[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[Sooh]

 

had a quick look on Dice in the last couple of games I was in and it seems to me Dice as wolf, comments more about people rather than to them, and doesn't say so much when he posts, and more fluff posts. So this would make me lean town on his posts here.

only going off of ME but i agree with this.  also seems more invested this game as well imo.

 

Kk.. I shall give him a pass for now. I reserve the right to tinfoil later

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

 

Peeked Darthe N0.

 

Result:

 

 

 

 

 

vote Durin

 

 

@Dice Why did you vote for that?

 

u know what that opening was so bad I'm going to vote her and throw away the key.

 

[v]Heart[/v] -_-

 

I agree that she had a bad opening (as does Darthe, apparently) but I don't think it's wolfy. From what I've seen from Heart so far, this is typical her.

 

 

I think Seph emphasizing that his vote on page 4 was serious is a little... awkward.  That's all I've got so far, and it might have been a joke that went wooosh.

Shad I am just trying to provide cover if there is a seer. I know a lot of people don't do it, but I find it fun and I think it helps me play better.

 

 

@Seph That is not how you seer cover. If you are actually going to provide cover, you make it believable. Don't peek more than one person, and DON'T say you are providing cover. It's obvious now that you aren't.

 

 

 

Just checking in until after work, obviously I need to [v]Hallia[/v]

 

 

Wolfy

 

 

 

 

 

Hey all.

 

I require one less vote to be lynched (Hated). Should be fun :)

CAn we prove your claim?

this is not serious right?

 

 

 

Wolfy

 

 

 

 

Seph I meant your post as a whole.

 

I'm gonna ride you hard this game. No freebies like last time and I haven't even decided what I think your alignment is yet

Something not right about this post. I'm not sure what yet. I'm tired and will be off to sleep soon. Maybe I'll figure it out in the morning.

 

 

 

Wolfy

 

 

@Wombat Could we possibly get some insight as to WHY these are wolfy? I've seen you do this as wolf, and I don't like it. I also don't see anything wrong with these posts myself.

 

Good morning everyone. 

 

You were busy last night!

 

Going to pull a Heart and tell you I'll catch up after work. See you then!

 

I don't like this post. If you don't have time to read, don't check in. And I REALLY don't like the bolded. Feels like you're buddying up to her.

 

Wombat says

This conversation the wolf air is not it ?

 

Csarmi

I do not know

 

Thanks for making me have to look that up........

 

FYI, If anyone posts in non-english, expect me to ignore you. I didn't even bother looking up the translations to what you guys said.

 

 

[v]Wombo[/v]

 

I wanna hear what you have to say. Your post is what stuck out the most so far, so you get my vote.

re.

 

 

Is this the support for your switch?  If so, this Eldrick post comes before you stated he was null. 

 

???

 

 

 I've been rereading the thread more carefully.

[Shad_]

 

That was unexpected and possibly out of character.

 

I will never make a post in-game for the purpose of insulting someone. I might insult people to get what I want. Does that make sense? If it's pretty clear that I think you're town and I take a cheap shot at you, the shot's probably aimed at other targets.

 

Ok Shad I have been giving you a town read so far but I wanna try and clear you if possible,  The first part will you elaborate on this for me and explain how you came to this.  Also be careful who you insult and why,  That kinda of stuff can backfire especially on a new player who gets a lot of flack for it and can't clearly and concisely defend themselves properly.

 

 

How can I put this concisely?  Darthe is a hard read and I've learned to not clear or condemn him for statements that I would find revealing coming from other players, but if Darthe is wolf I don't believe his honest assessment of Eldrick was written for cover.

[Zander?]

 

 

That was unexpected and possibly out of character.

 

I will never make a post in-game for the purpose of insulting someone. I might insult people to get what I want. Does that make sense? If it's pretty clear that I think you're town and I take a cheap shot at you, the shot's probably aimed at other targets.

 

Ok Shad I have been giving you a town read so far but I wanna try and clear you if possible,  The first part will you elaborate on this for me and explain how you came to this.  Also be careful who you insult and why,  That kinda of stuff can backfire especially on a new player who gets a lot of flack for it and can't clearly and concisely defend themselves properly.

 

 

How can I put this concisely?  Darthe is a hard read and I've learned to not clear or condemn him for statements that I would find revealing coming from other players, but if Darthe is wolf I don't believe his honest assessment of Eldrick was written for cover.

 

 

i can see where your coming from there.

