[Advanced] Vacation Mafia! Day 7

[peacesells]

Did you just say "supposed doc"?

[Yates]

Did you just say "supposed doc"?

 

Did you just try to make him look scummy for saying he isn't 100% sold on the Doc claim but willing to see it through?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Unless of course if Peace is the real full Doc.  

 

So yeah.  Let's pressure him.

WIFOM overdrive. 

 

 

Somebody had to say it.  Some call me Captain Obvious.

[keyholder21]

 

Did you just say "supposed doc"?

 

Did you just try to make him look scummy for saying he isn't 100% sold on the Doc claim but willing to see it through?

 

 

This.

[peacesells]

 

 

Did you just say "supposed doc"?

 

Did you just try to make him look scummy for saying he isn't 100% sold on the Doc claim but willing to see it through?

I did nothing. Rte is making his own case.

[Kaylee]

Official Vote Count

 

 

Mish (2): Dice, Despo

Dice (1): Peace

Peace (3): AJ, RTE, Ishy

 

Not Voting (11): Darthe, Yates, Mish, Key, BG, NotBob, Tress, Pral, Despo, Krak, Red

 

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch. Deadline Wednesday 9:30pm MST http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131023T2130&p0=197&msg=Day+2

[Krakalakachkn]

Des arguing about how scummy a dead Townie [Lenlo] who had already been lynched is has set of the scumdar levels to 11.

 

That is all.

 

Very scummy.  Perhaps Lenlo's reads hit home.  Not sure why else Des would go out of his way to argue.  It was a fairly easy post to ignore.

 

Ok, caught up. Sorry about that. Forgot to post before my trip. My bad.

 

Not sure how I feel about the Lenlo lynch. I feel some sympathy for him as I have been lynched in a similar context or a similar situation when I was town. It sucks but ah well. The NK doesn't say much but I guess that's the point of their killing an inactive.

 

VOTE DICE

 

Anyone remember the last scum to quit a game to avoid pressure...hmm.  Kinda ironic Dice replaces Hally.

 

I'm voting the play.  Not the claim. 

 

This has been the scummiest thing since day. I respect Hallia's claim. No one has CC'ed it, and I understand the pros and cons for this if there is a full-time Doc, and maybe it will be CC'ed eventually. But as it stands, the claim holds, and you need to respect the claim. This vote from peace doesn't make sense and I think that is very shaky "meta" or experience to vote based on.

 

Vote peace

 

"You need to respect the claim"

 

 

Wut?

 

 

In fact, this entire post was bad.  Commenting on the Lenlo lynch for no reason, commenting on the NK with nothing.  I'm not sure how the claim 'holds,' it's just kinda there - unmoving and unmoved.  You used the word 'respect' twice in that post and for whatever reason it makes me very suspicious.

 

 

 

Vote RTE

[Red2111]

class load just picked up with Music Appreciation (last 9wk course), so my time and cases will not what most of you are used to.  call this Red light.   just got done with my trig test, so I figure i'd take a break before jumping into reading a rose for Emily, tell tale heart and the Lottery for comp 2.   gah I HATE the lottery *shudders*

 

/off topic

 

 

so first off

 

Vote: Andy  for his play D1 on Dice/hallys claim. 

 

the NK on aemon is interesting.  might have been for meta/big game hunting, but so few have played with him I can see lurking being the reason.  which puts a mega FoS on Not Bob, Pral, Ishy and BG; who are also mega lurkers as of right now and posted less than Aemon. 

 

Pral is pinging hardcore.  my gut is going crazy on him.  mainly because if the scum is NKing lurkers, he's the #1 lurker in this game.  so why not hit him if their going for no info.  Aemon atleast posted thoughts on the game, which gives us some info, Pral OTOH had like 1 post.

 

 

the peacetrain stinks.  imo hes beating the grass right now, a-typical Mynd behavior as his reasoning is pure bullshanks.   and looky who latched on first, Mr scumster AJ.   a little eager there chap, aint ya?

 

 

Ishy's play is starting to ping btw.  a quiet ishy is like a quiet BG; I just don't like it.

 

the train on Mish is solid imo, he actions are scummy and deserve pressure because she needs to stop trying to lead the town like she is.  i'm still undecided if she's scum tho.  

 

 

RTE's vote is meh.  given that I think Andy is scum, and Ishy is pinging, well logically the scum wouldn't be stupid enough to place that many team mates on one train.  so by default, he gets the benefit of the doubt for now.

 

 

 

Also, Peace. HallyDice claimed an x-night doc. Don't you think if we had a full doc, they would have CCed by now?

 

and again I say, if there is a full doc, so what.  there can still be a x-night doc.   a full doc claim does nothing for or against Hally/Dices claim.  you sound like a scummy trying to lay track for a false claim as hard as much as you keep harping on it.

 

 

I think we can agree that in 90% of scenarios, what you would do and what a DMer would do is wastly different, Yates. Here, the norm would be to CC if you see someone claim the role you have. A game with a partial doc and a full doc, well I've never seen one in my mafia-time. So if we had a full doc, the norm here would be to CC such a claim.

