Underworld Mafia [Basic] - Game Over. TOWN WINS!

peacesells · July 2, 2013

Ok..woke up to my role pm this morning.

I can't believe how much defending has gone on in this game already. Hey people...let others answer for themselves.

Anyway, think 2 trains would be good. Dap and VOTE PANCHI.

ReleaseTheEvil · July 2, 2013

Official Vote Count:

Vam (1/8): Andrej

Darthe (1/8): Vam

Dap (1/8): Cloud

Cloud (3/8): Ithi, Despo, Dap

Panchi (1/8): Peace

Not voting (8/15): Turin, Chuckles, Mish, WBK, Darthe, Hallia, Panchi, Dice

No deadline... Yet

Darthe · July 2, 2013

Scum team:

Des, Dice, Cloud.

That was easy.

Unvote Vote Dice

This game has had one of the oddest first 5 pages that I have ever seen. It is like the setup for it is all wrong.

Des is the member of the team that I am least sure of, he just seems to be trying to bully his own meta to me. Dice is easy as mafia, he pushes too quickly and then ducks back when he realizes that he has done it. Cloud got on the list because of his weird case on Dap, who I don't fully trust either. But that probably makes him town ).)

Good news is that Peace, Ithi, and Vam are all still well in my eyes.

ReleaseTheEvil · July 2, 2013

Official Vote Count:

Vam (1/8): Andrej

Darthe (1/8): Vam

Dap (1/8): Cloud

Cloud (3/8): Ithi, Despo, Dap

Panchi (1/8): Peace

Dice (1/8): Darthe

Not voting (7/15): Turin, Chuckles, Mish, WBK, Hallia, Panchi, Dice

No deadline... Yet

Ithillian Turambar · July 2, 2013

Wow so when I make a joke vote I almost get lynched for it in two different games? But when I decide to drop it and spare the issues that come with it for once, and just focus on the game I get lynched for that? I think I can't do anything right in this game.

Anyone who says 'wow' is Mafia. And the woe is me story - boo hoo can't do anything right in THIS game?

You didn't make a joke vote here. My vote on you is because of your very creative case on Dap - which you seem to have spun out of thin air.

And two multiquote posts in the 1st three pages to make said case and vote.

And 'liking it more and more'

Seriously. You are Mafia aren't you?

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

Aren't you confident enough in your vote on me that you have to ask that? :unsure: Your case on me seems to be mostly made up of words that I tend to use all the time, so there isn't much sense in me trying to defend against it.

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

And with "this" game I mean Mafia, not this specific game.

Ithillian Turambar · July 2, 2013

I'm always confident.

You are not defending because you know your case is a pile of horse poo. So you gonna try shrug it off and hope it goes away.

Why is Dap Mafia again?

Can you explain your reasoning without quotes?

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

Go read back a page or two.

Ithillian Turambar · July 2, 2013

Can't you remember? You seemed convinced enough that you did some really nice multiquotes about it.

What's your case on him? In 30 words or less.

Because you really like your vote now, yes?

peacesells · July 2, 2013

Who let the dogs out?

Ithillian Turambar · July 2, 2013

Maybe they can remind Cloud of what his case was. He seems to have forgotten it.

That's the problem when you make stuff up.

You can't remember what you said because you didn't actually believe it lol.

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

Can't you remember? You seemed convinced enough that you did some really nice multiquotes about it.

What's your case on him? In 30 words or less.

Because you really like your vote now, yes?

I made the case because I disliked Dap's stance on Vam's vote on Darthe, and his inconsistency with Chuckles posts regardig Darthe's crazy theory. I liked it more and more because Dap only later felt the need to place a vote on Vam and was urging the rest to get a train started. Happy? And no I haven't forgotten it and I don't even know where you have gotten that idea from.

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

Now can you tell me what you find wrong about my case on Dap?

Ithillian Turambar · July 2, 2013

Just heading into parent's Evening.

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

A few more questions:

Why do you think that Dap is town?

What do you think of Peace who seems to agree with my case on Dap?

Andrej · July 2, 2013

So you got that Town role after all Darthe?

Vote Vam

(insert Jackie Chan face here)

wait, what? Why would you say this Andrej?

