Avatar The Last Airbender Town and SK wins!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Also don't be ridiculous about wanting me to be quiet about who I think is Mafia because I'm not letting other people join in. I've been at work all day and now I'm going to bed. When I'm not here the game has and will continue. Good grief.

[seph]

That was in reference to me saying he is town

Anyone who reads this can see once I vote you, you are tunneling me lol. you go from changing the reasons 2-3 times, and stick on the turin thing for 15 pages. I was giving you the benefit of the doubt because of Turin, I tried to drop it, but your only reason was I had turin town. I believe I have explained in DETAIL FOR YOU. and you alone.  You did come back as town ithi for a day. but it was at me like i expected, and while you questioned others you never once followed up until just now with aj.

Please show me one place in this thread where your actions benefit that of the town. i left yesterday and the page went up by 1 in the matter of 12 hours or longer???  I will not rest until you are lynched, everyone in this thread has noticed you acting differently [unvote]  [vote]Ithi[/v] Don't worry my vote is not leaving until one of us is gone. 

 

I have been really nervous this entire game, why on earth would I come at you if I were scum. I would kill you N1, no questions. The only thing I worry about turrin is he has made me change my mind twice now once in the other game, and this one. It was a really bad feeling and made me shy away.

 

 Posted by Turin Turambar on 18 April 2015 - 07:46 PM in The Black Tower (Social Group)

Seph, I didn't switch back to Darthe. I voted Cory to remind myself he could be mafia trying to place himself above the fray (still possible). Then I voted Ley for his unreasonable (IMO) push at Ithi. I am now voting Darthe because he has refused to give his reasons for any of his reads and he has ignored Ithi's casee on him. He looks to be most mafia of everyone so far. I was actually waiting for Darthe and Zander to come back and explain themselves. Darthe returned but refused to explain. Even a "feels" read would be something. His refusal to say anything  other than to say that others are playing bad is most suspicious.

 

and this  Posted by Turin Turambar on 18 April 2015 - 08:03 PM in The Black Tower (Social Group)

seph, on 18 Apr 2015 - 1:58 PM, said:

I was around Turin I just was taking my fiancee to work, while reading. there was quite a lot of posts in a short amount of time.

 

Okay. Well if you aren't posting it is pretty much assumed that you are not around. Or are lurking which is frowned upon.

 

So i do have him null for now.

 

 

 

Even if I am not lynched here I will probably be NK'ed as I am the only one attempting to move this thread. I am going to lay all my cards out on the table. ithi you are scum I think you played differently this game for a reason, I am not really sure I am believing everything you say because you have this post here.

. Posted by Ithillian on 26 April 2015 - 10:19 PM in DM Mafia Games

Four pages. I think Yates won.

 

Which is referring to what yates said in our other game. you claim you could not handle it elsewhere, and that may be. But here and in the sign up thread it seems like you and turin have been joking about it. With john snow's reference to the distancing, It seemed like that itself was distancing as both of you decided to say you did not receive it that way.

 

I am sure you are scum and I am putting john snow in there, with probably someone who has been more inactive, to answer you question on who I think is mafia.

[Andrej]

Ithi just saying things at this point.

 

The connection that you're trying to reinforce is premature at best. Nothing I have seen people point out make me think Seph is mafia, frankly. He's at least participating and attempting to back up what he says from what I have seen.

[Andrej]

Well that's not a productive stance to take Seph.

[seph]

Yea dice will probably smack me when he gets back.
Honestly at this point I feel like either we are just reading each other very very badly, and not meshing.

it has all looked very scummy to me, maybe I have been reading to many wiki sights... but that is how I feel, and I don't seeing anything changing that.

[seph]

EBWODP that is supposed to say or not meshing

[seph]

[v]ithi[/v]

[Sooh]

I feel like Seph is one I'd like to see live beyond D1, because I find his posts as of right now more like he's trying to find his way in the game and make his play his own. He doesn't feel at all like he has an agenda like he did after he returned as mafia in his first game. 

