Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[alannalynn]

Nope, still feel like AH is the way to go.

I'm willing to go this way later, if you're sure about it. I want to hear from more people first though

[alannalynn]

43 pages is a lot of work. I generally like to ISO and if I see something I remember sticking out to me, I'll click the link and read it in context to get a better idea of what was happening

[Talya]

Just doing Hally: (thanks to Laine for doing the Hally bit earlier, helped when reading this)

 

guess my poe is

 

not bob

AH

Laine

 

 

I would agree with that list Sili

 

Here Hally agrees with sili on his list.

And yet looking at the posts Laine quoted, she thought Laine was firm town, why now does Laine drop down her list so quickly? NotBob she has said before (but no reasons), AH she had as Null.

[alannalynn]

I feel like it'll be some great mystery we'll never solve as to why Hallia had NB at the bottom of her list all game but never voted him nor pushed a lynch haha.

 

Good point though Talya, I didn't catch that before

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Choose one and I will stick it to help, lol.

 

the good thing about people who don't post much is their ISO is on one page, lol

Alanna unless Alanna is playing, and then Laine? This is why I had a nickname in the first dang place

 

I'm going to be honest. I think this is hallia's town game.

I'm not seeing it. She's done nothing for town this game.

 

Hence it's her town game. The wolf we're looking for is quietly trying to sway the wagons day 2 and 3, 90% of the time, not a person who doesn't care what other people think of her or her reads.

[Sili Quirrels]

Just doing Hally: (thanks to Laine for doing the Hally bit earlier, helped when reading this)

 

guess my poe is

 

not bob

AH

Laine

 

 

I would agree with that list Sili

 

Here Hally agrees with sili on his list.

And yet looking at the posts Laine quoted, she thought Laine was firm town, why now does Laine drop down her list so quickly? NotBob she has said before (but no reasons), AH she had as Null.

She changed her mind

[Sili Quirrels]

43 pages is a lot of work. I generally like to ISO and if I see something I remember sticking out to me, I'll click the link and read it in context to get a better idea of what was happening

The other game you were in was 40 pages after day 1, how did you cope  D=

[alannalynn]

I may have to concede to your point. I could almost policy lynch her. Ugh. Unvote

 

But, we are doing good right now, if we mislynch at this point, it wouldn't hurt that bad. Though, I'd really like to get this game over, I feel like this and the other one I'm in are dragging.

[alannalynn]

 

43 pages is a lot of work. I generally like to ISO and if I see something I remember sticking out to me, I'll click the link and read it in context to get a better idea of what was happening

The other game you were in was 40 pages after day 1, how did you cope  D=

 

Barely. I'm pretty sure I was in over my head for my first game back.

[Sili Quirrels]

I may have to concede to your point. I could almost policy lynch her. Ugh. Unvote

 

But, we are doing good right now, if we mislynch at this point, it wouldn't hurt that bad. Though, I'd really like to get this game over, I feel like this and the other one I'm in are dragging.

I think it's important if we do mislynch, we mislynch the right person *nods*

[alannalynn]

Sili, when did you become the reasonable one?

[Talya]

I know sili, it's frustraing when you get nothing from her.

 

Darthe makes a point earlier when he said that Hallia was the competing train with Sooh, I can see that point.

 

 

 

Choose one and I will stick it to help, lol.

 

the good thing about people who don't post much is their ISO is on one page, lol

Alanna unless Alanna is playing, and then Laine? This is why I had a nickname in the first dang place

 

I'm going to be honest. I think this is hallia's town game.

I'm not seeing it. She's done nothing for town this game.

 

Hence it's her town game. The wolf we're looking for is quietly trying to sway the wagons day 2 and 3, 90% of the time, not a person who doesn't care what other people think of her or her reads.

 

 

This is where I think you have a good point as well...I guess I don't like the play style, as I don't think it is very pro town, but not a reason to vote now.

[Talya]

I think now Hally has been ISO'd to death.

[Talya]

Those not on Dae lynch: Dae, Heart, Hally, Darthe, Sooh

 

Those not on Sooh Lynch: Notbob, Heart, Sooh, sili

 

Heart wasn't on either.

 

Sili and Nonbob were on the Dae but not sooh.

 

I need to check, but I think sili was on the Dae lynch early then took his vote off and put it on again later.

 

I can see wolves going for Dae lynching, but they would not want to lose Sooh, so those on Hally's train look more suspicious.

