[Advanced] X-Men: Rise of Apocalypse - GAME OVER

[Nynaeve]

 Do you find it possible that Verbal messed up (he don't seem to be the type) ...

 

 

Do you even KNOW Verbal? :P

 

 

 

Nyn

[Nynaeve]

Nyn had a camped vote on Salami D1, which is basically meaningless, a late vote on Dice D2, which is also pretty bereft of meaning imo, and a camped vote on Mish D3, which is also not very meaningful.  That's a pretty bad voting record.

 

 

Well, I can always marry rich. I love that I always have that option.

 

 

 

Nyn

[WWWwombat]

Wombat, I find it interesting that the reasons you have for voting Tina are the same reasons that people suspect Mish and Krak (not so much confusion on the part of Krak, but skimming and not posting anything with real content to it). Is there any reason you are giving Krak a pass on that?

Krak does this all the time and Tina doesn't. Krak's been drawing an inordinate amount of heat and Tina hasn't. Makes me think Tina has friends and Krak doesn't.

[LilyElizabeth]

My character is Psylocke.

 

I didn't see any point in viewing anyone who I would only get their "appears as" alignment on. 

[aemonkristen]

I haven't been around in quite a while, so I have no meta on anyone anymore. I can see your point if this is Krak's normal play style, but that does not excuse it. In my opinion, he has done nothing to promote the game in any measurable sense toward a town win and that means he is acting anti-town. Csarmi has been much more active in his anti-town behavior, but I believe he is town nonetheless. His roleclaim is in line with what appears to be the mechanics of the game (appears as). I still have suspicions about Mish because of the confusion and other factors that we have discussed ad nauseum, but I also believe that the mafia has left her alive in the hopes that we would do their dirty work for them. I will do a reread on Tina when I get home (about 5 PST) and come back with my thoughts then.

[LilyElizabeth]

Vote Darthe

 

First, he defends Verbal, as Aemon says, and then he does everything possible to get me to view him UNTIL Csarmi reveals that he has the power to make him appear as his true alignment. Not a word on the subject since then. I'm pretty sure we have a godfather here. 

[Niniel]

Lily, can you view dead players?

[Darthe]

Vote Darthe

 

First, he defends Verbal, as Aemon says, and then he does everything possible to get me to view him UNTIL Csarmi reveals that he has the power to make him appear as his true alignment. Not a word on the subject since then. I'm pretty sure we have a godfather here.

I would still be willing to do it but I'm not going to get myself lynched for an opinion. Everyone snapped at the idea and your idiotic notion of scumhunting is FoSing anyone that's willing to tackle your less than optimal play so Ill let the situation ride until you all come to reason. My idea was the best move town could make and takes a lot of risk on mt part for various reasons. Try it or don't, but don't waste our time lynching someone because you disagree.

[csarmi]

Darthe, what is your idea exactly? What should I do tonight? What about Lily?

[Darthe]

I haven't been around in quite a while, so I have no meta on anyone anymore. I can see your point if this is Krak's normal play style, but that does not excuse it. In my opinion, he has done nothing to promote the game in any measurable sense toward a town win and that means he is acting anti-town. Csarmi has been much more active in his anti-town behavior, but I believe he is town nonetheless. His roleclaim is in line with what appears to be the mechanics of the game (appears as). I still have suspicions about Mish because of the confusion and other factors that we have discussed ad nauseum, but I also believe that the mafia has left her alive in the hopes that we would do their dirty work for them. I will do a reread on Tina when I get home (about 5 PST) and come back with my thoughts then.

It sucks to even have to say this but with the current trend, if we were to lynch everyone based on scumminess and illogical actions then scum would win every game on DM mafia. This site is essentially a metafest at this point. Not to say that the more logical players don't get ahead, they do, but its not as it should be.

[Darthe]

Darthe, what is your idea exactly? What should I do tonight? What about Lily?

I'm going to view as it says in my role PM. However the town can't trust that. Thus you should target me. Me turning gold at the will of a player will go a long way toward prpving you. Lily views me, she reveals the result, town is ahead. And lastly my particular role would be... lets say unpleasant for mafia to attack, even in the event of an RB. No need for me to reveal more yet.

[csarmi]

Just for the record, Darthe

- are you saying what your alignment/appearence are?

