[Basic] Die Hard for Mafia Game Thread

[Kaylee]

Kaylee..you are definitely town.  Given that..I think you made a better case against Dap than AJ.

I'd definately be willing to switch my vote to Dap but I think my case against AJ is worth looking at.

[dapianoplay3r]

 

Peace: I wanted to see reactions to the unvotes on Pral and my lunch break ended.

Dap: No, see my comment to Peace.

The fact that he wasn't hammered means he's town and scum were already on his train (not saying all of them), or he's scum and they're stalling the lynch. I'm not sure which yet.

If you are going to use the reasoning that he wasnt hammered therefore he is town then all the mafia must be on his train.

The whole reasoning hinges on the fact that mafia would of hammered if they could

i cant see post # but the ones aroubd that

i mention you and call out your logic then a few posts later you throw out like 3 posts. All consecutivly

 

That looked like you didnt likr getting mentioned and were diverting attention.

To me anyway

[Kaylee]

I mostly post from my phone. Even at the computer I sometimes post, then think of something I want to add and do. That's why I post consecutively.

[Kaylee]

Even as scum why would one person mentioning me make me want to divert attention? It wouldn't as that would only draw attention to myself. I don't play that paranoid...at least not for quite some time now.

[csarmi]

So far I have learned not to trust my judgement. I did vote Darthe first day. *headdesk* Which was silly I admit that.

What sort of statement is this? You should always trust your judgement.

Also, how was it silly to vote Darthe?

 

Dap has disappeared that's the one that is bugging me at the moment AJ.

 

I found his interaction with Darthe on day one suspicious and worth looking at. I know Darthe is town now, but Dap seems to have gone underground.

You know Darthe is town?

Have you seen his coroner report, or do you think he's town cause he isn't on your maffia team?

[Darthe]

Its probably the vig claim.

 

[csarmi]

Yes, but she said she knows.

 

I think you're town - for now anyway - but I don't know it.

[Andrej]

 

I'm voting Lenlo cause he's my best choice for scum.

 

 

Lol, yeah. Lynch this one.

Is there a reason you didn't grab this quote as well? It was directly on the same page.

 

@Kaylee - I had NB listed as a scum read from the get go. I think the reasons were glaringly obvious so I didn't state them. I unvoted him to question both because he was at L-2 and I was trying to avoid a quick pile up in case my suspicions were wrong. You yourself contributed to how quickly he was hammered after I revoted him.

[csarmi]

Not gonna be around today. Maybe from phone, but DM seems to play funny with the mail notifications these days so I can't promise that either.

[Andrej]

unvote

 

I'm leaving the hotel soon. I'll be in San Diego around noon on the 25th. See you guys then.

[csarmi]

I'd like to hear from Mish before moving my vote. Dice's play deserved a run-up and probably a lynching too.

[dapianoplay3r]

Even as scum why would one person mentioning me make me want to divert attention? It wouldn't as that would only draw attention to myself. I don't play that paranoid...at least not for quite some time now.

Your play reminds me of a game you were mafia in

That's pretty much it till a reread

[csarmi]

Dap, we need your cases.

[csarmi]

I never thought I would say this :(

[Kaylee]

 

 

I'm voting Lenlo cause he's my best choice for scum.

 

Lol, yeah. Lynch this one.

Is there a reason you didn't grab this quote as well? It was directly on the same page.

 

@Kaylee - I had NB listed as a scum read from the get go. I think the reasons were glaringly obvious so I didn't state them. I unvoted him to question both because he was at L-2 and I was trying to avoid a quick pile up in case my suspicions were wrong. You yourself contributed to how quickly he was hammered after I revoted him.

I know I did, now I'm glad as he was scum. I had my work vote in there as well to be looked at. I was quoting the votes with the reasons listed. I used the ones you had with the votes themselves. What I found curious, and you just pointed out, is that you thought he was scum, then unvoted to ask his reasoning, then re-voted with the reasons you gave. Yes you did make the above post as well, but if you were voting him because you thought he was scum, why say it's because of DL and because he's the longest train. Why list reasons other than something stating your suspicions?