 

I also find Tress' posts to ring town to me, because she seems genuine in her frustration. 

 

As for Turin I need some more time to read him more accurately. 

 

I think I'd like to take a look at Ithi's posts and see if there is anything there now to start with. 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I heard notbob was supposed to be pretty talkative, maybe I heard wrong

 

Most likely heard it wrong but not like there's a lot to comment on...why were you on some people's scumdar again?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Zander why are you claiming like that?

 

^^^^This^^^^

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

i think it should be clear who we'd like to hear more from. Notbob, and personally, some Nolder would be nice too

 

Not sure what you want to hear from me...very little substance in the game yet...

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

My possible mafia so far are within seph, thane,AJ and Eldrick.

 

It would these have an agenda...probably scum in this mix.

[Sooh]

Ok, so, based on some of my notes of today, where i ut some stuff that had my interest, i'm here so far:

 

 

 1.    Zander (mentored by Cory)

 

 no content till page 4, cory > Aj hi, #77 odd post.., #163/165 ask Thane if town, hunt wolves.

#182 in reply to #177, Seph villager in #190,

 

2.    Nolder

#175 first post. #177 unserious vote on Zander.#200 sus AJ? , 

 

3.    Eldrick

#95, first post strawberry, #96 jokevote, #97 suspicion on Ithi ‘train’ (agreed) , #118 also agreed. Ithi not warranting votes.#143 unvote jokevote, #144 good post imo, #241 fake votes?

 

4.    Sooh (mentored by Clov)

#205 questions AJ/Tress, mentions interesting htings? 

 

5.    Not Bob

#101 in (2:05), catching up, #102 (10 mins later) caught up (?) vote Eldrick, posts page 8, no real content, 

 

6. Thane me! Yay!

 

7. Seph (mentored by Dice)

Jokevote 1^st post(#4), #85 plead to Ithi to hunt, #87 votejump on Ithi ? 

 

8. Tress

(#5) why comment when obv jokevote?, #16 must be clear that #4 was jokevote, #86 vote on Ithi, #91 (John Snow?),  #94, not taking turins vote serious, #98, #106 laughs Turins post away… #114 further defense against Turin. Much defense? ; #208 also notices Ithi diffirent,still seems.. defensive #211

 

9. AJ

joking with tress, #62 LC comment from mentees..#120 question Notbob for #102 (good), #185 welcome Nolder, #191 opinion Seph, #198 reads, #238 vote NB

 

10. John Snow

#56 QT comment…? Nah, no slip… I think. #81 comment on #77 Zander.. #89, agreed it’s odd, vote Seph necessary?

 

11. Ithi

#44 turin vote. Not serious imo. Overall good gameplay. Though, a lot calmer in game than I remember. Been a while since game together though. #142 Seph vote. #244 also points out fake Eldrick #241, 

 

12. Turin

#92 vote tress, no previous gameplay, #99, #105 Tress mafia sus (good post), #194 small reads,

 

Ignoring ithi & Turin early game. Up until page 5.

 

Page 2 tress/aj joking, nothing standing out.

Page3 strawberry!

Page 7 AJ/Seph interaction, some more AJ/Tress joking,

 

Page 9 Seph/Ithi/Turin 

 

 

Turin

Ithi

AJ

Eldrick

 

Nolder

Sooh

John Snow

Tress

 

Notbob

Seph

Zander

 

Feeling townish vibes for the top 4, or haven't seen anything alarming. For the center 4: i realy don't know. Either not enough content, or too mixed feelings about them. Bottom three, i don't trust.

 

 

i'm stll somewhat wary of Ithi....i'm used to her being a pitbull, biting down and not letting go... she seems more like a shepperd here

 

Thane? You're aware of this juxtaposition, right?