- would you like us target you both?

- how would that prove anything about Lily?

[LilyElizabeth]

Lily, can you view dead players?

I haven't asked. Let me do that. 

[Darthe]

Just for the record, Darthe

- are you saying what your alignment/appearence are?

- would you like us target you both?

- how would that prove anything about Lily?

I will announce my alignment and appearance after lily does. If she is lying we caught scum. If she is honest we are good to go. I uniquely fit into this position because mafia will not want to NK me based on my role which I will also claim once Lily states what she believes it to be.You further choosing to gold me will equate to it proving that it was done by consxious choice of a player who has towns interests in mind.

 

It all fits. Besides which mafia has bigger fish to fry.

[csarmi]

 

Just for the record, Darthe

- are you saying what your alignment/appearence are?

- would you like us target you both?

- how would that prove anything about Lily?

I will announce my alignment and appearance after lily does. If she is lying we caught scum. If she is honest we are good to go. I uniquely fit into this position because mafia will not want to NK me based on my role which I will also claim once Lily states what she believes it to be.You further choosing to gold me will equate to it proving that it was done by consxious choice of a player who has towns interests in mind.

 

It all fits. Besides which mafia has bigger fish to fry.

 

 

I don't follow you Darthe. If I gold you tonight, then Lily will read your true alignment, regardless on your current appearance.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Just for the record, Darthe

- are you saying what your alignment/appearence are?

- would you like us target you both?

- how would that prove anything about Lily?

I will announce my alignment and appearance after lily does. If she is lying we caught scum. If she is honest we are good to go. I uniquely fit into this position because mafia will not want to NK me based on my role which I will also claim once Lily states what she believes it to be.You further choosing to gold me will equate to it proving that it was done by consxious choice of a player who has towns interests in mind.

 

It all fits. Besides which mafia has bigger fish to fry.

I don't follow you Darthe. If I gold you tonight, then Lily will read your true alignment, regardless on your current appearance.

You make a good point. Any other way costs two nights though. Only exception is if you two catch scum.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Just for the record, Darthe

- are you saying what your alignment/appearence are?

- would you like us target you both?

- how would that prove anything about Lily?

I will announce my alignment and appearance after lily does. If she is lying we caught scum. If she is honest we are good to go. I uniquely fit into this position because mafia will not want to NK me based on my role which I will also claim once Lily states what she believes it to be.You further choosing to gold me will equate to it proving that it was done by consxious choice of a player who has towns interests in mind.

 

It all fits. Besides which mafia has bigger fish to fry.

 

 

Then it's your word against hers.  

 

 

 

Just for the record, Darthe

- are you saying what your alignment/appearence are?

- would you like us target you both?

- how would that prove anything about Lily?

I will announce my alignment and appearance after lily does. If she is lying we caught scum. If she is honest we are good to go. I uniquely fit into this position because mafia will not want to NK me based on my role which I will also claim once Lily states what she believes it to be.You further choosing to gold me will equate to it proving that it was done by consxious choice of a player who has towns interests in mind.

 

It all fits. Besides which mafia has bigger fish to fry.

 

 

I don't follow you Darthe. If I gold you tonight, then Lily will read your true alignment, regardless on your current appearance.

 

You're going to gild him.

[WWWwombat]

What about gelding him instead?

 

I like how everyone is saying they'll reread Tina. I wonder when we can expect some actual opinions on her.

[Leelou]

Just under 24 hours for day. I'll post the vote count when I get home.

[csarmi]

What about gelding him instead?

 

I like how everyone is saying they'll reread Tina. I wonder when we can expect some actual opinions on her.

Any week now.

[Leelou]

Vote Count

 

Tina (2) - Krak, Wombat

Krak (2) - Darthe, Aemon

Lily (1) - Des

Darthe (1) - Lily

 

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline 23 hours, 7 mins

[WWWwombat]

 

What about gelding him instead?

 

I like how everyone is saying they'll reread Tina. I wonder when we can expect some actual opinions on her.

Any week now.

Less snide comments; more voting.

[WWWwombat]

Less than 24 hours before deadline and no one has more than 2 votes. You guys suck.

[WWWwombat]

You guys know we don't have RTE to bail us out this time, right?

[Leelou]

Random is looking like a possibility :-)