DPR Mafia - The Dark Monocle - Game Thread

[LilyElizabeth]

I think I'd shoot Not Bob. He's claimed an easily vetted role, yet hasn't used it?

[John E. Kelley]

Blah. Wrong, wrong, all wrong. Shoot Ape. Do it now. Or if you're a ninja, then stick him. But kill him either way.

[Leelou]

I think you should kill Verbal. Ape offered to jail him while you shoot NotBob. But if it´s Verbal and Ape that are the original mafia? Have JLM, Razen or Leelou claimed any roles? I can´t remember.

 

I claimed a role on my QT and it has been vetted, Meesh has verified that on thread already when Wombat asked.

[Verbal32]

Okay....

 

My candidates for my NK:

 

Ape

Verbal

Not Bob

 

What do others think?

 

I think the 2nd name is wrong. What? You asked!

 

 

 

THE APE SUCKS

 

I'd rather try and be wrong, than wait for someone to lead me around.

 

You should shoot NotBob, I'll jail Verbal.

 

I should have known to back of Wombat when NotBob said "get behind the Ape" its like he was telegraphing that I was pushing for a townie lynch. If there are no conversions tonight, and NotBob isn't the converter, then you'll know Verbal is.

 

No. If you folks want me to vet my role, you can't jail me....cause then I can't vet myself. And scum would be smart to holster and line up yet another lynch. C'mon Ape, you know this. If it means I have to fully reveal at night, then so be it. But a big FOS on you (even after I agreed with you today) for backing me into a corner.

 

 

 

In retrospect, Wombat was town but you are the one who was crowing that he had to be the converter. We agreed with your arguments. Along with our own suspicions of how he had played all game. Don't back pedal now and claim someone else was pushing this lynch, because that is the scummy. You're certain it's Not bob, then jail him let's see how the night plays out.

 

^ This

 

 

I think you should kill Verbal. Ape offered to jail him while you shoot NotBob. But if it´s Verbal and Ape that are the original mafia? Have JLM, Razen or Leelou claimed any roles? I can´t remember.

 

Huh? Weren't you the one saying I could back something up for you? Where's the love now? That's some pretty fast target switching.....

[Verbal32]

I think you should kill Verbal. Ape offered to jail him while you shoot NotBob. But if it´s Verbal and Ape that are the original mafia? Have JLM, Razen or Leelou claimed any roles? I can´t remember.

 

I claimed a role on my QT and it has been vetted, Meesh has verified that on thread already when Wombat asked.

 

I remember the claim, but how was it vetted?

[Leelou]

By a reaction on thread.

[John McClane]

In retrospect, Wombat was town but you are the one who was crowing that he had to be the converter. We agreed with your arguments. Along with our own suspicions of how he had played all game. Don't back pedal now and claim someone else was pushing this lynch, because that is the scummy. You're certain it's Not bob, then jail him let's see how the night plays out.

 

Huh?

 

I'm not back pedalling at all. I own my mistake. I was wrong, Wombat was probably right, there was no conversion N2 because they targeted Crusher. Oh well.

 

I never said I was certain it was Not Bob.

[John McClane]

Hmm, this is harder than I thought. I don't know who is telling the truth and who is lying, but every role except yours is either one I'd like not to risk you blocking, or else not one that you could use to vet.

 

Hmm. There were 2 docs and a CPR doc.

2 cops and a watcher AND a LD....

 

I wonder...if our tracker is town.

 

Oh dear lord, am I an idiot?...I've been reading through one of the QTs again...goodness gracious. Our tracker targed Wombat at least twice, assuming they've been telling the truth, and the first night he was tracked he targeted Key, presumably to see if she was in his guild, since they were both town with no affiliation...(I don't remember what night of the game that would have been)...and then, he was tracked again I think N4, and didn't go anywhere...

 

Why did our tracker not defend Wombat at least against the converter accusation, which was basically the whole case?

 

How did I forget that?

 

 

Yeah, I'd say that it would have been integral if someone that had tracked Wombat could have vetted him during my prolonged casing of him. I would have moved on. Oy.

[John McClane]

Blah. Wrong, wrong, all wrong. Shoot Ape. Do it now. Or if you're a ninja, then stick him. But kill him either way.

 

 

Well, at least I won't be the only one to be wrong. At least I derived my folly from my night action results.

[John McClane]

Okay....

 

My candidates for my NK:

 

Ape

Verbal

Not Bob

 

What do others think?

 

I think the 2nd name is wrong. What? You asked!

 

 

 

THE APE SUCKS

 

I'd rather try and be wrong, than wait for someone to lead me around.

 

You should shoot NotBob, I'll jail Verbal.

 

I should have known to back of Wombat when NotBob said "get behind the Ape" its like he was telegraphing that I was pushing for a townie lynch. If there are no conversions tonight, and NotBob isn't the converter, then you'll know Verbal is.

 

No. If you folks want me to vet my role, you can't jail me....cause then I can't vet myself. And scum would be smart to holster and line up yet another lynch. C'mon Ape, you know this. If it means I have to fully reveal at night, then so be it. But a big FOS on you (even after I agreed with you today) for backing me into a corner.