 

also something to note dont vig Darthe day 1 as one of your top town reads after a Darthe-esque move and then clear yourself completely town,

[Sooh]

Shad – Shad is a thoughtful player who has reasonable reasons for all his reads. He makes a lot of sense in what he does, and he doesn't have much meta to go on yet, so his reads are pure. I can't see him as scum when his reads and his thoughts are so well explained. He seems a lot like his previous game. I like him as towny so far. 

 

WomboCombo – Difficult to pin this hydra down. Wombat is a bit all over the place with his accusations of people being wolfy and AJ seems very focused on Seph for a long while. They do give opinions on other people, and I can see why their vote hasn't changed.  Nullish to me at the moment. 

 

I don't know how long I'll be here for today, so I'm going to [v]Seph[/v].

 

If anything changes before EOD I'm not entirely sure I'll be able to change my vote. EOD is 4am my time. I should still be here another couple of hours though. 

[Talya]

Sooh, we still have over a day left, it will be in the early hours of Sat morning for us.

[seph]

Ok what I find funny is people are still talking about the aj tunneling thing. That stopped pretty early on.

 

Sooh would you explain what you thought of shad vote on me please?

[seph]

Town

2. Durin I like darthes overall gameplay besides a couple of points involving sili, and a couple of random comments.

3. Alannalynn have liked her overall gameplay

8. Zander. Slight town, however why he is pushing the thread his vote is just sitting on me. He is engaging but not pushing anyone who might be a wolf.

9. Eldrick only worry was the role fish line, but I believe he is town and trust him

11. Yates came in strong, I find it funny after he posts darthe unvotes after calling out a so called scummy slip of mine. Then shad unvotes. Have him as a strong town currently. Trying to not let his views on me make my decision biased

13. Dice his emotion in his responses is what I really like. One of my stronger town reads. I don't see him letting go until.you prove him wrong.

17. WomboCombo slight town but I feel comfortable with this slot here

18. Csarmi4. Again one of my stronger town reads.

These are in no particular order but o feel like csarmi eld and alanna are my strongest town reads.

 

Sili I am unsure of, he defended me early (I see town sili pressuring me there) he tells aj he is going after the wrong guy like he knows (maybe he felt bad for me) and flip flops often. At one point it looked like he was trying to get around his defense of me to place a vote, then goes back to putting me in a town list....I am currently going to put him as slight town, I am going with he is trying to get a feel on me.

 

Thaneballs32 thane seemed nervous when he was asked about his reads. Just seemed off because he needed to talk to the hydra half you guys can have different reads.

5. NotBob your voting because my vote on shad? Your vote seems lazy and a placeholder vote

6. Leelou have a hard time with leelou

7. Sooh (Mentored by Pizza) I am going back and fourth, I will need to iso but disliked some of her last posts.

10. Talya I suck at reading tayla, but she doesn't feel like the towny she was last game.

12. Mawthex just coming into the game need more

 

14. Aiel <3

15. Shad (BFG)

16. Seph

[Sooh]

Sooh, we still have over a day left, it will be in the early hours of Sat morning for us.

Oh! You're absolutely right! That's good. Maybe I'll even be able to be here then!

 

Seph, I'll look at the circumstances around his vote and get back to you.

[seph]

Oops missed some

Heart, I think people need to wait for her before casting judgement. From what I have seen/heard her town and wolf games are not that similar

 

Shad/ still nothing I like from him, I dislike his vote and unvote after yates comes in. Just because I have 1 towny response doesn't erase my previous comments. I need to re read his interaction with others.

[Shad_]

Oops missed some

Heart, I think people need to wait for her before casting judgement. From what I have seen/heard her town and wolf games are not that similar

 

Shad/ still nothing I like from him, I dislike his vote and unvote after yates comes in. Just because I have 1 towny response doesn't erase my previous comments. I need to re read his interaction with others.

 

[seph]

Shad it is something on my mind. I know you unvoted because of the response.

It is me tinfoiling

[Verbal32]

 I've been rereading the thread more carefully.

 

I snipped out the rest of the MQ, but dude.....I'm completely lost on what the hell you're saying here.  I showed you that you said Eldrick was null, asked me why I said villager, and then I explained and you later had him as a ~strong village read.  Ok, but then I asked if my explanation made you change your mind, and you mentioned a post that did it, and then quoted it.

 

I then pointed out this post came before you noted Eldrick as null, and your answer is the above.  Suffice to say I have no freakin' clue what you're trying to do here, and it frustrates me.  I've been getting used to thinking you're a villager when I can understand you.......and I thought I was understanding you up through this instance.

