Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

dapianoplay3r · May 18, 2013

Id be down to lybxg rand i think

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2013

If we need to consolidate, I'd rather it be on Ithi than me, if she's telling the truth. I don't have any special powers. Of course, I'd rather us do so on actual scum.

Ok so you admit to not having any ability yet you said you would rather consolidate onto Ithi who is claiming an item... this statement makes absolutely 0 sense

your power of reading comprehension fail are amazing.

How so? She said we should consolidate on Ithi out of the 2 of them altho Ithi has claimed an ability and Hallia has not

Hallia · May 18, 2013

Actually here's the timeline:

I'm curious to see if I'm right.

Vote Ithi

The first person to vote for me has confirmed they did so for no reason. Other people have voted for me for innacurate reasons - and then ignored my correction. Yet other people have voted me because they apparently agree with the previous horse poo made up cases - and yet another just says vote me cos of the info. Now 'consoloidation' is being advised.

Why am I not surprised.

Turin got killed and I'm to be Lynched.

In other news I do really have a limited shot item that allows me to stop ghosts.

But feel free to carry on with your 'consolidation'

Also I'd love to see how EP acting like a twonk has got anything to do with me. Please explain how I'm encouraging him when I want him gone.

And post numbers mean nothing to me. I don't ever use the full version.

So does that mean we don't have to worry about consolidating? Will the phase actually end?

Unvote

If we need to consolidate, I'd rather it be on Ithi than me, if she's telling the truth. I don't have any special powers. Of course, I'd rather us do so on actual scum.

She revealed, I unvoted, and then said that, so...not sure where you're goin' with that.

DPR · May 18, 2013

Current Vote Count:

Mish (1) - Verb

Peace (1) - EP

Ishy (1) - Darthe

EP (3) - Ithi, NB, TGlems

Ithi (5) - Crush, Ape, Leelou, Lily, Rand

Hallia (5) - Kae, Wombat, Peace, Basel, Cloud

Verbal (1) - Tina

No Lynch (1) - Red

With 33 players, it takes 17 to lynch. The hour turns May 19th, 9:00 am EST.

wouldn't there only be 32 players now with Turin's death DPR?

32 players is correct. 17 to lynch. You have 13 hours and 15 minutes until the day turns.

peacesells · May 18, 2013

There you go EP.

Anyway..hallia is still scummy

Gabriel Kross · May 18, 2013

Read that last quote. it says you want us to consolidate on Ithi. It literally says it right in the quote...

Hallia · May 18, 2013

XD That's my bass ackwards derp. Me than Ithi. *hangs head in shame*

RandA lThor · May 18, 2013

The first person to vote for me has confirmed they did so for no reason. Other people have voted for me for innacurate reasons - and then ignored my correction. Yet other people have voted me because they apparently agree with the previous horse poo made up cases - and yet another just says vote me cos of the info. Now 'consoloidation' is being advised.

Why am I not surprised.

Turin got killed and I'm to be Lynched.

In other news I do really have a limited shot item that allows me to stop ghosts.

But feel free to carry on with your 'consolidation'

Also I'd love to see how EP acting like a twonk has got anything to do with me. Please explain how I'm encouraging him when I want him gone.

And post numbers mean nothing to me. I don't ever use the full version.

Hmm, I believe this even more than normal because as the first gift claim, your claim has a certain element of canon to it that fits what DPR might say, and doesn't seem just randomly made up. unvote

And I would like to point out that there won't be any Nights. We move from one hour to the next to the next.

Why is anyone talking about Day or Night actions? I know I can use mine any time.

This is actually a good point, I forgot about this aspect of the game.

And if there is, shes town?

Where you going with that cloud.

Also i feel rand is trying too hard

Um.... yes I am trying hard. I did last DPR game as well.

EP is always anti-town. His meta itself is anti-town. I was hoping he would have settled down by now but if anything he seems to have gotten worse. You need to start policy lynching him.

I wouldn't say always, its just that his play can get out of hand. And we shouldn't just policy lynch him, probability and meta says that he is town, odds aren't for us. Worst case scenario, we don't listen to him and he still improves our odds. Sad that you didn't or wouldn't think of this Womby, makes me a little suspicious.

