Kingdom Hearts Mafia - Game 1 - Destiny Islands [Mafia Win!]

[Krakalakachkn]

 

And just because something is an opinion doesn't mean it's truth value is unknowable. I have come to my opinion through experience in successfully rolefishing and manipulating people who talk too much at night. You can WIFOM or deceive the mafia with night talk, but it's super risky. Most of the time it's best to shut up unless you really need to toss the dice.

 

Seriously, you can't see the forest because your head is stuck up your butt at this point. You read me as Town all last game when I actually was scum, and I'm getting the feeling you've got a little complex about it. Hmmm?

 

 

 

And I get the feeling that this is all a trumped up exchange to distance and sow confusion/suspicion in separate directions.

[Tiinker]

Here and playing. Good to see everyone being their normal douchey selves   

 

Vote Tina

 

Passing off her vote as just oh so obvious combined with this high and mighty post.

 

 

@ Kronos - what kind of reasons would there be to vote any of them without any gameplay to look at? What kind of reasons would there be to not vote any of them without any gameplay to look at?  Think about that for a second or two. 

 

which is extremely flaky, is just about enough for me.

[Tiinker]

 

 

And just because something is an opinion doesn't mean it's truth value is unknowable. I have come to my opinion through experience in successfully rolefishing and manipulating people who talk too much at night. You can WIFOM or deceive the mafia with night talk, but it's super risky. Most of the time it's best to shut up unless you really need to toss the dice.

 

Seriously, you can't see the forest because your head is stuck up your butt at this point. You read me as Town all last game when I actually was scum, and I'm getting the feeling you've got a little complex about it. Hmmm?

 

 

 

And I get the feeling that this is all a trumped up exchange to distance and sow confusion/suspicion in separate directions.

 

I, too, get that feeling. 

[_CLOUD]

I have no idea what to think about those two.

[Darthe]

LAFO IMO

[DPR]

Unofficial Vote Count - Deadline in 14 hours or so.

 

Tina (4) - Kronos, Peace, Krak, Tinker

DPR (2) -  Wombat, GF

Despo (2) - DPR, Tina

Cloud (1) - BG

Darther (1) - Mish

 

My thoughts: I'll be around at deadline, so I can always pop a vote onto whatever wagon to avoid a random lynch. Having said that, I would rather vote Despo, Darther, or Wombat at this point to see where we're at. They've all made shady posts (imho) with no provocation.

 

I'll also point out that Tina's train got it's first push from (and this is just what I remember - I'll go back to confirm it) Wombat when he "pointed out" her "sheep" vote on Despo, right after I voted him. 

 

By that logic, from him and those voting her, GF should have also been called out on her sheeping Wombat. But no one has mentioned that...

 

I'll be back with a confirmation on that point in just a sec.

[Tiinker]

I was under the impression that most people were voting Tina for her shoddy replies rather than sheeping. Darthe strikes me as odd. No read, but he seems to be overly excited.

[_CLOUD]

I'm pretty sure that Kronos was the one who pointed out Tina's vote. 

 

 

Also, what does LAFO for?

[DPR]

 

I'm all for Tiink's idea, as long as I get to stay outside and watch

 

Takes the outsider perspective, apart from the group but not against it.  I think we've found a solo win candidate.

 

 

File this under DESPO IN MAFIA COVER MODE. heh

Don't give me away DPR! Our gambit is too obvious!

 

 

Well it certainly is now.

 

 

TGlems has been replaced by Krakalakachkn.

 

A N0 replacement... Meh.

 

 

I'm just glad I don't have 71 pages of catch-up.

 

 

It's 24 hours until night. These are my two best choices for scum so far. Gotta start somewhere.

 

Vote Despo

 Well, we got to start somewhere.

 

Vote Des

 

Tina echoes DPR.  Could be instinctual due to off-thread conversation and unconscious acknowledgement of DPR's seniority among the mafia team.

 

 

I stand corrected. Krak was the first to push this point, and his vote is on her.

 

@Verbal: I was mainly querying Des and DPR. They are often scummy as town so it will take a little more for them to garner my FoS. Darthe has my FoS.

