[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[Darthe]

I killed it. Darthe is now relatively anonymous for those that don't check out his facebook or profile

[peacesells]

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: Go town.

[GoldeneyesND]

 

Working graveyards this week. Was at sleep during the deadline. But..I'll be looking at you Ishy. We will know about you tomorrow.

Seems like scum took this as a cop claim. Question is did they use it to frame Ishy or would Ishy be obvious?

 

 

Was leaning scum on you yesterday. This does it for me. Nudge and a no vote=so scummy

 

Vote Kaylee

[keyholder21]

 

Unvote

 

 

For consolidation purposes and deadline approaching.

 

Vote AJ

 

I don't understand the pause here.  Why would you need 5 minutes to decide whether or not to lynch or go random? 

 

Hi all what did I miss?  Oh AJ is dead?  How sad.  See me commenting on how a town death is a personal loss to me?  That is a scumtell.  You guys know what a scumtell is right?

 

Cause AJ wanting to live wasn't one.

 

Oh, ok, excellent.  Glad you were around to help with that.

 

 

 

Working graveyards this week. Was at sleep during the deadline. But..I'll be looking at you Ishy. We will know about you tomorrow.

Seems like scum took this as a cop claim. Question is did they use it to frame Ishy or would Ishy be obvious?

 

 

Was leaning scum on you yesterday. This does it for me. Nudge and a no vote=so scummy

 

Vote Kaylee

 

 

Oh really?  Then why didn't you speak up to that effect when there were people on her train and were talking about her being scummy?   In fact, you also said the following things yesterday (see bolded):

 

 

 

 

 

Unvote. Vote Aida

 

It looks like Kay's train won't go anywhere.

 

Sound logic and reasoning

 

 

 

Unvote. Vote Aida

It looks like Kay's train won't go anywhere.

Is there a reason for this vote? Doesn't appear to be.

 

 

I don't have much of a reason. I would rather lynch her over AJ or Luci.

 

 

Weak. Cloud just wants to blindly lynch so he can play with the people he likes. Weak gameplay and attempting to nudge a train without a real reason. Cloud's game has been iffy to scum adjacent all game. I will believe the defense of Kaylee's meta because I have a town read on Ishy and I don't really see any strategic advantage to sticking his neck out for someone if he thought there was a good chance she'd be lynched (which there was at the time).

 

vote Cloud

 

 

Couple with the push for AJ's lynch yesterday, Vote Golden

[Kaylee]

From Golden:

 

Was leaning scum on you yesterday. This does it for me. Nudge and a no vote=so scummy

 

Vote Kaylee

 

 

 

I wasn't nudging him. I was pointing out a possibility. In fact I think it makes him less likely scum. That's why I didn't vote him.

[Kaylee]

Good points on Golden, Key.

[dicetosser1]

key  you mention the push for AJs lynch in regards to Golden. but he wasn't on that train. Am I missing something??

[GoldeneyesND]

 

 

Unvote

 

 

For consolidation purposes and deadline approaching.

 

Vote AJ

 

I don't understand the pause here.  Why would you need 5 minutes to decide whether or not to lynch or go random? 

 

Hi all what did I miss?  Oh AJ is dead?  How sad.  See me commenting on how a town death is a personal loss to me?  That is a scumtell.  You guys know what a scumtell is right?

 

Cause AJ wanting to live wasn't one.

 

Oh, ok, excellent.  Glad you were around to help with that.

 

 

 

Working graveyards this week. Was at sleep during the deadline. But..I'll be looking at you Ishy. We will know about you tomorrow.

Seems like scum took this as a cop claim. Question is did they use it to frame Ishy or would Ishy be obvious?

 

 

Was leaning scum on you yesterday. This does it for me. Nudge and a no vote=so scummy

 

Vote Kaylee

 

 

Oh really?  Then why didn't you speak up to that effect when there were people on her train and were talking about her being scummy?   In fact, you also said the following things yesterday (see bolded):

 

 

 

 

Unvote. Vote Aida

 

It looks like Kay's train won't go anywhere.

 

Sound logic and reasoning

 

 

 

Unvote. Vote Aida

 

It looks like Kay's train won't go anywhere.

Is there a reason for this vote? Doesn't appear to be.

 

 

I don't have much of a reason. I would rather lynch her over AJ or Luci.