 

Wich is how Cloud once made it to endgame as mafia by claiming doc; there was no doc in that game, so no CC = he was trusted (more or less). That's the flaw of the way. But most of the time, a fake-claim of a very common role (and doc is the most common of all) is usually CCed and thus the faker revealed.

 

seriously, you've been playing mafia for like a year.  just because you've never seen it doesn't mean it doesn't exist.  Kivs Police Academy game had nothing BUT cops in it.  some were insane, others niave, other innocent, ect.  it was a literal goat **** of a game, but fun as hell.   another game had a revolving SK role, that transferred to players upon death (kaths game).  just because YOU haven't seen it, doesn't mean it doesn't exist and doesn't make you the authority in this game for what can and cant exist.  unless your name is Kaylee and you created the set up, you need the stfu with trying to tell people what is and isnt' in a game.  because all it does it make you look like scum.

 

and FYI, I faked claimed an even night doc in an advanced game as a nilla townie, had a full healer CC me and still lived through the lynch.  so don't tell me it cant happen, because I've done it.  and I've also seen games with multiple doc roles in it.  your application for town leader has been revoked for lack of knowledge.

[Red2111]

short list for me is the following

 

 

1 - Andy

2 - Pral

3 - Ishy/BG/Yates/Not Bob

4 - Mish

[John E. Kelley]

That's seven players sis.

 

And I've been lurky?

[John E. Kelley]

If we don't count Kay-mod, I'm third in post count.

 

Lurky indeed.

[Red2111]

yes Ishy, lurky as in, not really giving info and your posts have been fluff to appear frequent enough that people don't call you lurkery. 

 

#3 people are all tied, cause you lot are all lurkery and that's all I got for you there

 

 

also worth noting.

 

 

Tress got heat D1, wagon switched to Len, Tress faded away and has yet to come back in.

 

this is interesting, given her claims as for why she was acting the way she did

[Red2111]

your lurkery when it comes to game related shiz 

[Red2111]

heres the lenlo vote.

 

 

Leno (9): Despo, Ishy, BG, Tress, Red, Aemon, AJ, NotBob, Key, Hally

 

 

red names are on my scumdar.

 

green are townie

 

purple is claimed and suspected townie (don't know about her claim, but bigger fish to fry rather than that WIFOM)

 

 

imo we should have competing trains with the players in red, these are most likely scum.   more could be told from analyzing how they acted on the vote,

 

iirc Despo was the most volcale to push on the

 

BG and Ishy pretty much wagon on Despos reasoning.

 

Tress's vote was a "save my ass, for majority" vote.  so that's a null tale imo

 

 

 

Anay's vote is by far the scummiest on Len's train  post #391

 

 

unvote; vote Lenlo

 

Doesn't look like there's any other place to go with just over 2 hours until DL.

 

Des, your list of scum is extremely counter intuitive. Why would you put both Lenlo and Tress down on the same team when they are voting each other? And please, don't give me some long winded explanation about how they are trying to distance.

 

here is the classic "vote for majority, while distancing myself from the fact I know he'll flip town"  you see how he attacks the main caser on Lenlo, while doing the reluctant vote.   classic scum move; about as classic as his reaction to Hally's claim (which was to get 100% in her pocket and attack those attacking her (aka Mish))

 

 

Notbob, key, Hally  semi-pingy vote, no insight, just a "for the majority"  but given the time stamps and closeness to the lynch, they're less pingy than BG and Ishy's votes.

[Darthe]

Why can't we all jist agree to lynch Darthe? He claimed scum.

[John E. Kelley]

inb4 Jester....

[Red2111]

Why can't we all jist agree to lynch Darthe? He claimed scum.

 

 

da faq  o.0

[Darthe]

But for real though.

[Darthe]

 

 

Why can't we all jist agree to lynch Darthe? He claimed scum.

 

da faq o.0

I missed you. Can we argue for a bit, just to feel like old times when the bulldog was feared by town and scum alike beforw marriage calmed her?

[Red2111]

:lol:

 

 

fine lurker.  FoS @ Farthe 

[John E. Kelley]

Ain't no man can calm her down.

[Red2111]

why u trying to distract from a lynch with jester nonsense?

 

 

hmmm Darthe?

[bgrishinko]

I too miss the bulldog. By the way Red, when's the last time you've seen me purposefully lurk as mafia?

 

Someone mentioned Tress having gone quiet, and I'd like to second that suspicion.

[Red2111]

Bg I said nothing about alignment, just that I don't like a  quiet BG.  I know how good of a player you are, you being quiet does nothing for the town.  

 

 

btw, you know I don't like Meta, nice way to jump to conclusions.  guilty conscious  *raises eyebrow*

 

 

but by all means, if you are scum, keep on lurking *smug grin*

[bgrishinko]

Fair enough. Seemed like you were suspicious of me cause of that. I got a new role at work that makes it so I can't lurk DM all day anymore. :(