 

Tina is rapidly climbing my list as well for her equivocal responses to WBK.

 

To be fair, this is Wombat's first mention of Tina. So, he had nothing to do with that train and hasn't voted for her.

[_CLOUD]

I was under the impression that most people were voting Tina for her shoddy replies rather than sheeping. Darthe strikes me as odd. No read, but he seems to be overly excited.

 

Yeah her vote on Despo didn't strike me as odd at first, but her explanation (or lack thereof) for her vote did.

[DPR]

 

 

And just because something is an opinion doesn't mean it's truth value is unknowable. I have come to my opinion through experience in successfully rolefishing and manipulating people who talk too much at night. You can WIFOM or deceive the mafia with night talk, but it's super risky. Most of the time it's best to shut up unless you really need to toss the dice.

 

Seriously, you can't see the forest because your head is stuck up your butt at this point. You read me as Town all last game when I actually was scum, and I'm getting the feeling you've got a little complex about it. Hmmm?

 

 

 

And I get the feeling that this is all a trumped up exchange to distance and sow confusion/suspicion in separate directions.

 

 

Ah ha - Krak pointed out that Tina "sheeped" me on my vote, but doesn't think that GF "shipping" Wombat's vote is any problem worth mentioning?

 

Then he wants to start shit with the above post (which I guess would be the 2nd gambit I'm running since the game started...damn I'm busy).

 

@ Krak - You posted after GF voted after Wombat. Why didn't you call that out for the same reason you called Tina out? 

[Niniel]

Point is you voted Des 2 minutes after DPR - yes I realize we have a 24 hour deadline, but that's no reason to not attempt to put work into it.  I find you joining in after so soon after DPR pingy - so I question it - you avoid my question, I vote and you continue to do so and then finally place a vote.  I can join trains for consolidation purposes, but think you are a better place to start.

 

I put some work in it by voting someone. What other work could I have put into it at that time? You should know by now that I almost always try to kick start games since I don´t like spam in mafia threads. 

 

So, you already think about giving up your vote on me and vote for consolidation?

 

 

Pretty much explained my end - any questions BG?

 

Not right now. Still waiting to hear from Tina. Then maybe I'll have some for both ya'lls.

 

 

What are you waiting for? 

 

 

@ Kronos - what kind of reasons would there be to vote any of them without any gameplay to look at? What kind of reasons would there be to not vote any of them without any gameplay to look at?  Think about that for a second or two. 

 

So why did you vote for Despo if there wasn't any gameplay to help you decide your vote on? Was your vote just meant to pressure Despo? And if so, what info do you expect to gain from Despo if the only thing you did was place a single vote on him?

 

 

Next time I should just write I VOTE THIS PERSON TO SEE HOW OTHERS WILL REACT TO MY VOTE. 

[Niniel]

Unvote. Vote Tiinker

[Tiinker]

 

 

@ Kronos - what kind of reasons would there be to vote any of them without any gameplay to look at? What kind of reasons would there be to not vote any of them without any gameplay to look at?  Think about that for a second or two. 

 

So why did you vote for Despo if there wasn't any gameplay to help you decide your vote on? Was your vote just meant to pressure Despo? And if so, what info do you expect to gain from Despo if the only thing you did was place a single vote on him?

 

 

Next time I should just write I VOTE THIS PERSON TO SEE HOW OTHERS WILL REACT TO MY VOTE. 

 

 

If you're frustrated with the way people have reacted to your vote, then maybe you shouldn't have voted in such a scummy manner. Just sayin.

[_CLOUD]

I think her vote worked out pretty well in the end as it generated a lot of discussion.

[Darthe]

^ interesting to me.

 

@Tiink,

I'm thrilled to be town again :p and in final fantasy no less!

 

@DPR, I get that my comments are odd, I've read that, but that doesn't make them scummy and you haven't explained that yet. Pure meta gaming seems contrived reasoning for a vote.

