[Advanced] Ghost in the Shell - MAFIA WIN

[Niniel]

Thought about if it was a good idea to share this or not but here I go.

 

I´m a one time tracker and I chose to track The Laughing Man yesterday to see what would happen. He didn´t visit anyone. It´s a bit confusing to me since that give us no clue to what he actually does in this game. Or maybe he is just so good at hiding himself and I couldn´t see him? In that case I just wasted my track but I thought I would give it a chance. Maybe someone has seen something during the night that could confirm this later or get to learn something that I can´t. (I´m not saying that you should reveal anything right away though.) 

[Killashandra]

That was a good idea even if it did not work Nin.

[Niniel]

One more thing. I feel that Lenlo´s vote on Adam was another "safe" vote after voting TLM. Now he wrote some posts that I thought looked good so I will focus on him when I re-read. Tied to that is DPR. Ed is right about the last game. DPR was mafia with me and he chose a few things to focus on so to look busy and steer the conversation like he wanted. Maybe he is doing it with Lenlo and the TLM talk? I´ve had a town read on DPR so far but I will look at that too. 

[Niniel]

That was a good idea even if it did not work Nin.

 

I guess we will find out later if it was good or not. BTW. I think you forgot me in your list. 

[Niniel]

Oh, and one more thing.

 

Zander - I obviously read that post wrong. You talked about Tigs and not me. Okay. 

[Niniel]

lol And one more thing. DPR forgetting that he got a pic in his PM is hardly  vote worthy. 

[Killashandra]

So I did. Just means you were not currently standing out enough to be off the top of my head. I probably would have had you in the middle but I am really liking your posts right now. I am choosing to trust your claim and call you town for now.

[Killashandra]

Though I dont know if me saying your likely town is going to be good for you. They might try to tinfoil you over it.

[Killashandra]

You are*

[Niniel]

I realise that I won´t have the time or energy to re-read the thread. Will do some isoing instead. Starting with Dice.

 

It´s clear that he is town reading Zander and Lenlo. Dice, are you usually good at reading Lenlo? You said in the beginning of the game that an arguing Lenlo is a townie Lenlo. Is there anything else that tells you that he is town? 

 

It seems that you are town reading DPR. You said that you didn´t think he would be as obvious as mafia. And you told Zander that you would cop him. What is your thoughts about him now? Actually, it would be great to get a list with your reads about all of the players. I like your "tone" in this game and if you are town then I will relay on your reads. (Well, if you are not it would be good to have your thoughts out there anyway.)

 

Are your intentions today to vote Ed? If so, why haven´t you already?

 

You said that you would go after Killa if Adam turned up town but you haven´t. Forgotten about that or simply changed your mind? (And if so, why?)

 

 

Do you still feel like Seph is suspicious? What do yout think about Ed voting him? 

 

 

 

I got a townie feeling from Dice but it would be good to see some answers to these questions. 

[Sooh]

[v]Zander[/v]

 

I'm done.

[dicetosser1]

I realise that I won´t have the time or energy to re-read the thread. Will do some isoing instead. Starting with Dice.

 

It´s clear that he is town reading Zander and Lenlo. Dice, are you usually good at reading Lenlo? You said in the beginning of the game that an arguing Lenlo is a townie Lenlo. Is there anything else that tells you that he is town? 

 

 

im ok at reading len  not great but not bad. hes involved. hes sticking to his guns.

 

 

It seems that you are town reading DPR. You said that you didn´t think he would be as obvious as mafia. And you told Zander that you would cop him. What is your thoughts about him now? Actually, it would be great to get a list with your reads about all of the players. I like your "tone" in this game and if you are town then I will relay on your reads. (Well, if you are not it would be good to have your thoughts out there anyway.)

 

 

i do think hes town but id cop him cause hes good enuff to trick people. i want to see a bit more from him about others then len and ed   he has started with killa so thats good

 

 

 

Are your intentions today to vote Ed? If so, why haven´t you already?

