[Basic] Elizabethan Mafia - Game Over

[Red2111]

Mothers milk in a cup!!

 

 

go team!!!! go town!!!!

[Moon Sedai]

Lily, I was thinking something similar.

 

Looking at voting records, the most concrete thing we have, ameg voted vs. innocent princess Red on day one, vs. Sakaea on day 2 (who i'm convinced is innocent because she was my target on night 1 and no one was killed) and the first to vote vs. Kiv on day 3.

 

Waaay a long time ago, in Looney Tunes Mafia, one of our members had us lead a day one lynch vs him.

And it is common for mafia members to distance themselves. especially if they were planning on letting one of them 'take one for the team."

 

Vote Ameg

 

This being said, I still strongly suspect jack, Hoof, Min, and Aemon.

 

Min, Kivam was so picking on you as scum that you might be innocent,

however, I've known mafia members near a lynch to 'narc out' buddies to make them appear innocent later on.

The four of you have been on the same lynches. Hoof didn't vote D3, but all of the rest of you were vs, Kiv.Still reeks of a mafia ploy.

 

And, a bigger question.

 

If red was a mason, who were HER Teammates? Speak up, secret society of goodies.

[Sakaea]

FOS Moon for Mason-fishing. IF the remaining Masons were to reveal, all that does is set targets on their backs for the scum to NK. I'm going to reread the last few pages, then will post with thoughts.

[Sakaea]

Wow, did you... just ADMIT to being scum???

 

I.... don't know what to say.

 

Cool???

 

On re-read, this seems a little bit forced. Possible scum-mate seeing Kiv's reveal, and going WTH just happened?

 

 

I was suspicious of Kiv for his continued linking of me and Min (and now Jack) but this new post from him...well, I'm holding my opinion for now.

 

Again, this seems a bit forced on re-read.

 

 

Vote Min

 

Distancing?

 

 

Okay, now that it's day, here's what I've been thinking...

 

Kivam is a slippery one. Taking what he did at face value, he is sacrificing himself in one game for the greater good of mafia and all that. Okay, maybe. But what if he's up to something more devious? That would be the Kiv I know and love. It could be that I'm overly wary because of how badly he kicked my butt in Eddie's game last year, but I have a thought.

 

What if he went through all that to make Amega LOOK extremely town? What if, in fact, they staged the whole thing? I've done it, and we all know Kivam has. That seems more likely to me than taking him at face value. So, I'm going to vote Amega

 

 

If Amega is lynched and flips town, Lily is next, IMHO. This whole post reads as scum trying to plant a possible gambit idea that didn't really happen. With that in mind, VOTE LILY.

[Tiinker]

Hey guys sorry I've been MIA. I'm in Greece atm and finding internet is actually pretty darn hard. I have to spend my days in starbucks.. I'll be on and off but I'll try get back in the game as soon as I can.

[LilyElizabeth]

FOS Moon for Mason-fishing. IF the remaining Masons were to reveal, all that does is set targets on their backs for the scum to NK. I'm going to reread the last few pages, then will post with thoughts.

 

Even worse, it narrows the pool for scum to find the finder. No, they should not reveal.

[LilyElizabeth]

You guys obviously weren't there the last game I played with Kivam, but he whipped my butt good. I spent the entire game 100% convinced he was town and letting him lead me around. I know what he is capable of. So, I may be overreacting a bit, I admit. But that's what it looks like to me.

[Minuet]

Heck I was thinking gambit too. Thinking we wouldn't think it was one because oh, it would be obvious that Kivam pulls a Kivam gambit on us.

 

Vote Ameg

 

Kivam however pointed at a lot of us, and honestly we can't all be mafia or the game would have ended. I am mad that the mafia killed off Red. She is a good player and it would have been nice to get her take on all of this.

 

Realistically I don't think Lily and Jack are both mafia. With Kivam on the team that is a huge out of balance deal. Mods do the random role assignment, but if it is too over power on the mafia side changes are made for game balance.