What in the world makes you think that's the worst case scenario?

No, I mean that if EP is not helping town so much that its a worst case scenario, then we can literally ignore him, and if he was still town, he would still help us by giving us numbers. Lynching him reduces our numbers and wastes a lynch if he's town, which I think he is.

With less than 24 hours to go, a weekend deadline, and nobody anywhere near a lynch, I think we need to start consolidating votes.

So eager to consolidate already? Seems like a chance to try and get some weak votes and a bad lynch in. If Lily is mafia, then I think that all the big trains right now are town, namely Ithi. In fact, if we lynch Ithi and she turns out town as she is the biggest train right now, I will look harder at Lily and Hallia.

No. Worst case scenario is that EP is mafia and that we ignore him because of his meta.

Slightly better but still bad case scenario is that he is town and people actually pay attention to him, thereby distracting themselves from actual scumhunting.

Second best case scenario is that EP is town and everyone ignores him. This is actually a pretty rosy scenario imo. It is hard for most players to ignore someone like EP. Also, doing so risks the worst case scenario.

Best case scenario is that EP is mafia and we lynch him immediately.

Top suspects right now:

Rand

Hallia

EP

By ignore, I didn't mean to ignore him indefinitely. I meant until he starts doing things that are mafia-like and scummy. Reminder that you said you wanted to policy lynch him because he usually does anti-town play. My argument on that was for a general all game strategy that we should employ him. And by ignore I didn't mean ignore his posts completely, I meant to ignore his plans, because if no one supports them, then it doesn't have any effect.

If we need to consolidate, I'd rather it be on Ithi than me, if she's telling the truth. I don't have any special powers. Of course, I'd rather us do so on actual scum.

I think you mean on me than Ithi, right?

So 12 more hours (if I got the timezone right)

14, actually.

Ok, thanks.

Rand setting up future lynches looks indeed to be scummy.

I never set up future lynches. I said if x flips town, then I will look at y more. Setting up lynches would be saying that after this lynch, we should lynch y after.

Gabriel Kross · May 19, 2013

If we need to consolidate, I'd rather it be on Ithi than me, if she's telling the truth. I don't have any special powers. Of course, I'd rather us do so on actual scum.

I think you mean on me than Ithi, right?

So 12 more hours (if I got the timezone right)

14, actually.

Ok, thanks.

Rand setting up future lynches looks indeed to be scummy.

I never set up future lynches. I said if x flips town, then I will look at y more. Setting up lynches would be saying that after this lynch, we should lynch y after.

Actually it's basically saying the same thing.

鲍勃不是我的名字 · May 19, 2013

EP is always anti-town. His meta itself is anti-town. I was hoping he would have settled down by now but if anything he seems to have gotten worse. You need to start policy lynching him.

I wouldn't say always, its just that his play can get out of hand. And we shouldn't just policy lynch him, probability and meta says that he is town, odds aren't for us. Worst case scenario, we don't listen to him and he still improves our odds. Sad that you didn't or wouldn't think of this Womby, makes me a little suspicious.

What in the world makes you think that's the worst case scenario?

No, I mean that if EP is not helping town so much that its a worst case scenario, then we can literally ignore him, and if he was still town, he would still help us by giving us numbers. Lynching him reduces our numbers and wastes a lynch if he's town, which I think he is.

With less than 24 hours to go, a weekend deadline, and nobody anywhere near a lynch, I think we need to start consolidating votes.

So eager to consolidate already? Seems like a chance to try and get some weak votes and a bad lynch in. If Lily is mafia, then I think that all the big trains right now are town, namely Ithi. In fact, if we lynch Ithi and she turns out town as she is the biggest train right now, I will look harder at Lily and Hallia.

No. Worst case scenario is that EP is mafia and that we ignore him because of his meta.

Slightly better but still bad case scenario is that he is town and people actually pay attention to him, thereby distracting themselves from actual scumhunting.

Second best case scenario is that EP is town and everyone ignores him. This is actually a pretty rosy scenario imo. It is hard for most players to ignore someone like EP. Also, doing so risks the worst case scenario.

