August 9, 2013: CONCLUDED

[dapianoplay3r]

Blah I'm dead

 

You got this town

[Pralaya]

And the obligatory question to Chuckles.

 

What was your reading this time?

[Tiinker]

Hmmm, I was wondering - maybe the mafia experts can help me.

 

With Mr. Ree as a the town jailkeeper, is it possible that we have a town doctor too?

 

Yes, we almost certainly have a doctor.

[lolguy26]

Meh, sad dap died I viewed him N1, and I got an innocent last night

[Tiinker]

I can't honestly be the only one to think that chuck needs to give us his reads so we can start focusing targets.. This is getting ridiculous. Get your reads out.

[lolguy26]

I've already given out, the one I viewed N1(dap) and N2 (yates) and unless your telling me the one person I viewed last night can somehow reveal the rest of scum, if I tell you the name, I'm not saying anything

[Verbal32]

If he's scum, I'll admit my idea sucked.  But if he's town, then I'll sit here and say "told ya so".

 

;-)

 

 

Cloud, Bonnie Kay, Vanilla Town, has been lynched.

 

 

 

Told ya so.  ;-)

[Verbal32]

Yes, we would have lynched a town power role in Ree......but at least we wouldn't have lost 2.

[Verbal32]

I'll say again, if there is a real Cop, NOW is the time to reveal.  I don't care if you have all dead townies as results - we need a scum lynch today.

[Tiinker]

I've already given out, the one I viewed N1(dap) and N2 (yates) and unless your telling me the one person I viewed last night can somehow reveal the rest of scum, if I tell you the name, I'm not saying anything

 

Holy S. Give us the name.

[bgrishinko]

I'm going back to my instinct and gut. As I mentioned before I still think that Serra is the best candidate for this game.

 

Vote Serra

[hazelkrs1]

at yet another convenient viewing for Chuckles. If you really are the Cop, you're terrible this game compared to the Pokemon game where you were Cop.

 

Gonna withhold my vote till I get to work later and can refresh myself on this game and the recent/long forgotten goings on.

[Krakalakachkn]

Really Des?  That wasn't cool.

[bgrishinko]

Really Des?  That wasn't cool.

 

Why?

[hazelkrs1]

 

How is that not cool? If he IS the Cop he's made some pretty awful type choices for "viewings", and he's played uberscummy. How am I out of line for mentioning that?

[Krakalakachkn]

This:

 

"If you really are the Cop, you're terrible this game compared to the Pokemon game where you were Cop."

 

 

I guess I just don't see the need to say something like this.  It just seems unnecessary.  

 

 

 

 

[Krakalakachkn]

I don't have a problem with you commenting on on his viewings or his play in this game, but it seems you went out of your way to smack him around.  I guess it was the comparison to last game.

 

 

 

But maybe I'm just being overly sensitive.

[bgrishinko]

If anything, it seems like a compliment to his play as cop in another game and then commenting on difference this game. 

[Pralaya]

I dont see a problem here

[lolguy26]

at yet another convenient viewing for Chuckles. If you really are the Cop, you're terrible this game compared to the Pokemon game where you were Cop.

 

Gonna withhold my vote till I get to work later and can refresh myself on this game and the recent/long forgotten goings on.

 

dude, i started getting scum there from D4 (or N3), and the fact that the mafia team seem to be NK'ing everyone i view isnt helping 

[Tiinker]

VIEWING LAST NIGHT PLSS 

 

PLS GOD COP GIVE US YOUR VIEWINGZ

[lolguy26]

VIEWING LAST NIGHT PLSS 

 

PLS GOD COP GIVE US YOUR VIEWINGZ

 

just humor me and give me a straight answer

 

why?

[Tiinker]

 

VIEWING LAST NIGHT PLSS 

 

PLS GOD COP GIVE US YOUR VIEWINGZ

 

just humor me and give me a straight answer

 

why?

 

 

You giving us the innocent you viewed last night let's us analyze who's been buddying them/trying to get them lynched.The word of the player can therefore be trusted and you can be more certain that the casing that they've done isn't twisted.  Not only does it give us more room to analyze, but it gives town a more focused group of people to look at for scum by confirming an innocent. What do you do when a player gets lynched and their alignment shows? You go back with new perspective and light is shed on things you didn't see before. What happens when a player is viewed? Same thing.

 

We're 8 to 1 right now and the only mafia that got died got NK'd by his own team. This means they hold a high proportion of votes which means that having any innocent confirmed, narrowing down possibilities, is vastly more helpful. You keeping this from us does what? It makes our casing less effective and increases our chance of missing scum today. Bottom line. 

 

Are you worried that the scum are going to kill the innocent that you will reveal? Well, what difference does it make if you don't tell us who he is? Dap died and you said "Oh yeah, I viewed him. Sorry I didn't tell you earlier.", explain how that was more effective than you telling us that when you revealed? You saving this for end-game when we're getting pooped is. not. helping. 

 

[lolguy26]

 

 

VIEWING LAST NIGHT PLSS 

 

PLS GOD COP GIVE US YOUR VIEWINGZ

 

just humor me and give me a straight answer

 

why?

 

 

You giving us the innocent you viewed last night let's us analyze who's been buddying them/trying to get them lynched.The word of the player can therefore be trusted and you can be more certain that the casing that they've done isn't twisted.  Not only does it give us more room to analyze, but it gives town a more focused group of people to look at for scum by confirming an innocent. What do you do when a player gets lynched and their alignment shows? You go back with new perspective and light is shed on things you didn't see before. What happens when a player is viewed? Same thing.

 

We're 8 to 1 right now and the only mafia that got died got NK'd by his own team. This means they hold a high proportion of votes which means that having any innocent confirmed, narrowing down possibilities, is vastly more helpful. You keeping this from us does what? It makes our casing less effective and increases our chance of missing scum today. Bottom line. 

 

Are you worried that the scum are going to kill the innocent that you will reveal? Well, what difference does it make if you don't tell us who he is? Dap died and you said "Oh yeah, I viewed him. Sorry I didn't tell you earlier.", explain how that was more effective than you telling us that when you revealed? You saving this for end-game when we're getting pooped is. not. helping. 

 

 

 

see i agree with alot of what you said, but the last part tho, not so much

 

 

 

Are you worried that the scum are going to kill the innocent that you will reveal? Well, what difference does it make if you don't tell us who he is? Dap died and you said "Oh yeah, I viewed him. Sorry I didn't tell you earlier.", explain how that was more effective than you telling us that when you revealed? You saving this for end-game when we're getting pooped is. not. helping. 

 

 

 

to answer this, if lets just say, the doc protects me, and the mafia know this, who are they most likely to NK, the confirmed townies, which pretty makes my view useless, i mean you give an example of dap, if i did say that i viewed him, that would have just painted a big target on his back, instead of being NK'd right away, he made it through and the only reason mafia NK'd him was cuz they saw him as a threat to their team instead of being confirmed.

 

where as if i say nothing, and lets just say i get another 2 innocents, what does that do, it dramatically reduces the pool in which scum hide, do you get why im "obtuse" and not giving my read now?

[bgrishinko]

Yeah... but... then some other townie other than Dap dies anyway so its a moot point and town can't narrow down the pool. Mafia don't need to narrow down the pool. They want to leave it wide open. This prevents town from doing as effective teamwork.