[Sooh]

ebwop - Turin already pointed that out and you responded... This is what you get for catching up 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

EBWODP 

[v]NotBob[/v]

 

 

I feel the worst about snow, thane, or zander

I feel like ithi, Tress, turin are town

everyone else is null.

 

Ithi I hope you know I was provoking you hoping for that reaction. All of my intents are for the town.

 

Thane what made you have a gut feeling on me? Playing with dice last game I had the same problem as I just do not understand it.

 

^^^ non-sequitur ^^^

[Turin Turambar]

[unvote]

 

[V] AJ [/v]

 

You might want to start bussing seph if you want to live.

 

I am all for AJ / Seph competing trains.

 

I can see them both as mafia. AJ feels like he is taking the role Cory played in that last BT game. running interference for Seph when he stepped in it early.

 

Seph. I don't see how you are coming from a town place right now.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

No, not with them.

You have me as a suspect. I want to know why

You're gonna have to wait till I can go collect the stuff that made me think it. I'm on my phone and can't do that atm.

But everyone else seemed to be just posting lists and I thought I'd share mine so far.

Why do you think I should have you as Town?

No worries about the quotes. Summations work just fine for me, I'm on my phone too so I know the pain.

 

I wouldn't use the word should in this case. You are free to develop your read on me however you choose so long as you're willing to explain it. I think I have enough content at this point for anyone to make a call one way or another, even if a weak one.

 

I don't like in actives but I think it should be the mods job to deal with them. Saying you want to lynch in actives is basically allowing an easy lynch without having to give reasons. Also they have no interaction in the game so even when you get the flip it can't help you.

Think of it more as me trying to smoke out the quiet players. The thread was getting stagnant so I wanted to procude some content with the idea. I'm also not particularly fond of lynching any of the more active players at this point. I think we both know it would be hugely irresponsible just to blindly lynch someone, so that isn't going to happen. The dog piling is meant to get people talking.

 

what is your opinion of Not Bob, anyway? I figured that someone like you would probably see where I was coming from when I voted him. He did a 'reply to a joke but say nothing else' type post on the page I voted him, and previously hadn't said much except to vote Eldrick for what I assume is a joke (I asked and wasn't given much of an answer) and reply to some other fluff early on.

 

 

lulz...the guy with an agenda...doesn't voice his concerns when he votes  me but since then he has pushed and prodded for opinions on my play...good luck with this tactic

[seph]

the vote on you ment nothing bob

[Turin Turambar]

I think I've given a healthy amount of stances both voluntarily and when asked for them. Also, it's perfectly acceptable that I ask questions that sometimes I don't respond to. As you can see, we're nearing 4 days into the game and we're just breaking into the 20s as far as page count goes - so by asking questions I get people to talk. If I don't feel the need to answer, then I don't, but each question I ask has a purpose those answers go into my weird little alignment calculator in my head for further examination.

Can you quote some solid stances please? The more the merrier.

[seph]

Turin you mafia to huh?

[Turin Turambar]

the vote on you ment nothing bob

All votes mean something. Your stated reason was to draw him out. Own it.

[seph]

Yea, that was said. I wan't goin to lynch the guy over that. AS I STATED THAT AS WELL.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I feel like Seph is one I'd like to see live beyond D1, because I find his posts as of right now more like he's trying to find his way in the game and make his play his own. He doesn't feel at all like he has an agenda like he did after he returned as mafia in his first game. 

 

I also find Tress' posts to ring town to me, because she seems genuine in her frustration. 

 

As for Turin I need some more time to read him more accurately. 

 

I think I'd like to take a look at Ithi's posts and see if there is anything there now to start with. 

 

This is not comforting.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

the vote on you ment nothing bob

 

the vote means more than words in my book

[John Snow]

-snip-

 

I am sure you are scum and I am putting john snow in there, with probably someone who has been more inactive, to answer you question on who I think is mafia.

 

 

Turin you mafia to huh?

 

OMGUS much?