[Christine]

Official Vote Count

Amega - 5 - Lily, Jack, Krak, Moon, Min

Lily - 2 - Hoof, Sakaea

Jack - 1 - Aemon

 

Not Voting - 3 - Amega, Tiinker

 

 

With 10 Alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

The Deadline is 9:00 PM EST on Thursday, August 18th.

[amegakure]

hmmm well it looks like im dead and really i cant tell from this bandwagon on whos scum. Im thinking lily is. She says how this intricate plan me and kiv had goes down to make me sound bad. But it could be that she is really doing the gambit and taking the chance to off me. But i dont know it wont work well when i flip town.

[Krakalakachkn]

I don't like this.

 

unvote

[Christine]

Official Vote Count

Amega - 4 - Lily, Jack, Moon, Min

Lily - 2 - Hoof, Sakaea

Jack - 1 - Aemon

 

Not Voting - 3 - Amega, Tiinker, Krak

 

 

With 10 Alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

The Deadline is 9:00 PM EST on Thursday, August 18th.

[amegakure]

you could call this an OMGUS vote and it sorta is but theres also the fact that your attempt just screams "attack while hes down" and im gonna take the chance to vote lily for this and already stated reasons

[aemonkristen]

Am I really the only one that sees Min and Jack as being the scummiest players on the board at the moment? Amazing. I am also cautious of Lily's calling gambit on this as well. Kiv is clever and he has used gambits, but that does not mean that everything he does is a gambit.

[Minuet]

Actually Ameg you gave reason for why you suspect Lily. So, imo it isn't an OMGUS vote.

 

I said over the night why I was going to vote for you today. It isn't that you were the only person, I said the next person. You were the next person.

 

Lily isn't the only one who thinks it could be some kind of gambit. She was the just the first to post about it. So, if you want to bitch and complain about not being the only one who brought up the random lynch, well Lily isn't the only one who brought up the gambit idea.

[amegakure]

either way im going to ignore you as that post had pretty much nothing to do with the game just pretty much you making a jab. and i would like to have fun with everyone in this game as long as can.

 

 

aemon i think youve said this a couple times what is it that you find scummy about them?

[Blackhoof]

True, aemon has offered no real evidence for his claims.

[aemonkristen]

Ameg and Blackhoof, since you are apparently skimming, I'll just quote this for you.

 

@Jack- Mostly it's this:

 

"if someone CC's, wel then we will see what shakes loose." that's a bait Sakea, verbatim how you wrote it. Your inviting a CC to get information. Or to try and lynch our uncountered doc.

 

Since when has saying "if this happens we'll have more to go on" been a bait? Especially if you believe Moon's claim of being the healer and protecting Sakaea (which you apparently do because you unvoted Moon). While it's not enough for me to call you scum outright, it has perked my ears more than a little. The fact that Amega and BG immediately followed your lead is also interesting, though BG pulled his vote off after Kiv pointed out the Moon protecting Sakaea factor.

 

Any other questions?

[Blackhoof]

fair enough.

[amegakure]

second that but i also followed that line of thinking too....hmmmm you mayb right aemon.

[amegakure]

really no posts for 5 hours. well anyway ill be busy for the next couple hours. hopefully there will be some new developments

[LilyElizabeth]

I hope this game isn't stalling. I'll be busy this evening, as well.

[Sedai]

I really see nowhere this can go.

 

Aemon, what if the mafia held their kill to draw out the doc? Then Moon reveals, and basically confirms Sakea. Sakea is far from innocent until a finder views her. We know Kiv was mafia, we know Kiv is devious. I'm saying maybe after Sakea wasn't killed and moon said she protected her, maybe Sakea is scum, and Kiv took what he could and basically confirmed her for the rest of the game, without her actually being confirmed. Her baiting a CC was suspicious and if Moon wouldn't have protected her she probably would have been lynched because of it. Kiv had more to gain by coming forward other then teaching a lesson, or he would have never done it. I'm putting my money on Ameg being a gambit, but I've got my eye on Sakea and Min also.

[Krakalakachkn]

Dammit Kiv!

[Minuet]

Jack you do make some good points. However, I am not scum. I have no idea about you, Lily or Kae. I will say that Ameg has continually proven himself unworthy of continuing in this game.