Best case scenario is that EP is mafia and we lynch him immediately.

Top suspects right now:

Rand

Hallia

EP

I agree with Wombat the most. Still think EP is the best lynch. Could go with either of his other two as well.

Also, John has gone conspicuously silent.

What's that all about?

Gabriel Kross · May 19, 2013

Wombat is as blind as a bat this game and you seem determined to follow him

Hallia · May 19, 2013

I've got a pretty strong feeling that wombat's mafia.

DPR · May 19, 2013

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FNfB6WfwM4

LilyElizabeth · May 19, 2013

I don't feel that Hally is mafia. I don't think any mafia team in their right minds would have let her come across the way she has.

I don't know what to think about Ithi. She's been acting defensive and less aggressive than I remember her play to be. She could have an item, or she could have made that up. I wish there was time to ask her what she means by stopping ghosts. I'd like to hear more of her story. But she's sleeping now and I will be before she gets up, I think.

I could switch to Rand, if y'all want to go there.

Gabriel Kross · May 19, 2013

Vote Peace it's the smart thing to do

LilyElizabeth · May 19, 2013

While I always think Peace is scummy, I think I'll hold off on that, thanks. :wink:

WolfbrotherKronos · May 19, 2013

Hallia's play is really strange

vote hallia

Hallia · May 19, 2013

Don't just go along with the mainstream wolfie; what about my play is strange, can you say exactly why?

WolfbrotherKronos · May 19, 2013

Its been said...for someone who thinks ithi is town you surd are doing a good job of advocatting her lynch

RandA lThor · May 19, 2013

If we need to consolidate, I'd rather it be on Ithi than me, if she's telling the truth. I don't have any special powers. Of course, I'd rather us do so on actual scum.

I think you mean on me than Ithi, right?

So 12 more hours (if I got the timezone right)

14, actually.

Ok, thanks.

Rand setting up future lynches looks indeed to be scummy.

I never set up future lynches. I said if x flips town, then I will look at y more. Setting up lynches would be saying that after this lynch, we should lynch y after.

Actually it's basically saying the same thing.

The seemingly small difference is large though. The first that I am going to do just uses lynches as a portion of a possible vote, like someone would use in a case. Setting up lynches would be to definitely or almost definitely plan to lynch the person the next day.

WWWwombat · May 19, 2013

Generally when someone says he is going to "look at" someone in a mafia game, it means he is planning a case. Telegraphing future cases as a townie is not very advantageous as it lets the mafia know what you are thinking. Telegraphing cases, however, is often used by mafia to make their arbitrary votes seem more deliberate and thought out.

WWWwombat · May 19, 2013

Generally when someone says he is going to "look at" someone in a mafia game, it means he is planning a case. Telegraphing future cases as a townie is not very advantageous as it lets the mafia know what you are thinking. Telegraphing cases, however, is often used by mafia to make their arbitrary votes seem more deliberate and thought out.

WWWwombat · May 19, 2013

Generally when someone says he is going to "look at" someone in a mafia game, it means he is planning a case. Telegraphing future cases as a townie is not very advantageous as it lets the mafia know what you are thinking. Telegraphing cases, however, is often used by mafia to make their arbitrary votes seem more deliberate and thought out.

WWWwombat · May 19, 2013

Generally when someone says he is going to "look at" someone in a mafia game, it means he is planning a case. Telegraphing future cases as a townie is not very advantageous as it lets the mafia know what you are thinking. Telegraphing cases, however, is often used by mafia to make their arbitrary votes seem more deliberate and thought out.

Tyler Glembo · May 19, 2013

So let's see, 3 people jump to defend EP saying that he is always scummy so they want to give him a pass? At least EP tried to deflect my case on him, whereas other people try to push it away on the grounds of meta.

Then we have Cloud and others voting Hallia after explaining multiple different rules to her for, supposedly, trying to pull a gambit with the rules? Or something? I don't get the case on Hallia at all. A big FoS on everyone voting Hallia because you are either town hurting town or you are scum.

I'm keeping my vote on EP. I'm willing to switch to Cloud, Rand, or anyone else voting Hallia atm.

Also Wombat, quadruple post? Lol

Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook