner]

[Ithillian Turambar]

Mynd is happy again - the gifs are back.

 

He's playing fiddle while the game burns.

 

I guess that's the best thing he could think of to post without him having to make a definitive statement.

[Turin Turambar]

 

Would you please give your thoughts and reads on every player in the game? Since you are claiming to be Town if you should end up lynched today we will be able to look at it knowing you had towns best interests at heart. please format each line as such: Please be definitive in your reads. no hedging. a simple town or mafia in the first line.

 

Mynd is Mafia. He keeps changing his story about what he is trying to say and then not really clarifying his statements. He has also uttered loads of rhetoric and accusations without making any real attempt to provide evidence to support his cases.

are you working on this still? or did you forget it was there? or did you just decide not to be pro town? Please comply. It really is important for the good of the town.

 

Here ya go, Turin...my responses in BLUE

 

1.) What percentage chance do you assign to Adler being  Ahhh maths!

  A. Vanilla Town?  0%

  B. Mafia? 30%

  C third party? 50%

  D some other town role?  20%

 

2.) do you still think that Thane is mafia? yes  If yes, then Why did you not decide to challenge him?  If I had challenged him, that would actually be me pushing for his lynch.  He was already at 6, I didn't need to do that.  The gladiator wasn't meant to secure a lynch, it was about putting Ithi's money where her mouth was.  Sure, it was an ego move, but you guys were being ridiculous. I figured this would put a stop to it.  I was wrong.

 

3.) Do you think I am mafia? I think you could be.  I was more convinced back when you two were coming at me like you were over the whole Irene Adler deal.  I am starting to think that maybe you are just (once again) playing blind to Ithi's manipulation of you.  Scumhunting doesn't mean the people you like are town.  It means reading someone town or scum despite how you personally feel about them. 

 

4.) Do you think Ithi is mafia? I think she could be.  I was more convinced back when you two were coming at me like you were over the whole Irene Adler deal.  Town or scum, I think the game will be a lot smother without her in it.  Even for you.  By your own admission, you always see her as town even when scum.    Scumhunting doesn't mean the people you like are town.  It means reading someone town or scum despite how you personally feel about them. 

 

5.) Which choice best describes why you think Ithi is a good lynch?  C first, then B a close second with A being kinda part of B. 

 

A. She is mafia.

B. She is a good info lynch.

C. Her presence is a distraction due to our interactions.

D. She has caught your entire mafia team

 

If you chose B, What info will you gather from a Mafia flip from her? Aside from one mafia scummie being down, we would also be able to go back and re-read who voted with her, who quickly voted off Thane when he VT claimed, etc.  Prior to all this business, I would have said it would make you scum too....but I think maybe you might just be manipulated by her.  You are working together, that is clear to me.  Either masons or scum because, as you very well know thanks to your complaint to the mod, apparently I was accusing you of cheating.  I wasn't.  I was accusing you two of working together as scum.   SO you are either masons or scum.  One or the other. This is also kinda the A part.....I think she's scum.

 

 

 

From a Town Flip from her?  Prior to all this foolishness with Irene Adler and Gladiatoring, we can look back at how she voted (and you too of course).  It does give you a bit more cred because I don't think that you are as likely to be scum as she.  I think if you were scum and she wasn't, you would also have to bend an ear to your mafia team before being as rash as the two of you have been. 

1. So you are back to her not being VT period. impossible. But she is only 30% to be scum. So why use that as a means to cast additional doubt on Thane? If the character is most likely 3rd party why would you characterize her as most likely scum?

 

2. This still doesn't make sense based on your other answers.

 

3 & 4. anyone could be mafia. please definitive answers. Like yes or no. you are all maybe. do you want to take a stand on anything? where did I admit that I always see her as town regardless of alignment? please provide evidence for your rhetoric.

 

5. Why  in the world would you initiate this challenge if you had the thought she was mafia as your third reason? You as town risked your one chance to battle a mafia as well as your life in the game to try for a policy lynch? Odd that in your reply about info your first thought is that it would be 1 scummie down. You only think she "could be mafia" and that the possibility of her being mafia was the third highest reason for challenging her. (your main one from your own explanation being to "shut her up" *real pro town*) In fact you don't really give any info gained from lynching her. So it appears that you don't even have a real reason that you are sticking to to validate your choice. 

 

I think in some weird way you are actually trying to get yourself lynched here. At least your reasons don't seem to hold water.

[Ithillian Turambar]

He gets Lynched.

 

Hallia Governates him.

 

Yay - they are both Conf Town.

 

It's a cunning plan.

[Turin Turambar]

When did I calm you down lol.

I said GFY to them. you said your spelling is atrocious when rushing. (which I was) I LOL'd then had to drive. so calmed down enough to stop posting and drive.

[Turin Turambar]

And he's a main character - how could you not know who he is?

I already said that I didn't read the books. 

 

 

 

I just read the wiki on him and LOL'd. it says he reached his high level through BULLDOG tenacity.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Unvote, Vote Mynd

[Ithillian Turambar]

He's also not answered any of the questions I asked him or responded to any of my points.

 

This is hardcore fencesitting happening. Attacking while actually not making any firm stances on anything.

 

He's already shown that he can interpret any of his posts in a number of ways - depending on the questions asked.

 

Which is why I believe he is Mafia.

 

What reason would a Town person have to be so evasive and twisty?

 

There's been an awful lot of 'aha, but I didn't actually say that' from him.

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

And he's a main character - how could you not know who he is?

I already said that I didn't read the books.

 

 

I just read the wiki on him and LOL'd. it says he reached his high level through BULLDOG tenacity.

It seems I have been typecasted.

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

And he's a main character - how could you not know who he is?

I already said that I didn't read the books.

 

 

I just read the wiki on him and LOL'd. it says he reached his high level through BULLDOG tenacity.

It seems I have been typecasted.

 

       

[Turin Turambar]

Ithi, do you want to vote Mynd again?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Lol yes. I forgot I'd had a moment there.

 

[V]Mynd[/v]

[Turin Turambar]

That's L-2 I think. maybe he should claim? oh wait, already did. 

 

Maybe he should give his reads as requested. And then self vote as also requested. 

[Turin Turambar]

and good night.

[Niniel]

Good morning.

 

[v] Mynd [/v]

[csarmi]

Morning.

 

Mynd still haven't commented on others or given a read list.

[csarmi]

Tina, you're hammering a lot lately.

 

It looks good on you.

[csarmi]

[V]Mynd[/v]

 

Just in case.

 

No governor pls.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

Mynd (9): Ithi, Turin, Chae, Pral, dice, Len, 鲍勃不是我的名字, Tina, csarmi

Ithi (2): Mynd, Hallia

 

Not Voting (5): Thrax, Tsuki, Despo, Thane, BFG

 

 

that was the hammer.

 

it is now twilight.