The poke at Darthe was about his comment in the sign ups about how he'd eventually get a town role if he continued to enter games. I wasn't infering that he did, I was asking. I can see how my wording might have been a little confusing.

Successfully ended the joke phase on page 1. I feel proud lol

But yes jokes are over, thank god

Lol glad to see you still have an ego :wink:

How it should be in every game

Who's up for a pressure train on Vam!

vote vam

Choo choo bitches

I can agree somewhat with what Cloud is saying about liking his vote more after this post. It stuck out to me as well while I reading. Dap, when did you get so free with your votes?

unvote

Turin Turambar · July 2, 2013

Some of the things that stood out during reading this morning...

Good evening. How has everyone's day been today?

and allow me to send out a Happy Canada Day to all Canadians here on DM.

Vam sucking up to the MOD? it worked cause he did get a BPV (even if it is a mouldy Darthe special) Okay that isn't really important just something I thought was funny.

Hey! Where did you get one of my BPVs?

Okay everyone, are we still on for this plan?

I support that we, as a group, no kill this entire game.

Why?

Because one of two things will happen: Either the moderator will end this game with they all lived happily ever after or...

D1: 1 death, no cornoner

1 NK

D2: 2 deaths, no coroner

1 NK

D3: 3 deaths, no coroner

1 NK

D4: 4 deaths, game.

That is 14 of 15 dead, and mafia only has a 25% chance of being the last person alive. Thus town has 75% chance to live assuming we just let the mod random kill everything.

Crazy theory is crazy. I don't think he was really serious about it however. More of a ice breaker. My opinion is that it would not work out very well. Can expound if asked.

So you got that Town role after all Darthe?

Vote Vam

Was this a "joke" vote? I wasn't sure. Also how can you say that Darthe is town after that post? I view it as strictly a continuation bet as it were in poker.

VOTE Darthe

for appearing to try to take a lazy approach to playing the game.

Odd vote and I don't agree with the reasoning he used after but I do like that he is stepping up, taking a stand and voicing opinions.

A gambit that he set up in the sign up thread?

I haven't got my pm yet..so consider this response a null tell and my actual true and true feelings.

I wouldn't put it past Darthe to set that up in the sign up thread.
But this thought?
It's not something I'd consider a gambit it's just a weird way of playing the game

It's one of those Darthe things you just ignore and actually do something worth doing

Meh...maybe, but I don't get you discouraging Vam when he actually put some real thought into a post. Why are you trying to change a good behavior?

Still no Role PM. Hey scum team guys...if I'm on your team can you send me a link to the QT. k-thanks.

Although, I have considered in the past going through half a game without reading my role pm. That would be interesting.

I agree with Peace about encouraging players to actually play. I don't really like the continued mentioning of no role PM. It seems like a way to say that everything he says can't be held against him cause he doesn't know what he is.

MOD, can you confirm if he had read his PM prior to this post? understood if not.

Lol this is amusing. I was posting it to be glib and because I have a reputation to uphold for ridiculous ideas. That this one happens to work based on the parameters set by the mod is of no consequence because it would be leaving the game up to randomness and... boring.

I can't yet decide if Vam was opportunistic here (leaning against) or if Dap is using this to apply some early pressure (leaning towards) but I think that either way it says good things about Vam and Peace based on their reactions to it.

Turin's first lackadaisical post is interesting. Why take the time to check in and state what you aren't doing?

I disagree with it in fact working out as well as darthe is suggesting. but again I don't really think he meant it as a serious plan.

My check in was just that. but it was a long day yesterday in the stupid SoCal desert heat. Here now and going thru the thread.

So you got that Town role after all Darthe?

Vote Vam

(insert Jackie Chan face here)

wait, what? Why would you say this Andrej?

It can't say anything about me...I don't have my role pm yet. lol darthe.

I don't care. Your play this far seems town. What are you trying to do? Screw your tells by playing town until you discover otherwise?

His play so far seems town..... dude it's two pages into the thread so far, and apparently Peace doesn't know his alignment yet (the mod confirmed that he couldn't send it earlier, Peace could have gotten it since, but meh).