 

 

 

i said id hold off  his reads list puts him on my watch carefully list. i dont have good reasons for sussing him   its just a feeling. so for now i watch

 

 

 

You said that you would go after Killa if Adam turned up town but you haven´t. Forgotten about that or simply changed your mind? (And if so, why?)

 

 

 

combination of forgotten and focussing on ed and tigs  think those two need to be sorted out or its gonna cause a headache later

 

 

 

 

Do you still feel like Seph is suspicious? What do yout think about Ed voting him? 

\

 

 

 

I dont know what to do with seph.  hes not being clear town like he can be. theres just something bugging me there. not really a good enuff answer but its what ive got

 

 

 

 

I got a townie feeling from Dice but it would be good to see some answers to these questions. 

 

 

there you go ninel   im in blue of course.  their probably rubbish answers but it what ive got right now.  im mostly watching and trying to find townies   think that will be easier this game then looking for scum.

 

i need to see more from you tho  ure null for me and thats bad.

[dicetosser1]

[v]Zander[/v]

 

I'm done.

 

sooh  is he scum?  or is that just a  thatdamnedcandian!!! type vote?

[Sooh]

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

I'm done.

 

sooh  is he scum?  or is that just a  thatdamnedcandian!!! type vote?

 

with the amount of refusal to listen to sense and nitpicking at people he has done this game he may very well be scum. If I had a hero shot this game I would definitely shoot here.

 

Also thatdamnedcanadian.

[Sooh]

When your argument is "I refuse to believe you experienced what I did the way you say you did, because I've treated others worse", then I'd say you're picking on and harping on things that are ridiculous.

 

I was attempting to build bridges with that post I made where I explained how I experienced things. Those bridges are well and thoroughly torn down.

[dicetosser1]

When your argument is "I refuse to believe you experienced what I did the way you say you did, because I've treated others worse", then I'd say you're picking on and harping on things that are ridiculous.

 

I was attempting to build bridges with that post I made where I explained how I experienced things. Those bridges are well and thoroughly torn down.

 

tbh  thats pretty typical zander tho    both in mafia and rl

[Niniel]

 

I realise that I won´t have the time or energy to re-read the thread. Will do some isoing instead. Starting with Dice.

 

It´s clear that he is town reading Zander and Lenlo. Dice, are you usually good at reading Lenlo? You said in the beginning of the game that an arguing Lenlo is a townie Lenlo. Is there anything else that tells you that he is town? 

 

 

im ok at reading len  not great but not bad. hes involved. hes sticking to his guns.

 

 

It seems that you are town reading DPR. You said that you didn´t think he would be as obvious as mafia. And you told Zander that you would cop him. What is your thoughts about him now? Actually, it would be great to get a list with your reads about all of the players. I like your "tone" in this game and if you are town then I will relay on your reads. (Well, if you are not it would be good to have your thoughts out there anyway.)

 

 

i do think hes town but id cop him cause hes good enuff to trick people. i want to see a bit more from him about others then len and ed   he has started with killa so thats good

 

 

 

Are your intentions today to vote Ed? If so, why haven´t you already?

 

 

 

i said id hold off  his reads list puts him on my watch carefully list. i dont have good reasons for sussing him   its just a feeling. so for now i watch

 

 

 

You said that you would go after Killa if Adam turned up town but you haven´t. Forgotten about that or simply changed your mind? (And if so, why?)

 

 

 

combination of forgotten and focussing on ed and tigs  think those two need to be sorted out or its gonna cause a headache later

 

 

 

 

Do you still feel like Seph is suspicious? What do yout think about Ed voting him? 

\

 

 

 

I dont know what to do with seph.  hes not being clear town like he can be. theres just something bugging me there. not really a good enuff answer but its what ive got

 

 

 

 

I got a townie feeling from Dice but it would be good to see some answers to these questions. 

 

 

there you go ninel   im in blue of course.  their probably rubbish answers but it what ive got right now.  im mostly watching and trying to find townies   think that will be easier this game then looking for scum.