 

 

Weak. Cloud just wants to blindly lynch so he can play with the people he likes. Weak gameplay and attempting to nudge a train without a real reason. Cloud's game has been iffy to scum adjacent all game. I will believe the defense of Kaylee's meta because I have a town read on Ishy and I don't really see any strategic advantage to sticking his neck out for someone if he thought there was a good chance she'd be lynched (which there was at the time).

 

vote Cloud

 

 

Couple with the push for AJ's lynch yesterday, Vote Golden

 

 

You're supposed to be a good mafia player aren't you? Show me my push for AJ. You're jumping on what you perceive is a weaker/less active player because you think I'm an easy lynch and you're being sloppy in the process. Misrepping is so slimy.  Kaylee and Key are looking fairly gross to me, I don't care about their metas I just look at what they've posted in-game so far. Ugh, now I have to Iso you sometime this week. Reading comprehension fail much? Leaning scum doesn't mean I will vote for someone for that read. I'm leaning scum on you, but I won't waste time chatting with you or voting you. Instead, I'll iso your conversations and see your logic fails. Considering your one post on me is replete with them, I presume the iso will take a while.

[hazelkrs1]

Just finished my reread... found something funny out. @Mish: I never voted AJ... but you have me listed 1st on his train in the VC. I voted Kay, which you counted, then unvoted and voted Key... I might have to grab quotes to show what I mean. Funny thing tho, heh. We actually weren't supposed to be able to secure a lynch yesterday. I would have voted him had my name not already been on the train, but still funny.

 

Also funny that some who were so ready to analyze my votes and question me for them, yet never asked why I was voting AJ or where that came from. Hmmm.

 

Anyways, lot of muddled stuff during my reread, but Darthe... is scum this game. Could be survivor. Not town, definitely not. Dude hasn't really contributed the entire game.

 

Vote Darthe.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

Ishy and AJ both defending Kaylee like this makes me nervous. Ishy not as much, although he had an earlier post I didn't like; he knows Kay's meta enough to make that determination (tho I disagree about his saying she always liked getting the game started). AJ doesn't really know enough to say yet, and in general his defense of her just strikes me as off. Thinking of switching to either.

Nuff said.

Yeahhhhh AJ is trying to play this all "too cool for school".

 

Obvious scum.

 

Unvote, Vote AJ

 

This is the game where we just have to bold, right?

 

 

Never mind, I found it, I'm a moron. Prob in too many games at once as well

 

Vote on Darthe stands tho.

[hazelkrs1]

Here's a little game for yall, I'll separate Darthe's fluff posts from his game related ones, tell me what you think:

 

Fluff:
 

 

 

 

 

Maybe we could get this pinned and people would notice it.

 

 

Maybe you'll learn along the way 

 

Thatthatthatthatthat

 

Also, I have a game that needs people. If anybody wants to try out something differen PM me plz.

 

Behavior can be changed. Personality remains mostly consistent. Thats a rule of psych.

Also, who would say they aren't town? Really a moot point.

 

 

 

Technically I am a student though I am currently out of school. Applying for graduate studies in neuroscience. Why do you ask?

 

 

 

I hear it is the best they have done in years.

 

 

Darthe recently voted hallu

 

 

:) lol Mish

 

 

Hallu is voting me and that is wrong.

 

 

It is a good way to die generally :p. I'm like a lodestone for PRs and NKs and worse.

 

 

Game too slow. Lets mass claim.

 

 

So you're saying I have to kill you at twilight. Shouldnt be too big an issue.

 

 

MMMEEEEHHHH

 

 

BUT CLOUD!  ITS SO HARD TO EXPLAIN MY NEGLIGENT REASONING!

 

 

Drink more

 

 

I get home around midnight.  It is the weekend so... yes.

 

 

Who slept with who?

I love workplace drama.

 

 

Heh WIFOM

 

 

I killed it. Darthe is now relatively anonymous for those that don't check out his facebook or profile

 

 

 

 

[hazelkrs1]

And "gameplay". I put it in sarcastic air quotes cause, well judge for yourself:

 

"Gameplay":

 

 

 

When I got my role PM I thougut I was evil.

Nope. Town this game.

Mafia wanna concede yet?


Ishy is total obv town btw.

 

 

And Snow looks good. Lets vote peace

 

(edited out Darthe's explanation to Luci of why he said Ishy was town)

 

(edited part 2 of Darthe's explanation of his town read on Ishy to Luci)

 

 

And here....we....go.

