[Advanced] Once Upon a Time Mafia- Game Over, Town Wins!!!

[Nikonis]

Turin beat me to it but here's the post.

Announcement: Turin is replacing Ice, and I have asked Dors or Panchi if they'd sub in for Ithi... if neither can however, but you know someone who could, please pm me or ask them to.

[wheeloftime13]

 

Evil went hunting during the night, and when Mother Superior (the Blue Fairy) cast a spell to try and aid the town, they struck... Her heart crumbled and when she fell to the ground, her wand, still clutched in her hand, started to glow with the power the last spell it had cast. When the town rose the next morning, many cried out with grief at the loss of such a strong, protective, and loving town member. Now they were desperate to have their revenge against the villains.

 

Thane 2- Blue Fairy, town roleblocker has been Night Killed...

 

It is now Day 3!!! Deadline: Saturday May 10, 20:00 EST http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140510T20&p0=814&msg=OUAT+Mafia+Day+3

[Turin Turambar]

vote RTE

[Tsukibana]

VOTE RTE

 

I think you holding on to Ithi, and being the only one to do so, just bit you in the ass.

 

SK would've pinged someone last night. Chae went down from a Vig.

[Turin Turambar]

VOTE RTE

 

I think you holding on to Ithi, and being the only one to do so, just bit you in the ass.

 

SK would've pinged someone last night. Chae went down from a Vig.

I am not getting what you are saying here

[Hallia]

 

I disagree that it's that easy. The only people who can do that so easily are mafia.

You are saying that it is hard to make a list of all the players and then give an opinion if they are more likely mafia or town in your own opinion?

 

It is more difficult for mafia because they first have to decide what to say about their teammates, and second need to make sure they are consistent..

 

just make everyone you are unsure of town. it will be okay. And format it correctly.

 

I find it odd that RTE seemed to know why I want these lists and yet is refusing to give his. I think I may be dead come day.

 

Hallia and RTE need more looking at. There was some linkage earlier also I think. I will try to look to find it..

 

 

I say it's difficult because I put my leans, and you wanted straight up 'THIS PERSON IS TOWN.  THIS PERSON IS MAFIA.'  I can give what I think, which is what I did.  But I can't say for sure who is what, which is why I said what I said.  Also there goes another person AJ was gunning for D1, down as town.  

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I stayed up late all night for this, got sidetracked, now here we are quite late and finally get to post.

 

Let's try to get a scum today.

 

I'm the Cop. Hallia is town. I can't wait to see AJ's reaction now. Wish I could see a video of him eating his hat, or all the other things he said he would do if he's wrong.

 

I got my time messed up while on vacation and missed my view first night. Sorry. Was going to lie about that but what's the point? Hence my night being short post. Time zones and long days. Sorry.

 

Now, that list.

 

Dawn - Scum

TG - Scum

Nikon - Scum

Talmanes - Scum

BFG - Scum

Turin - Town

Hallia - Town

RTE - Town

AJ - Town

Tsuki - Town

Ed - Town

 

Bit of a random order. Other than Dawn and TG not sure for scum reads. The Hallia town view surprised me. She could be GF but.. Meh.  We can figure that out I guess. Right now...

 

Vote Dawn

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Now Andrej, please make a big post about how you were wrong and OMG how can it be or Hallia is GF or something. Please, let me start my morning with a smile tomorrow.

 

Goodnight folks.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I meant to list BFG as Town, although tossup between her and Talmanes. Sorry. Tired.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

On a sidenote, the mafia team is doing very well. Kudos. I'll find you though.

[Hallia]

Well dang.  That was unexpected.  (for the record, LOL, been right on 2/3 of my reads so far. )

[Turin Turambar]

@Hallia, yes I want definitive statements. I maintain it isn't that hard. If you are leaning mafia on someone list them as mafia. If you are leaning town list them as town. If you think they are null, list them as town for the purposes of this exercise. Just please make the list and format it as I have asked.

 

 

@RTE, please reformat as I have asked.  "Turin is town". You claimed to know why it was important so please comply. 

