A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Gabriel Kross]

Two notes

1) I was at a wedding yesterday afternoon/night and then today my parents are coming to town and I'm spending time with them (and speed cleaning the apartment).

2) Firebird, what am I supposed to do when you call me mafia? Once your mind is made up there is no way I'd be able to convince you otherwise--the late Leelou is proof of that. So saying "I'm not mafia" and claiming  even would not do me any good when it comes to you. 

 

Will give updated reads and such when I get back on later. 

how is leelou proof of that? she was out of my list for a long time?

[Hallia]

It's my hubby's birthday, so I will be scarce.  I protected sir AJ last night.  I'll have my phone but someone once told me it's impolite to stare at my phone when in the presence of family and friends. XD

[Clovdyx]

Official Vote Count One:

Hallia (3/6): Andrej, Eternal Phoenix, Thane

 

Not Voting (7/10):

Hallia, Aiel Heart,  Talya, White Knight, Alannalynn, Seph, Cass

 

With ten alive it takes six to lynch.  Deadline is at 11 PM EST on May 24th, 2015.  

[alannalynn]

I think Andrej wanted my reasons? So I'll go ahead and put them out there, I can go into more detail if needed, these are just off the top of my head for now.

 

Cass- I have liked her readings most of the game, I really have no reason to have her any lower on this list
Seph- I think most of what happened D1 was misunderstanding, I'm pretty sure Seph is town, I haven't seen anything strange from him lately
Talya- gut feeling, and she's played a pretty clean game
EP2- I would have him lower than right here, mainly because of behavior. I'm leaning town because of his interactions with Pizza.
Andrej- largely POE, he's pinged me earlier in the game for being entirely too townie, not sure if that's a null tell, but I'll leave him here in yellow
Thane- Now that he's not confirmed town (by Pizza) I'm putting him back to where I would have had him earlier in the game. Some of this is POE, some gut, but there's something off about Thane.
WhiteKnight- vote stealer- I don't believe that we have two vote powers for the town in this game, honestly, that is why he is in my scum category. If Leelou was town, then WK is mafia
AHeart- Haven't gotten a good feeling since she replaced in, she has been making uninformed votes (ex Verbal) and still leaning way scum on her since she outted WK's power from a "misread"
Hally- claimed bodyguard- I've had her here the whole game, I do not believe her claim and I think she's been floating the majority of the time. I don't know how she's escaped as many potential lynches as she has.

 

Vote: Hallia

[alannalynn]

Wow pretty

[Gabriel Kross]

[unvote]

[Gabriel Kross]

I have a plan

 

Town needs to trust me and even out the votes on Hallia and AH leave it at a 50/50 for now.

[Gabriel Kross]

[v]AH[/v]

[White Knight]

So can we assume they'll be in at some point to say something. 

[Gabriel Kross]

So can we assume they'll be in at some point to say something. 

why? you either think she's mafia or she's not. she claimed a long time ago

[Gabriel Kross]

AJ is there any particular reason why you don't trust Hallia?

[Gabriel Kross]

for theory's sake everyone is highly suspicious of both AH and Hallia yes? Why not put equal votes on both and let random decide. If it hits the mystery team we could still survive this. If it hit's Tina's team then it's less likely that town will win but their's a chance.

[Gabriel Kross]

there's*

[seph]

If we do the random thing ep then everyone could use that as a excuse to place their votes. And wouldn't yield as much information.

 

I would rather lynch ah over hallia, pizza protected her vigorously, and she has had him as a wolf the entire game pretty much.

[v]ah [/v]

[Gabriel Kross]

It would.

[Clovdyx]

Official Vote Count One:

Hallia (3/6): Andrej, Thane, Alannalynn

Aiel Heart (2/6): Eternal Phoenix, Seph

 

Not Voting (5/10):

Hallia, Aiel Heart,  Talya, White Knight, Cass

 

With ten alive it takes six to lynch.  Deadline is at 11 PM EST on May 24th, 2015.  

[Andrej]

It's my hubby's birthday, so I will be scarce. I protected sir AJ last night. I'll have my phone but someone once told me it's impolite to stare at my phone when in the presence of family and friends. XD

Why did you protect me over one of the outed PRs?

 

Who would you / are you planning to vote today?

[Andrej]

AJ is there any particular reason why you don't trust Hallia?

I think the fact she is the only claimed protective (and not even one that can wifom against NKs) PR and we have been seeing VTs / other PRs flip before her is troubling. Also her choice of protects in this case.

 

Pizza also said something about her lying about her role before he was modkilled and he flipped role cop. This is sorta wifomy but still. He had already outed himself at that point so I don't see the reason to lie about something like that.

 

That also makes them not teammates because he wouldn't check someone in his QT (obviously)

 

I think she's a good lynch here.

[Andrej]

for theory's sake everyone is highly suspicious of both AH and Hallia yes? Why not put equal votes on both and let random decide. If it hits the mystery team we could still survive this. If it hit's Tina's team then it's less likely that town will win but their's a chance.

What's even the point of this? It doesn't require for people to take hard stances if some arbitrary is doing to be the deciding factor.

[dicetosser1]

That Dice kill just doesn't make sense to me.

 

Mafia kills me thinking AWesome!@ thatll shut him up! then they see the flip and go 

 

what does a stump even do?

 

keeps annoying mafia

 

 

WK - you were going to explain you vote thing! I cant believe that town has double vote type roles.

 

It's not an everyday thing - it's limited, just as was Leelou's. 

 

 

Previous actions taken?

[Gabriel Kross]

 

for theory's sake everyone is highly suspicious of both AH and Hallia yes? Why not put equal votes on both and let random decide. If it hits the mystery team we could still survive this. If it hit's Tina's team then it's less likely that town will win but their's a chance.

What's even the point of this? It doesn't require for people to take hard stances if some arbitrary is doing to be the deciding factor.

 

there's more to it than I'm letting on.

[Andrej]

[Gabriel Kross]

[unvote]  [v]Hallia[/v] if Hallia flips mafia, Seph is on her team.

[Gabriel Kross]

the plan was to see where people voted see who tried to save who at the last second

[Gabriel Kross]

the only problem is the game is too inactive to use this strategy.