Wheel of Time Mafia Game Thread

[Adella]

David, if you would have actually read my post about my reasoning for voting you, you would have seen that Red's ounishment from the mod really had nothing to do with my vote. Even without Wombat punishing Red, I'm still inclined to believe her for right now as everything she has said so far is believable. I'm not against taking a second harder look later though.

 

My reasons for voting you were basically that you were twisting things, coming up with very weak reasoning for FOSing people, and because I honestly don't want to lynch Aemon or Red at this point. That leaves you as a very good lynch candidate, and you are doing virtually nothing to convince me otherwise.

 

 

Also, thanks to Aust(?) for the code tip. I wasn't sure if just typing the color would work, I will remember that.

[Moon Sedai]

David, if you would have actually read my post about my reasoning for voting you, you would have seen that Red's ounishment from the mod really had nothing to do with my vote. Even without Wombat punishing Red, I'm still inclined to believe her for right now as everything she has said so far is believable.

 

I agree, Adella. I will also say that I've noticed Red has amazingly accurate scum-dar in past games.

Though I could be proven wrong later, for now, I believe that Red is upright and honest.

[Nynaeve]

Well, I think I'm going to shy away from my habit of voting randomly for the 8th person on the list on day 1... seeing as we're running out of time and a controlled lynch is better than a random one by the mod. I think Aust summed it up pretty well in his post, as far as our choices go, and I'm leaning towards David by that line of thought. So... Unvote... Vote David

 

Also, I have to say that Aust is a very attractive guy, good dresser and he seems to have made some good points so he's got brains. Statistics show that finding a male with all the right parts and a brain to match is rather rare. So you better nab him quick, ladies. And watch out from Quibby... he'd steal him away if you give him half a chance. Greedy bastard... :P

 

 

 

Nyn

[Alanna]

I'm posting from the ereader at work which I just found out I could do. Its kind of hsrd though kol. Anyway unvote vote david. Aust makes a good point that there seems to be little risk in lynching him esp since he's done nothing to defend himself.

[David Hermes]

ok guys. I have 15 votes on me so there are 4 votes till the hammer. So I might as well reveal my power which is very useful.

I am a role-blocker. I can stop any player's night-action that I target.

[David Hermes]

Since I cannot hint my character, you will have to make your own minds up about my alignment.

[dapianoplay3r]

Even if you are a role blocker both Red and aemon's potential powers are more important than yours.

UNVOTE

VOTE DAVID

[David Hermes]

Even if you are a role blocker both Red and aemon's potential powers are more important than yours.

UNVOTE

VOTE DAVID

That's right potential powers. Nothing based on fact, just their convictions. Red's only power is knowing who the true DR is. But what is this idea based on? it's based on red's own words. And anyway, in the series, Moirraine took Rand, Mat and Perrin, as all three were ta'averen. I don't think she knew who of the 3 was the dragon reborn, not until the end of the 1st book when everyone found that Rand was a channeler. So, do you really think that red can magically know who the DR is? I don't think so.

Whereas my role-blocker ability has a tangible and substantial use for the town. I ask you now to honestly and logically weigh up my power and red's power. Who's power is more useful? Finding the DR or stopping any night-action?

[bgrishinko]

ok guys. I have 15 votes on me so there are 4 votes till the hammer. So I might as well reveal my power which is very useful.

I am a role-blocker. I can stop any player's night-action that I target.

 

Pfft... too late for that kind of tactic now.

[David Hermes]

Wait! Red's item has been redistributed. Red became role-less. So it's her item that allowed her to know who the DR is not her role. Since she's role-less and item-less it's less of a waste than lynching a role-blocker, which you have to agree, has far more wight than a role-less player whose power very likely came from her item. So why are you voting me when I'm far more useful. Is there anything here that's logically wrong?