 

 

 

In retrospect, Wombat was town but you are the one who was crowing that he had to be the converter. We agreed with your arguments. Along with our own suspicions of how he had played all game. Don't back pedal now and claim someone else was pushing this lynch, because that is the scummy. You're certain it's Not bob, then jail him let's see how the night plays out.

 

^ This

 

 

I think you should kill Verbal. Ape offered to jail him while you shoot NotBob. But if it´s Verbal and Ape that are the original mafia? Have JLM, Razen or Leelou claimed any roles? I can´t remember.

 

Huh? Weren't you the one saying I could back something up for you? Where's the love now? That's some pretty fast target switching.....

 

 

You want another night/day to vet a role you are reluctant to reveal to us. But I'm scummy.

[Niniel]

Sorry, meant Pale, not Razen.

 

Verbal - I have stated several times that I´m suspicious of you.

 

Leelou - who do you think Meesh should kill?

 

Actually - Meesh just pick the one you find most suspicious.

[John McClane]

Meesh, tell me who you are going to shoot. I don't want to jail the same person you shoot. Jail = protect/roleblock.

 

Look at my QT, Bob's most recent post - he is definitely scum. So, if you want to shoot him go for it.

 

JLM and Verbal both discouraged me from jailing verbal, making up something about me back-pedalling. I'm not doing that, and they are trying to goad me into jailing NotBob instead. I think its imperative that I jail Verbal. You shoot NotBob.

 

If I had to guess right now, Verbal, JLM, NotBob and maybe Ishamel.

 

Brilliant play to have Ishmael protect Wombat to drive up the suspicion on him.

[John McClane]

Bob is obviously scum.

 

I jail Verbal, and no conversions happen. He's converter, and it vets my role.

 

We lynch Verbal tomorrow. Follow it with JLM.

 

Huzzah!!!

[Leelou]

Leelou - who do you think Meesh should kill?

 

I'll answer shortly, I want to know something first.

 

Meesh, was the tracker active and posting during the Wombat lynch?

[JenLenaMom]

Converter is not the only scum role I think we've come to that consensus. Tracking Womby and him not being the converter don't necessarily correlate.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Meesh, tell me who you are going to shoot. I don't want to jail the same person you shoot. Jail = protect/roleblock.

 

Look at my QT, Bob's most recent post - he is definitely scum. So, if you want to shoot him go for it.

 

JLM and Verbal both discouraged me from jailing verbal, making up something about me back-pedalling. I'm not doing that, and they are trying to goad me into jailing NotBob instead. I think its imperative that I jail Verbal. You shoot NotBob.

 

If I had to guess right now, Verbal, JLM, NotBob and maybe Ishamel.

 

Brilliant play to have Ishmael protect Wombat to drive up the suspicion on him.

 

I'm trying to make sure he knows your the original scum. Only way the Pilot Guild crashes and burns was for a terrorist like yourself to sell us out.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Meant she.

Sorry Meesh.

Ape is still scum and when I flip you'll see that I'm town.

Hopefully, the Ape is dead before I.

After that you can do what you want.

[DPR]

I have corrected the final vote count.

 

NotBob did not vote twice. His vote was on Wombat.

[Niniel]

How many of you have had bulletproof vests? I shot Verbal and it didn't kill him. It was after the meeting with the ghosts. (There is a scene if you want to check it out.) I'm not actually asking you to answer that question but Meesh can check the qts. If more people had them it doesn't mean much but if only Verbal is hard to kill it might mean something. Maybe there have been more scenes that I can't remember right now.

[mmeeshal]

Leelou - who do you think Meesh should kill?

 

I'll answer shortly, I want to know something first.

 

Meesh, was the tracker active and posting during the Wombat lynch?

Yes. And pushed for the lynch, too. And has a crappy defense for not mentioning the tracking. You (the tracker, not Leelou) tracked Wombat on N4--I went back and checked the dates. There WAS a conversion that night. Link to scene here. You didn't even say who you tracked after N4. Also, last night there WAS a conversion, so I dunno what you're on about. The only conversion that didn't happen during the night was the first one, so you have no excuse.

 

Hmm...You know what. I've made my decision. I don't believe the tracker. Should I shoot the tracker or Verbal? I think Verbal's more likely to be the converter. It'd be safer for me to shoot him; if he's not the converter we can lynch the "tracker" tomorrow. Who would you rather jail? I'll name names if you choose to jail the tracker.

[mmeeshal]

Ugh, I'm totally not clarifying who I'm talking to in that post.

 

Very first two sentences are @Leelou.

 

Rest of the first paragraph is @Tracker.

 

Last paragraph is general but partly aimed at the Ape.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I have corrected the final vote count.

 

NotBob did not vote twice. His vote was on Wombat.

 

 

Don't think I voted Wombat.

[John McClane]

Converter is not the only scum role I think we've come to that consensus. Tracking Womby and him not being the converter don't necessarily correlate.

 

 

Make case was built on Wombat being the converter, because of the N2 rolelbock and no conversion. If the tracker could have course corrected me, I'm just sayin... they should have.

[Leelou]

I say Verbal and Ape jails the tracker.

[JenLenaMom]

I didn't track Wombat night 2. and I don't remember seeing a conversion for the scene from last night. A lot went on with me this weekend and I'll admit to skimming all the back and forth crap between Ape and Meesh.

 

Shoot me I don't care. This damn game is giving me a headache anyway.