November 7th, 1606: Day 4 (CONCLUDED)

[Leelou]

 

 

Unvote, Vote: Csarmi

 

Jokes aside, this is actually a really good idea.

 

HERE WE GO, LYNCH SALAMI, HERE WE GO!!!!!

 

 

Sorry, I couldn't help it.

 

 

woohoo...

 

unvote, vote salami

 

 

Still watching cloud though...

 

 

Ah yes, it's this thread...

[lolguy26]

 

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

The premise is simple.  Csarmi posted the exact same way in all three threads.  If he were Town, why would he do that?  As scum, it makes perfect sense.

 

Since we don't know which game(s) he is scum in, we just lynch him in all 3.  The serves a second purpose in exposing votes on his wagon across all three games.  If he flips scum in one game, for example, and that's the only of the two games that you didn't vote for him what would that say about you?  Scum buddy.  So this is a really a trap to find his scum buddies in whichever game(s) he's scum in.

 

We're obviously overlooking the remote possibility he's Town in all 3 and risking it in favor of the home run swing.

 

 

i think thats being a bit too ambitious, and scum would most likely bus their teammate, probably at various time during the train or atleast thats how i see it 

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

The premise is simple.  Csarmi posted the exact same way in all three threads.  If he were Town, why would he do that?  As scum, it makes perfect sense.

 

Since we don't know which game(s) he is scum in, we just lynch him in all 3.  The serves a second purpose in exposing votes on his wagon across all three games.  If he flips scum in one game, for example, and that's the only of the two games that you didn't vote for him what would that say about you?  Scum buddy.  So this is a really a trap to find his scum buddies in whichever game(s) he's scum in.

 

We're obviously overlooking the remote possibility he's Town in all 3 and risking it in favor of the home run swing.

 

 

i think thats being a bit too ambitious, and scum would most likely bus their teammate, probably at various time during the train or atleast thats how i see it 

 

 

Protecting your arse?

[csarmi]

The premise is simple.  Csarmi posted the exact same way in all three threads.  If he were Town, why would he do that?  As scum, it makes perfect sense.

It makes perfect sense as town too.

 

1) Getting the game started is a nice thing.

2) You're making a mountain out of a molehill.

3) Does it make perfect sense to direct attention on yourself as scum first thing in the game?

 

Since we don't know which game(s) he is scum in, we just lynch him in all 3.  The serves a second purpose in exposing votes on his wagon across all three games.  If he flips scum in one game, for example, and that's the only of the two games that you didn't vote for him what would that say about you?  Scum buddy.  So this is a really a trap to find his scum buddies in whichever game(s) he's scum in.

 

We're obviously overlooking the remote possibility he's Town in all 3 and risking it in favor of the home run swing.

4) A lot of people are scum in at least one of the games. So does it make sense to run someone up in all threads then? Maybe so. But you could do that to anyone.

[bgrishinko]

 

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

The premise is simple.  Csarmi posted the exact same way in all three threads.  If he were Town, why would he do that?  As scum, it makes perfect sense.

 

Since we don't know which game(s) he is scum in, we just lynch him in all 3.  The serves a second purpose in exposing votes on his wagon across all three games.  If he flips scum in one game, for example, and that's the only of the two games that you didn't vote for him what would that say about you?  Scum buddy.  So this is a really a trap to find his scum buddies in whichever game(s) he's scum in.

 

We're obviously overlooking the remote possibility he's Town in all 3 and risking it in favor of the home run swing.

 

 

 

But waaaiiiiittt.... you just gave away the secret plan! Now what?

[csarmi]

OK, night all. It's hard to stand up from the computer, but I wake at seven.

[lolguy26]

 

 

 

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

The premise is simple.  Csarmi posted the exact same way in all three threads.  If he were Town, why would he do that?  As scum, it makes perfect sense.

 

Since we don't know which game(s) he is scum in, we just lynch him in all 3.  The serves a second purpose in exposing votes on his wagon across all three games.  If he flips scum in one game, for example, and that's the only of the two games that you didn't vote for him what would that say about you?  Scum buddy.  So this is a really a trap to find his scum buddies in whichever game(s) he's scum in.

 

We're obviously overlooking the remote possibility he's Town in all 3 and risking it in favor of the home run swing.

 

 

i think thats being a bit too ambitious, and scum would most likely bus their teammate, probably at various time during the train or atleast thats how i see it 

 

 

Protecting your arse?

 

 

definitely

 

is that your only comment cuz i dont know if you agree or disagree with the logic  

[Yates]

...scum would most likely bus their teammate, probably at various time during the train or atleast thats how i see it ...

See, that's the trap.  You put his buddies in a situation where they have to bus or be exposed.  OR not vote at all...  Which is the other place to look for scum when this is all said and done.

[peacesells]

yo

[_CLOUD]

I don't think that a scum team would bus their teammate this early. It would be a big sacrifice and I think they will just try to break it down instead.

[Niniel]

Here.

[Yates]

Let's not show our cards right now.  We each have things we'll be looking for on each Salami Wagon.  I'd rather talk about it tomorrow and let people play this however they think they would play this without benefit of knowing what we are looking for.