 

So please help me here.  I think you're the villager I've been reading you as, but you need to help me get over this hump.  Help me Sili-Q, you're my only hope.

 

>_>

<_<

 

 

 

 

c wut i did thar?

[Sooh]

Ok what I find funny is people are still talking about the aj tunneling thing. That stopped pretty early on.

 

Sooh would you explain what you thought of shad vote on me please?

It seems to me like Shad's initial vote was to see how you would react and make his mind up from that. He must have seen things he liked about you since, seeing as he unvoted you. I don't really understand what you're getting at in your read of Shad, which he has already pointed out. 

[Verbal32]

Shad it is something on my mind. I know you unvoted because of the response.

It is me tinfoiling

 

How so?  Sounds like you are saying you read him as potential wolf and that hasn't changed....so how could you be tinfoiling, then?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Right now If i moved my vote its be going to Seph.

 

 

 

 

 

Peeked Darthe N0.

Result:

 

 

 

 

vote Durin

Villager.

[v] dice [/v] why do you think that aj?

 

 

This stood out to me. He votes me but questions AJ over his read of me. Doesnt ask anything about my vote.

 

Ther rest of his play during that time was just downright scummy as well

 

Agree with this observation.

 

 

 

Town

2. Durin I like darthes overall gameplay besides a couple of points involving sili, and a couple of random comments.

3. Alannalynn have liked her overall gameplay

8. Zander. Slight town, however why he is pushing the thread his vote is just sitting on me. He is engaging but not pushing anyone who might be a wolf.

9. Eldrick only worry was the role fish line, but I believe he is town and trust him

11. Yates came in strong, I find it funny after he posts darthe unvotes after calling out a so called scummy slip of mine. Then shad unvotes. Have him as a strong town currently. Trying to not let his views on me make my decision biased

13. Dice his emotion in his responses is what I really like. One of my stronger town reads. I don't see him letting go until.you prove him wrong.

17. WomboCombo slight town but I feel comfortable with this slot here

18. Csarmi4. Again one of my stronger town reads.

These are in no particular order but o feel like csarmi eld and alanna are my strongest town reads.

 

Sili I am unsure of, he defended me early (I see town sili pressuring me there) he tells aj he is going after the wrong guy like he knows (maybe he felt bad for me) and flip flops often. At one point it looked like he was trying to get around his defense of me to place a vote, then goes back to putting me in a town list....I am currently going to put him as slight town, I am going with he is trying to get a feel on me.

 

Thaneballs32 thane seemed nervous when he was asked about his reads. Just seemed off because he needed to talk to the hydra half you guys can have different reads.

5. NotBob your voting because my vote on shad? Your vote seems lazy and a placeholder vote

6. Leelou have a hard time with leelou

7. Sooh (Mentored by Pizza) I am going back and fourth, I will need to iso but disliked some of her last posts.

10. Talya I suck at reading tayla, but she doesn't feel like the towny she was last game.

12. Mawthex just coming into the game need more

 

14. Aiel <3

15. Shad (BFG)

16. Seph

 

Because of the vote on Dice.  No reason, no evidence and then directing a question to AJ.  

 

What was the purpose in that post?

[seph]

On the idea verbal, not on his alignment.

 

Look at when yates first post. Pretty sure he was the only one to agree with me on shad vote.

 

Shorty after darthe and him unvote.

[seph]

Because I was arguing to aj about the situation. The vote was simply because dice voted durin

[seph]

The purpose was to see how aj responded, aj is usually a good reader of dice, and it helps me with alignment on both of them

[Talya]

Rereading today something pinged me about Zander. His posts seem very "careful" for want of a better word.

 

He has been fixated on CS, in fact over 12 posts going on about his claim, how it could be mafia claim, etc. mentioning a couple of times, but this seems OTT

 

There seems to be a this need for reassurance, and buddying, at least that's how I feel.

 

 

Sooh when u are caught up tell me what you think of Zander so far.

 

what do you think of me this far?

 

 

 

*snip*

 

could we be mindmelding? #FullZanDarther??

 

 

 

Yates can see into my very soul he knows me so well!!!

 

Yates I love you!!!!

 

 

*snip*

 

 

@ Sili am i reading seph wrong?

 

His read list, he has done a few of these, this was the fourth he did yesterday. There has been a progression on each read, things added as the day has gone, which is good. It feels very staged? he hasn't changed on Seph, in fact keeps asking everyone what they think on him, (or Cs). Once in the list, no one seems to move (except CS who went from slight wolf to Null). It all seems careful and precise.

