Blackhoofs Ghost Town Mafia (Advanced) TOWN WIN!!!

[Leyrann]

probably

that doesn't change the fact that we shouldn't be killing anyone over it

if Tina has been acting scummy then fine

make a case and maybe we'll lynch her

because you could just as easily say the deaths were started because Ishy or Min were banished as Tina being resurrected

 

But someone has to kill them.

[Nolder]

maybe?

but not over that

[Blackhoof]

still waiting on some actions

[mmeeshal]

For cereal? XD

 

Get active, people!

 

(before anyone points the "hypocrite" finger, there's a difference between lurking, which is what I'm doing, and inactivity, which would appear to be what some other people are doing)

[SBoydW]

Yeah I think we're all lurking till the slackers with night actions stop slacking.. c'mon people!!!

[amegakure]

Pokes*

[Netbattler11]

*haunts*

[keyholder21]

I don't really see where Tina has been scummy.

 

 

HOWEVER, the timing of her resurrection and then the multiple kills do seem to be very close together. There a spot in between where only one person is killed, but she says she wasn't around that day, so that could be why.

 

 

Interesting how against the Tina vote Nolder is, and how for it SB seems to be. Unless they just like arguing with each other.

 

 

I wonder what happens when we're all ghosts. Then it's banishment instead of lynching, maybe?

[killuliu]

I wonder what happens when we're all ghosts. Then it's banishment instead of lynching, maybe?

 

I'm not quite sure, but I understood that when one of the teams has more than half of the living players, it wins. So if I'm right, then the game can't get into a situation where everyone is dead :)

[Graendals favourite]

One of the teams?

[Leyrann]

Town or Mafia.

[Netbattler11]

Bah, I wish I had kept a log of who died/undied/was banished when. Its not usually that hard with just deaths, but now deaths aren't deaths.

[Netbattler11]

Day One:

Min Lynched

 

Night One:

Min Coronored and Banished

Wombat Ressed

Tina Ressed

Red NKed

Wombat Banished

 

Day Two:

Nolder SKed

Meesh SKed

Kivam Lynched

 

Night Two:

Kivam Ressed and Coronored

Wayward Fool NKed

Red Banished

 

Day Three:

Wombat SKed

BG SKed

Kivam Lynched

 

Night Three:

In Progress

[Leyrann]

Night 2 has two resurrections less than Night one...

 

I wonder if there is maybe a one time role, or if someone just forget to sent in the NA, or if it even is something else...

[Graendals favourite]

but according to the rules, if someone does not send a night action, it will be applied randomly anyway.

[mmeeshal]

That's interesting; I don't recall ever seeing that and I didn't spy it in the rules just now when I looked....

[Leyrann]

but according to the rules, if someone does not send a night action, it will be applied randomly anyway.

 

That's a lie. FoS on you.

[Nolder]

Interesting how against the Tina vote Nolder is, and how for it SB seems to be. Unless they just like arguing with each other.

you know

this keeps happening to me

and I know it's a fairly easy mistake but it gets old after awhile

 

if you look at what I'm saying you can see I'm not really against a Tina lynch

I'm against lynching her based on the theory that because the kills started at the same time she was resurrected it must be her

there are any number of possibilities why those kills started

I'm not saying it's not Tina

but I'd rather lynch her because she's scummy rather than using circumstantial evidence to get her killed

it also worries me how gung ho a few people are about killing her

 

now I will admit in this specific case, as I said, I do have a town read on Tina and I'll get to that at some point but I want to make sure we're clear that I often argue things out of principal regardless of faction

such as when I didn't want to lynch people who were inactive in....I think Lily's magical beings game?

yeah I was town and I think it's bad to lynch inactives but I promise you I'd have said the same stuff as scum (unless I was being lazy)

 

so when you make the accusation that "Nolder is defending X person(s)" sometimes you should take a closer look because often it's not about the people

 

but according to the rules, if someone does not send a night action, it will be applied randomly anyway.

 

That's a lie. FoS on you.

no wait I remember that too

maybe it was something Hoof said but didn't actually include in the rules?

I was pretty sure he said that somewhere

 

edit for blue

[amegakure]

I agree I've seen it to.. ill see if I can find it

[mmeeshal]

That would be great, because it's really not ringing any bells for me. XD

[amegakure]

I looked. But just first few pages didn't see it. But it could b somewhere

[Graendals favourite]

but according to the rules, if someone does not send a night action, it will be applied randomly anyway.

 

That's a lie. FoS on you.

No, well it was not in the rules, but here it is: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/63945-blackhoofs-ghost-town-mafia-advanced/page__view__findpost__p__1980738

 

Also noticed in the rules that the ghosts can't vote or perform night actions. There is no day actions mentioned there, so this is illuminating: anything done at night is done by the living, by day perhaps not so.

[Netbattler11]

Yah, i remember hoof saying that. Might have been when he posted a deadline. He should add it to the rules though.

 

You forgot your blue ley.

[Netbattler11]

Ninjas...

 

And grendael, that's possible, but kind of iffy.

[Graendals favourite]

hmm, I guess so. I've wondered about ghosts sometimes, but yes it is the living who must do what is done. We must pray for tomorrow.