[Standard] Final Fantasy VII Mafia - Mafia Wins D4

[Pralaya]

Hally ! Where are you?

 

(I feel like a poor boy who got stood up on his date :( .... TWICE !)

[BFG]

Liz: can't see anything scummy in her posting, I just don't think there's anything she couldn't post as mafia either.

 

General impression from Day 1 is that she did more with less than most other people (so disagree somewhat with Cory on his general assessment there )

 

Engagement increased Day 2 in line with the thread. Approach to the game is townie generically (avoiding unhelpful arguments, working with town reads) I just can't say it's alignment indicative.

 

If I have concerns it's with the vote on Csarmi (after town reading him) and how she ended up with Darthe and Alanna as suspects. She picked an arbitrary post about 'no lynching' to pick at with Darthe and then built from there, although I can understand it in context of Darthes posting, and again she was engaging Alanna on a serious note early (asking opinions about Darthe etc). However her read on Darthe developed and she was poking Kat and Sooh so elaborateshruggif

[Nynaeve]

I am being cooperative.

 

*facepalm*

[BFG]

Lol Pral

[Cory Caboose]

Basically how I feel about Liz too BFG

[Cory Caboose]

Her d2 was better than her d1 as well imo

[BFG]

Her d2 was better than her d1 as well imo

Yes

[Lizabeth]

Trying not to get sucked in to playing mafia from work

 

but just wanted to respond to BFG's question about the Csarmi vote to clear things up (for some reason it's not letting me quote - my work computer apparently does not like DM :( )

 

BFG, I voted Csarmi because he was in not in my certain town pile at that point. He hadn't shown up since early D2 and I was the sole vote on Sooh since Cory moved over to Csarmi. So I wanted to build momentum with some kind of wagon before we got to the last few hours of the day.

 

Since he's shown up again, I feel better about him again. And I don't know why Chris keeps missing my vote switches, because I had switched back to Sooh this morning

 

(I love you Chris <3) 

[BFG]

I don't see her on a team with Cory or Sooh. I'd be surprised at Csarmi.

 

Leaves Nyn, Kat, Pral and I have a town read on both Nyn and Pral.

[BFG]

Thanks, as I said I'm not really reason you scummily, just not sure where your town and mafia game differ

[BFG]

And I noted the vote switches :p

[Nynaeve]

Since he's shown up again, I feel better about him again.

 

Can you explain why??

[Clovdyx]

Vote Count!

 

• Sooh - 3 - Nynaeve, Lizabeth, Cory Caboose
  
• Katiora - 2 - BFG, Csarmi
  

 

Day Two ends at 12:30 Eastern time on Tuesday, 11/1.

[Clovdyx]

Ask A Mod!

 

Q: It looks like you made a mis-

A: Site rules prevent me from telling you what I think.

[BFG]

Pral, did you explain what you meant about Sooh and Ironeyes/Darthe?

[Katiora]

I have lost BFG's faith despite not being allowed to pursue any of my suspects rationally when [people tend to just lazily clear me based on whether or not I lynch wolves instead of my posts]

 

Pral and csarmi are lost

 

If there's a villager in Liz/Sooh they are probably lost

 

Sadly Kat and Nyn are the only people that have any faith in my whatsoever and I would think Kat's ??? faith is probably more of a telltale sign she's a wolf anyway so L O L

NOT A WOLF. I have played with you like 3 games and totally thought you were wolf 1 of those for doing the things you're doing now as town. I have also learned from being wolf that if you're a town and can't rely on ANYONE that you completely screw over town. Suspecting everyone is a sure way to lead a mislynch. I HAVE to believe that you and Nyn are town. At least until I have a better option. Otherwise I can be steered by anyone. I just have to trust in my instincts that you are town and hope it doesn't completely screw me over. 

[Katiora]

Okay, it worked!

 

And I have to get to work. I'll be back at end of day.

 

@Kat, did you ever get around to isoing Sooh? What are your current thoughts on Csarmi?

I didn't I had to leave work early for haloween festivities and hers was the longest. I started it but I was so distracted I didn't get to finish it. Hoping to do it this morning

[Katiora]

[v]Kat[/v]

why? 

[Katiora]

 

 

[v]Kat[/v]

Why Kat?

Partially wagons

 

 

I have always thought that to create a wagon was a horrible reason to vote. 

 

oh okay

 

[v]Kat[/v]

This looks scummy. Opportunistic much? 

[Katiora]

 

This leaves a short list. 

 

3. Lizabeth - i don't know. The other game I have played with her I thought she was slightly scummy the whole game and she was town. 

4. Csarmi - don't know what to expect. Never played with before. All of ya'll seem to like his EoD but to  me it's like he came in just in time to stir the pot and create confusion. 

5. Prallia (Pralaya/Hallia) - eh. they haven't posted enough for anything so i'm not sure where to put them. Pral always thinks i'm scummy I usually think he's scummy because normally as inactive as I am I have many more posts than him. I hate his case on Cory. I think it's crazy and very well could be scum trying to push someone he knows could be a danger to him and Hallia when she starts posting. Which brings me to Hallia. I would have thought that she would have posted SOME at night. But she hasn't. The last time Pral had a partner that pretty much had radio silence (granted with a good excuse) he ran that game. I would remember. I was the partner. And he's one heck of a wolf. I'd like to hear more from him with better reasoning than ONE game maybe a year ago.

6. BFG - I'm not sure what to think of BFG. I almost feel like she knows too much. Her read on me early game... I don't know where she got it from but I know it's right. 

7. Sooh - I'm fixin to do an ISO of. She's been fairly active in the game. But I think that Cory has had some valid points on her. 

 

So right now if i had to choose 3 i'd probably go Csarmi, Prallia, Sooh, in no particular order. But i'm about to ISO all three of those and see what I come up with. shouldn't take me long with the first two anyway. 

 

I don't like this list by Kat specially because she is dithering so much on her reads. There is no strong stance on anyone.

 

For example, Her read on me is more on my push on Cory. But, the whole tone of it is not to take a stance on it but pushing the fact that I could be scum who is trying to get Cory killed. The lack of that stance is what I don't like. And, this extends to her reads on all others too.

 

yes and everyone else's stances are firm at that point of the game as well. We all know who the wolves are  

[Katiora]

And after that.. I would feel good about a Csarmi/Pral vote. Not as sure about Sooh but I'm about to ISO her so we shall see. 

[BFG]

Out for an hour, will be back soon

 

Looking forward to what you have Kat :)

[BFG]

Kat, what's different between Csarmis voting today and yesterday?

[Cory Caboose]

[v]Kat[/v]

[Katiora]

[v]Kat[/v]

Why?

Kat, what's different between Csarmis voting today and yesterday?

D1 he came in last minute and i thought he had some confusion which would have been warranted. Today it's like he doesn't care as much. At least that's the attitude I get form it. And when someone calls him out on it he does a "Seriously!?" type post and people drop it. I mean, you gave almost no reason for voting me besides to create a train and he just jumps on. He's sheeped you the entire game. It's a BAD look.