[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[Red2111]

and my tone right now is reflecting the fact i dont feel well. i'm not meaning to snap at you BG, but frnakly i just dont have the want, or energy for this right now. all i really want, is bed. especially since the bright background of DM isn't doign much for my eye atm.

[bgrishinko]

Fair enough.

 

And You are right, I misspoke that term. Scum = anti-town. I should have said I no longer believe you are mafia.

[Sakaea]

http://timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20121029T13&p0=2440

 

3.5 hours to go guys. Waiting on a couple more NAs. Get 'em in!

[Sakaea]

Night is over. Scene coming.

[Sakaea]

A chilly morning dawns. As the city wakes for the day, a guard goes to wake Ned. There is no answer....when they finally break into his room, he is found, not a mark on his body.....

 

 

John Snow, Eddard Stark, lie detector, town, has been killed.

 

It is now Day 6. With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

[ed2funy]

I saw Ed and thought that I died for a second.

 

Bye John.

[Basel Gill]

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

[Sakaea]

On a completely non-game-related note....

 

 

I JUST GOT A PHONE CALL AND I HAVE A JOB INTERVIEW ON WEDNESDAY FOR AN ON-CALL RADIOLOGIC TECHNOLOGIST POSITION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FIRST JOB INTERVIEW IN ALMOST 2 YEARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Sakaea]

Now back to your regularly scheduled game.

[ed2funy]

Awesome! Congrats, Kae!

In celebration, can I get a day viewing? >.>

[bgrishinko]

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

 

Um..........

 

Didn't EP do that like Day 1-3?

[JenLenaMom]

Congratulations Kae!!!

[michellem]

Congrats Kae! And good luck!

[RandA lThor]

Congratulations Kae! That's great news! Good luck with the interview!!!!!!!! You have to tell us how it went!! And also I am in agreement with BG, why did you do that again basel?

[Gabriel Kross]

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

 

Basel actually blocked nobody.

 

I blocked 2 people last night. Basel and Dice. I pretty much picked a random for the second. However I do not believe basel to be town so blocked him.

[Kaylee]

Congrats Kae!

[RandA lThor]

I blocked Verbal last night. So we know that he wasn't the one to make the kill, even if he is scum.

 

Basel actually blocked nobody.

 

I blocked 2 people last night. Basel and Dice. I pretty much picked a random for the second. However I do not believe basel to be town so blocked him.

 

Ooh, the blocker got blocked!!!!!!!!!!

[ed2funy]

Interesting. Interesting, indeed.

Meanwhile, EP is still Town, y'all.

[dicetosser1]

EP why the change? you have been absolutely adamant about Verb all game and now u dont block him?

[hazelkrs1]

Whelp, I figured it woud be tough for Red to wifom the mafia team on 3 targets, should be easier with only two major ones. And since we got the mafia RB'er yesterday, it doesn't hurt as much to lose one of our investigative roles. Still, losing our LD stinks, cause he was insurance in case the mafia team has a GF.

 

EP why the change? you have been absolutely adamant about Verb all game and now u dont block him?

 

This doesn't really make that much sense. Even if EP still distrusts Verb, it makes a lot more sense to try using his role to see if he can possibly ferret out scum by blocking diff people. Why should him not blocking Verb continuously stand out at all?

 

Plus, are you really trying to soft-fos EP after Ed said he just viewed him last night?

 

I got a couple of biggish posts inc, next one will be my case on Cyan, one after that will be other quotes and thoughts

[dicetosser1]

no im not its just he has gone from dead on verb nobody else but darthe mattered then after the cult comes out he says oh no i doint think he is scum i think he is cult.. now he doesnt block him at all

 

 

i simply wondered has he found something we missed.

[hazelkrs1]

Vote BG. But meh, this means I should probably go read back on Darthe

 

Night, why do you think Darthe is more likely to be scum?

 

This was after Darthe issued his challenge. First off, the emoticon after that sentence saying she needs to go back and look at Darthe kinda stands out to me, and then also note the faint defense of him right after that

 

Well that was interesting. Bah I was so sure BG was mafia

 

This was after Darthe flipped mafia. Big ping, cause just because Darthe flipped mafia doesn't mean BG isn't, it still could have been a gambit between the two (altho I doubt that, so good on them if it was cause it didn't really seem like one).

 

Plus, it's one of those generic "Whoops! Can't believe I was wrong!" statements after the fact, and those are pretty much always scummy

 

Ed, I agree with you about Tress. Her lack of game related posts and general lurkyness for most of this game has been scummy. I haven't played with her before that I remember, so I don't know if this is usually how she plays, but she's made less non spammy posts than I have, which is saying something since I haven't been posting that much

 

For now I will Vote Tress.

 

Meh I wasn't finished >.<

 

As for Razen, I haven't been paying enough attention to his posts to have gotten a read on him so I think Tress is a better option right now.

 

To the bolded: She's admitting that she hasn't been that active, and that inactivity would seem suspicious. So she's basically admitting to sketchy behavior

 

The underlined is a lot more obvious tho, another attempt at trying to defend a mafioso without really defending them.