[Kaylee]

Dap, we need your cases.

Others are making cases as well.

[Hallia]

Official Vote Count:

 

 

 

Mish(3): Peace, Csarmi, Lenlo

 

Andrej(3): Pral, Darthe, Kaylee

 

 

 

Not Voting: Luci, Mish, Dap, Andrej

 

 

 

Deadline for Day 2 is set for Wednesday, Sept. 25 at 7pm PST.  With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

[peacesells]

Darthe...you gonna keep ignoring my questions?

 

Explain your town reads on Dice/mish and Dap.

 

 

 

Dap, you gonna stick with the meta BS?  How many times have you argued that meta casing is wrong?

[Darthe]

^Later. For now I'm busy.

[Darthe]

Technically I explained dice long ago. When luci asked how I got my early reads.

[peacesells]

wasn't much of an explanation for such a strong town read. 

[csarmi]

Technically I explained dice long ago. When luci asked how I got my early reads.

Well no you didn't. you quoted a post of his and sayid it showed Dice was town. I didn't understand the connection.

[Andrej]

 

 

 

I'm voting Lenlo cause he's my best choice for scum.

Lol, yeah. Lynch this one.

Is there a reason you didn't grab this quote as well? It was directly on the same page.

@Kaylee - I had NB listed as a scum read from the get go. I think the reasons were glaringly obvious so I didn't state them. I unvoted him to question both because he was at L-2 and I was trying to avoid a quick pile up in case my suspicions were wrong. You yourself contributed to how quickly he was hammered after I revoted him.

I know I did, now I'm glad as he was scum. I had my work vote in there as well to be looked at. I was quoting the votes with the reasons listed. I used the ones you had with the votes themselves. What I found curious, and you just pointed out, is that you thought he was scum, then unvoted to ask his reasoning, then re-voted with the reasons you gave. Yes you did make the above post as well, but if you were voting him because you thought he was scum, why say it's because of DL and because he's the longest train. Why list reasons other than something stating your suspicions?

My suspicions were already on thread. First post.

[Kaylee]

I understand that AJ. The question is why then say it's for DL and longest train instead of saying something like "for previously stated reasons", or don't give one as you already had given one. They just seem to conflict.

[Luciena]

 

 

 

I sprained my wrist on Wednesday, so have been out of it for the last couple of days. Sorry about not being online.

 

 

I mentioned NotBob’s reasoning for Lenlo’s self vote seemed off to me.

 

 

I asked Lenlo about it as did Darthe, twice as I remember, Cloud asked me to make sure whether I was going to vote Lenlo or not. (pressure on me Cloud  said)

 

I voted Darthe as his interaction with Dap sounded very chummy, I might have been mistaken in that

 

 

 

Concerning NotBob I already got a bit iffy when he kept on Lenlo for not reading the rules.

 

 

 I am believing Lenlo at the moment with the explanation he gave.

 

 

Hence

 

 

Vote NotBob

 

Luci tries to vote NB but fails to realize he's already been hammered. (Not sure if she didn't read the posts where it was mentioned that Lenlo had already hammered).

 

 

I read the posts but thought if the deadline had not passed you could still vote. So I did. 

 

So far I have learned not to trust my judgement. I did vote Darthe first day. *headdesk* Which was silly I admit that.

What sort of statement is this? You should always trust your judgement.

Also, how was it silly to vote Darthe?

 

Dap has disappeared that's the one that is bugging me at the moment AJ.

 

I found his interaction with Darthe on day one suspicious and worth looking at. I know Darthe is town now, but Dap seems to have gone underground.

You know Darthe is town?

Have you seen his coroner report, or do you think he's town cause he isn't on your maffia team?

 

 

 

Its probably the vig claim.

 

 

 

Yes, but she said she knows.

 

I think you're town - for now anyway - but I don't know it.

 

I thought when you claim a role it was supposed to be your real one? Hence the belief that Darthe was the Vig.

Or you Csarmi being the Doc. I believed you as well or you don't take that into account? 

 

From now on I will take it into consideration that everyone is lying.