Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Pralaya]

How am I being opportunistic?

 

Yea I think he'd hold out. And no I'm not 100% sure. Second guessing myself...

 

So what are your thoughts?

 

He would have held out on claiming. Not on signalling.

Why would he hold out on signalling till last few hours before the deadline?

[csarmi]

I was joking, or did you miss the :P ?

Yea it wasn't funny.

 

I'm pretty sure that if I added a smiley in the end of the sentence then calling you what I think you are right now wouldn't be an insult anymore...

[csarmi]

 

 

How am I being opportunistic?

 

Yea I think he'd hold out. And no I'm not 100% sure. Second guessing myself...

 

So what are your thoughts?

He would have held out on claiming. Not on signalling.

Why would he hold out on signalling till last few hours before the deadline?

Dunno. But it sure stood out.

 

So what do you think his results were?

[Tsukibana]

Oh, come off it. You and Hallia both are quick to say "Oh, I am insulted", but what is calling a person "derp" other than a polite way of saying "retard"?

Don't see me crying.

[Lenlo]

 

I was joking, or did you miss the :P ?

Yea it wasn't funny.

 

I'm pretty sure that if I added a smiley in the end of the sentence then calling you what I think you are right now wouldn't be an insult anymore...

 

Yo dawg, chill. Were all bros playin a game.

[Tsukibana]

 

 

How am I being opportunistic?

 

Yea I think he'd hold out. And no I'm not 100% sure. Second guessing myself...

 

So what are your thoughts?

He would have held out on claiming. Not on signalling.

Why would he hold out on signalling till last few hours before the deadline?

Dunno. But it sure stood out.

 

So, for once I agree with CS...

[Turin Turambar]

Cs,sorry but I think you lose the right to get emo about jokes when you have already gone full **** bomb at someone. For saying you are mafia in a mafia game.

 

 

Is emo the new black?

 

 

 

 

You wanna vote Despo? I think it is the only way you survive today, TBH.  

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

*****Ok people modspeak****

 

Weve been super lenient with the language and the asterisks and the acronyms. We've only called people out on it when it's gotten repetitive.

 

But we're right on the line and I'm asking nicely - step back.

 

No more skirting around what you all know doesn't fly in his forum.

 

Don't even hint at the kinds of names you'd like to be calling each other. Don't use asterisks or acronyms. Don't throw personal insults around and if you do, don't be surprised when they get thrown back at you.

 

Last warning here. Play nice.

 

Carry on.

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

How am I being opportunistic?

 

Yea I think he'd hold out. And no I'm not 100% sure. Second guessing myself...

 

So what are your thoughts?

He would have held out on claiming. Not on signalling.

Why would he hold out on signalling till last few hours before the deadline?

Dunno. But it sure stood out.

 

So what do you think his results were?

 

this is silly. It would be purest speculation to guess at who got peeked and what the results were. 

 

But if we are going to speculate then My 2p is that Holmes was likely to be a full cop as in law enforcement a detective is more than a regular cop. So Holmes got role and alignment meaning that he wouldn't be fooled by a GF where as Lestrade was a regular cop and only would get alignment. But there are many ways it could have gone down so without any actual words from the said investigators it is better to just go off what is in the thread. Unfortunately we will never know. Therefore it is a waste to assume to know. 

[Tsukibana]

Lestrade wasn't even a very GOOD cop, at that, was he? All the non-canon stuff paints him as a buffoon, half the time.

[Lenlo]

Q: Wheres Dice and BFG?

[csarmi]

Cs,sorry but I think you lose the right to get emo about jokes when you have already gone full **** bomb at someone. For saying you are mafia in a mafia game.

 

 

Is emo the new black?

 

 

 

 

You wanna vote Despo? I think it is the only way you survive today, TBH.

Been receiving trolling and provocations for a week or so. For some players most of the play consists of hounding me. I have a low tolerance.

 

So yea I meant to insult. Cause that's the new black.

 

As for Despo sure. but I'm less sold on him than Tina or Len.

[csarmi]

@Turin: Rags is a great player and he knew he must have been under the gin due to the char claim. I find it very unlikely that he wouldn't leave clear trails on his views in this case.

[csarmi]

@Tsuki: for what its worth I didn't mean "derptown" as an insult, rather than a description of your play as I see it.

 

I can tone it back to "a townie who is seriously off and way too stubborn to see the light".

[csarmi]

 

Cs,sorry but I think you lose the right to get emo about jokes when you have already gone full **** bomb at someone. For saying you are mafia in a mafia game.

 

 

Is emo the new black?

 

 

 

 

You wanna vote Despo? I think it is the only way you survive today, TBH.

Been receiving trolling and provocations for a week or so. For some players most of the play consists of hounding me. I have a low tolerance.

 

So yea I meant to insult. Cause that's the new black.

 

As for Despo sure. but I'm less sold on him than Tina or Len.

Rags flipping town seriously shaken my reads. Add to the Pral stuff and that I just dunno what to do with you and you can see why I'm hesitant on Despo now... I just don't understand his switch either.

