Pokemon Mafia IV: The Mystery of Heart Island--GAME OVER--TEAM ROCKET WIN

[seph]

I have no read on Jon currently but I'm willing to bet Hallia is just getting that middle of the pack vote in.

I was confused on some of his posts, but I think the post before this one by you, helped clarify it.

Re reading as his first thought process makes more sense, and males halliah's post look really bad imo.

Also I am not sure I am getting the same vibe from eld here. He is blatantly shouting he is town over, and over.

 

 

Yay! Finally town!

Thank you for breaking the chain, Heart.

I....don't know if I buy it.

God I love Pokemon.

Eldrick is town for sure. Maybe Seph as well.

[v] Zander [/v]

Follow me asap or be branded a wolf later

Gross.

Six posters, high likelihood that we already have a wolf in thread. Not enough to go off of but IMO I'd go ahead and put Eldrick and John snow as town and might drop Seph back to null for being foppish but idk him well enough to really make that assertion yet.

Talk to me

Why are you trying to channel Correh?

So far Zander's posts look good to me.

I don't expect anyone to buy it. That would be stupid to assume I'm town without reason. I'm just glad I am.

[Gabriel Kross]

he is also very new, and hinted at something I have a very high expectation to be in this game.

[seph]

he is also very new, and hinted at something I have a very high expectation to be in this game.

Maybe I am to tired to get this. Blah.

What are your thoughts on darth and ithi ep?

[Gabriel Kross]

 

he is also very new, and hinted at something I have a very high expectation to be in this game.

Maybe I am to tired to get this. Blah.

What are your thoughts on darth and ithi ep?

 

Darthe is known to be active as mafia or town he reminds me alot of Myndrunner i dunno if I spelled that right, but I doubt you know who that is, so atm I'd say null read on him.

 

Ithi on the other hand is notorious for singling me out on day 1, the fact that she hasn't this game puts her on my list of people to watch.

[seph]

Good to know about darth. I like the direction he is headed for now.

I would say eld,snow,halliah's are mixed for me right now.

Pretty sure I can lean town on you ep

[Hallia]

Eld has been in a couple of games. I'm not cutting him as much slack as I am say Mashiara.

[Gabriel Kross]

Eld has been in a couple of games. I'm not cutting him as much slack as I am say Mashiara.

oh I'm not cutting him any slack but with the way he posted those two posts made it pretty clear to me he is just a lonely townie with no clue what to do since this would be his first game without others to give him advice. I don't like his preaching his townie-ness but I can't see his hint of cyndaquil as being a lie.

[Eldrick4221]

he is also very new, and hinted at something I have a very high expectation to be in this game.

 I hinted at something? I said who my Pokemon was, which for all intents and purposes is a character claim, which really has no impact on the game whatsoever.

 

I'm keeping an eye on whoever it was that tried to buddy up to me for the sole reason that I have a fire Pokemon. I wanna say Zander, but I'll have to go double check. It's no reason to think i'm town, and claiming it is your reason is suspicious.

[Eldrick4221]

God I love Pokemon.

 

Eldrick is town for sure.  Maybe Seph as well.  

 

[v] Zander [/v]

 

Follow me asap or be branded a wolf later

so Darthe, why did you try to start a train on Zander?

[Gabriel Kross]

 

he is also very new, and hinted at something I have a very high expectation to be in this game.

 I hinted at something? I said who my Pokemon was, which for all intents and purposes is a character claim, which really has no impact on the game whatsoever.

 

I'm keeping an eye on whoever it was that tried to buddy up to me for the sole reason that I have a fire Pokemon. I wanna say Zander, but I'll have to go double check. It's no reason to think i'm town, and claiming it is your reason is suspicious.

 

You didn't specifically say you have the pokemon Ciydaquil therefore it was more of a hint really, and tbh the only reason I'm even believing you're town is because of the Cyndaquil

[dicetosser1]

EP that post of eldricks was pretty obviously a character claim imo. Also how many pokemon are there? like total?

[Gabriel Kross]

EP that post of eldricks was pretty obviously a character claim imo. Also how many pokemon are there? like total?

I'm using what I know as a basis for believing it. I have my suspicions on which games this ties in with. If I'm right it means all but X/Y gen are viable.

[dicetosser1]

so you are gaming the mod then

[Gabriel Kross]

no, I made an assumption. However based on my pokemon and the the 1 claimed pokemon it fits.

[dicetosser1]

but you didnt believe it was an actual claim

[Gabriel Kross]

I called it a hint because he didn't outright say his pokemon was Cyndaquil, whether I read it as a hint or claim is like the difference between green apples and red apples.

 

For the record his exact words were "I choose you Cyndaquil" that's a hint at best.

 

However good attempt at distracting. drawing the topic off issues of relevance to debate claim vs hint and trying to discredit Eld's claim/hint what-have you by speculating the number of pokemon in the game. Cyndaquil would be a ballsy fake claim considering it's a starter pokemon.

