Darthe
-
Posts
26834 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by Darthe
-
-
Expand
View from the crows nest:
I feel like some folks came out of the gates a little hot lol. It’s probably enthusiasm, but I can also squint and see motivation to repeat last game’s so-crazy-it-might-just-work magic.
@SinisterDeath you’ve given your reason for prompting discussion but I still have 2 questions:Why not give it a little more time to see if your plan worked before stating what your purpose was? Your admission of your purpose lets the non-participants know your plan and they can slide in with excuses, real or other, nullifying your results?
What’s up with all the italics? I was going to wait to ask but since you are explaining things, what is the purpose of over emphasizing so many points?
This was a nothing-burger to me.
-
Expand
Things are heating up. Interesting to see the sparring going on but cannot make much sense of it yet. Want to wait to see how the early spammers adjust to the more serious tone.
Not making sense of it is good. Do you have any feelings? It’s fine if they’re light or insubstantial.
-
-
-
Expand
Darthe's question....
My response, which is heavy (I totally intended that pun) with sarcasm (it actually saddens me that the art of sarcasm is apparently a long lost talent)
Seriously man, it's on the same page. I'll explain it anyway....
1) Darthe asked a question.
2) I responded that I didn't know but he should ask someone who at least acts like he knows how to play
3) inserted the name of someone with the implication that he didn't know how to play but acted the part..
It was a joke (obviously a very poor joke as you don't usually have to explain them when they're good) in response to someone asking if the joke phase was over.
I had intended to quote it in my response but I keep forgetting that if you merely hit the "quote" button, on mobile at least, you have to click the little bubble on the bottom right of the screen to respond with that quote in the response as opposed to just highlighting the quote and pushing the "quote selected" button which automatically put the selected quote in the post box.
This was intuitive and obvious btw, no clue why it was even a point.
-
Expand
Soft claim. Nice.
Bruh you can count that one as a hard claim
ExpandDarthe clearly flubbed on the unprompted reads.
Was Darthe lying? Or did he just not see DPRs request? I dunno.
I slept on it and still think this is conceptually wrong enough to be wolf motivation. Words have definitions. A 3 player WTL is a different thing than a reads list. EP getting instantly salty about the distinction is a wolf trying to sell a line. These two questions above are somehow worse. vote: SD
ExpandTo me this is weird. You were following last game so I think you know Darthe's work/home schedule. He was constantly late on deadline things and very spotty in the evenings to even do VCs. I'm not sure of DPR'S schedule but I do know he is a busy guy.
Looks like a sketchy reason to shade someone.
Tbh this seemed jokey to me, and I see where it was followed up on. No one would out themselves on page 10 over a thing like this. Hell, the only reason I think EPs or SDs posts are real is because EP has the subtlety and rust of an axe left in the stump and SD is trying to jump on any WIFOM he can find.
ExpandGK's list. Mostly nothing reads which is to be expected. There are a few things that ping.
His enthusiastic comment on Tephulis. Feels like it could be seeing up an "oh I was wrong, silly me" if Tephulis flips mafia.
The Darthe take fells wrong. I don't know why yet. Gonna have to ponder that.
The Tigraine take might be something. Darthe's question about joke phase was to everyone imo. Tigraine said she didn't know and kicked it to Heavy to answer. I need to see if Heavy was active in thread at that time.
If GK is mafia I think his comment on Dice is suspicious.
Cool so Turins town.
-
Expand
why give an easy out?
There's an incredibly easier one which also happens to be the right answer.
-
I promise you do not
- SinisterDeath, Tigraine and ed2funy
-
3
-
If anyone needs that explained I have a handy wiki that'll help.
-
-
Ah I gotcha. A couple issues there. First, I didn't associate a WTL with a full reads list. Second, and more important, that's not the beating the grass DPR was doing that I referred to.
-
Expand
Where did Darthe say he had a question for Heavy, I looked and couldn't find one... I'm now a bit curious on your alignment.
We are in for a long game aren't we?
-
Expand
you lightly paint Teph as sus for seeming a bit more experienced than expected, then toss in a comment about Teph giving a list unprompted, when DPR specifically asked Teph for a list. It felt like you were laying groundwork for a case with a false claim.
Ah, nono. No sus at all, just wariness. He's been watching his spouse play and he sounds not like a noob. Been fooled by new players too many times, acknowledging that I'm not biting on that again to give them free town points is not the same as sussing them.
When did DPR ask for the list? That'd actually take away the bit of cred I was giving. -
OK I think I got it. You're saying DPR asked for a list from someone and I sussed you for DPR not giving a list. I have no idea how you got that from what I said, but it's what it appears you took away.
-
Expand
it wasn't an unprompted reads list DPR literally asked for the list from them and you know this because you commented on me susing DPR for not in turn giving a list. VOTE DARTHE that was a weird move.
I for the life of me can't follow what you're trying to say here.
-
Expand
I was out of options lol after ed ruined claims by the most epic slip ever, my only shot was to hope they wouldn't think I was the bigger threat. Ironically I was gonna target Verbal that night phase and it would've started the next day in the same exact position started the day with. Only difference is, I would've met my win requirement.
Woulda been sick if you pulled it off, but that's the game sometimes.
What are you seeing so far in this one? -
Expand
Nah, I just blame @ed2funy cause that's usually where its deserved.
@Darthe idk, this is only my 2nd game in something like 10 years and I was super busy at the beginning of yours so ask someone who at least acts like they know what they're doing.... @HeavyHalfMoonBlade Darthe has a question for you
Yeah I dunno that claiming 3p was the most +ev play lol
- keyholder21 and Tigraine
-
2
-
Tarot, horoscopes, Myers Briggs, it's so human to want to be seen. I kinda dig gettin the empress tho.
-
Ya'll gotta get with the times, Mudvayne was cool 20 years ago. They still are, but they were too. Saw em in concert once.
Reads are pretty non outside of this page. This isn't sus, but I'ma be wary of Teph. He's brand new but he's been watching his wife's games and clearly has the voice of someone who already know the game, so that's a danger. That said, the excitement to play looks good. Unprompted reads list was a positive surprise as well.
Wes beating the grass is also positive. EP bit instantly, but the meta's so old that I really just wanna sit on that for now.Are we through the joke phase?
-
Expand
If you don’t derail the next 20 pages for setup spec we’re lynching you
- ed2funy and keyholder21
-
2
-
Expand
Are you going to Chris Hemsworth the game?
If by this you mean am I gonna try to be the hero and absolutely die for it…
Yes.
- Tigraine and SinisterDeath
-
2
-
God it’s good to be town again, that was not the way to come back from a multi-year hiatus.
And cabin in the woods imo, best in the genre.
-
🙂 JK good to see you EP
-
Expand
I used to have it say "formerly Eternal Phoenix" under my pfp but I guess that disappeared at some point
Who?
Camp Dreadfall Mafia Game -- GAME OVER -- MAFIA WIN!
in DM Mafia Games
Posted
I don’t agree but this perspective seems hard for a new wolf. +1 point