[Advanced] Hobbit Mafia Town Wins!

[Lenlo]

We need to consolidate on someone. Starrik claimed a power role and Dice claimed vanilla townie so I think Dice is our best bet of the two and peoplea re leaning that way already. We have to avoid a random.

 

vote Dice

[hazelkrs1]

I agree that Poison Doc is prob too obscure for Starrik to have thought of, but yall are forgetting that if he's scum then he would have a QT full of other, possibly more experienced players who could have fed it to him. That being said for now it seems more legit to me.

 

As for Dice, vanilla claim means we won't really be risking much. The fact that he all but disappeared after first catching a little bit of heat and then people focusing on Starrik just screams that he was trying to lay low on purpose.

 

I do agree about Panchi tho. I know I'll prob once again sound like a jerk, but I think some people just sign up for a game like this thinking it will be novel fun, but once they're in it they just clam up cause they don't know how to play. The only way to learn is to actually try playing.

[hazelkrs1]

Bah why couldn't you have just claimed vanilla? Well I still don't know if I believe you. That seems like a rather obscure role, though if we really do have a poison thingie in this game..... Unvote Vote Dice. I still don't want a random. What did the mod tell you about your role Starry?

 

Btw, this post pinged majorly to me btw. Apparently Cyan is mad at Starrik for claiming something other than vanilla... cause she wanted an easy lynch? The ellipse in the middle seems a little peculiar... could be that Cyan is the poisoner.

 

And the last part just seems like she's trying to be a helpful townie, asking him details about his role. I don't think the role really needs that much explanation. He's a poison Doc. He protects against poison.

 

If it wasn't so close to deadline I'd prob consider moving my vote to Cyan.

[dicetosser1]

i disappeared cause i got sick actually

 

 

We need to consolidate on someone. Starrik claimed a power role and Dice claimed vanilla townie so I think Dice is our best bet of the two and peoplea re leaning that way already. We have to avoid a random.

 

vote Dice

 

Now how many times have i seen this and everybody jumped on it for being scummy? Answer a lot. FOS

[WWWwombat]

We need a lynch. Deadline this close to Thanksgiving is kinda nuts but you guys aren't playing with your heads right now. Townies need to vote Dice.

[Turin Turambar]

I would prefer not to lynch members of the party of 12 dwarves a hobbit and a wizard if possible. They may be the key to winning this game.

 

Starrik is claiming poison doc so I think he needs to be given a chance to prove his worth. However he could actually be the poisoner hoping to draw out the real poison doc. It could also be a complete fabrication. Then tomorrow no one dies and he gets to claim that he protected someone.

 

It always sounds wrong to me when people start telling others how to vote or how to play. I am around and can change to help secure a lynch. I don't like the Dice train.

 

How much time to deadline? How many folks on line?

[michellem]

Len, major FoS for wanting to lynch Dice, also FoS on Des for being ok with the lynch. I don't want a random lynch either, but the way you worded your post Len... Major, major pings. I think it's really stupid to lynch one of the dwarfs.

 

Also, I have no idea what happened to the time, if Rand extended it, because now it's 3 hours left oO

[Darthe]

Yeah this holiday is a crap time, I barely have signal to play and falcon has no Internet so he is gone for the weekend from my understanding.

[Turin Turambar]

Just read thru again and the two I would prefer to vote are Lenlo and Basel. Basel for his injecting motive into Panchi's odd vote. It looked like an easy shot at a new player. But basel is gone so he won't be able to respond. Lenlo for his pushing a dwarf lynch. The party is definitely in the game and town. So with no cc Dice is town. Rather not lynch town.

 

The other option could be to lynch one of the total inactives like Player. I don't think he has made a content post the entire game.

 

In fact since I am still here unvote. vote Lenlo

[michellem]

I agree with you Turin. unvote vote Lenlo

[michellem]

Not that I think it matters, because I just took a closer look at the time counter, and we have passed deadline. I didn't realize it started counting upwards when time was out.

[Starrik]

This late in the game, we need a lynch and I'm not happy with killing dice, who has so far not got much against him. I'll give Lenlo a chance to respond first.

[Starrik]

So we have a random lych Day 1? This isn't good.

[michellem]

I'm not sure if it'll be a random lynch, or if you'll die Starry since I think you have the most votes. Rand hasn't specified in the OP what will happen if consesus isn't reached before deadline.

[Turin Turambar]

Maybe not. If we keep playing and achieve a lynch Rand MIGHT accept it. worth a shot until he says otherwise in my opinion.

[Tyler Glembo]

We need a lynch. Deadline this close to Thanksgiving is kinda nuts but you guys aren't playing with your heads right now. Townies need to vote Dice.

 

Slight ping for pushing a quick lynch on a claimed vanilla. No suggestions for a better option?