 

i need to see more from you tho  ure null for me and thats bad.

 

 

Ok. Thanks. So basically you want to focus on Ed and Tigs now. And watch. A little careful. 

[Niniel]

Sooh, I get what you mean. I´ll have him as town for now though. 

[dicetosser1]

yeah i am being careful.  theres a lot of words going in this game and i feel im missing something. its like i can feel it in the back of my head but i cant get it forward.

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

You may post.

 

 

 

Thats my character on the far right. I guess he wont be used in the little post stories until I get lynched or night killed.

 

Pretty cool set up. Nice Flavor.

 

Good job shad_

 

 

DPR I am not claiming anything ... well in my mind claiming vt is worthless. To me it seems the only claims that matter are the ones that could be figured out with out dying first. lol Which is special roles.

 

 

How many mis lynches can you make plus the night kills and still win? Like zander #themathishard

 

 

I remember you saying earlier that you don't have any knowledge of the source material - I'll have to go back and find that to confirm.

 

But if you did say that, how do you know who your character is?

 

I didn't get a pic in my role PM. 

 

I got a pick in miiiiiine.

 

 

I just checked - i stand corrected - I did get a pic.

 

But it was a single person pic - not a group pic. 

 

 

[v] DPR [/v]

 

outted scum is outted imo

 

 

DPR is FROZEN!?!?!!?

 

 

 

This is the kind of posting that rings the Zander alarm for me. 

 

I know you play the spaz - we've covered that. But this turns away from gamesolving and goes down a road where you're creating the narrative instead of reading it.

 

It's the same as what you're doing to Sooh - this will be hard for you to understand while you are channeling Cornholio, but people do actually go to bed sometimes.

 

You want to talk about my pic comment, fine - that's legit. But that ain't what you're doing here.

 

Pic talk incoming. 

[seph]

Ed I really am glad you finally kicked it into gear man.

 

I skimmed through most of this and I know there was questions for me but I'm waiting for nyn to give some comments first.

 

Also I'm pretty sure I'm not voting niniel this game either.

[seph]

If you guys had something you want me to answer please reiterate it, if not I'll get to it before dl.

[Nynaeve]

It won't happen for at least 4 hours. That's when i get home. For now im just peeking in on breaks.

[seph]

No problem nym, I'm taking a nap before Robin get a off and we go shopping

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

 

You may post.

 

 

 

Thats my character on the far right. I guess he wont be used in the little post stories until I get lynched or night killed.

 

Pretty cool set up. Nice Flavor.

 

Good job shad_

 

 

DPR I am not claiming anything ... well in my mind claiming vt is worthless. To me it seems the only claims that matter are the ones that could be figured out with out dying first. lol Which is special roles.

 

 

How many mis lynches can you make plus the night kills and still win? Like zander #themathishard

 

 

I remember you saying earlier that you don't have any knowledge of the source material - I'll have to go back and find that to confirm.

 

But if you did say that, how do you know who your character is?

 

I didn't get a pic in my role PM. 

 

I got a pick in miiiiiine.

 

 

I just checked - i stand corrected - I did get a pic.

 

But it was a single person pic - not a group pic. 

 

 

 

My response to Killa's post previous to this is what prompted her to post the above pic. 

 

When I saw it, the thing that struck me odd was that she had posted the group pic - which I knew I didn't get - and that she pointed out which character was hers, even though it's not labeled. I thought I remembered her saying she wasn't familiar with the source material and it struck me as odd that she'd post the group pic and know which character was hers. I hadn't looked back at my PM since the game started and I don't know the characters either, so I jumped on what I thought was a slip.

 

I was quick to respond, but I shoulda given it a sec and thought it out. 

 

I get that Killa used the pic above to avoid quoting her PM and that the character she talks about is the only one with a beard... 

 

I claimed the mistake. It is what it is. 

 

I still have issues with her confident-yet-unconfident posting style, but that has nothing to do with pics or flavor. Will address along with some fresh takes on D2 after a reread.