 

Also, by your words it appears that you viewed Hallia N2. Who did you view N1? I also assume that you got a town result on them. might as well put it all out there now.

 

 

Finally, Who are you? I look forward to seeing your reply in the morning.

[Turin Turambar]

Missed where you said you didn't submit. I must say it is convenient. Still character claim please.

[Hallia]

See, that I can do.  I'll likely have lots of towns.

[Turin Turambar]

Fair enough. I can work with that. Include yourself as well please.

[Tsukibana]

 

VOTE RTE

 

I think you holding on to Ithi, and being the only one to do so, just bit you in the ass.

 

SK would've pinged someone last night. Chae went down from a Vig.

I am not getting what you are saying here

 

ahh, &*%$. I absolutely, 100% messed that up. I have no idea why I thought RTE was the one badgering Ithi.

UNVOTE

[Turin Turambar]

[...]

 

 

Town reads on Turin, Tsuki, Ithi (sorry to see you go ) BFG,

 

Town lean on AJ

 

Scum read on Dawn and Thane

 

Scum lean on Hallia and Nikon

 

Null on TG (he said he had some R/L stuff going on FYI), Talmanes, Ed (posting was ok but very low volume, hard to make much of out it, almost a town lean though but too little to go on)

 

Happy with my vote for now but at deadline would switch to Thane or, as a last resort, Hallia for consolidation (scum lean but I'm wrong about her a lot and worried I might be here as well).

 

I stayed up late all night for this, got sidetracked, now here we are quite late and finally get to post.

 

Let's try to get a scum today.

 

I'm the Cop. Hallia is town. I can't wait to see AJ's reaction now. Wish I could see a video of him eating his hat, or all the other things he said he would do if he's wrong.

 

I got my time messed up while on vacation and missed my view first night. Sorry. Was going to lie about that but what's the point? Hence my night being short post. Time zones and long days. Sorry.

 

Now, that list.

 

Dawn - Scum

TG - Scum

Nikon - Scum

Talmanes - Scum

BFG - Scum

Turin - Town

Hallia - Town

RTE - Town

AJ - Town

Tsuki - Town

Ed - Town

 

Bit of a random order. Other than Dawn and TG not sure for scum reads. The Hallia town view surprised me. She could be GF but.. Meh.  We can figure that out I guess. Right now...

 

Vote Dawn

 

I meant to list BFG as Town, although tossup between her and Talmanes. Sorry. Tired.

Why did BFG go from a solid town read to the last non-scum read of your town pile? 

 

What made TG go from null to a sure scum read? 

 

What did Ed do to be above BFG in your town pile. he was null and hasn't even posted since you made the previous list.

[Turin Turambar]

Tsuki, Since your on right now can I get a list from you as well please? 

 

Do you believe RTE's claim? 

[Turin Turambar]

Also RTE, can you answer my questions posted earlier about your comment about what I was doing?

[Andrej]

 

 

VOTE RTE

 

I think you holding on to Ithi, and being the only one to do so, just bit you in the ass.

 

SK would've pinged someone last night. Chae went down from a Vig.

 

I am not getting what you are saying here

 

ahh, &*%$. I absolutely, 100% messed that up. I have no idea why I thought RTE was the one badgering Ithi.

UNVOTE

 

I'm wondering about this myself. You seemed to have been suggesting that RTE (or whoever you actually meant) is guilty because Ithi/Thane2 turned up Town and because they were pushing her? How does this make sense if she was the mafia NK?

 

I don't think we should jump to conclusions about the NK just yet - this could be TMI on Tsuki's part for doing so.

 

Thane/Ithi just flipped as a RBer so they could have very well blocked the NK from the mafia team and Thane2 was killed by someone else. Or mafia could have shot where the Doc protected, etc. There are several possibilities. I think whoever killed Chae needs to come forward and confirm if they shot Ithi as well. If so then scum either was blocked or hit the Doc protect.

