[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[Darthe]

'd

[Basel Gill]

I can't tell if that push was complete sarcasm or if you really are that bad as mafia..

 

Darthe, who is this for? Was it in reply to my post right above yours, or another post, or what?

[Darthe]

Vote NS. I've been away all day long, so a good deal of this is stuff that I have been beaten to the argument. But his supplying an entire list without any reason was something I've never seen in any game before that I can recall. Voting or FoSing one person with no case, yes I've seen that, but a full scum list? The comment that he hopes town loses pings hard. Who wants town to lose? That's right: scum! And let's not forget the blatant and unrepentant OMGUS on Red, backed up by the logic of "she's wrong and must therefore be scum". Riiiight. I think that if Basel 1.0 were still around, that he might have NKed NS just on policy for all the trolling.

 

So if NS is scum, and is lynched... win. If NS is town and is lynched... well, he has not been a team player and has not really made an attempt to be helpful toward town. So not as big a win, but I'd still call it a small win.

I can't tell if that push was complete sarcasm or if you really are that bad as mafia..

 

Tada. We really didn't need the impressionism.. Its only point is to try and buff your own image in the game and it reads as very.. theatrical. AKA

[Basel Gill]

Vote NS. I've been away all day long, so a good deal of this is stuff that I have been beaten to the argument. But his supplying an entire list without any reason was something I've never seen in any game before that I can recall. Voting or FoSing one person with no case, yes I've seen that, but a full scum list? The comment that he hopes town loses pings hard. Who wants town to lose? That's right: scum! And let's not forget the blatant and unrepentant OMGUS on Red, backed up by the logic of "she's wrong and must therefore be scum". Riiiight. I think that if Basel 1.0 were still around, that he might have NKed NS just on policy for all the trolling.

 

So if NS is scum, and is lynched... win. If NS is town and is lynched... well, he has not been a team player and has not really made an attempt to be helpful toward town. So not as big a win, but I'd still call it a small win.

I can't tell if that push was complete sarcasm or if you really are that bad as mafia..

 

Tada. We really didn't need the impressionism.. Its only point is to try and buff your own image in the game and it reads as very.. theatrical. AKA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNtrJc03Beo

 

Gee, here's a radical thought for you... I might honestly believe that NS is scum? You present the only options here as me being sarcastic, or that I'm just really bad as scum, as if these are the only two possibilities there are. You respond with a confusing post that doesn't even quote who you're replying to. And then you go on to say you don't need the impressionism. Where do you get impressionism? If I see someone as scum, do you seriously expect me to not call them out?

[Gabriel Kross]

This has been an incredibly active game. Dice, if you're still up, what are your thoughts on some of the players that have been in the spotlight lately? Nightstrike, BG, Razen, Red, Ed... to name a few

 

i musta gone to bed when you posted this.I got very distracted by nights reactions with red and red and EP going back and forth

 

nightstrike is acting crazy.almost EP crazy. BG is someone I always have problems reading, Most of the time i get him wrong. Im trying to figure Ed out..this is the first time ive played with himand all that humor and spam is distracting. Razen i havent really paid attention to

 

I am kinda on the same page as Red re EP I dont trust him. theres no real difference i dont think between silencer and jailer. Either could be a scum role cause they basically do the same thing so its easy to claim the town version.

 

Red ....Red is just so aggressive i dont really know what to make of her. part of me always wants her lynched just so she cant bulldog me!! and part wants her to stay as she gets reactions out of people but that makes it hard to figure if she is town scumhunting or mafia rolehunting if u get me.

 

 

Atm Night is the one i am watching the most. but i am also keeping an eye on EP

 

except Nol just fully cleared me.

 

I shall go with a VOTE VERB like I said I would

[ed2funy]

Except, I am pretty sure Nol said that to placate Red.

 

It hasn't changed my opinion of you, atm. In the sense that he didn't make me start trusting you.

[Gabriel Kross]

Except, I am pretty sure Nol said that to placate Red.

 

It hasn't changed my opinion of you, atm. In the sense that he didn't make me start trusting you.

 

Nice way to cast doubt on the mod-confirmed townie...

[ed2funy]

Nice way of twisting things.

I only cast doubt on his verifying you.

 

Because let's face it, if he knew from the Mods you and John were Town, he would have said so off the bat. And he only said that after constant badgering.

[Nolder]

I wouldn't do that

[Gabriel Kross]

Nice way of twisting things.

I only cast doubt on his verifying you.

 

Because let's face it, if he knew from the Mods you and John were Town, he would have said so off the bat. And he only said that after constant badgering.