[Gabriel Kross]

I'm getting scum vibes from Dice. I still believe Hallia is mafia as well so I'll leave my vote there.

[dicetosser1]

I called it a hint because he didn't outright say his pokemon was Cyndaquil, whether I read it as a hint or claim is like the difference between green apples and red apples.

 

For the record his exact words were "I choose you Cyndaquil" that's a hint at best.

 

However good attempt at distracting. drawing the topic off issues of relevance to debate claim vs hint and trying to discredit Eld's claim/hint what-have you by speculating the number of pokemon in the game. Cyndaquil would be a ballsy fake claim considering it's a starter pokemon.

 

So one thing hasnt changed. You still miss the point. Im not  discrediting Eldrickj at all. I said flat out I thought he claimed.

 

Im looking at YOU.

 

 

Okay here's my reasoning on why I voted for Hallia, The first 2 quotes are of Eld's very poor choice of game start that has beginner written all over it.

 

 

 

Cyndaquil, I choose you.

 

Cmon buddy, let's go find us some team rocket.

 

I read the second post as him claiming to have Cyndaquil, which I have a very high reason to believe is in this game. Again a very rookie mistake that I comment on below in the bold.

 

 

Ive cut this thing up to get at the bit i wanted

 

The red is why im looking at you. I wanted to know WHY you have a high reason to believe Cyndaquill is in this game.  

 

You explained why you thought that and that was fine. but then you went and twisted things.

 

My questions were aimed at you. About why YOU were saying what you were saying.

 

I never discredited eldrick. 

 

and in a POKEMON game doesn't it seem obvious that some one saying "I choose You  name of pokemon"  woulde be a claim done thematically?

 

unvote

 

vote EP

[Gabriel Kross]

sigh if you missed my blatant hint shame on you. I don't follow your logic on why you're voting me. I said I have a very high reason to believe cyndaquil's in this game, and that's what you're basing this on? lol. Please refer to my previous post where I said I have scum vibes on Dice kthnx have a nice day.

[Gabriel Kross]

also please elaborate on what I "twisted around"

[dicetosser1]

that im somehow discrediting Eldrick.

 

 

as for blatant hint?  A a HINT by definition isnt blatant and B not everyone is a pokemon nerd

[Gabriel Kross]

 

I called it a hint because he didn't outright say his pokemon was Cyndaquil, whether I read it as a hint or claim is like the difference between green apples and red apples.

 

For the record his exact words were "I choose you Cyndaquil" that's a hint at best.

 

However good attempt at distracting. drawing the topic off issues of relevance to debate claim vs hint and trying to discredit Eld's claim/hint what-have you by speculating the number of pokemon in the game. Cyndaquil would be a ballsy fake claim considering it's a starter pokemon.

 

So one thing hasnt changed. You still miss the point. Im not  discrediting Eldrickj at all. I said flat out I thought he claimed.

 

Im looking at YOU.

 

 

Okay here's my reasoning on why I voted for Hallia, The first 2 quotes are of Eld's very poor choice of game start that has beginner written all over it.

 

 

 

Cyndaquil, I choose you.

 

Cmon buddy, let's go find us some team rocket.

 

I read the second post as him claiming to have Cyndaquil, which I have a very high reason to believe is in this game. Again a very rookie mistake that I comment on below in the bold.

 

 

Ive cut this thing up to get at the bit i wanted

 

The red is why im looking at you. I wanted to know WHY you have a high reason to believe Cyndaquill is in this game.  

 

You explained why you thought that and that was fine. but then you went and twisted things.

 

My questions were aimed at you. About why YOU were saying what you were saying.

 

I never discredited eldrick. 

 

and in a POKEMON game doesn't it seem obvious that some one saying "I choose You  name of pokemon"  woulde be a claim done thematically?

 

unvote

 

vote EP

 

that reads as if you're saying I tried to change my stance on something hence "twisting around"

 

that im somehow discrediting Eldrick.

 

 

as for blatant hint?  A a HINT by definition isnt blatant and B not everyone is a pokemon nerd

it's blatant because the thing I hinted is only done by one pokemon as far as I know. Not to mention I gave another subtle hint when combined with my main hint by refering to "what I know" is why I beleive his cyndaquil claim/hint whatever. Also for the record if you're going to play a pokemon themed mafia game it's atleast wise to brush up on popular/well-known pokemon

[dicetosser1]

except that i put immediately under it what i think you twisted.

 

doing a google search on a character is not necessarily going to give u enuff info to pick up hints. You seem to be doing a lot of assuming this game

[Gabriel Kross]

or you could google search the hints, you seem to be making a lot of illogical comments.

[Eldrick4221]

And seeing if Ithi would try to use it.  She tends to be overzealous as scum so it helps me to get an early good read of her.

I buy this.