Lord of the Rings Mafia [Advanced Mafia] Town Wins!!!!

[Hallia]

Believe so

[Tigraine]

I must have slept through that part of the game!

[RandA lThor]

Official Vote Count

 

Dap(1): Hally

Hally(1): Nya

Not Voting(4): Tigs, Tina, Dap, Talya

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch

L-3

Deadline:http://www.timeandda...ngs Mafia Day 8

[dapianoplay3r]

Hally what have all your actions been?

 

There might be info in thete

[Hallia]

I viewed Heart, who turned into Wombat; I killed Cloud; I protected Tigs one night, and roleblocked Nya the night Tigs said she did nothing.  O.o  Ohmigosh.  I missed that.

 

Unvote

Vote Nya

[Hallia]

N6 I holstered my RB, then went on a limb and RB'd her on N7

[Hallia]

And according to the OP, there was no kill N7

[Hallia]

Going back, the OP says that Turin died N6, but right after he dies, the day says it is now day 8, typo or did we skip a day?

[RandA lThor]

Sorry typo, there was a kill on night 7.

[Hallia]

S'okay! So that's what I've got.

[dapianoplay3r]

That confused me

 

so Nya was RBed the night she did nothing?

[Hallia]

Yes.  Don't know if it means anything, or if she was just plain town.

[dapianoplay3r]

There was still a kill right?

 

Therefore I don't think she is our killer

[Hallia]

Exactly, that's why I asked about the clarification on the day/night thing.

 

Unvote

[dapianoplay3r]

So me or Tina right ?

[Tigraine]

I viewed Nya on N6.

[Tigraine]

Do you have anything left Hallia?

[Tigraine]

Sorry for the double and triple posting :D

 

Anyway, if wombat was viewed as town why are we considering him as a possibility?

 

Wasn't there only one person with the recruiting ability so far? Does the recruit not count if its used on the symp?

[Tigraine]

I'm thinking its either dap or hallia because of their proximity to Tina in the listing. Could explain how easily it got mixed up on who had the NA WHEN I viewed her.

[Hallia]

Nah, got nothin' left.

[dapianoplay3r]

Don't base it off that

 

When I modded listing made no difference. I had a list of NA as they occurred and updated the results as the NAs happened

 

Order didnt feature at all

[Nyanna al'Meara]

Ooo, I'm quite sure its Hallia now. Not calling OMGUS, but that vote was just jumpy :P

[Hallia]

Because there was an error in the days and nights? How is that jumpy? When logic prevailed, I changed my opinion.

[Tigraine]

Oh well, it was a thought worth voicing lol

 

So what do we do?

 

I have only checked 2 of the people still alive I believe...they didnt have a kill on those nights and we still had a kill during both nights. It stands to reason that neither are the remaining mafia member. Of course that is based on whether or not you believe my claim and if you do then That means 3/6 we know are not scum and of course 2 of the other 3 remaining know they aren't as well. So...I have a 1/3 shot to pick scum as do Tina and Nya. 2 people have a 1/2 chance at hitting it.

[Talya]

@ Tigs...there has b a been ight kill each night, so you can't be alive because someone else is protecting you all the time. You are alive because the mafia don't feel threatened by you or you are mafia. 

 

to all - So again, please all go through that list and say if you think it could be correct and if not who you think that person could be. There is a good reason for it. Only those not town would want to ignore it. if will give us some info. All you have to do is copy and paste it, take out your own name and if you don't agree write next to it in another colour who you think they could be. Because at the end of the day you know who you are and if I have the wrong person down for a character we may be able to work this out.

 

Dap - Eowyn

Nya - Theoden

Tigs - Gimli

Tina - Gollum

Hally - Aragorn

Tallya - Can't possible say ;-)