[Turin Turambar]

So why didn't he get killed night 1? Ithi had claimed. Mafia knew it was true. No way that mafia really thought they would get her lynched. I think the Dice 1.0 shot was pure luck. No I think that mafia thought Holmes HAD to be the cop and were searching for him.

 

Pretty sure that neither Tina or Lenlo are getting lynched today without some sort of result to point the way. But by all means make a case. 

[dicetosser1]

I'm pretty sure Hally is town because of her save. If she were scum:

 

1) she'd be better off using that save later on herself or any useful scummate

 

2) she's a nice girl. I'm pretty sure she realized how I'm feeling about being in this game and she would have let me die.

 

I already covered this Csarmi.

 

Oh BTW, why would Lestrade have been the likely cop? It would seem that Holmes would be the cop.

 

So you as mafia have one role that is outed, fully claimed and another that is a maybe. Which one would you be more likely to block? 

 

 

I have no idea why you are taking this personally. No one called you a bad player or said you should feel bad. I just don't think you are town. Frankly it all sounds like a pile of AtE.

 

 

You see I don't care if you think I am a good player or not. To quote your little buddy "I DO WHAT I WANT".

 

The only person on your current mafia list I would even consider voting is Despo and I wanted to see your flip to gauge him a bit more. You really should have asked Hallia to let you die. She would have listened to you. It is the job of a miller to die to further the towns goals frequently. You seemed to follow that right up until the point it looked like you would actually get lynched.

 

Are you doubting Krak now? how does that mesh with your previous Chae read? 

 

 

 

Cause Holmes already flipped, this is role Madness and what else are you gonna make Lestrade?  in keeping with his charachter he may be a dumb cop or something or only right half the time or something, but i think the flip would've shown that

 

 

 

Numbers > distraction. Even if I get mislynched again Mafia is not better off than saving their own.

 

 

 

 

 

Turin - has been active and is making good reads. Town.

 

 

Not too sure how you can say that, and yet contradict 2/3 of those reads, but OK.

 

Interesting, about the roles and such... but wasn't the King of Bohemia a generally bad person?

 

 

You can go and read his posts. Although I don't agree with his reads, he is making good points. As an example, even today, he was looking back at NotBob's posts trying to see what he could have said. 

 

And, no, don;t think the King was a villain. He just hired Holmes for a case.

 

 

 

I would say the King was the villian of the piece. he tried painting Adler bad and no she really wasnt. She was even honorable refusing to use things against the king.

[dicetosser1]

vote Hally

[Tsukibana]

@Tsuki: for what its worth I didn't mean "derptown" as an insult, rather than a description of your play as I see it.

 

I can tone it back to "a townie who is seriously off and way too stubborn to see the light".

"What it is worth" to me is this: This is a game. Anything said in this game causes me NO emotional impact. HOW people play this game might get me frustrated, but there are too many ways that something/ANYTHING can easily be interpreted as an insult if someone so desires to take it that way. Real feels have no place in a game where you will be called a liar, dumb, stubborn, scumtastic, crap player, idiot, etc... (no matter HOW you try to cushion it) 50 ways before the last post.

No insult meant, or taken.

 

You still played like scum up until the last day.

[Tsukibana]

Addendum - Any player who brings real feels into a game like this is automatically scummy, in my book. We all know what we signed up for.

[csarmi]

So why didn't he get killed night 1? Ithi had claimed. Mafia knew it was true. No way that mafia really thought they would get her lynched. I think the Dice 1.0 shot was pure luck. No I think that mafia thought Holmes HAD to be the cop and were searching for him.

 

Pretty sure that neither Tina or Lenlo are getting lynched today without some sort of result to point the way. But by all means make a case.

Lenlo isn't commenting on anything but me or defending himself if need be.

 

Tina dropped in yesterday with a scumtastic reasoning, dropped off w/o adding more as top candidate and asked that she don't understand why she was being voted.

 

Plus Thane spew (random lurker thing).

[csarmi]

Good night and wake. Phone is dying.

[csarmi]

Addendum - Any player who brings real feels into a game like this is automatically scummy, in my book. We all know what we signed up for.

Dogmatic play is always bad.

 

And we all bring real feelings into games a thousand ways. We aren't computers.

[Lenlo]

 

So why didn't he get killed night 1? Ithi had claimed. Mafia knew it was true. No way that mafia really thought they would get her lynched. I think the Dice 1.0 shot was pure luck. No I think that mafia thought Holmes HAD to be the cop and were searching for him.

 

Pretty sure that neither Tina or Lenlo are getting lynched today without some sort of result to point the way. But by all means make a case.

Lenlo isn't commenting on anything but me or defending himself if need be.

 

Tina dropped in yesterday with a scumtastic reasoning, dropped off w/o adding more as top candidate and asked that she don't understand why she was being voted.

 

Plus Thane spew (random lurker thing).

 

Because the only thing going on today is you or you attacking people.

[csarmi]

See?