[Darthe]

Double ninjad

[DPR]

DreadPirateRoberts 20 Nolder 20 WWWwombat 15 Darthe 15 _CLOUD 14 WolfbrotherKronos 11 Tiinker 11 Misheru Sedai 9 TinaHel 8 Krakalakachkn 7 bgrishinko 6 Despothera 5 peacesells 5 Hallia 5 Verbal32 4 dapianoplay3r 4 Graendals favourite 3 TGlems

 

 

This low post count aint gonna cut it with 24 hr deadlines. 

[Niniel]

 

 

 

@ Kronos - what kind of reasons would there be to vote any of them without any gameplay to look at? What kind of reasons would there be to not vote any of them without any gameplay to look at?  Think about that for a second or two. 

 

So why did you vote for Despo if there wasn't any gameplay to help you decide your vote on? Was your vote just meant to pressure Despo? And if so, what info do you expect to gain from Despo if the only thing you did was place a single vote on him?

 

 

Next time I should just write I VOTE THIS PERSON TO SEE HOW OTHERS WILL REACT TO MY VOTE. 

 

 

If you're frustrated with the way people have reacted to your vote, then maybe you shouldn't have voted in such a scummy manner. Just sayin.

 

 

I´m not frustrated. The vote is obviously there to get reactions. 

[Tiinker]

Unvote. Vote Tiinker

 

And why myself in particular? You were looking to get reactions, and now you have them. Share some thoughts pls. Or is it all just so obvious? If you were purely looking to garner reactions from people then I don't know why you would echo someone else as quickly as you did, and as the first legitimate case of the day no less. There's no way in hell you wouldn't get called out on it. Not to mention you barely posted. What exactly did you expect to get out of your vote if it wasn't a scummy train on yourself if you didn't follow through with posts of your own? 

 

Ain't buying it. 

[Tiinker]

^ interesting to me.

 

@Tiink,

I'm thrilled to be town again :p and in final fantasy no less!

 

@DPR, I get that my comments are odd, I've read that, but that doesn't make them scummy and you haven't explained that yet. Pure meta gaming seems contrived reasoning for a vote.

Not directed at me here but I stated you were odd as well.

 

Overexcitedness makes it look like you know something I don't. 

[DPR]

^ interesting to me.

 

@Tiink,

I'm thrilled to be town again :p and in final fantasy no less!

 

@DPR, I get that my comments are odd, I've read that, but that doesn't make them scummy and you haven't explained that yet. Pure meta gaming seems contrived reasoning for a vote.

 

Not for nothin', but if all you're going to do is make weird posts, wtf good are you? And of course that makes them scummy - you admitting that your posts make no sense is an admission that you are intentionally spamming the board, creating distraction and confusion. If you were to, oh, I don't know, preface the whole bit with "I'm throwin' half a bottle of Makers Mark back tonight, so expect a ton of no-game related, offensive and sexually inappropriate posts", then at least we would know to expect it, and you've qualified it.

 

But you just act weird. Oh well.

[Darthe]

I would have to agree except for on two points. One, I didn't state that my posts were useless, I merely agreed that they were odd. as well they should be.

Two, your view only works if the goal is efficiency. Mine is not, as efficient scum hunting can be done quite simply. My goal is to manage a balance between efficiency and fun. :nods:

[Darthe]

 

 

^ interesting to me.

 

@Tiink,

I'm thrilled to be town again :p and in final fantasy no less!

 

@DPR, I get that my comments are odd, I've read that, but that doesn't make them scummy and you haven't explained that yet. Pure meta gaming seems contrived reasoning for a vote.

Not directed at me here but I stated you were odd as well.

 

Overexcitedness makes it look like you know something I don't.

Any response given to this would be bad for the town, thus I don't know why you said it.

[Niniel]

 

Unvote. Vote Tiinker

 

And why myself in particular? You were looking to get reactions, and now you have them. Share some thoughts pls. Or is it all just so obvious? If you were purely looking to garner reactions from people then I don't know why you would echo someone else as quickly as you did, and as the first legitimate case of the day no less. There's no way in hell you wouldn't get called out on it. Not to mention you barely posted. What exactly did you expect to get out of your vote if it wasn't a scummy train on yourself if you didn't follow through with posts of your own? 

 

Ain't buying it. 

 

 

Oh, the why me question. Because you were just lazy and jumping on an easy bandwagon?