Vote Hallucination.

As for John Snow I can't explain it which is why I went for the slightly more hedgy "looking good". Basically this is just me knowing him and seeing something I wouldn't expect from him if mafia. He tended to rush his game more and should have here since he hasn't been scum in so long. Excitement, ya know?

 

 

 

That is all that you have to say about that?

 

 

Nope. I believed it which is why I said it. Did I not just type out an entire passage explaining my reasons?

Actually, you avoiding reacting because you think I am looking for reactions is scummy.

FoS for now.

 

 

Double ninjad. And ishy not reading my post is also a sign of towniness.

 

 

I don't understand your question.

Also, Key doesn't get it :p

 

 

 

Okay, finally quote loaded.

No, but I feel like you will turn out to be mafia. I may be wrong, after all this is my first game.

Unvote: Snow
Vote: Darthe

Are you actually responding to what I say or is there some conversation going on that I am missing here?

 

 

 

You've been lurking. Noted.

Ishy defending me. Meh.

 

 

Kaylee train = crap tier.

 

 

unvote vote hallu

Frozen

 

Votes r still on kaylee?

 

 

Ill take a pic of the bar when I get home and let you all decide

 

 

Hey I think I promised a pic.  What am I drinking tonight folks?

 

(edited out pic of his liquor cabinet cause it was huge)

 

 

Not my cabinet, though certainly some of my bottles.  Afraid that scotch and cigars, while cliche, just work together.

 

 

WTL Des and AJ.  Just because they talk a lot without saying anything.  

 

 

I'm drinking. Having a Shiva IPA.

 

 

Tonight is gonna be gooooooood

 

 

OH NOES HE CAUGHT US!

 

Serious though if we lynch luci and she is town does that mean that you will think me town?

 

 

NOTHING

 

 

Hi all what did I miss?  Oh AJ is dead?  How sad.  See me commenting on how a town death is a personal loss to me?  That is a scumtell.  You guys know what a scumtell is right?

 

Cause AJ wanting to live wasn't one.

 

 

 

Half of those posts barely qualify as gameplay posts. Dude shows no interest whatsoever in trying to lynch scum. Let's make it easy for him.

 

Here we go lynch Darthe, here we go!

[michellem]

*pats Des on the head*

 

I know I've screwed up the VCs alot, but not THAT much

 

Speaking of, let's get the current up now.

[Tommyrod]

 

I hereby acknowledge this game. But I won't be able to read the thread until tonight. So bear with me

 

Hi Darthe 

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Kaylee (1): Golden
Golden (1): Key
Darthe (1): Des

With 11 alive, 6 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (8): Cloud, Kaylee , Darthe, Hallu, Dice, Ishy, Luci, Tom

Deadline will be a little after midnight Friday (early am hours Saturday), thats Friday afternoon/early evening for the 'Muricans.

[michellem]

Ya'll forgot to say hi to Tom Not a very good first impression guys!

 

Thanks for joining us Tom

[John E. Kelley]

Who is this and who is he replacing?

 

Welcome to the game either way.

[Darthe]

Pretty much the leader of the mafia team in my champ game

[Darthe]

Hi Tom!

[keyholder21]

key  you mention the push for AJs lynch in regards to Golden. but he wasn't on that train. Am I missing something??

 

Seriously dice?  FOS.

 

 

 

This. I was hoping AJ was kidding because it's a flat dumb idea. I understand Cloud jumping on the idea, he seemingly has no clue what he's doing. AJ, you should know better. 

 

Unvote  Vote AJ

 

NOW it's a lynch 

 

Final Vote Count:

 

Aida (2): Cloud, AJ

Golden (1): Aida

Cloud (1): Kaylee

Hallu (1): Darthe

AJ (7): Des, Hallu, Dice, Golden, Key, Ishy, Luci

Luci (1): Peace

 

With 13 alive, 7 is needed to achieve a lynch.

Not Voting (0):

 

Deadline Monday 2AM GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131209T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D1

 

Scene incoming.

 

[keyholder21]

Hi Tom :).  

[keyholder21]

 

You're supposed to be a good mafia player aren't you? Show me my push for AJ. You're jumping on what you perceive is a weaker/less active player because you think I'm an easy lynch and you're being sloppy in the process. Misrepping is so slimy.  Kaylee and Key are looking fairly gross to me, I don't care about their metas I just look at what they've posted in-game so far. Ugh, now I have to Iso you sometime this week. Reading comprehension fail much? Leaning scum doesn't mean I will vote for someone for that read. I'm leaning scum on you, but I won't waste time chatting with you or voting you. Instead, I'll iso your conversations and see your logic fails. Considering your one post on me is replete with them, I presume the iso will take a while.