 

The obvious ones are out there so no biggy...

[lolguy26]

 

...scum would most likely bus their teammate, probably at various time during the train or atleast thats how i see it ...

See, that's the trap.  You put his buddies in a situation where they have to bus or be exposed.  OR not vote at all...  Which is the other place to look for scum when this is all said and done.

 

i see and you make a fair point

[lolguy26]

I don't think that a scum team would bus their teammate this early. It would be a big sacrifice and I think they will just try to break it down instead.

 

i think this was in response to me or atleast commenting on my post

 

the whole scum team wont bus at once, they'll do it at various points, and a sacrifice for town cred is most likely worth it when someone plays like salami has 

[Yates]

...a sacrifice for town cred is most likely worth it when someone plays like salami has 

What do you mean by the bolded?

[lolguy26]

 

...a sacrifice for town cred is most likely worth it when someone plays like salami has

What do you mean by the bolded?

 

 

his play has been sorta all over the place, his trap, his lack of proper defence and his ever changing story on why he played the way he did 

[Yates]

his play has been sorta all over the place, his trap, his lack of proper defence and his ever changing story on why he played the way he did 

How has his story changed?

 

Also, has he been less "all over the place" in any particular thread?

[lolguy26]

he said it was a trap, then he said pressure/getting the game going, and the game started like a couple of hours ago

[_CLOUD]

 

his play has been sorta all over the place, his trap, his lack of proper defence and his ever changing story on why he played the way he did 

How has his story changed?

 

Also, has he been less "all over the place" in any particular thread?

 

 

Check my post in the first game where I explained that his story keeps changing.

[Yates]

Check my post in the first game where I explained that his story keeps changing.

Too lazy to look... linky?

[Razen]

 

 

his play has been sorta all over the place, his trap, his lack of proper defence and his ever changing story on why he played the way he did 

How has his story changed?

 

Also, has he been less "all over the place" in any particular thread?

 

 

Check my post in the first game where I explained that his story keeps changing.

 

 

That's wonderful.  But why do you answer for Chuckles?

[_CLOUD]

Game 2: 

 

 

From trying to maintain the same strategy in all three games? Why would you do that if you weren't mafia?

Why not? I'm town, I don't have to come up with lies and fancy plays and such.
I can just play a honest game without complications. Maffia, on the other hand, will have to watch themselves. The more intertwined it gets, the bigger web of lies they have to weave, the easier it'll be to pick to catch them.

 

 

Game 2: 

 

 

The premise is simple.  Csarmi posted the exact same way in all three threads.  If he were Town, why would he do that?  As scum, it makes perfect sense.

It makes perfect sense as town too.

1) Getting the game started is a nice thing.
2) You're making a mountain out of a molehill.
3) Does it make perfect sense to direct attention on yourself as scum first thing in the game?
 

Since we don't know which game(s) he is scum in, we just lynch him in all 3.  The serves a second purpose in exposing votes on his wagon across all three games.  If he flips scum in one game, for example, and that's the only of the two games that you didn't vote for him what would that say about you?  Scum buddy.  So this is a really a trap to find his scum buddies in whichever game(s) he's scum in.
 
We're obviously overlooking the remote possibility he's Town in all 3 and risking it in favor of the home run swing.

4) A lot of people are scum in at least one of the games. So does it make sense to run someone up in all threads then? Maybe so. But you could do that to anyone.

 

 

Game 1 with my reply also from game 1: 

 

 

Scummy play?

@Razen: Nolder wasn't doing the same thing that Csarmi was doing. Now everyone is doing it though with voting for Csarmi in all three threads, but that is just a reaction to his scummy play.

Scummy play? Being a little bit too oppurtunistic, aren't you? I've placed a trio of obvious joke votes. Getting a lot of action on it is something I really like. Cause discussion helps town.
Your argument is interesting - and scummy.

 

 

So you say that early play and a lot of discussion helps town, but then you call my reasoning for voting for you scummy? I also find it amusing that you first mention that your votes across the three threads were a trap, and then it was just a townie move because they have nothing to hide, and now they are joke votes? Make up your mind dude.

 

 

 

He hasn't defended himself like this in game 3 yet.

[Lenlo]

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

They already made all the train jokes.

 

 

 

 

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

NO BRAKES

 

 

 

I liked this one the best.

[lolguy26]

 

 

 

his play has been sorta all over the place, his trap, his lack of proper defence and his ever changing story on why he played the way he did 

How has his story changed?

 

Also, has he been less "all over the place" in any particular thread?

 

 

Check my post in the first game where I explained that his story keeps changing.

 

 

That's wonderful.  But why do you answer for Chuckles?

 

 

check the time posts dude

[_CLOUD]

 

 

 

his play has been sorta all over the place, his trap, his lack of proper defence and his ever changing story on why he played the way he did 

How has his story changed?

 

Also, has he been less "all over the place" in any particular thread?

 

 

Check my post in the first game where I explained that his story keeps changing.

 

 

That's wonderful.  But why do you answer for Chuckles?

 

 

I didn't answer for Chuckles. He already gave his own answer to Yates, and after his post I explained that I noticed the same thing.