[dapianoplay3r]

dude moiraine will have some sort of cool power and you are also just a potential power since we dont know for sure on you either. And stopping NA is only good when you stop the right NA. If you stopped the healer thats a waste of their action. In most games only the GF can send in the NA so you have to target one player to get the kind of help your promising and Im pretty sure you dont know who they are

[dapianoplay3r]

Maybe she has a power as well

[David Hermes]

Maybe she has a power as well

She lost her item. I mean song's ability depends solely on her item. Trench's curse depends solely on his item. If their item was there what do you think they would be? I think they'd be vanilla townies or normal mafia. I did ask for you to weigh up our powers. Tell me which one is worth more than the other.

[David Hermes]

Maybe she has a power as well

She lost her item. I mean song's ability depends solely on her item. Trench's curse depends solely on his item. If their item was there what do you think they would be? I think they'd be vanilla townies or normal mafia. I did ask for you to weigh up our powers. Tell me which one is worth more than the other.

typo: "if there item wasn't there" it should read.

[dapianoplay3r]

its like three hours to the deadline im not changing my vote

[David Hermes]

its like three hours to the deadline im not changing my vote

Fair enough. I still want my question answered. Who's power is more important, mine or red's? The other you have to consider is whether she still has the power or because we all know for a fact that she doesn't have her item. And my power is not item-based.

[David Hermes]

Dammit typos: should read as "The other thing you have to consider is whether she still has the power or not"

[dapianoplay3r]

Im sure Red must have some sort of power. Her character is too important not to. TBH your power isnt very defining. You could be a solo or mafia or town with it and the way you are acting suggests 1 and 2 rather then 3

[David Hermes]

Im sure Red must have some sort of power. Her character is too important not to. TBH your power isnt very defining. You could be a solo or mafia or town with it and the way you are acting suggests 1 and 2 rather then 3

can you be more specific specific? because all I'm asking is to weigh up our powers (which you haven't done by the way) and make a rational decision. Now you are right that it is close to the deadline but not perilously close. So, fair enough, keep your vote where it is, but for some reason you don't want to admit that a role-blocker certainly has more worth than a power that probably requires an item. Now why is that?

[hotpocket2006]

Wait! Red's item has been redistributed. Red became role-less. So it's her item that allowed her to know who the DR is not her role. Since she's role-less and item-less it's less of a waste than lynching a role-blocker, which you have to agree, has far more wight than a role-less player whose power very likely came from her item. So why are you voting me when I'm far more useful. Is there anything here that's logically wrong?

 

Items and role's are two different thing. Items give you roles, but some people may have a role without an item too.

[dapianoplay3r]

This is an item game and so most of the time everyone will have some kind of power. Your power bugs me cos it will harm the town more than the mafia just by probability (there is more chance of you blocking town since there are more of them). Plus I cant think of a character that would have your ability and be more important than Moiraine.

Now as for your power compared with hers. If she has no power she will still have a bond so two people will die. That also means Lan could have a power and we could lose that.

[Adella]

The mod stated that he took away Reds item AND her action for the night, which implies she had both. David this is not a useful power that you're claiming and like Player(?) said, it could be pretty much any alignment.

 

I could see moraine having a power and an item like her angreal that maybe doubles her power or some such. We also don't know how the mod distributed items, it may have been random for some of them (or all, which is why Song is still on my list, just not at the top) so having an item doesn't say much for whether you have an ability.

[David Hermes]

This is an item game and so most of the time everyone will have some kind of power. Your power bugs me cos it will harm the town more than the mafia just by probability (there is more chance of you blocking town since there are more of them). Plus I cant think of a character that would have your ability and be more important than Moiraine.

Now as for your power compared with hers. If she has no power she will still have a bond so two people will die. That also means Lan could have a power and we could lose that.

Yes that's a possibility. Now it's just depends on who you believe.

[dapianoplay3r]

yes adella(?)

why do i have a question mark?

[Adella]

I put the question mark like that when I'm not 100% sure who said whatever I'm talking about at the time.

 

David you are totally the main point of what Song, Player, and myself just said. You're just digging yourself deeper while you think you're digging yourself out imo.