 

 

Or maybe he didn't want multiple outed mod confirmed town targets? We saw that the mafia decided not to go after either of the claimed characters, why? It's because we still had reasonable doubt pointed at us, now that Nolder has outed that we are modconfirmed to him, then we are the prime night targets.

 

Casting doubt on something that an in thread mod-confirmed town says is 100% modconfirmed to him is casting doubt onto a modconfirmed town.

[Darthe]

Vote NS. I've been away all day long, so a good deal of this is stuff that I have been beaten to the argument. But his supplying an entire list without any reason was something I've never seen in any game before that I can recall. Voting or FoSing one person with no case, yes I've seen that, but a full scum list? The comment that he hopes town loses pings hard. Who wants town to lose? That's right: scum! And let's not forget the blatant and unrepentant OMGUS on Red, backed up by the logic of "she's wrong and must therefore be scum". Riiiight. I think that if Basel 1.0 were still around, that he might have NKed NS just on policy for all the trolling.

 

So if NS is scum, and is lynched... win. If NS is town and is lynched... well, he has not been a team player and has not really made an attempt to be helpful toward town. So not as big a win, but I'd still call it a small win.

I can't tell if that push was complete sarcasm or if you really are that bad as mafia..

 

Tada. We really didn't need the impressionism.. Its only point is to try and buff your own image in the game and it reads as very.. theatrical. AKA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNtrJc03Beo

 

Gee, here's a radical thought for you... I might honestly believe that NS is scum? You present the only options here as me being sarcastic, or that I'm just really bad as scum, as if these are the only two possibilities there are. You respond with a confusing post that doesn't even quote who you're replying to. And then you go on to say you don't need the impressionism. Where do you get impressionism? If I see someone as scum, do you seriously expect me to not call them out?

 

I fully expect you to play to your beliefs in game, however the bolded is clear Impressionism and a quite blatant push on someone who is already almost certain to die. Not to mention that nobody needed this case rehashed, it's only purpose, again, is to make it appear as if you're scum hunting. Good job on the far overly defensive reply though, kudos. Again, if you wanted to help the town at least give something more than what everyone else already knows thrown about in a different manner.

[ed2funy]

I do what I want.

 

Riiiight, so his constant statements saying you are Town and trying to pass you off as confirmed wasn't the same thing. It was to him.

 

EP, you were only a target at Night because of your gameplay.

 

No, it's casting doubt on his truthfulness in this particular matter when it's been a point of discussion since he started doing it. I have not said he isn't Town. Nor have I said he doesn't have the Town's best interest at heart. I believe he does, but that doesn't mean he won't lie as a Townie to make his point. I've done it. It's not a great idea, but unless a Mod confirms you or John, then there IS doubt on who you are.

[Darthe]

Nice way of twisting things.

I only cast doubt on his verifying you.

 

Because let's face it, if he knew from the Mods you and John were Town, he would have said so off the bat. And he only said that after constant badgering.

 

 

Or maybe he didn't want multiple outed mod confirmed town targets? We saw that the mafia decided not to go after either of the claimed characters, why? It's because we still had reasonable doubt pointed at us, now that Nolder has outed that we are modconfirmed to him, then we are the prime night targets.

 

Casting doubt on something that an in thread mod-confirmed town says is 100% modconfirmed to him is casting doubt onto a modconfirmed town.

 

Just a quick aside; I hate mechanics like this. It's proxy bullshanks and even if it doesn't cast doubt on Nol it does on you. At worst it will eventually be an almost mod-pushed waste of a day to test how reliable Nol's info is.

[Darthe]

Unless of course Nol lies ).) Ninja Ed

[RandA lThor]

Honestly, I am getting a town read on Ed right now. No mafia would be so belligerent, accuse a mod-confirmed townie, and do this. Its one of those things where he is so scummy that he has to be town.

[RandA lThor]

Not necessarily has to be, but you get my pont, very likely.

[Songstress]

I was originally getting a town vibe - if one with a bit of a language barrier and some extra frustration - from Nightstrike, but his more recent posts have been more anti-town than frustrated town, especially the "I hope you lose" bit. At this point, I'm hoping he is frustrated mafia instead of town reacting that badly.

 

While reviewing my notes from D1, Rand also stood out - there were several times when taking notes I seriously thought "are you getting splinters from sitting on that fence, Rand?" Rand could use some pressure as well. I think he's grown past the point of getting flustered and announcing himself as mafia in games, but we may learn something nonetheless.