 

From that NotBob and Heart look worse.

 

does anyone know a way I can search for the voting tags on this thread?

[Leelou]

Vote Count
 
NO ONE
 
With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. 
 
Deadline - Tuesday 10 am EDT

[Talya]

Sooh's first comment on Heart

 

*** SNIP***

 

Heart feels a bit like she did in Middle Earth when she was mafia. I can't really pinpoint why. It's more a feeling right now. 

 

 

 

 

 

Shad - He defends Eldrick during D1. No clear TMI, but enough hinting for it to be strange. He also seems to have extensive knowledge about the game for only having read a bit of House of Cards. That's very impressive to pick up on all that from only reading one game, if that's indeed what you did. He had a semi-strange post around EOD 1 when he felt "really, really awesome right now, even though we're losing." 

 

He has a couple of posts whick I find strange. He seems to be hinting at a wolf meta, even though he says this is his first game. It just pings me to have such a clear idea about how you would behave in a situation you haven't been in. 

 

I find myself leaning mafia on him. 

 

***SNIP***

 

Hallia has barely made any reads or contributed to anything yet. Scum lean.

 

***SNIP***

 

 

Heart - She reads 2/3 of the players scummy, which is a little strange, then again, as I'm writing this I realize that I also probably have too many scum reads, so maybe she's paranoid town too. Null for now.

 

***SNIP***

 

Notbob - I have said it before and I'll say it again. I'm having issues reading him. He DOES seem to be prodding people to make reads, but there's little follow up. Make it a null for now.

 

 

 

Here we have her views on Hally, Notbob and Heart.

 

TL;DR

 

Shad - scum lean

 

Dae - null/scum lean

 

Alannalynn - town lean

 

Verb - town lean.

 

Hallia - scum lean.

 

Darthe - scum lean

 

Heart - null

 

Sili - town lean

 

Talya - null

 

Notbob - null

 

Her list

 

I'm finding Hally going up in my list as I read this. She had both Notbob and Heart as Null. Although her first thought was that Heart played like she did in Middle Earth game and then she gives her a Null later. Shad she has a wolf, but I'm not so sure now.

 

I will change my bottom two to Notbob and Heart. I think that Heart should go before notbob.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Should have known.

 

Vote Shad

[Shad_]

^ case closed

[Aiel Heart]

*Sigh* Sili, you're wrong.

 

Lemme go eat breakfast and then I'll post thoughts on things

[Shad_]

If NotBob is scum, the only chance he has is to get some people who were off the radar lynched, because at the current rate it's still him or AH next on the chopping block.  I'm not ready to vote Hallia or Laine yet and you shouldn't be either.  Town is acting suspicious of me all of a sudden so I'm his best bet.

 

Do you really still need help figuring me out?  Sooh is a great place to start.  Notice how she tries to fluff the hell out of me when she thinks she can get a Darthe train going D2 and when I jump all over her D3.  She misread my reasons for supporting Eldrick and targeting Darthe as sympathy/omgus.  She was wrong.  If I voted for people based on how they felt about me god knows I wouldn't have maintained Laine as v all game.  I nailed Sooh's game plan in post #564 when Talya was the only other vote on her and I could have bumped AH to L-2 instead.

 

[v]NotBob[/v] because if he can't give a reason at this point it's because he doesn't have one.

[Hallia]

I will agree and also go with

 

Vote: NotBob

 

Because I'm 90% sure it's between him and AH

[Clovdyx]

Vote Count
 
Shad - 1 - Notbob
Notbob - 2 - Shad, Hallia
 

With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.  Deadline is 10 am Eastern on Tuesday.

[Darthe]

Do remember to not get too close to a hammer folks.

 

Hally is town, we can stop worrying there. Today is ah/notbob and if it doesn't work tomorrow is the living one and shad

[Darthe]

BTW ty doctor

[Darthe]

Oh I'll toss this out, unless the doctor self protected the doc should reveal.

 

If the doc reveals the cop should reveal. Unless the cop has been really bad that gives us at least two views from the cop and hopefully only one overlap with the doc for a total of four clear people, maybe six at best, lynch happens, doc protects cop, cop Views someone, doc dies, we go into tomorrow with six alive and four confirmed mechanically locking the game.

 

But that's only if the cop didn't view the doc. If the doc self protected still prob needs to reveal today.

 

It's all optimal so we don't lose that info