It's NEVER a good idea to start saying someone seems town early day 1. Never ever ever. You also seem to be chainsaw-defending Darthe pretty hard too.

Darthe's crazy theory is actually a lot more sensible than most of his lol. Unfortunately I still wanna play the game, not roll the dice.

Gonna Vote Dap for now.

Agreed that the Andrej post is odd. I can see some mentioning of Darthe's read on Peace but you seem to be going overboard to make a big deal of it.

BOLDING: Not sure but it looks like you agree with the validity of his plan.

Lol whoops Unvote, Vote Darthe

The crazy theory I can forgive. Saying someone appears to be town on page 2 I cannot.

And then not so much... I don't really understand the point of the last part being the thing that you find most vote worthy in the game to date.

yello

@darthe: do you like getting lynched D1 or did you finally accept that teh gods of random.org just dont like you?

This whole series by chuckles just felt very strange to me. strange post is strange

how am i even implying that?

its clearly a joke and its dripping in sarcasm

and immediately called just a joke. drips of backpedal which is called out by Dap.

making up random theories isnt really protown in anyway is it

The darthe game plan is what I am assuming he is referring to? It was not random. It was looking at the game setup and trying to manipulate it in a way to try to make town win. Do you think the town would win easily following the plan? If you do then why would you consider his putting it out there to be anti-town? You can say that it would be a cheap victory but that is not the same as saying he is anti-town for voicing the idea. Maybe you were a bit scared of the thought?

No
But sometimes it is awfully fun. Just keep em to yourself

Dap agrees with chuckles take, but in a possibly joking way. What do you think of chuckles Dap?

Hallia · July 2, 2013

That certainly was a fast start. I like it! Cloud seems awfully defensive. For pressure:

Vote Cloud

_CLOUD · July 2, 2013

That certainly was a fast start. I like it! Cloud seems awfully defensive. For pressure:

Vote Cloud

And me being defensive equals me being mafia? What a weak vote.

peacesells · July 2, 2013

That certainly was a fast start. I like it! Cloud seems awfully defensive. For pressure:

Vote Cloud

This is horrible reasoning and very lazy town play or opportunistic scum play. Defensiveness has shown over and over again to be used by both alignments. It is a null tell.

Now if you say someone slipped by saying "blah blah blah" and is therefore scummy while being defensive that is different.

UNVOTE VOTE HALLIA

peacesells · July 2, 2013

We should all lynch hallia for her opportunistic vote and weak reasoning.

Turin Turambar · July 2, 2013

My second post got eaten for excessive quotes. Reason # 375 for hating multi-quote.

The TL;DR version was that I find Ithi's case on Cloud compelling, I was just about ready to vote him when this happened...

Ok..woke up to my role pm this morning.

I can't believe how much defending has gone on in this game already. Hey people...let others answer for themselves.

Anyway, think 2 trains would be good. Dap and VOTE PANCHI.

You want trains on a perpetual newbie(panchi) and on Dap. Why not cloud?

That certainly was a fast start. I like it! Cloud seems awfully defensive. For pressure:

Vote Cloud

And me being defensive equals me being mafia? What a weak vote.

She said for pressure. Cloud you don't seem to be handling it very well. As far as being defensive It doesn't necessarily mean you are mafia but it looks to me like you are annoyed at being caught out today.

That certainly was a fast start. I like it! Cloud seems awfully defensive. For pressure:

Vote Cloud

This is horrible reasoning and very lazy town play or opportunistic scum play. Defensiveness has shown over and over again to be used by both alignments. It is a null tell.

Now if you say someone slipped by saying "blah blah blah" and is therefore scummy while being defensive that is different.

UNVOTE VOTE HALLIA

Peace, you are defending Cloud pretty hard here. I'm torn deciding if you are in this together or you just are taking an opportunity to defend a townie. Right now I am leaning toward the former. but either way I am thinking you sir are mafia.

vote PEACE

Hallia · July 2, 2013

He's on his white horse, off to defend his fellow scum perhaps?

peacesells · July 2, 2013

How have I defended cloud? I attacked Hallia's horrible play.

Now she is buddying up to you. You guys working in tandem? Why are you defending Hallia?

Underworld Mafia [Basic] - Game Over. TOWN WINS!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook