A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Darthe]

Darthe - Eru, Vt has been modkilled

[Hallia]

1: I think Yates is as full of crap as a Christmas turkey

2: there is no way someone got a guilty on me, so IF he's tellin the truth

 

[unvote]

[v] Thane [/v]

Whether Yates is or is not lying, I am ok with this vote. Thane has literally done nothing and has clearly shown no remorse. I would take him over Verb any day.

[Cass]

It's possible I have a blind spot re: Hallia, but I thought she was town due to her attitude last time, and she was.  I'm sticking with that vibe I get from her until she fools me.

 

How did you find her attitude earlier in this game Verb?

 

I found it very different to her opening from last game. Here she seemed much more diplomatic and less confrontational, and being a good deal more open with her opinions and reasons early on until around the time of the Yates lynch when she started getting heat.

[Hallia]

I don't think I really got hear, except from AlannaJr

[Hallia]

Heat even

[Yates]

Darthe don't edit you pleb

Darthe mod kills himself.

 

WE ALL WIN!

[Yates]

[unvote]

 

In case that wasn't clear.

[Leelou]

 

Darthe don't edit you pleb

Darthe mod kills himself.

 

WE ALL WIN!

 

 

WOO

[Yates]

1: I think Yates is as full of crap as a Christmas turkey

Hally. I'm just a VT. I swear. Probably. Why on Earth would YOU change your vote based on something you know I totally made up?

[Cass]

Re: Thane

So far this game I haven't seen very much of him actually giving any reads or anything that implies that he's working on it to solve it. 

 

Re: Hallia

Also hasn't done a great deal this game in terms of giving reads, and I don't feel too fantastic about her. It seems her votes have been given on other people's cases without giving any reads or leans of her own. 

 

I can see why Yates would pick these two as fake peeks. 

 

I agree that Thane doesn't look too good for unvoting and voting Hallia here.

 

 

 

Can you all give me your opinions on Dice?

I think he looks horribly scummy so far this game... 

 

I read him ?scum early on for lack of aggression, leaning away from that due to aggression D2, but I still find some of his question style and possibly his vote on you slightly off. Perhaps I'm making the same mistake with him that he did with me last time and giving him too much leniency due to RL but I don't know. 

 

What else have you got?

[Hallia]

Yates, did you miss the I don't wanna lose Verb part?

 

He's a better asset.

 

[Verbal32]

I don't see a way there is only town on my wagon.

 

EP

Eldrick

Yates

Pizza

Laine

 

That is how I'd order them from town to scum if I knew somebody had to be scum.  I doubt more than 1, so either Pizza or Laine is my best guess.

[Sooh]

**snip**

 

I read him ?scum early on for lack of aggression, leaning away from that due to aggression D2, but I still find some of his question style and possibly his vote on you slightly off. Perhaps I'm making the same mistake with him that he did with me last time and giving him too much leniency due to RL but I don't know. 

What else have you got?

 

 

Mainly the same thing. I have found he has done very little in terms of giving reads, and yes, I felt like his vote on me was off. I just can't seem to shake that he isn't being Town!Dice, which is why I'm reaching out to you who have played with him longer to see if anyone else feel the same way as I do. I find that it's much more compelling to me to go in that direction right now rather than at Thane/Hallia. 

[Leelou]

I don't see a way there is only town on my wagon.

 

EP

Eldrick

Yates

Pizza

Laine

 

That is how I'd order them from town to scum if I knew somebody had to be scum.  I doubt more than 1, so either Pizza or Laine is my best guess.

 

I've been meaning to address Laine's posts. I'll see what I can do right now. 

[Verbal32]

2. Sooh
5. Dice
7. Thane
9. Talya
15. Andrej
16. Alannalynn
19. seph

24. Pizzaguy

 

 

Copy/paste from the OP - this is my YOLO scum team(s).

[Yates]

2. Sooh

5. Dice

7. Thane

9. Talya

15. Andrej

16. Alannalynn

19. seph

 

Copy/paste from the OP - this is my YOLO scum team(s).

On board.

[Yates]

Yates, did you miss the I don't wanna lose Verb part?

 

He's a better asset.

 

Yates 1.0 was a better asset than anyone in this game... So your logic is weak.

[Cass]

Mainly the same thing. I have found he has done very little in terms of giving reads, and yes, I felt like his vote on me was off. I just can't seem to shake that he isn't being Town!Dice, which is why I'm reaching out to you who have played with him longer to see if anyone else feel the same way as I do. I find that it's much more compelling to me to go in that direction right now rather than at Thane/Hallia. 

 

Interesting, what's your read on me?

 

You know I <3 you but this is tinfoil Cass... I trust noone when I play and you've said you'll never trust me again so adding in the explanation about 'reaching out' seems strange... Currently I think I'm putting Dice at about the same level as Thane. Scummy to start and now not sure. And I'm still not certain that you're not Scum yourself.

[Yates]

[v]Thane[/v]

[Yates]

Thane is scum, yall.

[Verbal32]

 

Yates, did you miss the I don't wanna lose Verb part?

 

He's a better asset.

 

Yates 1.0 was a better asset than anyone in this game... So your logic is weak.

 

 

Better assets don't get themselves lynched.  Just sayin'.

 

<3

[Niniel]

I´m on page 76 now and I feel like voting Verbal. So this is my INTENT TO VOTE VERBAL unless I find something more townie after that. 

 

First he states that he think AJ vs. Yates is w/w but from different teams. 

 

In #915 he says that it doesn´t matter who of AJ or Yates that dies. 

 

Then we have the posts where Yates said the wrong name - Seph instead of Zander.

 

#936 Verbal votes Yates because of that. Yates had said Seph was lock wollf earlier and now he had him in his town list. 

 

#979 He unvotes after claim and Yates explaining about the mix up. 

 

When Leelou asks him who he wants to vote he says probably Seph but never votes. What happened to AJ?

 

 

This all look to me that Verbal is trying to play two people against each other (AJ and Yates) - then finding a reason to vote Yates. He doesn´t mention AJ again, if I remember it right.

 

 

Then he went after Leelou during the night. He told me that he never said she was mafia but now that I looked back and in #1325 he says that he takes back his town read on Leelou and thinks she is on a mafia team hunting other mafia. 

 

 

 

This is what I´ve got so far but will go back to look after page 76. 

[Thane Vakarian]

unvote

 

[v]Thane[/v]

 

i'll prove you wrong, Yates

[Leelou]

unvote

 

[v]Thane[/v]

 

i'll prove you wrong, Yates

 

I really dislike this play. 

[Verbal32]

I´m on page 76 now and I feel like voting Verbal. So this is my INTENT TO VOTE VERBAL unless I find something more townie after that.

 

Heh, keep reading.