 

Just read thru again and the two I would prefer to vote are Lenlo and Basel. Basel for his injecting motive into Panchi's odd vote. It looked like an easy shot at a new player. But basel is gone so he won't be able to respond. Lenlo for his pushing a dwarf lynch. The party is definitely in the game and town. So with no cc Dice is town. Rather not lynch town.

 

The other option could be to lynch one of the total inactives like Player. I don't think he has made a content post the entire game.

 

In fact since I am still here unvote. vote Lenlo

 

I prefer the idea of inactives who haven't made content posts.

 

Len, major FoS for wanting to lynch Dice, also FoS on Des for being ok with the lynch. I don't want a random lynch either, but the way you worded your post Len... Major, major pings. I think it's really stupid to lynch one of the dwarfs.

 

Also, I have no idea what happened to the time, if Rand extended it, because now it's 3 hours left oO

 

So if you agree or disagree with the Dice lynch it is scummy either way?

 

If Rand is willing to extend the deadline:

After a quick reread vote BG. So far the only thing I've seen from BG is lurking and waiting until the Starrick train had gotten rolling and then jumping on to the train. Then he made a few non-game related posts about formatting.

[Starrik]

We're actually just getting further away from a consensus here.

[Tyler Glembo]

Yeah, but the Lenlo and Wombat posts both pinged and made sense at the same time. Yes, we do not want to lynch a claimed townie but yes we want to achieve a lynch. I'll change my vote if I see a compelling case.

[Lenlo]

Len, major FoS for wanting to lynch Dice, also FoS on Des for being ok with the lynch. I don't want a random lynch either, but the way you worded your post Len... Major, major pings. I think it's really stupid to lynch one of the dwarfs.

 

Also, I have no idea what happened to the time, if Rand extended it, because now it's 3 hours left oO

Look. There are 12 Dwarves, a wizard and a hobbit. Not all of them are power roles that I can guarantee. The three most likely to have power roles in that group are Thorin Oakenshield, Biblo and Gandalf. He is not one of those 3 so I am willing to take the risk.

 

Just read thru again and the two I would prefer to vote are Lenlo and Basel. Basel for his injecting motive into Panchi's odd vote. It looked like an easy shot at a new player. But basel is gone so he won't be able to respond. Lenlo for his pushing a dwarf lynch. The party is definitely in the game and town. So with no cc Dice is town. Rather not lynch town.

 

The other option could be to lynch one of the total inactives like Player. I don't think he has made a content post the entire game.

 

In fact since I am still here unvote. vote Lenlo

 

You two act like we really have a choice. I dont want to lynch him either but its better than a bloody random! Give me a better alternative because right now you two are diverting attention away from the best bet we have today of achieving a lynch. Do you want it to go random? Because thats not a town move at all.

[Lenlo]

I would prefer not to lynch members of the party of 12 dwarves a hobbit and a wizard if possible. They may be the key to winning this game.

 

Starrik is claiming poison doc so I think he needs to be given a chance to prove his worth. However he could actually be the poisoner hoping to draw out the real poison doc. It could also be a complete fabrication. Then tomorrow no one dies and he gets to claim that he protected someone.

 

It always sounds wrong to me when people start telling others how to vote or how to play. I am around and can change to help secure a lynch. I don't like the Dice train.

 

How much time to deadline? How many folks on line?

Wanna know whats key to winning this game? Lynching the scum. Wanna know what we cant do if we jump off a train every time someone claims a dwarf? Lynch scum.

[michellem]

No, I don't want it to go to random, but it sits really, really bad with me to lynch someone I strongly believe to be town. Anyhow, doesn't matter, we've passed deadline.

 

 

 

And TG: You must have misread me. I ment that Des and Len was both suspicious for being ok with the Dice-lynch.

[Turin Turambar]

The key is that the dwarves are nearly certainly in the game and nearly certainly town. I also think that most will be vanilla but guess what? they are still townies. Confirmed townies are a valued commodity.

 

As far as anyone fake claiming a dwarf, they will get cc'ed and we will get the mafia. Most likely before we run out of dwarves. I kind of doubt there are 12 mafia in the game. This may all be moot due to the posted deadline already being past. Your response is signalling to me that I may be right about you. We can keep playing until Rand tells us that it is no longer day.

[beanie]

Bah guyyyyyyys you let it go random! <.<

 

Despo you should have just moved your vote to me. It wouldn't have made a difference since everyone else decided to make it go random anyways I'm not mad, just annoyed that the person who we could have lynched to avoid a random could actually be someone important. As it is now we have nothing.

 

And you used ... in your post too lol.

[Lenlo]

You and Turin both are at the top of my list come D2.

 

Your both incredibly scummy to me right now. Your defense of Dice and moves to get it to go random reek of trying to look town and sloppy scum play.

[Lenlo]

Turin you are focusing almost purely on the theme and not on gameplay. No one is confirmed town until a cop views them or they are lynched.