 

 

First Bold:  am I?  Where in the thread does it say this?  I haven't played with you before, so where did you get this impression?  I might be the worst player ever for all you should know. 

 

Push for AJ is down below.

 

First Underlined: Weaker and less active can be two very different things.  Regardless, though, where in my vote for you did I say anything about your activity or you being a weaker player?  This is some twisty BS.  

 

Second Bold: No, it doesn't mean that you will vote for someone.  However, there are multiple times that you could have said ANYTHING about leaning scum on Kay.  But you didn't.  In fact, you argued FOR her being town by mentioning that you had a town read on Ishy and didn't think he'd stick his neck out for someone not town.  Additionally, you told Cloud that it was "sound logic and reasoning" to not be on Kay's train.  Why would you think it's sound to get off her train if you are leaning scum on her?

 

Second Underlined: Well that's helpful. You won't "waste time chatting" essentially meaning you will make up your mind and not change it?  That's hardly good for town.  Town players often have scummy posts; scum players often have very townie sounding posts.  Not open for dialogue is NEVER good for town.  Also, not going to waste your time voting me?  WTH?  If you think I'm scummy, vote for me.  Your vote is what matters and this game is all about getting the scum, so why wouldn't you vote for someone if you think they are scummy?

 

Push for AJ:

 

This. I was hoping AJ was kidding because it's a flat dumb idea. I understand Cloud jumping on the idea, he seemingly has no clue what he's doing. AJ, you should know better. 

 

Unvote  Vote AJ

 

 

Survivor, though neutral is naturally anti-town because they win with either party. As such, the survivor doesn't care which side wins. They won't eat a NK, because scum has no reason to get rid of them. Survivors will vote to remove confirmed town at the end of the game because all they have to do is survive. Survivor is an easy town lynch. This is obvious from a 10 second look at the wiki. I know AJ is intelligent because I've played with him before. This gambit is scummy, he's trying to set up tomorrow's lynch and hoping Aida goes today.

 

 

Your reasoning was thin, you said he was trying to set up tomorrow's lynch, and your vote put him as the highest train 4 hours before deadline.

 

 

 

A lot of condescension and anger for one vote. 

[michellem]

The night had been a long one for the Downworlders; everyone had locked their doors, but they also knew that if a Shadowhunter really wanted in, a simple lock wouldn't hold against runes. Most of them spent the night with weapons at the ready, staring at their doors.

 

Dawn broke, and one by one they came out of their rooms and gathered in the library. One of the werewolfes looked around, counting to himself. "We are missing one! Peace has not come down yet." They went to check his room, and it looked like Peace had not been troubled by the same sleeplessness at the others; he was in his bed, and a seraph blade had made sure he would never wake from his slumber.

 

Peace, werewolf, vanilla town, has been nightkilled.

 

It is now Day 2.

 

 

Aida needs a replacement, so I'll give you guys some extra time this Day since her replacement hasn't played on DM before, to catch up on the game and get familiar with the vibe. Everyone say hi to Tom :)

 

Right here, Ishy. Might wanna read the mod posts ;)

[keyholder21]

Who is this and who is he replacing?

 

Welcome to the game either way.

 

Skimmer.  

 

The night had been a long one for the Downworlders; everyone had locked their doors, but they also knew that if a Shadowhunter really wanted in, a simple lock wouldn't hold against runes. Most of them spent the night with weapons at the ready, staring at their doors.

 

Dawn broke, and one by one they came out of their rooms and gathered in the library. One of the werewolfes looked around, counting to himself. "We are missing one! Peace has not come down yet." They went to check his room, and it looked like Peace had not been troubled by the same sleeplessness at the others; he was in his bed, and a seraph blade had made sure he would never wake from his slumber.

 

Peace, werewolf, vanilla town, has been nightkilled.

 

It is now Day 2.

 

 

Aida needs a replacement, so I'll give you guys some extra time this Day since her replacement hasn't played on DM before, to catch up on the game and get familiar with the vibe. Everyone say hi to Tom :)

 

[keyholder21]

Oh, lol, ninja'd by mod.