 

Take Two-  (I forgot some of the reads I had)

 

Town Reads-

 

Sili- like the reasoning, not jumping on things.  seems to be driving to game solve

eldrick- liking his posts.  he's engaging and asking great questions and making good observations

alanna- still liking alanna nothings changed

shad- like his interaction with seph.  hes not afraid to post his thoughts and go for broke.

 

Slight Town Reads-

 

Durin- Were seeming to agree on a fair bit.

Yates- Coming in pretty strong and trying to help the game move along.

Talya- Have had no probs thus far with her posts.

Dice- he's more engaging then when he was wolf in last game. 

 

Null-

Sooh- Been wrong on her every game thus far.  reserving judgement till later.

Csarmi- Trending up a little for me.

Thaneballs32-  need to look over these

WomboCombo-  not a fan of the early aggression but that doesn't make them scummy

 

Slight Wolf Lean-

 

Leelou- Looking back not of a big fan of the jumping AH and Sooh early.

 

 

Wolf-

 

seph.- already went into this

 

Need to see a lot more from:

 

Mawt

AH

 

 

His post I quoted earlier about Sili to ISO seph again. He answered that fine, but the bit about getting Sili to read it and change his mind also struck me as odd. i' not sure if I would put him above AWombyJ on my list, I need to go over their posts again

[WWWwombat]

Talya, what makes you think we don't want Seph lynched?

[WWWwombat]

Shad – Shad is a thoughtful player who has reasonable reasons for all his reads. He makes a lot of sense in what he does, and he doesn't have much meta to go on yet, so his reads are pure. I can't see him as scum when his reads and his thoughts are so well explained. He seems a lot like his previous game. I like him as towny so far. 

 

WomboCombo – Difficult to pin this hydra down. Wombat is a bit all over the place with his accusations of people being wolfy and AJ seems very focused on Seph for a long while. They do give opinions on other people, and I can see why their vote hasn't changed.  Nullish to me at the moment. 

 

I don't know how long I'll be here for today, so I'm going to [v]Seph[/v].

 

If anything changes before EOD I'm not entirely sure I'll be able to change my vote. EOD is 4am my time. I should still be here another couple of hours though. 

 

Sooh gets town points for reading the thread.

 

 

Town

2. Durin I like darthes overall gameplay besides a couple of points involving sili, and a couple of random comments.

3. Alannalynn have liked her overall gameplay

8. Zander. Slight town, however why he is pushing the thread his vote is just sitting on me. He is engaging but not pushing anyone who might be a wolf.

9. Eldrick only worry was the role fish line, but I believe he is town and trust him

11. Yates came in strong, I find it funny after he posts darthe unvotes after calling out a so called scummy slip of mine. Then shad unvotes. Have him as a strong town currently. Trying to not let his views on me make my decision biased

13. Dice his emotion in his responses is what I really like. One of my stronger town reads. I don't see him letting go until.you prove him wrong.

17. WomboCombo slight town but I feel comfortable with this slot here

18. Csarmi4. Again one of my stronger town reads.

These are in no particular order but o feel like csarmi eld and alanna are my strongest town reads.

 

Sili I am unsure of, he defended me early (I see town sili pressuring me there) he tells aj he is going after the wrong guy like he knows (maybe he felt bad for me) and flip flops often. At one point it looked like he was trying to get around his defense of me to place a vote, then goes back to putting me in a town list....I am currently going to put him as slight town, I am going with he is trying to get a feel on me.

 

Thaneballs32 thane seemed nervous when he was asked about his reads. Just seemed off because he needed to talk to the hydra half you guys can have different reads.

5. NotBob your voting because my vote on shad? Your vote seems lazy and a placeholder vote

6. Leelou have a hard time with leelou

7. Sooh (Mentored by Pizza) I am going back and fourth, I will need to iso but disliked some of her last posts.

10. Talya I suck at reading tayla, but she doesn't feel like the towny she was last game.

12. Mawthex just coming into the game need more

 

14. Aiel <3

15. Shad (BFG)

16. Seph

 

Why does this list post not have any scum reads?

[seph]

I have it as town and not town verbal

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Because I was arguing to aj about the situation. The vote was simply because dice voted durin

 

Why are you protecting Durin?

[Sooh]

I may read the thread, but knowing what day it is is apparently too much to ask...