 

If Thane2 was NK'd by the mafia team then I want to look back at his reads. As far as I remember he had Tsuki & Nikon as his top scum reads, so him dying twice like that could mean he was on the right track prior to his lynch.

 

Looks like scum was trying to lurk their way through this game, tsk tsk.

 

TG and Tal just shot up as my top 2. Ed literally hasn't posted since D1, so I'm not sure what to really think there. I think TG coming in to vote like he did is a pretty good sign he is scum and was prompted via the QT to try hammering Thane in case his self-vote wasn't counted - he did something very similar at Lylo as scum in the game I just finished modding. AFK tells always ping me. Tal I've already mentioned earlier, I don't like how he hasn't been around since he threw his vote on me yesterday and vanished.

 

After those two I would probably rank the rest as:

 

Nikon (for his speed hammer of Thane1 and the way he has sort of gone with the flow of the thread with his votes/casings - one of his scum reads is always the top wagon when he joins)

 

BFG (for her pushing of RTE, although I can't blame her completely for that, and lack of voting on any of the complete wagons although showing up after the fact D2)

 

Tsuki (for the potential TMI slip just now)

 

vote Talmanes

 

This is where I'm gonna go today. I have an idea on Dawn but I want her to speak up first before I expound more.

[Andrej]

Now Andrej, please make a big post about how you were wrong and OMG how can it be or Hallia is GF or something. Please, let me start my morning with a smile tomorrow.

 

Goodnight folks.

 

 

I would have found the scum eventually

 

You realize you probably would've been lynched today if it weren't for your Cop claim, right? So although, yeah - I was wrong - you could've done a better job portraying yourself as well. It's not like I'm the ONLY one who has been suspicious of you this game for what you have said/done.

 

That goes for Hallia too. Having the Cop need to clear you as a townie isn't awesome by any means - their job is to find scum. If you are town you basically just wasted a Cop view that could've found one of the mafia players. YOUR job is to make yourself look as townie as possible.

 

I'm also not going to rule out the potential of a GF just yet. I want to see Hallia actually start to contribute this game. She seems much more amenable to list some reads now that she is 'cleared' and Night is over - still not good vibes.

[Andrej]

Hey Tsuki - didn't you say you liked to wait until the last minute to vote?

 

Hmmm. 

[Tsukibana]

 

 

Thane/Ithi just flipped as a RBer so they could have very well blocked the NK from the mafia team and Thane2 was killed by someone else. Or mafia could have shot where the Doc protected, etc. There are several possibilities. I think whoever killed Chae needs to come forward and confirm if they shot Ithi as well. If so then scum either was blocked or hit the Doc protect.

 

Read the lynch scene again, genius. "Her heart crumbled...". The vig/SK used an arrow. The Queen takes hearts.

[Andrej]

 

 

I disagree that it's that easy. The only people who can do that so easily are mafia.

You are saying that it is hard to make a list of all the players and then give an opinion if they are more likely mafia or town in your own opinion?

 

It is more difficult for mafia because they first have to decide what to say about their teammates, and second need to make sure they are consistent..

 

just make everyone you are unsure of town. it will be okay. And format it correctly.

 

I find it odd that RTE seemed to know why I want these lists and yet is refusing to give his. I think I may be dead come day.

 

Hallia and RTE need more looking at. There was some linkage earlier also I think. I will try to look to find it..

 

 

I say it's difficult because I put my leans, and you wanted straight up 'THIS PERSON IS TOWN.  THIS PERSON IS MAFIA.'  I can give what I think, which is what I did.  But I can't say for sure who is what, which is why I said what I said.  Also there goes another person AJ was gunning for D1, down as town.

 

Lol - at least I'm trying.

 

Easy for you to snipe from the sidelines when you haven't actively done anything this game.

 

Keep it up though, you're doing great drawing in NAs that could have been used to find actual mafia.

[Tsukibana]

Hey Tsuki - didn't you say you liked to wait until the last minute to vote?

 

Hmmm. 

Yes, I did. And see what happens when I try to do something different? I jump to erroneous conclusions.