MAFIA - **STARGATE SG1** - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS

[Pralaya]

Pray- I really don't like how he keeps saying someone "felt scummy" without saying why, just seems like he was trying to slip in with a bandwagon vote even tho he'd been pretty inactive all game, and lastly I REALLY don't like his character hint AtE and mock nonchalant attitude

 

 

Not true. I did mention why I voted for RTE. In fact the "opportunistic voting" reason that I used against RTE yesterday is the exact same reason you are thinking against RTE now.

 

But yes, I may have sounded mocking because it was absurd seeing a train on me just because I voted someone in Day 1 and it seems to happen in most games where I am town.

[dapianoplay3r]

Lol did you honestly think D1 votes werent looked at or analysed....

[Pralaya]

Lol did you honestly think D1 votes werent looked at or analysed....

 

I think D1 votes are usually misanalysed. At least from my experience.

[dapianoplay3r]

Yea mafia tend to forget they are looked at D1 and slip.... Thats how we catch D1 mafia

[hazelkrs1]

@mod: so is Niel aalive?

 

 

There are 18 it takes 10 to lynch

 

Talya said this^ when Cindy asked how many were alive after Darthe got replicated or w/e. She also repeated that in recent VC's. So it doesn't look like Niel or Darthe died, but something def seems to have happened to them.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

you've telegraphed that shot, and I wouldn't base a lynch on what you may or may not do tonite anyway.

 

@ des, I didn't point out those trigger fails to bring the mods attention to them. she's watching the triggers herself. even when they're not blue.

 

I brought them up bc in an SG1 game that incorporates replicators, I think it's pretty likely there are at least two threats to town, and the replicators probably the more dangerous.

 

and that seems necessary when half the first real life day is people chiming in w how they not knw the show.

 

and half of yesterday bickering w csarmi who's claimed willful ignorance of the whole reason for the replicators existence in the show and quite possibly in the game did what it was probably intended to and drove me nuts.

 

so there are a couple ppl I'd like to keep as close an eye on as anyone playing scummy today,

 

and tomorrow maybe there'll be more.

 

or maybe not.

 

but it serves no purpose to keeping that possibility hidden.

[Basel Gill]

Still liking my Berf vote. I'm off to work and won't be on till after the DL

[ReleaseTheEvil]

We need to start thinking consolidation soon as we are far from it at the moment.

 

Not convinced on Basel but Pral is the way to go today I think. Unfortunately he hasn't had too many interactions with others so it wouldn't be an incredibly telling lynch, but if he's scum he needs to go. And I think he is.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

I'll be checking the game throughout the day tho I'll be distracted, I will be here at DL.

 

I like my vote where it is.

[hazelkrs1]

@Pral: not buying it. RTE's vote on Dap wasn't opportunistic at all; Dap had no votes on him at the time and voting for a claimed vig is obviously going to get yousome attention. WWhich it did. The point of opportunistic voting is voting where it won't stand out too much to try and blend in. As for his vote on you, that WAS opportunistic, but that came AFTER you voted him

 

@Cindy: eh, I guess I can see how you would pay special attention to that kind of thing. I still think its antitown to point out something like that, but when we first saw that trap we had no way of knowing if Talya would confirm who set it off like she did.

 

@Basel: Really dude? Gonna hold town hostage like that and not claim? If you were town you would have claimed by now. Leaving my vote where it is.

 

And with that I'm going to bed. See y'all later.

[dapianoplay3r]

They are silenced. Didnt the scenr say they were knocked out

i wager they be back come dat

[csarmi]

Hey guys. Got swamped in work all of a sudden. Will have minimal activity during the day but I'm ready to move vote if need be.

 

When is deadline?

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

in sure they'll come back at day. not the point, dap.

 

DL is 3 EST

[WWWwombat]

Lady Talya, I voted Basel

[WWWwombat]

Still liking my Berf vote. I'm off to work and won't be on till after the DL

Forcing town to blind lynch him is about as anti-town as it gets.

 

ALL ABOARD!

[Locke]

What is AtE?

 

Still liking my Berf vote. I'm off to work and won't be on till after the DL

 

We need to start thinking consolidation soon as we are far from it at the moment.

 

Not convinced on Basel but Pral is the way to go today I think. Unfortunately he hasn't had too many interactions with others so it wouldn't be an incredibly telling lynch, but if he's scum he needs to go. And I think he is.

Famous last words.  Even though RTE says we need to start thinking consolidation, they're both pushing the opposite. The Berf and Pralaya trains are basically dead (2 and 3 votes, not much interest)  It's Basel (6 votes) or RTE for a longshot (4 votes).  I find it interesting that neither of you are willing to vote each other.

^Assuming I counted votes correctly. 

[WWWwombat]

AtE = Appeal to Emotion

 

It's Despo's new favorite scumtell.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

how is Basel more likely scum than pray or dice? or des? or RTE?

 

and how does his play since last night, especially, differ from RTEs? cause you pretty much convinced me there and I can see two possibilities for Basel's play now and the RTE scenario you presented is one of them. and btw after RTEs follow vote on ours I'd be as happy to move back to him now as stay on pray.

 

and daps post immediately prior to Basels, where he reads scum elsewhere but also leaves his vote on berf? did I miss a response?

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

I see I missed an unvote vote.

 

I guess that's a response.

[Talya]

My apologies for the vote count. I rushed this morning to get it done before work, because I don't like to leave it too long. 

 

So...

 

VOTE COUNT:

 

Berf (1): Basel, 

Basel (6): Csarmi, Locke, Berf, Wombat, Tina, Des

Desp (1): Turin

RTE (4): NotBob,  Dice, Pral, Dap

Pral (3): cindy, RTE, Hally

 

With 18 it takes 10 to lynch

 

Deadline is here

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

unvote vote RTE

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I'm not voting Basel yet because I don't think he's done much that is particularly scummy.

 

The scummiest thing he's done so far is leave knowing he won't be around at deadline without claiming or anything given how many votes are on him.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

is lenlo the only non voter?

 

dap, or any vig... if you take a daytime shot... if you really do have one... does it end the day?

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

you and pral haven't claimed either. not sure who should or when. I think when he left the votes might have been closer but I'm not sure, the counts got a little mixed up.

[WWWwombat]

how is Basel more likely scum than pray or dice? or des? or RTE?

 

and how does his play since last night, especially, differ from RTEs? cause you pretty much convinced me there and I can see two possibilities for Basel's play now and the RTE scenario you presented is one of them. and btw after RTEs follow vote on ours I'd be as happy to move back to him now as stay on pray.

 

and daps post immediately prior to Basels, where he reads scum elsewhere but also leaves his vote on berf? did I miss a response?

Is this directed at me?

 

Basel's play is terrible. First he came out with those wishy washy reads. Then when called on it, he tried to fabricate reads on RTE, Berf, Pralaya, and Dice. The only read he put any legit reasoning into was RTE and that was still a terrible case (despite all the suspect stuff RTE has done).

 

Furthermore, he claims to have a strong enough scum read on RTE to base town reads on other players yet he's unwilling to switch to RTE before deadline? And he doesn't reveal?

 

Basel is not trying to play a pro-town game in any way.