 

Vote Rand

[RandA lThor]

I was originally getting a town vibe - if one with a bit of a language barrier and some extra frustration - from Nightstrike, but his more recent posts have been more anti-town than frustrated town, especially the "I hope you lose" bit. At this point, I'm hoping he is frustrated mafia instead of town reacting that badly.

 

While reviewing my notes from D1, Rand also stood out - there were several times when taking notes I seriously thought "are you getting splinters from sitting on that fence, Rand?" Rand could use some pressure as well. I think he's grown past the point of getting flustered and announcing himself as mafia in games, but we may learn something nonetheless.

 

Vote Rand

 

well at least you acknowledge that. yes, I have been fence-sitting a little, but I have also shown clear opinions in this game as well. The fence sitting has mainly been because I have been confused this game about somethings going on, but that's no excuse. Yes, I have been fence-sitting a little in this game, going to try and get clearer views soon, but I have not been fence-sitting the whole game.

[peacesells]

I never have understood how fence sitting can be considered a legit accusation. At best its a little wifom. If you are town, you have no direct knowledge of alignments. Therefore fence sitting is natural.

 

The wifom part I get cause scum can use fence sitting as a way to hedge.

 

But fence sitting on it's own is not an indication of guilt. I've felt that way many times as town.

[Songstress]

I never have understood how fence sitting can be considered a legit accusation. At best its a little wifom. If you are town, you have no direct knowledge of alignments. Therefore fence sitting is natural.

 

The wifom part I get cause scum can use fence sitting as a way to hedge.

 

But fence sitting on it's own is not an indication of guilt. I've felt that way many times as town.

 

It's coming across to me as playing a little too careful - trying to play both sides of the fence, so to speak, not being willing to be pinned down to a position.

[RandA lThor]

I never have understood how fence sitting can be considered a legit accusation. At best its a little wifom. If you are town, you have no direct knowledge of alignments. Therefore fence sitting is natural.

 

The wifom part I get cause scum can use fence sitting as a way to hedge.

 

But fence sitting on it's own is not an indication of guilt. I've felt that way many times as town.

 

It's coming across to me as playing a little too careful - trying to play both sides of the fence, so to speak, not being willing to be pinned down to a position.

 

It could be that, but for me, it was just not knowing who was really mafia and not wanting to randomly cast a vote down, since for me at that point it was pretty much 50 50.

[Kaylee]

Night is my top choice for the obvious. I was orginally leaning town for him but his recent postings reak. The list without a case, and the "if these people are town I hope we lose" post. With how rapidly his train is building I'll hold off a vote for now.

[Nolder]

I never have understood how fence sitting can be considered a legit accusation. At best its a little wifom. If you are town, you have no direct knowledge of alignments. Therefore fence sitting is natural.

 

The wifom part I get cause scum can use fence sitting as a way to hedge.

 

But fence sitting on it's own is not an indication of guilt. I've felt that way many times as town.

I think it's more townie to vote hop than fence sit

[ed2funy]

Honestly, I am getting a town read on Ed right now. No mafia would be so belligerent, accuse a mod-confirmed townie, and do this. Its one of those things where he is so scummy that he has to be town.

1. I am not so scummy.

2. I could be expertly fooling you. But I'm not. I don't think I am acting scummy. I am just saying it how it is, yo. *copies Red's gangs signs*

 

 

 

well at least you acknowledge that. yes, I have been fence-sitting a little, but I have also shown clear opinions in this game as well. The fence sitting has mainly been because I have been confused this game about somethings going on, but that's no excuse. Yes, I have been fence-sitting a little in this game, going to try and get clearer views soon, but I have not been fence-sitting the whole game.

How many times you going to admit to fence-sitting in this post? hahaha

 

 

I never have understood how fence sitting can be considered a legit accusation. At best its a little wifom. If you are town, you have no direct knowledge of alignments. Therefore fence sitting is natural.

 

The wifom part I get cause scum can use fence sitting as a way to hedge.

 

But fence sitting on it's own is not an indication of guilt. I've felt that way many times as town.

 

It's coming across to me as playing a little too careful - trying to play both sides of the fence, so to speak, not being willing to be pinned down to a position.

This. When people accuse of fence-sitting, it is because they think it sounds too intentional.

[RandA lThor]

I never have understood how fence sitting can be considered a legit accusation. At best its a little wifom. If you are town, you have no direct knowledge of alignments. Therefore fence sitting is natural.

 

The wifom part I get cause scum can use fence sitting as a way to hedge.

 

But fence sitting on it's own is not an indication of guilt. I've felt that way many times as town.

I think it's more townie to vote hop than fence sit

 

reasoning?