 

BG's case on Red is pretty convincing. I think for now I will Vote Red, though I suppose I can change my vote to Razen later if it's necessary.

 

What I don't like about this post is her echoing BG's case. I'm just never a fan of that move, it reeks of trying to pawn off blame for someone's lynch to someone else.

 

While we're on the subject tho, I meant to comment about BG still not trusting Red. I don't really see anything there now. Your case on her yesterday def made a good bit of sense, but I was def leaning towards her being mafia over being cult. I don't see her getting recruited to cult cause she was kind of playing sporadically once she replaced back in, and Red usually has a knack for dying early, whether it's by lynch or NK. That doesn't make for a good recruit, CL's usually stay away from higher profile players

 

Mmmmm fine. I think it's highly unlikely that someone would fake claim a major character like that. Unvote.

 

I'd like to hear from Razen though before putting him at what I believe is L-1.

 

Reads as trying to buy time for Razen to come up with some kind of defense or fake claim

 

Oh wait, never mind, Ed was already voting for him.

 

 

Well he hasn't shown up, and I get the feeling he's not going to so I'll just go ahead and hammer.

 

Vote Razen.

 

Seems a lot like a reluctant hammer

 

Vote Cyan

 

Btw, this was just a collection of recent quotes, especially the ones from day 3 when the challenge occured. Didn't feel like going through the whole thread to build a giant case on her, but I think this is enough and she even admitted to not contributing that much to the gameplay. Still, pretty confident that Cyan is scum.

[Gabriel Kross]

EP why the change? you have been absolutely adamant about Verb all game and now u dont block him?

 

You really should start reading the game more closely or taking notes, I stated previously that while I still don't trust Verb, call it stubborness if you will, he isn't a main concern at this point. We know Razen isn't the Mafia killer at this point, I had half expected basel bussed him for townie cred hence the vote on basel. However, your White Knight act for Tress earlier in game and your lack of attention to details in the game is what nudged me towards you over some other people.

[hazelkrs1]

GRRRRRRRRR it did it again!!!!!!

 

 

Gotta start doing my posts on wordpad again, this is getting really frustrating.

 

In a way it's good tho cause I had just gotten to this, and this is semi-important and needs mod verification so it's prob best to put it on it's own:

 

Official Vote Count:

 

BG (4) – Cyan, Rand, Red, Darthe

 

Darthe (7) – NS, BG, EP, Mish, Eds, Songs, peace

 

 

Not voting (10) - Kaylee, John Snow, Verb, JLM, Des, Razen, Basel, dice, Ishy

 

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

 

A Gladiator Challenge has been issued! You must now vote for either BG or Darthe. 2 contestants in the Game of Thrones one-on-one; who will live?

 

 

Eddie, y u no say hi 2 me? *cries*

 

Um, I didn't say investigative roles.

 

No, you said blocking roles, if I recall correctly. But the same logic that Ishy pulled up applies. Enabling a certain type of role is awfully specific - especially when you can impact all players with that said type of role. I don't like it at all. Vote: BG.

 

all right i can agree with those arguments

 

vote BG

 

Official Vote Count:

 

BG (7) – Cyan, Rand, Red, Darthe, Razen, Despo, Ishy

 

Darthe (9) – NS, BG, EP, Mish, Eds, Songs, peace, Basel, dice

 

 

Not voting (4) - Kaylee, John Snow, Verb, JLM

 

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

 

A Gladiator Challenge has been issued! You must now vote for either BG or Darthe. 2 contestants in the Game of Thrones one-on-one; who will live?

 

 

 

WoT was PR'd due to posting after I had said not to, and for then editing that post. That is all. No hidden motive. She was then replaced because she couldn't keep up with the game. Finito.

 

So I was checking the votes, and seeing how they compared to the final vote counts so I could look for people changing their votes and whatnot and found this. On the bottom of page 95, we got the vote count that I quoted up there first, which was the last one before Dice's vote. Dice voted BG, but on the next vote count his vote was counted in the Darthe train, and was never moved. Dice never voted again, or posted again for that matter, before the challenge ended.

 

@Mods: Can we get confirmation on this please? It starts on page 95, and after Dice votes for BG he never switches his vote to Darthe. I doubt this would have kept Darthe from getting hammered, I just wanted to make sure if it was a mistake or not

[hazelkrs1]

As far as what I was originally going to comment on, Dice follows along with Razen's logic onto BG, even though his vote was counted for Darthe.

 

Dice, why wouldn't you have said something if your vote wasn't counted correctly?

 

This pings pretty big to me, both the vote for BG and the fact that he didn't ask the mods for clarification.

 

Then there's the fact that Dice has only contributed 34 posts out of 2,500 total (Yay! I'm post #2,500! ), which is obviously a very small percentage. And he replaced in day 1, so he can't use that excuse for his low post count.

 

Now with his recent faint pushing on EP, I gotta say he's pinging pretty big