[Advanced] Malazan Mafia - Game On

[Ithillian Turambar]

Also - I vote against double day. Killing me now will harm Town and give the Mafia an easier victory.

[bhskeeper11]

Ithi, I completely disagree.

 

Since we are all vanilla now, I assume that only the mafia has any night action, so they may kill at random. That means losing a townie...always. If we have a second day, the town has the chance to kill a mafia.

 

Every day phase we have is a chance to kill mafia. Not voting for another day phase instead of going into night ONLY helps mafia. That is one more night they have to kill the rest of us.

 

Day phase is the ONLY opportunity for townies to kill mafia now.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Yes, I do see what you are saying but you want to lynch me or Kill and we are NOT mafia. If I thought a real Mafia would get lynched then double day would definitely be worth it. That being said - if you do get a double day and lynch me at least you will be as bloody puzzled as I am with my fellow Town's game playing.

 

I'm really sorry but I'm genuinely trying to protect as many Town People as possible.

[bhskeeper11]

So am I.

 

I am doing what I think is best for town. In no way, shape, or form will going straight to night phase help town.

 

There is a chance that Day lynch results in a mafia kill. There is NO chance that a NK results in a mafia kill.

 

We can't run away from the risk of lynching a townie by giving the mafia a free hit.

[LilyElizabeth]

No worries about me being one vote shy of a lynch. I would have self-voted. There have been people trying really hard to lynch me from the beginning of the game. I was pretty tired of it.

 

 

Go town!

[Christine]

The one big thing that is screaming at me at this point is everyone going after reveals, but Jack said that the mafia has a fake role to claim. Doesn't that mean reveals are pointless?

[WWWwombat]

Character != Role

[Christine]

Fake Character, then.

[WWWwombat]

Yeah they have fake characters but they will at least be forced to claim roles.

[WWWwombat]

Besides, what's the harm in it?

[Amadine]

In Favored Paran, was vanilla town to start and still am vanilla town.

 

I agree Kate is starting to ping, but so is ithi. *waits for day*

[Amadine]

Stupid auto correct Tavore Paran*

[bhskeeper11]

In Favored Paran, was vanilla town to start and still am vanilla town.

 

I agree Kate is starting to ping, but so is ithi. *waits for day*

 

Might I ask what I've done to ping on your radar?

 

I stuck my neck out to say that I thought Ithi was mafia. She was calling out someone who ended up flipping town. I continued to push that Ithi and Kill are mafia, as much for their push on Lily as for their desire to not go into a double day phase.

 

Unless I am completely mistaken, my logic for going into a double day phase vs. going straight to night was sound. So, anyone who wants to go straight into night is handing the mafia an advantage and I wouldn't mind knowing why.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Cos we are not mafia

 

:reasoningends:

[WWWwombat]

2. Tina - claimed Gessler, Tough

3. Ithi - claimed Shadowthrone, Mason

4. Kil - claimed the Rope, Mason

5. Wombat - Blend, 50% chance of avoiding NAs

8. Amadine - claimed Tavore Paran, vanilla

11. Kate - claimed Smiles, vanilla

12. Ishmael

13. Christine

15. Krak - claimed Janath Anar, vanilla

16. Ed - claimed 2-shot vig?

[Ithillian Turambar]

:thinkinginthread:

 

The other thing you might want to consider, if you are determined to lynch either me or Kill, is which one of us to do. We are both the same so it makes no difference really.

 

But Kill has only just joined and I would feel bad about him getting dead so quickly. He's not even really had a chance to play. Mind, I have been playing and following the game more as its been going along - so might be more sensitive to what's been happening and therefore more useful in the rest of the game.

 

I dunno really. The selfish part of me has been enjoying playing this game. I think its the first game I have ever enjoyed and its basically been because I've not been on my own (berf briefly, jack lots and now kill) or on the bad guys team. But Kill deserves a chance to actually play the game for a bit and if you lynch me he will be exonerated. At least till the Mafia NK him the next night to stop you all from having a confirmed Townie in your midst.

 

I think I will leave you all to make your own choice on that though. Obviously I would prefer than neither of us die.

[Krakalakachkn]

Wombat, what are your thoughts on Ithillian/Kill?

[WWWwombat]

I'm not sure yet tbh. Btw Ithi, can you still talk to Kill offthread?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Yes I can, although he's in Finland and its like 2 hours ahead there or something, so I doubt he will be up now. It would be gone 2pm there. It's gone midnight here which is bad enough.

 

:goingtobedreallysoon:

 

Why do you ask?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Although our QT is somewhat barren apart from me chattering at Jack. I've got one post from berf and a few from Kill today. Nothing of any real import though. I've basically been playing the game by myself with Jack making polite conversation, so that I didn't feel too lonely.

[Christine]

I am Icarium, SK.

[John E. Kelley]

2. Tina - claimed Gessler, Tough

3. Ithi - claimed Shadowthrone, Mason

4. Kil - claimed the Rope, Mason

5. Wombat - Blend, 50% chance of avoiding NAs

8. Amadine - claimed Tavore Paran, vanilla

11. Kate - claimed Smiles, vanilla

12. Ishmael

13. Christine

15. Krak - claimed Janath Anar, vanilla

16. Ed - claimed 2-shot vig?

If we're all revealing I'm Bottle, Town. And would love it if someone familiar with the series could tell me his/her story.

[John E. Kelley]

Vanilla, no role btw.

[bhskeeper11]

Ishy, I think there was a conspiracy to give us not cool names. Smiles and Bottle? Really? What were their mothers thinking?

[ed2funy]

I say we extend Day and lynch Kill.

 

They could eaily be a town/mafia partnership.

 

Also I would say 2 or 3 mafia left. 5 or 6 to start off sounds stupid. I can only come up with a few reasons why it might hit 5.